PDA

View Full Version : Dayne Crist


Billingsley26
08-01-2007, 06:04 PM
Can anyone explain to me why he chose to go to Notre Dame? I mean I think hes a solid prospect, but I hope hes aware that he will be 2nd to Jimmy Clausen until Clausen absolutley unravels. I thought this kind of a weird decision. Any explanation?

bwillie26
08-01-2007, 06:13 PM
Can Clausen throw a pass in-game before everyone proclaims him the second coming?

The last guy who went to Notre Dame who played QB and had this much hype didn't pan out as well as originally thought. He could go on Regis & Kathy Lee to throw passes, but not as well during games.

Billingsley26
08-01-2007, 06:18 PM
Can Clausen throw a pass in-game before everyone proclaims him the second coming?

The last guy who went to Notre Dame who played QB and had this much hype didn't pan out as well as originally thought. He could go on Regis & Kathy Lee to throw passes, but not as well during games.

I beg to differ that point about Quinn. All im saying is that he could be as far back as 3rd.

Michigan
08-01-2007, 06:25 PM
Can anyone explain to me why he chose to go to Notre Dame? I mean I think hes a solid prospect, but I hope hes aware that he will be 2nd to Jimmy Clausen until Clausen absolutley unravels. I thought this kind of a weird decision. Any explanation?

What makes you think Crist is anything more than backup material? His film isn't that impressive...

Turtlepower
08-01-2007, 06:34 PM
Crist has got the a rocket arm, but is pretty precise with his throws as well. Crist figures that Claussen will leave after his Junior year, giving him two seasons to play under Charlie Weiss in Notre Dame. The offense fits his style much more than a spread or WCO.

Billingsley26
08-01-2007, 06:35 PM
What makes you think Crist is anything more than backup material? His film isn't that impressive...

Well, he was at the Elite 11 camp, and had offers from ND, LSU and USC as his top 3.

bwillie26
08-01-2007, 06:35 PM
I beg to differ that point about Quinn. All im saying is that he could be as far back as 3rd.

I'm not even talking about Quinn. Brady Quinn was nowhere near as touted as Clausen. Nowhere near as touted as Ron Powlus (the QB I was referring to in the first place), either.

Billingsley26
08-01-2007, 06:36 PM
I'm not even talking about Quinn. Brady Quinn was nowhere near as touted as Clausen. Nowhere near as touted as Ron Powlus (the QB I was referring to in the first place), either.

O, ok. Because Quinn went on Regis and Kelly and threw a ball there as well.

bwillie26
08-01-2007, 08:29 PM
^

Notice I said Regis & Kathy Lee. Going a little bit back in the day on you. ;)

Billingsley26
08-01-2007, 08:31 PM
^

Notice I said Regis & Kathy Lee. Going a little bit back in the day on you. ;)

Got a little ahead of myself there. lol. I just saw Regis and thought immediately that you were talking about Quinn. lol.

jbeans187
08-02-2007, 12:05 AM
I hope Crist beats out Clausen

soybean
08-02-2007, 12:15 AM
I hope Crist beats up Clausen

that's much better...

jbeans187
08-02-2007, 12:40 AM
that's much better...

Nice, either one is good for me

rainbeaukid2
08-02-2007, 02:14 AM
crist is a ****** man-child. he torched us twice although we still beat him once

Axl Rose
08-03-2007, 01:33 PM
Can anyone explain to me why he chose to go to Notre Dame? I mean I think hes a solid prospect, but I hope hes aware that he will be 2nd to Jimmy Clausen until Clausen absolutley unravels. I thought this kind of a weird decision. Any explanation?

Dayne Crist is all you ask for in a QB, hes got all the mental tools, and definitely all the physical ones as well. But hes still young and being groomed for the QB position for a couple of years behind some one as knowledgeable Jimmy Clausen will only help. Besides I have a feeling if all goes well for Jimmy he might declare for the draft early and Crist could start by his red shirt sophomore year.

Axl Rose
08-03-2007, 01:37 PM
What makes you think Crist is anything more than backup material? His film isn't that impressive...

LOL, but John Weinke's was right? I guess all the offers from schools like LSU, Nebraska, USC, Florida State, and yes even Michigan don't mean anything right?

