nfl fantasy advice thread

[duckseason]

the only way i can do 10 anymore is to pump the hell out of the bench, so that you're really having to work towards the end of the draft to get guys. i hate when, at any given time, you can grab a borderline starter off waivers to fill in for a bye week.

I was just talking with my brother yesterday about how awesome it would be to have a full 32 team keeper league. If it were possible to get that many reliable guys together for the long haul, I'd jump all over it. In the inevitable event that someone has to drop out, you'd just have to "sell" his team. It would be difficult to set up but I think it would be the ultimate fantasy game.

[Vikes99ej]

IDK, I still have fun in a six-person league, and I guess that's all that matters.

[TimD]

I was just talking with my brother yesterday about how awesome it would be to have a full 32 team keeper league. If it were possible to get that many reliable guys together for the long haul, I'd jump all over it. In the inevitable event that someone has to drop out, you'd just have to "sell" his team. It would be difficult to set up but I think it would be the ultimate fantasy game.

wait like you could only pick whatever team you rep or just a 32 man league

[Buckeyes]

If you had QB's Donovan McNabb, Matt Lienart, David Garrard, and Matt Schaub... who would you start?

[duckseason]

wait like you could only pick whatever team you rep or just a 32 man league

A 32 man league. That would be beastly. Have a rookie draft every year.

[BrownsTown]

it'd be tough to put together... i mean, how do you deal with starters/reserves? inevitably, if you start more than one running back, people will be forced to play guys who have no chance of getting points simply because they had the misfortune to draft in the wrong position (just as an example position).

if you could work out the scoring, i think it'd definitely be intriguing.

Yea, whoever got the 32nd pick would be doomed.

[BrownsTown]

If you had QB's Donovan McNabb, Matt Lienart, David Garrard, and Matt Schaub... who would you start?

It depends. Probably Leinart for the first few weeks to see if McNabb is back in form, if he gets back in form then, McNabb as your normal starter, and Leinart when he's playing a bad defense, which he often does. If McNabb and Leinart are both playing tough defenses, play whichever of Garrard or Schaub is playing the easier one.

[duckseason]

it'd be tough to put together... i mean, how do you deal with starters/reserves? inevitably, if you start more than one running back, people will be forced to play guys who have no chance of getting points simply because they had the misfortune to draft in the wrong position (just as an example position).

if you could work out the scoring, i think it'd definitely be intriguing.

Yeah, you'd definitely have teams get stuck in the cellar for awhile. Teams could be lacking a true starter at multiple positions. Maybe 32 is too much. But I like the idea of having a huge league where the teams actually resemble a real team. Maybe 20-24 would be better.

[duckseason]

Yea, whoever got the 32nd pick would be doomed.

You're right, that initial draft would be real tough and quite unfair.

[BrownsTown]

You're right, that initial draft would be real tough and quite unfair.

Although...if it would be long term, the last place finisher could have first pick of the rookies so you wouldn't need to do a whole nother draft, just one with rookies. And then they'd either get a starter or a person splitting time which would be tough to find in a league that big.

[duckseason]

Although...if it would be long term, the last place finisher could have first pick of the rookies so you wouldn't need to do a whole nother draft, just one with rookies. And then they'd either get a starter or a person splitting time which would be tough to find in a league that big.

Yeah, they'd also get #33 which would be a high quality player. They might go QB-WR with those picks and then work on getting their RB as a rookie. As a long term thing, I think it would be fun as hell.

[scottyboy]

24 sounds about right to me. that way, you can pretty much get a top guy at at least one position, which, while slightly less interesting overall, i think is important for the fun factor. if my best guy is scoring 6 points, it doesn't matter if all my guys score 6 and i'm .500. but if i have a guy who's a top scorer, even if the rest of my team sucks, it's probably at least more interesting to follow the team through the season. but it would definitely still keep up the talent dilution levels.

*shrug* the only other problem is finding 24 people who are capable of paying attention all season.

hmmm does njx want to run such a 24 person draft?

[duckseason]

24 sounds about right to me. that way, you can pretty much get a top guy at at least one position, which, while slightly less interesting overall, i think is important for the fun factor. if my best guy is scoring 6 points, it doesn't matter if all my guys score 6 and i'm .500. but if i have a guy who's a top scorer, even if the rest of my team sucks, it's probably at least more interesting to follow the team through the season. but it would definitely still keep up the talent dilution levels.

*shrug* the only other problem is finding 24 people who are capable of paying attention all season.

I agree. I think 32 is going overboard. For multiple reasons. It would already be difficult enough to get 32 guys to make the commitment and not flake. With 32, there'd certainly be some perennial cellar dwellers who would likely just give up.

[Godsend]

who would you start between e. manning (at DAL) and alex smith (vs ARI)???

[P-L]

I do a six team league every year and I think it's fun and a bit challenging. You have a stacked team, but so does everyone else. If one of your top players gets injured, you really have plan well and make good moves to make up for it.

[duckseason]

who would you start between e. manning (at DAL) and alex smith (vs ARI)???

That's a toughie. I personally like Smith because I see that as a shootout. But, I'm a Cowboys fan and may not be willing to admit that the G-men will score on us. I could probably flip a coin with that one but would take the guy who's playing at home against a team with a weak defense who will likely pass a lot themselves thereby slowing the clock while simultaneously putting pressure on the 9ers to keep up with the quick scores. Also, Jacobs and Droughns seem more likely to get redzone carries than Gore does.

[Vikes99ej]

Is San Diego's defense going to have a field day against Rex Grossman?

[bsaza2358]

I like San Diego's D to come away with at least 3 sacks and 2 turnovers off Grossman and the Chicago O. Could be even worse. I don't expect that game to be really close.

[duckseason]

which is funny because this is my situation. except +roethlisberger.

Not sure why, but I really like Roethlisberger this year. And I expect the Steelers to come out of the gate quick, putting 30+ on the Browns. That's more of a feeling than anything tangible.

[bsaza2358]

I think Big Ben is a solid, solid QB. He is smart, generally doesn't turn the ball over, and he has excellent weapons with Parker, Miller, Ward, Holmes, and Washington. I think Tomlin's scheme and toughness will be a huge benefit. Ben's health is also a plus.

[bsaza2358]

Do we know for sure that Matt Prater is the starting kicker for Atlanta? I had Cundiff in my deep league (start 2 K's), but I dropped the dude for Prater as insurance.

[thefalconer]

Do we know for sure that Matt Prater is the starting kicker for Atlanta? I had Cundiff in my deep league (start 2 K's), but I dropped the dude for Prater as insurance.

yep. its pretty much certain that prater will be the guy for us. he looked impressive in preseason.

[thetedginnshow]

Okay I may be doing this big trade but first I have to know which TE to keep. Shockey or Winslow? They're both pretty much question marks with huge potential, but I don't know which one I should keep around.

[bsaza2358]

Shockey is in a better offense, but Winslow gets targeted more often. I would keep Shockey because I think he'll have more TD opportunities.

[Basileus777]

Should I start:
Reggie Bush or Clinton Portis
Carson Palmer (against Baltimore) or Matt Hasselbeck

[RoyHall#1]

Definitely go with Bush, Indy has a terrible run defense. As for the QB situation, I'd go with Palmer just because of how much of a stud he is.

[Vikes99ej]

Never, ever start Matt Hasselbeck. Ever.

[bsaza2358]

I consider Palmer a must start in any format and any situation. Maybe if Hasselbeck is playing a very weak defensive team, and Palmer is scheduled @ Buffalo in a snowstorm, you can consider Hasselbeck ahead of him. Palmer is a top 3 QB at worst.

[bsaza2358]

I agree with starting Bush over Portis this week as well. Miami's rush D is very solid, and the Redskins are splitting carries between Portis and Betts. Portis may or may not be healthy. Meanwhile, Bush is a ridiculous weapon. Go with Reggie against a potentially suspect Colts D.

[princefielder28]

I agree with starting Bush over Portis this week as well. Miami's rush D is very solid, and the Redskins are splitting carries between Portis and Betts. Portis may or may not be healthy. Meanwhile, Bush is a ridiculous weapon. Go with Reggie against a potentially suspect Colts D.