Burdmanindaclub
08-08-2007, 12:43 PM
Jimmy Clausen will be a bust mark it down!! On August 8th at 1:42 PM I said he will be a bust, He's going to be another over hyped qb that goes to stupid ND.

I was watching a video on rivals, and they said Crist has more of a upside then Jimmy Clausen, but it is dumb why would Crist go somewhere he may not play till his junior or senior season, he could have easily gone to any other D-1 school and start pretty much anywhere his freshman year.

Axl Rose
08-08-2007, 05:31 PM
Jimmy Clausen will be a bust mark it down!! On August 8th at 1:42 PM I said he will be a bust, He's going to be another over hyped qb that goes to stupid ND.

I was watching a video on rivals, and they said Crist has more of a upside then Jimmy Clausen, but it is dumb why would Crist go somewhere he may not play till his junior or senior season, he could have easily gone to any other D-1 school and start pretty much anywhere his freshman year.

Unfortunately there seem to be a lot of people wanting Clausen to bust just out of spite, living up to the hype will be difficult but hes a hard worker and a student of the game, I think he has a very good chance to be a special player.

As for Crist, I agree hes a stud but throwing him in to the fire as a freshmen is a bad idea. There have been countless stud QB's coming out of HS that people thought could start right away like Kyle Wright, Xavier Lee, Anthony Morelli, Ryan Perollieux, ect. Its better for him to learn for a year or two IMO.

WildDude
08-08-2007, 06:50 PM
Kyle Wright might even lose his starting job as well as Anthony Morelli if he dosent shape up cause hes got pat devlin waiting and it all depends on pats development we'll see what happens, i think Christ has a chance cause i personally think Demetrius is gonna win the job hes the kind of qb weis never had someone who can actually move

JayP
08-09-2007, 12:06 AM
Could it be that Crist, like all those LBs and RBs that go to USC, wants to prove himself against the best? Yes, he could have went somewhere else and been a starter instantly, but what challenge is that?

Hate Clausen all you want, but he was the #1 QB recruit last year, and put up sick stats his senior year with bone spurs in his throwing arm. Jones was an Army All-American. Sharpley was Michigan's Gatorade POY.

Yet Crist thinks he could step in there and be the starter in short order. Kid's got sack, and I'm glad he's gonna be Irish.

Sniper
08-09-2007, 12:25 AM
LOL, but John Weinke's was right? I guess all the offers from schools like LSU, Nebraska, USC, Florida State, and yes even Michigan don't mean anything right?

Weinke is good too, rated one of the most accurate QBs this year but we're not blowing him left and right.

Crist is a very good QB who I think will end up beating out/up Clausen. I think he's got a strong arm, moves around fairly well and can put the ball in tight spots. Doesn't seem to be as much as a ***** as Clausen is.

Sniper
08-09-2007, 12:27 AM
Could it be that Crist, like all those LBs and RBs that go to USC, wants to prove himself against the best? Yes, he could have went somewhere else and been a starter instantly, but what challenge is that?

Hate Clausen all you want, but he was the #1 QB recruit last year, and put up sick stats his senior year with bone spurs in his throwing arm. Jones was an Army All-American. Sharpley was Michigan's Gatorade POY.

Yet Crist thinks he could step in there and be the starter in short order. Kid's got sack, and I'm glad he's gonna be Irish.

Whoa whoa whoa whoa wait...The best? He would have gone to SC to match up with the best QBs. Sanchez is a former Parade HS POY and Mustain was the #1 QB in his class. Isn't Aaron Corp, another highly touted QB headed there too?

Clausen, for the last time, had sick stats because he played weak competition and was adept at putting the ball in Marc Tyler's gut. Always helps when you have 10 D-1 players on your team playing a bunch of nobodies.

WildDude
08-09-2007, 12:31 AM
Clausen didnt go to SC cause he was terrified of competition i give credit to christ... clausen thought he had the job at ND all locked up since Brady Quinn is graduating well clausens got another thing coming

Sniper
08-09-2007, 12:56 AM
Clausen didnt go to SC cause he was terrified of competition i give credit to christ... clausen thought he had the job at ND all locked up since Brady Quinn is graduating well clausens got another thing coming

Don't you know Clausen is getting 4 Heismans and 4 NCs? :rolleyes:

JayP
08-09-2007, 01:25 AM
Whoa whoa whoa whoa wait...The best? He would have gone to SC to match up with the best QBs. Sanchez is a former Parade HS POY and Mustain was the #1 QB in his class. Isn't Aaron Corp, another highly touted QB headed there too?