No doubt....I expect the Colts D to return to the form they showed before acquiring Booger last season

[RonnieRun23]

My receivers are Steve Smith, Randy Moss, Braylon Edwards, Ronald Curry, and Branden Jones.

I'm leaning towards starting Smith, Edwards, and Curry.


Thoughts?

[Scotty D]

Stallworth over Calvin Johnson?

[GB12]

Stallworth over Calvin Johnson?
I would. The Raiders have a strong pass defense and I think Johnson is the third reciever behind Furrey at this point.

[Scotty D]

I would. The Raiders have a strong pass defense and I think Johnson is the third reciever behind Furrey at this point.

What I'm thinking. Anybody use ESPN? Are the rosters locked already? I'm having trouble changing my lineup.

[Paul]

I spent a pick on Portis, and with his injury problems I've been trying to move him but nobody is biting. Lamont Jordan, Deshaun Foster and LenDale white are available FA. Should I drop Portis for one of them or should I holt tight and see what happens.

My other RB:
Stephen Jackson
Marion Barber
Fred Taylor

[thetedginnshow]

Quickly! I'm about to go into a 12 man draft with the 8th spot. Who should I probably be going for at that point? Peyton, Westbrook, Parker, and Rudi?

[RoyHall#1]

Quickly! I'm about to go into a 12 man draft with the 8th spot. Who should I probably be going for at that point? Peyton, Westbrook, Parker, and Rudi?

Id say Westbrook, Parker, Johnson in that order.

[Paul]

I'd pick Westbrook.

[GB12]

I spent a pick on Portis, and with his injury problems I've been trying to move him but nobody is biting. Lamont Jordan, Deshaun Foster and LenDale white are available FA. Should I drop Portis for one of them or should I holt tight and see what happens.

My other RB:
Stephen Jackson
Marion Barber
Fred Taylor
Woah, you would just drop Portis. I don't understand at all why you would do that. He's way better than anyone you could pick up and second best on your team.

[BrownsTown]

Woah, you would just drop Portis. I don't understand at all why you would do that. He's way better than anyone you could pick up and second best on your team.

Yea, hold on to him. He's going first round in some leagues.

[Paul]

Woah, you would just drop Portis. I don't understand at all why you would do that. He's way better than anyone you could pick up and second best on your team.

Yes, seriously thinking about it. He is constantly injured, and it looks like it's the same old news this year according to Yahoo. And apparently Betts maybe ahead of him at this point(may need confirmation). If somebody picked him in the 1st that was a big reach, I got him in the tailend of the 4th. But will probably end up holding on to him for now as I just read he participated in his first full practice today.

[Scotty D]

Didn't Portis get injured in pre-season last year. Portis is the kind of guy that would let an injury linger not to play in pre-season. I'm thinking hes fine and just doing everything he can to not play in the pre-season.

[thebow305]

Ok, I have Muhsin Muhammed as my fourth wideout. Should I drop him for any of the following: Kevin Curtis, Marty Booker, Dwayne Bowe, Ronald Curry, Jerry Porter, Wes Welker, Amani Toomer, Jacoby Jones, Matt Jones, or Michael Jenkins?

[BrownsTown]

Ok, I have Muhsin Muhammed as my fourth wideout. Should I drop him for any of the following: Kevin Curtis, Marty Booker, Dwayne Bowe, Ronald Curry, Jerry Porter, Wes Welker, Amani Toomer, Jacoby Jones, Matt Jones, or Michael Jenkins?

Curtis, Porter or Jenkins, I don't think Moose will do much this year.

[princefielder28]

Curtis, Porter or Jenkins, I don't think Moose will do much this year.

That Bears' offense is dull

[RoyHall#1]

definitely get Porter.

[GB12]

definitely get Porter.

If your going for a Raiders WR I'd take Curry over Porter.

[thebow305]

I was thinking Curtis, why Porter or Curry over him?

[thebow305]

Also, what about Daunte, I have him as my backup, should I drop him for Alex Smith?

[thefalconer]

take jenkins. he looked promising in preseason and should be a dominant slot reciever.

[thebow305]

anyone????

[KCJ58]

Curry>Porter

[thefalconer]

wow. of course you drop daunte! alex smith is poised to have his breakout year and he does have some formidable weapons around him.

[SuperMcGee]

Who should I start at my W/R spot this week?

Norwood
Galloway
Branch
Chester Taylor

1/2 point per reception

***separately***

Which one should I start out of these 3:

Mark Clayton
Jerricho Cotchery
Santonio Holmes

[Billingsley26]

Who should I start at my W/R spot this week?

Norwood
Galloway
Branch
Chester Taylor

1/2 point per reception

You must mean your FLEX position. I would go with either Chester Taylor or Deion Branch. I think Taylor will be the featured back for this week anyways, and should get alot of touches. Plus its Minne, and I expect them to run ALOT. Branch is Seattle #1 target. Alot said there.

[GB12]

You must mean your FLEX position. I would go with either Chester Taylor or Deion Branch. I think Taylor will be the featured back for this week anyways, and should get alot of touches. Plus its Minne, and I expect them to run ALOT. Branch is Seattle #1 target. Alot said there.
Um, yeah that's what he said...

I would go with Branch and Clayton.

[Billingsley26]

Um, yeah that's what he said...

I would go with Branch and Clayton.

In case you didnt pick up on it, he edited it!!! It previously said who should i start at WR!!!

Anyways i stand with my choices.

[GB12]

In case you didnt pick up on it, he edited it!!! It previously said who should i start at WR!!!

Anyways i stand with my choices.

I'm sure he just forgot the "/". And anyways when you quoted him it was correct so how the hell was I supposed to know if he did.

[SuperMcGee]

In case you didnt pick up on it, he edited it!!! It previously said who should i start at WR!!!

Anyways i stand with my choices.

Actually I edited in the separate advice part for the Clayton/Cotchery/Holmes conundrum

It said W/R the whole time, so FACE!

[thetedginnshow]

Wow. Okay. Well, I definitely didn't read the rules completely with this league, especially since he changed them right before we started, but oh well. Here's the results from the 12-man league.

QB - David Garrard
RB - Brian Westbrook
RB - Reggie Bush
UT - Ladell Betts
UT - Adrian Peterson
WR - Larry Fitzgerald
WR - Santana Moss
WR - Calvin Johnson
TE - Antonio Gates
DEF - JAX
K - Joe Nedney

BN - Tarvaris Jackson
BN - Derrick Mason
BN - D.J. Hackett
BN - Drew Bennett
BN - Jason Witten
BN - SEA

I know, extremely weak at QB, but it didn't help that one guy took Carson, Brady, and Favre.

[alca1992]

Marion Barber III
Clinton Portis

im really leaning to Barber who do guys think

Denver
Oakland

im thinking oakland anyone agree

[bsaza2358]

I like Denver and Oakland both as fantasy D's this season. Denver will run the ball and has the mile high advantage, but I think Oakland has a more talented defense. The problem there is that the Raiders O is not looking too strong, which means the Oakland D is on the field a TON.

[Jughead10]

I've been racking my brain over this one. I have one spot remaining on my squad for week 1. Who should I start.

Calvin Johnson @ Oakland

Jerry Porter vs. Lions

Heath Miller @ Cleveland


I feel I'll probably be starting CJ the majority of the season, but I don't want to his first game at Oakland with a great secondary.

I'm really caught between Miller and Porter and right now I'm leaning a bit towards Miller.

[Billingsley26]

I would probably go with Porter against the Lions. The Lions have pretty much no secondary.

[princefielder28]

I've been racking my brain over this one. I have one spot remaining on my squad for week 1. Who should I start.

Calvin Johnson @ Oakland

Jerry Porter vs. Lions

Heath Miller @ Cleveland


I feel I'll probably be starting CJ the majority of the season, but I don't want to his first game at Oakland with a great secondary.

I'm really caught between Miller and Porter and right now I'm leaning a bit towards Miller.

Jerry Porter is the #1 WR against a Lions secondary that is quite weak

[scottyboy]

go with Miller. Porter's QB is awful, and will be on his arse the whole game, even if it is Detriot's D...