Clausen, for the last time, had sick stats because he played weak competition and was adept at putting the ball in Marc Tyler's gut. Always helps when you have 10 D-1 players on your team playing a bunch of nobodies.

According to your logic, Tyler's as bad as Clausen, since he played against the same weak competition, and also had 10 D-1 players against the same bunch of nobodies...well, at least until he broke his leg that is.

Sanchez is a headcase waiting to implode. Mustain has serious mommy-attachment issues, and also was on a HS team with 4 D-1 prospects on the offensive side of the ball. If his mom imploded because he had to hand off to a freakin' Heisman Trophy candidate RB, what is she gonna do when he's second fiddle to the other talent at USC? And Corp was a 2 star until he pledged to USC, then he miraculously leaped up to a 4 star...even won California POY because the sportswriters were pissed that Jimmy spurned USC. Sad thing is, the kid obviously has a vote of no confidence from Carroll, considering Petey was still chasing Clausen up until the last minute then turned around and promised Crist he'd start ahead of Corp. Plus, most USC fans I know are banking on Matt Barkley to sign in '09 and take over as a 3-4 year starter.

USC's QB depth is good in name only. It'll be interesting to see how their QBs do under 100% Sarkesian tutoring and no remnants of Norm Chow training.

Sniper
08-09-2007, 01:37 AM
According to your logic, Tyler's as bad as Clausen, since he played against the same weak competition, and also had 10 D-1 players against the same bunch of nobodies...well, at least until he broke his leg that is.

Sanchez is a headcase waiting to implode. Mustain has serious mommy-attachment issues, and also was on a HS team with 4 D-1 prospects on the offensive side of the ball. If his mom imploded because he had to hand off to a freakin' Heisman Trophy candidate RB, what is she gonna do when he's second fiddle to the other talent at USC? And Corp was a 2 star until he pledged to USC, then he miraculously leaped up to a 4 star...even won California POY because the sportswriters were pissed that Jimmy spurned USC. Sad thing is, the kid obviously has a vote of no confidence from Carroll, considering Petey was still chasing Clausen up until the last minute then turned around and promised Crist he'd start ahead of Corp. Plus, most USC fans I know are banking on Matt Barkley to sign in '09 and take over as a 3-4 year starter.

USC's QB depth is good in name only. It'll be interesting to see how their QBs do under 100% Sarkesian tutoring and no remnants of Norm Chow training.


Tyler is better than Clausen. Tyler is big, fast, powerful, not a *****. Hence I like him.

Sanchez and Mustain, like them or not, are both excellent QB prospects. Excellent running game or not, Mustain still went 8-0 in the SEC. You do know usually when you're ranked a 2 star it means they haven't seen much of your film? Like Carroll needs to be recruiting 2 star QBs, give me a ******* break.

Carroll always recruits until the end, it's how he's assembled the team he has and all those great running backs. RoJo was a Michigan lock for a while it seemed. Carroll kept recruiting, now we're discussing what kind of impact Rojo will have as a freshman for the Trojans. Joe McKnight was supposed to be an LSU Tiger or go to Ole Miss

Crist is nasty good. He'll be the guy at QB IMO.

JayP
08-09-2007, 02:10 AM
Tyler is better than Clausen. Tyler is big, fast, powerful, not a *****. Hence I like him.

Sanchez and Mustain, like them or not, are both excellent QB prospects. Excellent running game or not, Mustain still went 8-0 in the SEC. You do know usually when you're ranked a 2 star it means they haven't seen much of your film? Like Carroll needs to be recruiting 2 star QBs, give me a ******* break.

Carroll always recruits until the end, it's how he's assembled the team he has and all those great running backs. RoJo was a Michigan lock for a while it seemed. Carroll kept recruiting, now we're discussing what kind of impact Rojo will have as a freshman for the Trojans. Joe McKnight was supposed to be an LSU Tiger or go to Ole Miss

Crist is nasty good. He'll be the guy at QB IMO.

So lemme get you logic straight....Clausen benefitted from having Tyler (despite the fact he was still putting up numbers after Tyler was lost for the year), but Mustain's 8 SEC wins can't be attributed to the fact that Darren McFadden is a stud and Felix Jones is no slouch? Contradict yourself much?

Right....Carroll never gets desperate and recruits low level QBs or goes to second and 3rd options...well, except for Samson Szakacsy. A 3 star QB who pledged to USC? The horrors!

I may have been off on Corp's ranking, but I know it did go up when he pledged. Miraculously enough, Corp and Szakacsy both pledged to USC right after Clausen and Mike Paulus both spurned USC.

And depending on who gets the starting QB job this year, both Crist and Clausen may be riding the pine. If Sharpley wins the derby, the job is up for grabs in 2 years. If Jones wins it, it could be a long wait for both.

Sniper
08-09-2007, 02:32 AM
So lemme get you logic straight....Clausen benefitted from having Tyler (despite the fact he was still putting up numbers after Tyler was lost for the year), but Mustain's 8 SEC wins can't be attributed to the fact that Darren McFadden is a stud and Felix Jones is no slouch? Contradict yourself much?

Right....Carroll never gets desperate and recruits low level QBs or goes to second and 3rd options...well, except for Samson Szakacsy. A 3 star QB who pledged to USC? The horrors!

I may have been off on Corp's ranking, but I know it did go up when he pledged. Miraculously enough, Corp and Szakacsy both pledged to USC right after Clausen and Mike Paulus both spurned USC.

And depending on who gets the starting QB job this year, both Crist and Clausen may be riding the pine. If Sharpley wins the derby, the job is up for grabs in 2 years. If Jones wins it, it could be a long wait for both.

Perhaps reading is not your strong suit. "Excellent running game or not, Mustain went 8-0". Obviously I don't think Clausen didn't play a big role in them winning games, but some people are going a little over the top. The 'Michael Jordan of HS Football"? A wee bit of a stretch I'd say.

You're gonna like this one. http://rivals100.rivals.com/viewprospect.asp?pr_key=48745&sport=1 Now my eyes may be deceiving me, but I do believe that says Arizona State (signed LOI) under his profile, but that could just be me. Let's look at SC's QB signees since 2002 shall we?

2002: John David Booty, NR (Because he left HS early) I'm assuming he's a 4-5 guy coming out of HS
2003: Rocky Hinds, 4 star
2005: Mark Sanchez, 5 star
2006: Garrett Green, 3 star
2007: Aaron Corp, 4 star

So Pete's gotten one 3 star recruit, never a 2 star. And usually a 2 star in the middle of the season or before the season means they haven't watched your film yet. For example, Mike Cox, RB who recently committed to Michigan, is expected to be a high 3/low 4 in the next rankings. Corp was a 2 who went to a 4 after they watched his film.

JayP
08-09-2007, 09:37 AM
Perhaps reading is not your strong suit. "Excellent running game or not, Mustain went 8-0". Obviously I don't think Clausen didn't play a big role in them winning games, but some people are going a little over the top. The 'Michael Jordan of HS Football"? A wee bit of a stretch I'd say.

You're gonna like this one. http://rivals100.rivals.com/viewprospect.asp?pr_key=48745&sport=1 Now my eyes may be deceiving me, but I do believe that says Arizona State (signed LOI) under his profile, but that could just be me. Let's look at SC's QB signees since 2002 shall we?

2002: John David Booty, NR (Because he left HS early) I'm assuming he's a 4-5 guy coming out of HS
2003: Rocky Hinds, 4 star
2005: Mark Sanchez, 5 star
2006: Garrett Green, 3 star
2007: Aaron Corp, 4 star

So Pete's gotten one 3 star recruit, never a 2 star. And usually a 2 star in the middle of the season or before the season means they haven't watched your film yet. For example, Mike Cox, RB who recently committed to Michigan, is expected to be a high 3/low 4 in the next rankings. Corp was a 2 who went to a 4 after they watched his film.

Actually, I've been reading for quite some time. Maybe your skills are a bit lacking, since Clausen was dubbed the "LeBron James of HS Football", not the Jordan. I see it as him being labeled as being so good it was like watching a man playing among boys, which it was.