[P-L]

Calvin probably won't start the first game, although he should still see plenty of playing time. With that being said, Porter and Miller are both starting for their teams. The Lions have the worst secondary in the league, but Porter hasn't been consistently good ever. I'd probably go with Miller.

[Jughead10]

I might end up starting both Porter and Miller. I forgot I had Wilford in my starting lineup. I can't trust Garrard at all to get him the ball.

[RoyHall#1]

I might end up starting both Porter and Miller. I forgot I had Wilford in my starting lineup. I can't trust Garrard at all to get him the ball.

Definitely start both of them then.

[bsaza2358]

Forget Garrard getting Wilford the ball. Worry about Wilford even getting open at all. The guy is just not a good fantasy play...

[Twiddler]

Okay, I need advice on a WR situation in a ten team league. My top three receivers at this point are Steve Smith, Roy Williams, and Reggie Brown. They are all good, I'm not messing with them. However my two backups are Joe Horn and Anthony Gonzalez. And while I don't think they are bad, I may have the opportunity to upgrade them. Free agent WR's in this league at this point are Brandon Marshall, Ronald Curry, Bobby Wade, Brandon Jones, Demetrius Williams, and Michael Jenkins. Preferably I'd drop Horn who is on the downside of his career in favor of a guy who could have a breakout year. I guess the idea of Peyton Manning throwing to Anthony Gonzalez is probably going to make me want to keep him, in case it turns to be like Brandon Stokely in his big year. Any thoughts?

[Sniper]

Okay, I need advice on a WR situation in a ten team league. My top three receivers at this point are Steve Smith, Roy Williams, and Reggie Brown. They are all good, I'm not messing with them. However my two backups are Joe Horn and Anthony Gonzalez. And while I don't think they are bad, I may have the opportunity to upgrade them. Free agent WR's in this league at this point are Brandon Marshall, Ronald Curry, Bobby Wade, Brandon Jones, Demetrius Williams, and Michael Jenkins. Preferably I'd drop Horn who is on the downside of his career in favor of a guy who could have a breakout year. I guess the idea of Peyton Manning throwing to Anthony Gonzalez is probably going to make me want to keep him, in case it turns to be like Brandon Stokely in his big year. Any thoughts?

Keep Gonzo, but I have a feeling Horn will be Harrington's favorite target. If you're dead set on dropping Horn, grab Williams

[bsaza2358]

I would drop Horn for Marshall, Jones, or Williams. I like the upside and offsenses of these players better.

[Twiddler]

Keep Gonzo, but I have a feeling Horn will be Harrington's favorite target. If you're dead set on dropping Horn, grab Williams

That's the thing though, he may be Harrington's favorite target. While I like having top receivers, I prefer a lesser receiver with a better QB. And I was kind of thinking along the lines of what you said bsaza, now I just kind of need to make a choice.

[Twiddler]

I ended up pickup up Jones. We'll see if its a good move in the end. But in reality, it probably won't matter because he'll probablhy never play unless its a heavy bye week.

[thetedginnshow]

Okay, help me out here. Rank Torry Holt, Roy Williams, and Lee Evans in the order that you'd want them.

[Gridiron]

Who should I start at WR?

Demetrius Williams @ CIN

Craig Davis @ CHI

thanks

[Paul]

Okay, help me out here. Rank Torry Holt, Roy Williams, and Lee Evans in the order that you'd want them.

1A) Torry Holt
1B) Roy Williams
2) Lee Evans

Can't really go wrong.

[thetedginnshow]

So would you do Holt and JAX for Roy and GB? Or just might as well stay put?

[RoyHall#1]

So would you do Holt and JAX for Roy and GB? Or just might as well stay put?

Stay with Holt, he'll have a better year than Williams. Better team, less people taking the ball from him.

[princefielder28]

Who got the better deal????

Team A gets: Willie Parker and Jerricho Cotchery
Team B gets: Deuce McAllister and Larry Fitzgerald

[BrownsTown]

Who got the better deal????

Team A gets: Willie Parker and Jerricho Cotchery
Team B gets: Deuce McAllister and Larry Fitzgerald

Team A. But it's really close. I never do a trade unless I feel confident I'm getting the better deal.

[Twiddler]

wait till monday. i think curry's the best bet of that bunch, but *shrug*

I'll hopefully get a chance to see some of them in action this weekend and if they are still availble and I have changed my mind than I will make my move.

[thetedginnshow]

Is there a big difference fantasy-wise between these TEs? LJ Smith, Owen Daniels, Ben Watson, and Marcus Pollard. Considering touches, ability, and injuries.

[Shiver]

WR dilemma:

PPR league

Roddy White vs Minnesota
Demetrius Williams vs Baltimore
Greg Jennings vs Philadelphia
Brandon Marshall vs Buffalo

[thetedginnshow]

WR dilemma:

PPR league

Roddy White vs Minnesota
Demetrius Williams vs Baltimore
Greg Jennings vs Philadelphia
Brandon Marshall vs Buffalo

How many can you start? I'd go Jennings, then White, then Williams, then Marshall. Just because of how much the Falcons are throwing now, I'd have it between Jennings and White, and the other two are a little further away from those two.

[thetedginnshow]

Is there a big difference fantasy-wise between these TEs? LJ Smith, Owen Daniels, Ben Watson, and Marcus Pollard. Considering touches, ability, and injuries.

For the new page.

[Shiver]

How many can you start? I'd go Jennings, then White, then Williams, then Marshall. Just because of how much the Falcons are throwing now, I'd have it between Jennings and White, and the other two are a little further away from those two.



I have to choose one of them for my flex position. I have Terrell Owens, Lav Coles and Santonio Holmes starting already.

[scottyboy]

braylon against pit? or Shaun alexander against the bucs?

[thetedginnshow]

Which two should I start out of Betts, AD, and Witten?

And should I grab LJ Smith, Ben Watson, or Marcus Pollard?

[thetedginnshow]

Does this trade heavily favor one side?

Steven Jackson, Housh, Willie Parker, Jason Elam, and PHI
for
Shaun Alexander, Roy Williams, Travis Henry, Kellen Winslow, MIA

[yodapoop]

Who should I start (only 1):Sexy Rexy, Daunte, or Tavarius?

[BrownsTown]

Does this trade heavily favor one side?

Steven Jackson, Housh, Willie Parker, Jason Elam, and PHI
for
Shaun Alexander, Roy Williams, Travis Henry, Kellen Winslow, MIA

If the bottom team has any sort of TE, Jackson > Alexander, Housh and Roy are about equal, and Parker > Henry.

[thetedginnshow]

If the bottom team has any sort of TE, Jackson > Alexander, Housh and Roy are about equal, and Parker > Henry.

BTW do you know how Winslow has been? I haven't heard anything from him. The bottom team has Shockey, FYI.

[thebow305]

Who should I start (only 1):Sexy Rexy, Daunte, or Tavarius?


Start Rex.... I won't say that often, but Daunte isn't starting this week for the Raiders and I would start Steve Hutchinson at QB before Tavaris Jackson.

[BrownsTown]

BTW do you know how Winslow has been? I haven't heard anything from him. The bottom team has Shockey, FYI.

Winslow is still probably the most talented player on the Browns offense. Some think he may do better than Gates if he can get some redzone looks. And since the bottom one has Shockey, that's great for them.

[thebow305]

If the bottom team has any sort of TE, Jackson > Alexander, Housh and Roy are about equal, and Parker > Henry.


Willie Parker and Steven Jackson is just disgusting.

[BrownsTown]

Willie Parker and Steven Jackson is just disgusting.

Must be a small league. I got S-Jax, MJD, and Portis in a 12 team league.

[Shiver]

against any other team? jennings. this week? marshall. i could see a 3/60/1 game from him. not sure if the other guys can beat the corners on those teams.



I just remembered that the Bills now have Jason Webster as their #2 corner. That makes Marshall a lock in my books. Two years of Webster is enough to tell me that.

[thetedginnshow]

Oh. I thought it was Youboty. I had to have faith in the Buckeye. Yeah, Marshall's probably a good bet then.

Does anyone know how LJ Smith is doing exactly though? Because under any normal circumstance I'd pick him up for sure, but I'm not sure about his health. And then with Watson, I don't know exactly how many touches he'll get.

[RonnieRun23]

Pick 2 out of these 4

Branden Jones, Ronald Curry, Randy Moss, or Braylon Edwards

[princefielder28]

Pick 2 out of these 4

Branden Jones, Ronald Curry, Randy Moss, or Braylon Edwards

Edwards and Moss

[SuperMcGee]

Oh. I thought it was Youboty. I had to have faith in the Buckeye.

This still seems to be a misconception by quite a few people, even though Thomas is the nickel back and Youboty has been behind Webster and Greer all preseason.

[Caddy]

I <3 Reggie Wayne.

[Crazy_Chris]

Which two should I start out of Betts, AD, and Witten?

And should I grab LJ Smith, Ben Watson, or Marcus Pollard?

Start Adrian Peterson and Witten

[Nelo Ice]

so my cousin asked me to fill his final spot in a 12 team league...only problem is no one could make any of the drafts and the final draft time he could set was sep 4th at 11 and no one could make it either so my team was completely random based on my pre draft rankings lol


i ended up getting
peyton manning
marvin harrison
reggie wayne
chris chambers
marty booker(dropping him for wes welker, dont like miamis offense heh)
edge
clinton portis
chester taylor
todd heap
dallas clark
vinatieri
nedney
Bears D
Jags D

i ended up starting every colt but clark btw
just wondering im thinkin jto ust go with jags D against the titans and should i try to unload chambers along with booker

[thefalconer]

i would try to trade wayne or harrison for a andre johnson or someone with a little less caliber. having four players from the same offense is not smart in ff. otherwise, you got yourself a decent team considering no real draft was conducted.

[bsaza2358]

so my cousin asked me to fill his final spot in a 12 team league...only problem is no one could make any of the drafts and the final draft time he could set was sep 4th at 11 and no one could make it either so my team was completely random based on my pre draft rankings lol


i ended up getting
peyton manning
marvin harrison
reggie wayne
chris chambers
marty booker(dropping him for wes welker, dont like miamis offense heh)
edge
clinton portis
chester taylor
todd heap
dallas clark
vinatieri
nedney
Bears D
Jags D

i ended up starting every colt but clark btw
just wondering im thinkin jto ust go with jags D against the titans and should i try to unload chambers along with booker

I would try to unload Harrison or Wayne with Portis or Taylor for a RB upgrade. I'm not a huge fan of your RB's. Clark is a decent TE option, but he's not better than a top 10 guy most weeks.

[RoyHall#1]

I would try to unload Harrison or Wayne with Portis or Taylor for a RB upgrade. I'm not a huge fan of your RB's. Clark is a decent TE option, but he's not better than a top 10 guy most weeks.

And drop Nedney for a WR or RB.

[thebow305]

OK....

Kevin Curtis @ Green Bay or
Vincent Jackson Vs. Chicago or
Jerricho Cothcery Vs. New England

Who should I start?

[thebow305]

Ok... Keeping in mind, my recievers are Kevin Curtis, Jerricho Cotchery, Plaxico Burress, Vincent Jackson, and Ted Ginn Jr., would it be smart of me to offer a trade such as:

LaDainian and Jerricho Cotchery

for

Steven Jackson and Torry Holt

[bsaza2358]

I'd ask for a little more on the LDT side. Holt's injury worries me.

[RoyHall#1]

I'm against trading LT period. That deal's close, but I'd stick with LT.

[Jughead10]

Just picked up Crayton to start against my Giants. Glenn is out two weeks and now ESPN is saying he might be put on IR.

[thebow305]

In a Yahoo league, if I put up LaDainian on the trading block, just to see what I will get for him, looking for a RB and WR in return, if someone offers me a WR and RB it won't automatically do the trade will it? I have to approve any trade first right?

[bsaza2358]

Unless there is an actual trade agreement, offers are offers.

[nvot9]

Who to start at QB? Should I go with Carson Palmer against the Ravens or Alex Smith against the Cardinals?

[Shiver]

WR dilemma:

PPR league

Roddy White vs Minnesota
Demetrius Williams vs Baltimore
Greg Jennings vs Philadelphia
Brandon Marshall vs Buffalo

against any other team? jennings. this week? marshall. i could see a 3/60/1 game from him. not sure if the other guys can beat the corners on those teams.

Now Terry Glenn is out. Do I start Patrick Crayton over those receivers? I am a little leery of starting both Crayton and Owens. Thoughts?

[Jughead10]

Now Terry Glenn is out. Do I start Patrick Crayton over those receivers? I am a little leery of starting both Crayton and Owens. Thoughts?

Our DBs suck. Start em both.

[BrownsTown]

Amani Toomer for Chris Henry, RB. I got Toomer. Should I do it?

[Jughead10]

Amani Toomer for Chris Henry, RB. I got Toomer. Should I do it?

I dunno how many carries Henry will be getting? Toomer will be a starter. And he is Eli's safety net. If he stays healthy I'd guess 700 yards and 6 TDs on the season.

[bsaza2358]

I'm not sure how well Toomer will hold up this season, since he's over 30 and is coming off an Achilles tear. That kind of surgery can end careers. Many players who have Achilles injuries never recoup their prior skills. The Giants have 2 young WR's in Smith and Moss, and I expect them to make plays and see the field. I would hold Henry and try to get a less questionable player in a stronger offense.

[fenikz]

Who should i start as my 2nd RB?

Clinton Portis vs Miami
Edgerrin James vs San Fransico

&

would you drop any of these players for Warrick Dunn?

QB Carson Palmer
WR Lee Evans
WR Laveranues Coles
WR Joey Galloway
RB Stephen Jackson
RB Clinton Portis
TE Antonio Gates
B Edge James
B Jerious Norwood
B Tatum Bell
B Jerry Porter
B Mark Clayton
B Matt Leinart

[bsaza2358]

That is a tough call fen. I think that James will get more touches and plays against an easier D. Miami's front 7 is pretty tough. SF's is also talented, but still developing.

[thetedginnshow]

Hmm. I can't decide if I should start Roy Williams or Lee Evans. Or start both and sit Andre Johnson.

[bsaza2358]

I'm not a huge fan of the Evans matchup against Denver because he will be doubled all game by Champ and a safety. I think Williams is a must-start. When in doubt, choose the guy going against the worst D.

I say start Williams and Johnson.

[nvot9]

Who to start at QB? Should I go with Carson Palmer against the Ravens or Alex Smith against the Cardinals?

My gut feeling was to take a risk and go with Alex Smith, because he's looking very sharp and is facing a pretty bad pass defense, meanwhile, Carson Palmer's facing a very strong Ravens D who he doesn't have a great history against..

[thebow305]

Who should i start as my 2nd RB?

Clinton Portis vs Miami
Edgerrin James vs San Fransico

&

would you drop any of these players for Warrick Dunn?

QB Carson Palmer
WR Lee Evans
WR Laveranues Coles
WR Joey Galloway
RB Stephen Jackson
RB Clinton Portis
TE Antonio Gates
B Edge James
B Jerious Norwood
B Tatum Bell
B Jerry Porter
B Mark Clayton
B Matt Leinart


It's gotta be James for sure. I know I'm a homer, but Clinton Portis won't gain more than 40-45 yards on our defense. If that!

[bsaza2358]

there isn't a safety on our roster capable of double covering lee evans. my grandmother could burn lynch or ferguson.

Taking into account the pass rush differential and overall secondary quality, I believe that Johnson will have more opportunities for big plays than Evans this week.

[bsaza2358]

That being said, having to choose between Williams, Johnson, and Evans is a good problem to have.

[thetedginnshow]

That being said, having to choose between Williams, Johnson, and Evans is a good problem to have.

Well, it isn't just them. I have Boldin too, haha. But he's a lock.