Maybe you missed the fact that Szakacsy decommitted from USC at the last moment to join Erickson at AZ St., so he was very much a USC recruit. (http://rivals100.rivals.com/barrier_noentry.asp?sid=880&script=content.asp&cid=544395&fid=&tid=&mid=&rid=) Believe me, there were enough Trojan fans who were all over the Rivals & Scout ND boards telling anyone who would listen how much better off they were not getting Clausen and getting Corp & Szakacsy when they committed back to back.

Besides, I've seen Corp play. Quite impressive in the CIF championship game, but I don't think he's a good fit at USC. His skillset would probably be better suited at Florida or West Virginia....basically, any team that has an offense that is more suited for a mobile QB. USC's offense is tailor made for a drop back passer, and that isn't Corp's style. I also know it isn't USC's style to tweak their offense to suit a player....either you do what's asked, or you ride the pine. A guy coming out of a West Virginia-style offense is goign to struggle with a pro style offense for some time. I don't think Corp ever sees the field as a QB. If USC lands Barkley in the future class, expect Corp to bulk up and play FB or TE, or to just transfer a la Hinds.

Axl Rose
08-09-2007, 01:21 PM
Weinke is good too, rated one of the most accurate QBs this year but we're not blowing him left and right.

Crist is a very good QB who I think will end up beating out/up Clausen. I think he's got a strong arm, moves around fairly well and can put the ball in tight spots. Doesn't seem to be as much as a ***** as Clausen is.

I never said Weinke wasn't good, but to act like Crist's highlight video was disappointing when he was being recruited by every major program including Michigan is ridicules.

Axl Rose
08-09-2007, 01:38 PM
Whoa whoa whoa whoa wait...The best? He would have gone to SC to match up with the best QBs. Sanchez is a former Parade HS POY and Mustain was the #1 QB in his class. Isn't Aaron Corp, another highly touted QB headed there too?

Clausen, for the last time, had sick stats because he played weak competition and was adept at putting the ball in Marc Tyler's gut. Always helps when you have 10 D-1 players on your team playing a bunch of nobodies.

First of all Clausen Committed to ND before Mustain transfered to SC or Corp verballed to SC. So to say he was scarred of the competition is hilarious especially since he verballed to ND where he would have to battle 3 highly rated QB's for the starting job. Besides Mustain was trying to commit to ND after he first de-committed to Arkansas but coach Weis wanted to wait for Clausen, and Coach Carrol was still trying to recruit Clausen even after he received a verbal from Corp. So Clausen must be a good prospect if he had coaches passing on other highly ranked QB's for him.

Clausens been impressing since his freshmen year, and the fact that every major program in the nation was interested in him shows that he does have skills.

soybean
08-09-2007, 01:46 PM
According to your logic, Tyler's as bad as Clausen, since he played against the same weak competition, and also had 10 D-1 players against the same bunch of nobodies...well, at least until he broke his leg that is.

Sanchez is a headcase waiting to implode. Mustain has serious mommy-attachment issues, and also was on a HS team with 4 D-1 prospects on the offensive side of the ball. If his mom imploded because he had to hand off to a freakin' Heisman Trophy candidate RB, what is she gonna do when he's second fiddle to the other talent at USC? And Corp was a 2 star until he pledged to USC, then he miraculously leaped up to a 4 star...even won California POY because the sportswriters were pissed that Jimmy spurned USC. Sad thing is, the kid obviously has a vote of no confidence from Carroll, considering Petey was still chasing Clausen up until the last minute then turned around and promised Crist he'd start ahead of Corp. Plus, most USC fans I know are banking on Matt Barkley to sign in '09 and take over as a 3-4 year starter.

USC's QB depth is good in name only. It'll be interesting to see how their QBs do under 100% Sarkesian tutoring and no remnants of Norm Chow training.

Where do you get your information? corp a 2 star? he won CIF and state with the only loss to servite. Get your info straight.

soybean
08-09-2007, 01:53 PM
delete post.

JayP
08-09-2007, 03:41 PM
Where do you get your information? corp a 2 star? he won CIF and state with the only loss to servite. Get your info straight.

Try reading the whole post and getting your own facts straight. I said I may have been off on his initial star ranking, but I know he wasn't a 4 star player from the get go. He got his 4th star after committing to USC. And its hilarious that Corp won California POY, yet Clausen took pretty much every national award he went up for. Tell me it isn't homerism when a kid is a Parade and Army All-American, listed as the #1 prospect in the country, but not considered the POY in his state.