[Nelo Ice]

I would try to unload Harrison or Wayne with Portis or Taylor for a RB upgrade. I'm not a huge fan of your RB's. Clark is a decent TE option, but he's not better than a top 10 guy most weeks.

well i put wayne portis and nedney on the the block
gonna see if i i can try pulling off steven jackson from another team in my league
his wrs are plaxico buress darrel jackson and vincent jackson

[KCJ58]

will Mason Crosby start for the Packers

[AlexDown]

1 point every 10 yards for WR and 6 for a TD

Who should I start

Braylon Edwards against PIT

L. Coles against NE

B.Berrain against SD

[MNRunLeft]

Who should I start this week Donald Driver against Philly or Mark Clayton against the Bengals? I'm up 39 after the Thursday night game I had Addai and Wayne and the team I'm playing had Brees.

[nvot9]

Phili's got a very good D, but Driver is worlds better than Clayton in my book, plus the Bengals have Deltha O'Neal, so I'd start Driver.

Bumping my question again...

Should I start Carson Palmer against a tremendous Ravens D who he's had trouble against, or up and coming Alex Smith against a weak Cardinals D?

[MNRunLeft]

I'd start Palmer, he's actually had some good games against he Ravens last year Chad Johnson and Housh each had big games against ravens. I'm starting Chad and I have no worries.

[BrownsTown]

1 point every 10 yards for WR and 6 for a TD

Who should I start

Braylon Edwards against PIT

L. Coles against NE

B.Berrain against SD

I may be a homer, but Braylon is a big physical reciever and will get more redzone looks than the other too, not to mention he's facing the worst defense of the 3.

[BrownsTown]

I'm not sure how well Toomer will hold up this season, since he's over 30 and is coming off an Achilles tear. That kind of surgery can end careers. Many players who have Achilles injuries never recoup their prior skills. The Giants have 2 young WR's in Smith and Moss, and I expect them to make plays and see the field. I would hold Henry and try to get a less questionable player in a stronger offense.

I have Toomer, I'd be getting Henry.

[Shiver]

I may be a homer, but Braylon is a big physical reciever and will get more redzone looks than the other too, not to mention he's facing the worst defense of the 3.

I would take Pittsburgh's defense, right now, over both San Diego and New England.

[thefalconer]

muhammed or crayton?

start marion barber or muhammed/crayton?

[duckseason]

muhammed or crayton?

start marion barber or muhammed/crayton?

Start Barber. The RB/WR position is almost always better utilized by playing a RB if you have one. He's much more likely to score than the other two. I'd say it's a tossup between Muhammad and Crayton. I'd probably give Crayton the edge this week considering Muhammad's slight injury concerns and the fact that Crayton will almost certainly see single coverage all night against a suspect secondary.

Oh, and don't forget about the potential Ron Rivera effect.

[thefalconer]

how about santonio holmes, crayton, or michael turner?

[RonnieRun23]

Should I drop Matt Schaub and pick up Alex Smith/J.P. Losman?

This is for my back-up quarterback.

[Billingsley26]

allright heres my question:

LJ Smith or Randy Mcmichael to start this weekend??

[thefalconer]

Should I drop Matt Schaub and pick up Alex Smith/J.P. Losman?

This is for my back-up quarterback.

i would pick up alex smith in a heartbeat.

[BrownsTown]

Should I drop Matt Schaub and pick up Alex Smith/J.P. Losman?

This is for my back-up quarterback.

Funny thing is...JP Losman and Alex Smith are my platooning starters...

I'd go Smith.

[RonnieRun23]

Should I drop DeAngelo Williams/Jerious Norwood for LaMont Jordan?

[TimD]

Should I drop DeAngelo Williams/Jerious Norwood for LaMont Jordan?

i heard lamont wasn't doing that well this summer... this may be rumor but im just saying what i heard

[B-Dawk]

should i start Fred Taylor or Lamont Jordan for my last RB slot

[duckseason]

should i start Fred Taylor or Lamont Jordan for my last RB slot

Don't even hesitate to go with Taylor. The Lions are actually kinda stout up front and I expect the Raiders to attack them through the air. RB's on teams that are projected to win are always a good idea. Not that the Raiders won't beat the Lions, but I think the Jags have a good shot at being up by a few scores in the fourth thereby increasing the overall carries for the RB's. Oh, and Taylor is just a better overall RB.

[P-L]

I'd go with Fred Taylor. I don't expect the Raiders to run the ball against the Lions for two reasons: They won't be able to and they will be picking apart our secondary. I think Taylor is the better back anyways.

[Caddy]

Should I drop DeAngelo Williams/Jerious Norwood for LaMont Jordan?

I wouldn't.

Norwood and Williams have way more potential to score points than Lamont Jordan playing for a pitiful Oakland offense.

[Zbikowski_9]

Who should i start, Marshawn Lynch (Bills) or Edge James (cards)

I drafted edge before Lynch, but i am sort of regretting it.

Whoever it is at least they will be with LT.

Alsoshould i change anything at WR

Andre Johnson
Hines Ward
Braylon Edwards

Gre Jennings
Brandan Jones


and Qb Buldger over Lienart?

and finaly Ben Watson (pats) over Miller (pits)

[alca1992]

Who should i start, Marshawn Lynch (Bills) or Edge James (cards)

I drafted edge before Lynch, but i am sort of regretting it.

Whoever it is at least they will be with LT.

Alsoshould i change anything at WR

Andre Johnson
Hines Ward
Braylon Edwards

Gre Jennings
Brandan Jones


and Qb Buldger over Lienart?

and finaly Ben Watson (pats) over Miller (pits)

i think i would go with lynch. i dont know why its just a good hunch. evreything else is fine

[NYGibril28]

Clinton Portis @ Miami or Santonio Holmes @ Cleveland

???

[BrownsTown]

Clinton Portis @ Miami or Santonio Holmes @ Cleveland

???

Always go with the RB...plus Holmes will be matched up with Eric Wright, most likely.

[GB12]

For anyone that has him, sit Greg Jennings. He is out this week against the Eagles.

[BrownsTown]

Ok here's my starting lineup with a few key backups, tell me anyone I should switch out/in

Alex Smith at Arizona
MJD at Tennessee
S-Jax at Carolina
Fitz at San Fran
Marvin Harrison at NO (too late)

I've got Leon Washington, who will be getting more carries, Clinton Portis and JP Losman on the bench. Oh, and Brandon Marshall.

[alca1992]

looks pretty good

[alca1992]

calvin johnson
mark clayton
patrick crayton

which 2 should i start

[Billingsley26]

LJ Smith or Randy Mcmichael this week to strt at TE? Anyone???

[alca1992]

LJ Smith or Randy Mcmichael this week to strt at TE? Anyone???

mcmicheal. i have a really good feeling about him

[Billingsley26]

calvin johnson
mark clayton
patrick crayton

which 2 should i start

Calvin Johnson and Clayton. Clayton I think is for sure the #1 guy in baltimore. CJ and Crayton I think will be #3's today, but CJ I expect to get more looks and touces. Id go with CJ and Clayton.

[alca1992]

Calvin Johnson and Clayton. Clayton I think is for sure the #1 guy in baltimore. CJ and Crayton I think will be #3's today, but CJ I expect to get more looks and touces. Id go with CJ and Clayton.

yea but what about crayton alot of people are saying he will have a lot of points this week

[BrownsTown]

Calvin Johnson and Clayton. Clayton I think is for sure the #1 guy in baltimore. CJ and Crayton I think will be #3's today, but CJ I expect to get more looks and touces. Id go with CJ and Clayton.

Crayton's number two, Glenn is out. And CJ is against the Raiders. Go Clayton and Crayton.

[Billingsley26]

Crayton's number two, Glenn is out. And CJ is against the Raiders. Go Clayton and Crayton.

Ya I forgot about Terry Glenn. I think hes right, go with Clayton and Crayton. Makes sense.

[alca1992]

one more question

Should i sit Lee Evens (whos facing Denver-which means champ bailey) in favor of patrick crayton (another leauge)

[Billingsley26]

one more question

Should i sit Lee Evens (whos facing Denver-which means champ bailey) in favor of patrick crayton (another leauge)

I wouldnt do that. Denver has no safties worthy of covering Lee Evans. I expect, and from what I hear here in Buffalo, they will try to exploit the middle of the field on Denver. I wouldnt sit him, I have a good feeling that Buffalo will surprise today.

[BrownsTown]

Oh my god, my RBs are doing absolutely horrible.

[Scotty D]

Oh my god, my RBs are doing absolutely horrible.

Yeah I still have Cadilliac to go but Steven Jackson gave me 1.5 pts. I should win though.

[thetedginnshow]

Oh thank god I didn't listen to that one guy. Lee Evans with a nice 0 points. Roy at least got 7 or 8.

[RoyHall#1]

I have 6 fantasy teams and all 6 are very likely to win thanks to Jon Kitna... who is on 5 of them. And Andre Johnson helped (on 4).

[Tubby]

Who got the better of this trade

Team A gets Donovan McNabb and Darrell Jackson
Team B gets Jon Kitna and Donald Driver

Team A has Torry Holt, Roy Williams, Chris Chambers, and Brandon Marshall as their other WR's
Team B has Chad Johnson, Braylon Edwards, DJ Hackett, and Brandon Jones as their other WR's

Team A has Eli Manning as their other QB
Team B has Matt Hasselbeck and Matt Schaub as their other QB's

[princefielder28]

Who got the better of this trade

Team A gets Donovan McNabb and Darrell Jackson
Team B gets Jon Kitna and Donald Driver

Team A has Torry Holt, Roy Williams, Chris Chambers, and Brandon Marshall as their other WR's
Team B has Chad Johnson, Braylon Edwards, DJ Hackett, and Brandon Jones as their other WR's

Team A has Eli Manning as their other QB
Team B has Matt Hasselbeck and Matt Schaub as their other QB's

Team B, no doubt

[thetedginnshow]

So Shaun and Henry got me a combined 34 points. I was going to trade a guy those two for Steven Jackson and Willie Parker. Haha. Now I should be able to get them for cheap... wish me luck!

[RoyHall#1]

So Shaun and Henry got me a combined 34 points. I was going to trade a guy those two for Steven Jackson and Willie Parker. Haha. Now I should be able to get them for cheap... wish me luck!

Yeah, you should definitely do that trade. Most people would probably do that now if they were in his shoes.

[JeffSamardzijaIRISH]

Nice 0 points Lee Evans, and only 7 points Ronnie Brown. 1 Point from Steven Jackson, 3 from Cedric Benson, and now I need Plax to give me 16 more points for a win on one team. Donte' Stallworth gave me 1 point and 4 from Colston. 2 points for Jamaal Lewis and 18 points in total for this team, although 4 players haven't played yet, but I don't think they can get 90 points... Deuce McAllister giving me 3 points, but oh well, atleast I can salvage a win........

[Billingsley26]

Nice 0 points Lee Evans, and only 7 points Ronnie Brown. 1 Point from Steven Jackson, 3 from Cedric Benson, and now I need Plax to give me 16 more points for a win on one team. Donte' Stallworth gave me 1 point and 4 from Colston. 2 points for Jamaal Lewis and 18 points in total for this team, although 4 players haven't played yet, but I don't think they can get 90 points... Deuce McAllister giving me 3 points, but oh well, atleast I can salvage a win........

Well right now Plax has 4 catches for 97 and 2 td's

[D-Unit]

What do you make of Belichick's use of Maroney?

[bsaza2358]

Between Eli, Plax, Romo, and TO, last night's game had monster fantasy implications for Week 1. Unfortunately, with the injuries to Eli, Jacobs, and Umenyiora, the GMen are looking pretty soft...

[bsaza2358]

Sell high on Brown if you can...

[bsaza2358]

Maybe you could trust Peterson, but who would really pick Curry and Brown to explode to that extent. I am pretty confident that both won't replicate those single numbers again the rest of the season.

[Billingsley26]

i wish the guy with jackson was an idiot. i'd go for that trade.

what's sad is that i had brown, peterson and curry on my bench this week because i wasn't sure they'd do anything this early. so much hate.

Im feeling your pain right now. Not exactly the same, but still pretty bad for my team.

Willie Parker, eh
Brian Westbrook, eh
Roy Williams, NOTHING
Marc Bulger, NOTHING
Randy Mcmichael, NOTHING
Plaxico Burress, I LIKE, I LIKE ALOT

I mean come on, on paper that looks like one hell of a team. BTW, the team I am playing, started Tom Brady, Marshawn Lynch, Adrian Peterson, Steve Smith and Calvin Johnson. Ive pretty much lost this one.

EDIT- I am ashamed to say I got beat by a bunch of rookies.

[McGahee]

Hey, I had the 2nd overall pick and took LJ, here's my team

QB:
Marc Bulger
Alex Smith
John Kitna

RB:
Larry Johnson
Ronnie Brown
Michael Turner
Vernand Morrency

WR:
Marvin Harrison
Javon Walker
Isaac Bruce
Mike Furrey
Robert Meachem
Dwayne Bowe

TE:
Chris Cooley
Randy McMichael

K:
Jeff Wilkins

Def:
Chargers


Who do you guys think is expendable? Who should I try and trade for?

I'm thinking of dropping Meachem and picking up DJ Hackett or Nate Burleson (which one is better?)

And I also need to dump Turner.

Any trade scenarios/ideas would be great

[bsaza2358]

Curry always had the talent, but he has had Achilles tendon repair surgery on both ankles and hasn't done anything consistently on the field in his 4-5 years in the league. When he's healthy, he flashes considerable talent, but I always question converted QB's and Achilles surgeries. Kudos to those who took that risk.

[bsaza2358]

Hey, I had the 2nd overall pick and took LJ, here's my team

QB:
Marc Bulger
Alex Smith
John Kitna

RB:
Larry Johnson
Ronnie Brown
Michael Turner
Vernand Morrency

WR:
Marvin Harrison
Javon Walker
Isaac Bruce
Mike Furrey
Robert Meachem
Dwayne Bowe

TE:
Chris Cooley
Randy McMichael

K:
Jeff Wilkins

Def:
Chargers

Your RB's are a big, big problem. I don't think Brown or LJ will get consistent push early on this year. Morency is useless. Turner is okay as a #4 for now. You need to drop Meachem and pick up Burleson. You need to trade your WR depth for RB upgrades. See if you can move a QB as well.

[thetedginnshow]

Hey does anyone here know in a Yahoo! league if I drop a starter that's already played their game at this point, will I lose their points for the week, or are those points already logged?

[Sportsfan486]

I've got 109 points with 1 RB, my TE and Kicker yet to play..

I think I could win.

Tom Brady
Rudi Johnson
Lamont Jordan
Travis Henry
T.O.
Javon Walker
Vernon Davis
Neil Rackers
Packers D

..plus a strong bench.. yeah.. I'm totally winning this year.

[Scotty D]

I need Cadillac Wiliams injury info!

[bsaza2358]

Hey does anyone here know in a Yahoo! league if I drop a starter that's already played their game at this point, will I lose their points for the week, or are those points already logged?

You should be okay. Players are usually locked when their game starts.

[thetedginnshow]

You should be okay. Players are usually locked when their game starts.

As in their stats or the actual player? Because I can drop starters, but I am worried that the points will go away.

[thetedginnshow]

Yeah, I figured out. I automatically get the guy, it just doesn't show up until after the week's games.

[bsaza2358]

Exactly. Players starting when the games start are locked for the week, then it processes effective Week 2.

[JETS5128]

Guys, with Pace out how much do you think that will affect S-jax's numbers, should i try to trade him???

[thetedginnshow]

Guys, with Pace out how much do you think that will affect S-jax's numbers, should i try to trade him???

Depends on what you'd be getting. I wouldn't downgrade immensely, because he played last year for a while without Pace and did just fine. But if you can get a great deal out of it, go for it.

[JETS5128]

THinking about trying to trade for Harrison and Gore but not sure if it's worth it

[TimD]

Guys, with Pace out how much do you think that will affect S-jax's numbers, should i try to trade him???

not after a crappy week 1... give him at least another game to rebuild his stock or prove himself to you

[duckseason]

Yeah, always remember to sell high and buy low. If you think Jackson's production will take a big dip this year, wait for him to have that inevitable big game and for your opponent to have a big need at RB. Then proceed to pillage.