Corp was option #3 for USC behind Clausen and Paulus, in that order. Most ND & USC fans assumed that since Clausen and Paulus both had high interest in USC and ND, whoever pulled the trigger first would seal the deal for the other. When Clausen committed, everyone figured Paulus was USC bound. Amazing that when Paulus shocked everyone by heading to N.C., Corp and Szakacsy committed rapid fire.

Sniper
08-09-2007, 04:03 PM
I never said Weinke wasn't good, but to act like Crist's highlight video was disappointing when he was being recruited by every major program including Michigan is ridicules.

I didn't say Crist was disappointing.

soybean
08-09-2007, 05:01 PM
Try reading the whole post and getting your own facts straight. I said I may have been off on his initial star ranking, but I know he wasn't a 4 star player from the get go. He got his 4th star after committing to USC. And its hilarious that Corp won California POY, yet Clausen took pretty much every national award he went up for. Tell me it isn't homerism when a kid is a Parade and Army All-American, listed as the #1 prospect in the country, but not considered the POY in his state.

Corp was option #3 for USC behind Clausen and Paulus, in that order. Most ND & USC fans assumed that since Clausen and Paulus both had high interest in USC and ND, whoever pulled the trigger first would seal the deal for the other. When Clausen committed, everyone figured Paulus was USC bound. Amazing that when Paulus shocked everyone by heading to N.C., Corp and Szakacsy committed rapid fire.

you could be right but this is all hearsay. How do YOU know how bad SC wanted Clausen or Paulus? and that corp was just a last minute resort?

soybean
08-09-2007, 05:08 PM
plus i still dont believe that usc was that actively pursuing clausen considering he commited a year early.

i don't know why we're arguing about jimmy clausen though, ryan mallet is a much better qb than him

Axl Rose
08-09-2007, 05:59 PM
I didn't say Crist was disappointing.

My post was in response to Michigan.

Sniper
08-09-2007, 06:09 PM
plus i still dont believe that usc was that actively pursuing clausen considering he commited a year early.

i don't know why we're arguing about jimmy clausen though, ryan mallet is a much better qb than him

Bless your heart for that last remark :) I don't want to be accused of homerism

JayP
08-09-2007, 07:24 PM
you could be right but this is all hearsay. How do YOU know how bad SC wanted Clausen or Paulus? and that corp was just a last minute resort?

You can't possibly be that stupid.

How do I know USC wanted Clausen or Paulus? I dunno...the well publicized text message that Clausen received from Pete Carroll right after the Sugar Bowl stating "Do you still wanna do this? You can still change your mind." Gee...that sounds like Pete Carroll was after him. Or maybe the fact that USC sent Clausen a schollie offer when he was a sophomore (http://www.pe.com/sports/college/usc/stories/PE_Sports_Local_D_web_carroll_15.35acbd8.html) means that they wanted him pretty badly?

Regarding Paulus, read away: http://northcarolina.scout.com/2/525423.html. In case you're too lazy to click it, lemme pull a quote for you:

"It came down to USC and North Carolina and I called Coach Bunting and let him know."

"Coach Bunting was extremely happy. He said 'I'm a very, very happy head coach right now. I'm grinning ear to ear.'"

A four-star prospect, according to Scout.com, Paulus also made a phone call to Southern Cal head coach Pete Carroll to inform him of the decision.

"Coach Carroll was very classy; he said 'You're unbelievable, we wish we could have had you - North Carolina is really lucky because you're going to be very good,' " Paulus said.

I think it's safe to say Pete wanted both of them, but I'm thinking Clausen got his schollie offer first, then Paulus, then Corp. Especially considering this article (http://notredame.rivals.com/content.asp?SID=961&CID=540387) alludes to the fact that Corp got his USC offer in late April (definitely after Clausen committed and around the time Paulus probably notified Carroll he was going to UNC) and accepted quickly.

But no, I'm just full of heresay.

soybean
08-09-2007, 08:12 PM
You can't possibly be that stupid.