[Twiddler]

Okay, on my main team I have both Marc Bulger and Steven Jackson for a ten team league. Didn't seem like a bad idea in the beginning, but now that Orlando Pace is out for the year, I am looking to shop Steven. Is this a good idea? My thoughts is that his production won't be at the level of a #2 pick so I might be able to salvage value quickly out of him. I know its fast and its only after one week but I think that losing Pace is really going to hurt him badly, moreso than Bulger, who it will also hurt considerably.

[JETS5128]

Yeah, i definetly think i'll wait this one out, no reason to act right away

[Twiddler]

Yeah, i definetly think i'll wait this one out, no reason to act right away

I'll see what kind of offers I get though. I mean, at this point, my team is falling apart for various reasons and I'm in 9th place so if I can get a deal that might help me out at other positions then yes, I'll do it. I've got nothing to lose in this league.

[Billingsley26]

Since when does Ed Reed return punts???

Nate Clements is holding it down nicely as well. Hes looking good for 88 mil right now.

[Twiddler]

Since when does Ed Reed return punts???

Nate Clements is holding it down nicely as well. Hes looking good for 88 mil right now.

From what I understand he was in there because BJ Sams couldn't because of some injury I believe. Could be wrong though.

[Billingsley26]

From what I understand he was in there because BJ Sams couldn't because of some injury I believe. Could be wrong though.

Well, he ran back a 63 yarder for a TD. Looks like it worked.

[UKfan]

Would you trade LJ for SJax?

[princefielder28]

Would you trade LJ for SJax?

SJax > LJ............

[drowe]

so, apparently i had the "All Disappointment Team" this week.

QB-Leinart
RB-Bush
RB-McGahee
WR-Lee Evans
WR-Boldin
WR-Stallworth
TE-McMichael
DEF-Bears

my butt hurts.

[Twiddler]

so, apparently i had the "All Disappointment Team" this week.

QB-Leinart
RB-Bush
RB-McGahee
WR-Lee Evans
WR-Boldin
WR-Stallworth
TE-McMichael
DEF-Bears

my butt hurts.

I feel your pain man, I had a pretty rough week too. But not at the level of yours.

QB-Marc Bulger
RB-Steven Jackson
RB-Cedric Benson
WR-Steve Smith(thank the lord)
WR-Roy Williams
WR-Reggie Brown
TE-Chris Cooley
DEF-Miami
D-Keith Bullock(3 tackles)
K-Robbie Gould

[SuperMcGee]

I lost this week because I had Witten on the bench. I had the only matchup where that would've made a difference, and I'm currently in last because the only people that can do anything for me are Balt's D/ST (thank you Ed Reed) and Andre Johnson

and yeah, how would you rate LJ this week against Chicago? I'm ready to play Marion Barber over him.

[princefielder28]

so, apparently i had the "All Disappointment Team" this week.

QB-Leinart
RB-Bush
RB-McGahee
WR-Lee Evans
WR-Boldin
WR-Stallworth
TE-McMichael
DEF-Bears

my butt hurts.

Oh wow!......can't say much about that; I guess it can't get any worse in the upcmoing weeks

[Wootylicous]

Here is mine :

QB - M. Bulger
RB - R. Johnson
RB - B. Westbrook
WR - P. Burress
WR - D. Driver
WR - H. Ward
TE - K. Winslow
K - Jason Elam
DST - Colts

[thetedginnshow]

I lost this week because I had Witten on the bench. I had the only matchup where that would've made a difference, and I'm currently in last because the only people that can do anything for me are Balt's D/ST (thank you Ed Reed) and Andre Johnson

and yeah, how would you rate LJ this week against Chicago? I'm ready to play Marion Barber over him.

Yikes. At the last second, I switched Betts to Witten. Looking forward, Witten's supposed to be used in more packages this year and in sets where he'll be like a WR and get plays downfield, so he could be a fantasy stud so long as the Dallas offense stays hot.

[SuperMcGee]

Yikes. At the last second, I switched Betts to Witten. Looking forward, Witten's supposed to be used in more packages this year and in sets where he'll be like a WR and get plays downfield, so he could be a fantasy stud so long as the Dallas offense stays hot.

My original plan was to put Witten into what I thought was a W/R/T slot, but was actually limited to W/R. So instead I played (ugh) Deion Branch :(

[bearfan]

Alright, I am in a ppr league. Normal scoring otherwise, and my friend wants a trade:

I get:
Rudi Johnson

He gets:
Reggie Bush

Now I am real tempted to take it, Rudi is consistant 1200yrd+ seasons w/ 12-14TDs a year. My only problem is that Bush is an awesome ppr guy, and while he may get less TDs, he will get 60-90 rec. this year (if follows last year), and then add on the rushing yards and recieving yards. What do you guys think?

[bsaza2358]

I think Bush will match Rudi's yardage this year with 5-6 TD's, but the PPR is the kicker. I'd stick with Reggie.

[Shiver]

I am contemplating picking up Tarvaris Jackson and dropping Alex Smith (QB). Is that a wise decision?

[Vikes99ej]

Okay guys...

Tom Brady vs. SD or Jay Cutler vs. OAK?

Gore @ STL, AD @ DET, LT @ NE, MJD vs. ATL, or Betts @ PHI?

I'm thinking about starting Peterson at Detroit, but I'm not sure.

[thetedginnshow]

Okay guys...

Tom Brady vs. SD or Jay Cutler vs. OAK?

Gore @ STL, AD @ DET, LT @ NE, MJD vs. ATL, or Betts @ PHI?

I'm thinking about starting Peterson at Detroit, but I'm not sure.

I actually think I'd take Brady. I just think they could exploit that secondary, and have a solid enough line to handle that blitz.

How many RBs are you starting? I'd rank it Gore, Drew, LT, AD, and then Betts, but it is always tough to sit LT... I just imagine that Gore will bounce back big, Drew should demolish ATL and I think they'll definitely focus on running it more this week, LT is always worth points and I think he'll have some extra motivation going up against NE, AD seems wise as the Raiders had a ton of rushing yards against the Lions though the Vikes don't quite have as great of a passing attack, and Betts might be getting less and less carries. That's how I see it anyway.

[Vikes99ej]

I actually think I'd take Brady. I just think they could exploit that secondary, and have a solid enough line to handle that blitz.

How many RBs are you starting? I'd rank it Gore, Drew, LT, AD, and then Betts, but it is always tough to sit LT... I just imagine that Gore will bounce back big, Drew should demolish ATL and I think they'll definitely focus on running it more this week, LT is always worth points and I think he'll have some extra motivation going up against NE, AD seems wise as the Raiders had a ton of rushing yards against the Lions though the Vikes don't quite have as great of a passing attack, and Betts might be getting less and less carries. That's how I see it anyway.

I start two runningbacks.

[Vikes99ej]

seems difficult to argue with starting LT and Gore. moreso considering LT's likely pissed about last week.

Yeah, I just looked at Gore's and LT's stats against those teams during the last two years, and that's who I think I'm going with.

[Paul]

A few different leagues.

D. McNabb vs Was
or
J. Cutler vs. Oak


Randle El vs Phi
or
B. Marshall vs. Oak

And which combination of 2 RB should I use this week
Steven Jackson vs SF
Marion Barber vs Mia
Clinton Portis vs Phi

[princefielder28]

A few different leagues.

D. McNabb vs Was
or
J. Cutler vs. Oak


Randle El vs Phi
or
B. Marshall vs. Oak

And which combination of 2 RB should I use this week
Steven Jackson vs SF
Marion Barber vs Mia
Clinton Portis vs Phi

McNabb, Randle El, Steven Jackson, and Marion Barber

[Shiver]

A few different leagues.

D. McNabb vs Was
or
J. Cutler vs. Oak


Randle El vs Phi
or
B. Marshall vs. Oak

And which combination of 2 RB should I use this week
Steven Jackson vs SF
Marion Barber vs Mia
Clinton Portis vs Phi

McNabb
Marshall
Jackson
Portis

[AlexDown]

I may be a homer, but Braylon is a big physical reciever and will get more redzone looks than the other too, not to mention he's facing the worst defense of the 3.

Good thing I started Coles!

[KCJ58]

Should I accept this trade

I Give:
Jay Cutler (QB)
Thomas Jones (RB)
Heins Ward (WR)

I Recieve:
Matt Leinart (QB)
Maurice Jones Drew (RB)
Braylon Edwards (WR)

[KCJ58]

^^^^^^^^
any 1 im stuck and i need to make a choice

[duckseason]

^^^^^^^^
any 1 im stuck and i need to make a choice

It obviously depends on what value you put on each individual player, but I'd personally reject it. I think it looks to be pretty even, and I only like to make trades when I feel I have the clear advantage. I don't think you'd be getting ripped off if you pull the trig, but I just wouldn't personally feel the need to do so. If you're looking to off some of those players, do so when their stock is up a bit more.

[thetedginnshow]

Should I accept this trade

I Give:
Jay Cutler (QB)
Thomas Jones (RB)
Heins Ward (WR)

I Recieve:
Matt Leinart (QB)
Maurice Jones Drew (RB)
Braylon Edwards (WR)

Personally, I wouldn't do it. Cutler and Leinart will probably put somewhat similar numbers throughout the season. Hines should be far more consistent than Braylon. And I don't particularly have a ton of faith in Drew to stay healthy, and he still does technically split carries, and if Jones stays healthy all year he should be solid. But of course, Cutler could have a breakout season, Leinart could crumble, Drew stays healthy and dominates, Ward gets injured, and Quinn comes in and turns Braylon into a stud. So it's really up to you.

[alca1992]

ok im saying im going to chosse adrian peterosn (MIN). who should i switch with Reggie Bush or Larry Johnson

[drowe]

ok im saying im going to chosse adrian peterosn (MIN). who should i switch with Reggie Bush or Larry Johnson


yeah, i'd start bush. johnson against the bears isn't a great matchup. he may score once, but, he'd be hard pressed to have a GREAT game. Bush has the higher upside.

[drowe]

ok, i need help
Matt Leinart vs Seattle
or
Rex Grossman vs KC

also,
Miami's defense vs Dallas
or
Buffalo's defense vs Pittsburgh

[Newbs24]

Need a little help. I know some of the guys like Portis are still nursing injuries (now he has bruised ribs) but just looking on who to start for my free league.

WR/RB:
Brandon Jackson vs NYG
Santanio Holmes vs BUF
Brandon Marshall vs OAK
Clinton Portis vs PHI
Derrick Ward vs GB

Also which QB should I start in my big money league. QB is without a doubt the weakest spot on my team.
Jay Cutler vs OAK
Matt Schaub vs CAR.

I think I am gonna go with Cutler because Carolina has a good D.

[princefielder28]

Need a little help. I know some of the guys like Portis are still nursing injuries (now he has bruised ribs) but just looking on who to start for my free league.

WR/RB:
Brandon Jackson vs NYG
Santanio Holmes vs BUF
Brandon Marshall vs OAK
Clinton Portis vs PHI
Derrick Ward vs GB

Also which QB should I start in my big money league. QB is without a doubt the weakest spot on my team.
Jay Cutler vs OAK
Matt Schaub vs CAR.

I think I am gonna go with Cutler because Carolina has a good D.

Go with Portis and Cutler; Detroit was able to throw he ball well against Oakland and Carolina shut down the St. Louis passing attack so Cutler is the way to go

[Newbs24]

Thanks alot. Another question. I just won my first game and usually have good luck when I stick with my original teams but I was wondering if anybody had any suggestions on how to improve my team. I am in a 12 team league. We start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, TE, K, D/ST. I got luck they forgot to add the flex.

QB: Cutler, Schaub, Garrard
RB: LT, TJones, Norwood, Ahman Green
WR: Harrison, Andre Johnson, Wes Welker, Patrick Crayton
TE: Ben Watson, Tony Scheffler
K: Jeff Wilkins (STL)
D/ST: Bengals (picked them up to go against Cleveland), NYJ.

The team isn't all that good but I am hoping that Dunn gets hurt and I can plug Norwood in if needed. I am not that happy with Jones as my #2 RB but was wondering if any good deals could be made. Every team is pretty even in our league. Thats what you get when $100 per person is thrown into the pot for some big payouts.

[Newbs24]

with a team that small, you should have some good waiver wire guys available.

Not at all. Actually I am maxed out on the number of players at each position except for the K spot. I think I am gonna hold out and play with my team. I like what I am hearing about Norwood this week already so I think think he will be a good start for me.

[Godsend]

would you cut adalius thomas or larry foote for stephen cooper? i'm in a dinasty league, i have thomas and foote in their last year of contract, i could sign cooper for two years.
my other two LBs are tatupu (3 years remaining) and june (last year of contract).

what would you do? let cooper go or sign him?

[TheMadLionsFan]

John Kitna or Marc Bulger

[BrownsTown]

Pick two: Steven Jackson against San Fran, Clinton Portis against Phili, Maurice Jones-Drew against...I forget.

Pick one: Alex Smith vs. Stl or JP Losman vs. Pittsburgh

[princefielder28]

Pick two: Steven Jackson against San Fran, Clinton Portis against Phili, Maurice Jones-Drew against...I forget.

Pick one: Alex Smith vs. Stl or JP Losman vs. Pittsburgh

Steven Jackson, Jones-Drew, and Alex Smith

[BrownsTown]

Steven Jackson, Jones-Drew, and Alex Smith

MJD did horrible last week...I'm hesitant to put him in.

[thetedginnshow]

MJD did horrible last week...I'm hesitant to put him in.

Then why ask? Haha. But Drew is against the Falcons, who Peterson ran all over last week, while I believe Jackson for the Pack didn't quite do as well against the Eagles. Not that that should be the deciding factor, but it's something to consider. I'd just figure Drew would get more carries this week, while Portis with bruised ribs, may not have another monster game. But you never know.

[princefielder28]

MJD did horrible last week...I'm hesitant to put him in.

Atlanta's rush defense wasn't the most impressive against Minnesota and Jones-Drew can put up yards quick

[bantx]

my fantasy is going good out of 3 of my fantasy teams i got 2nd in 2 and 3rd in one im awesome

[KCJ58]

who should i start this week

Carnell "Cadillac" Williams or Ahman Grren

[Crazy_Chris]

If Carnell is Healthy enough to play go with him but from what i've read right now he's a game time Decision. Also after what Carolina Did to steven Jackson i don't like Ahman Greens chances of having a big game this week.

[fenikz]

Who should I start this week?

Phillip Rivers @ NE
Jay Cutler vs Oak

Edgerrin James vs Sea
Clinton Portis @ Phi

MJD vs ATL
Chris Brown vs IND

[SuperMcGee]

League 1:
I need a W/R starter out of Joey Galloway, Deion Branch, Jerious Norwood, Derrick Ward

One TE out of: Witten @MIA, V. Davis @STL

League 2:
Two RB out of: Larry Johnson @CHI, Marion Barber @ MIA, Edge vs. SEA, ....DeAngelo Williams vs. HOU, T. Bell vs. MIN.
---------------------

Any insight on these? TE and flex killed me last week (Branch and Davis. Ouch.)
Other league RB I currently have LJ benched, just wondering if I should reconsider what was once seen as my top gun with that awful matchup.

[princefielder28]

League 1:
I need a W/R starter out of Joey Galloway, Deion Branch, Jerious Norwood, Derrick Ward

One TE out of: Witten @MIA, V. Davis @STL

League 2:
Two RB out of: Larry Johnson @CHI, Marion Barber @ MIA, Edge vs. SEA, ....DeAngelo Williams vs. HOU, T. Bell vs. MIN.
---------------------

Any insight on these? TE and flex killed me last week (Branch and Davis. Ouch.)
Other league RB I currently have LJ benched, just wondering if I should reconsider what was once seen as my top gun with that awful matchup.


Branch, Davis

Marion Barber III and Edge

[Shiver]

I have a tough call in my flex position this week:

Brandon Jackson (vs New York) vs Brandon Marshall (vs Oakland)

PPR league, both have seemingly favorable match-ups.