How do I know USC wanted Clausen or Paulus? I dunno...the well publicized text message that Clausen received from Pete Carroll right after the Sugar Bowl stating "Do you still wanna do this? You can still change your mind." Gee...that sounds like Pete Carroll was after him. Or maybe the fact that USC sent Clausen a schollie offer when he was a sophomore (http://www.pe.com/sports/college/usc/stories/PE_Sports_Local_D_web_carroll_15.35acbd8.html) means that they wanted him pretty badly?

Regarding Paulus, read away: http://northcarolina.scout.com/2/525423.html. In case you're too lazy to click it, lemme pull a quote for you:

I think it's safe to say Pete wanted both of them, but I'm thinking Clausen got his schollie offer first, then Paulus, then Corp. Especially considering this article (http://notredame.rivals.com/content.asp?SID=961&CID=540387) alludes to the fact that Corp got his USC offer in late April (definitely after Clausen committed and around the time Paulus probably notified Carroll he was going to UNC) and accepted quickly.

But no, I'm just full of heresay.

read my post again. if pete really wanted clausen or Paulus THAT BAD. he would have got them. Plus schools always offer schollies to players even when they don't expect them to start. paulus would have never played. I suppose garrett green will be the next carson palmer too.

mqtirishfan
08-09-2007, 09:22 PM
read my post again. if pete really wanted clausen or Paulus THAT BAD. he would have got them. Plus schools always offer schollies to players even when they don't expect them to start. paulus would have never played. I suppose garrett green will be the next carson palmer too.

Are you joking? Does USC have a special button they press for anybody they want? I bet any top prospect who goes elsewhere is just a guy that Pete Carrol declined. I bet USC could just go to every prospect and sign them, regardless of who else is recruiting them.

JayP
08-09-2007, 11:55 PM
read my post again. if pete really wanted clausen or Paulus THAT BAD. he would have got them. Plus schools always offer schollies to players even when they don't expect them to start. paulus would have never played. I suppose garrett green will be the next carson palmer too.

My god....you really are that dense.

Clausen was down to ND & USC and Paulus was down to NC & USC. For someone who really didn't want those guys, Pete sure as hell put forth a lot of effort recruiting them and getting to their top 2.

If Pete really wanted them, he'd have them huh? I can rattle off a LONG list of players Carroll wanted and didn't get...lemme think of a few off the top of my head....Dayne Crist...James Aldridge...James Wilson...Percy Harvin...Donovan Warren...Sam Young...Darius Flemming...nope, guess Pete was joking by showing up at their schools, offering them scholarships, meeting with their coaches and parents, and trying to get them to come to USC. That prankster....whoo.....Carroll is one funny man!

Sure Carroll had no intention of ever playing Paulus. If that makes you sleep better at night, go right ahead and keep thinking that. Just like you keep thinking that Green was projecting as a QB in college (he was coming in as a safety I think, but switched to QB due to lack of depth).

Sniper
08-10-2007, 12:09 AM
My god....you really are that dense.

Clausen was down to ND & USC and Paulus was down to NC & USC. For someone who really didn't want those guys, Pete sure as hell put forth a lot of effort recruiting them and getting to their top 2.

If Pete really wanted them, he'd have them huh? I can rattle off a LONG list of players Carroll wanted and didn't get...lemme think of a few off the top of my head....Dayne Crist...James Aldridge...James Wilson...Percy Harvin...Donovan Warren...Sam Young...Darius Flemming...nope, guess Pete was joking by showing up at their schools, offering them scholarships, meeting with their coaches and parents, and trying to get them to come to USC. That prankster....whoo.....Carroll is one funny man!

Sure Carroll had no intention of ever playing Paulus. If that makes you sleep better at night, go right ahead and keep thinking that. Just like you keep thinking that Green was projecting as a QB in college (he was coming in as a safety I think, but switched to QB due to lack of depth).

Ok I don't agree with soybean's earlier point. But lack of depth at QB or pretty much any position is not a problem with SC.

JayP
08-10-2007, 12:48 AM
Ok I don't agree with soybean's earlier point. But lack of depth at QB or pretty much any position is not a problem with SC.

I disagree. Like I said in another thread, USC has depth in name, but something isn't quite right. Check out this quote from their practice reviews: (http://usc.scout.com/a.z?s=15&p=2&c=666809)

*Backup quarterback Mark Sanchez has struggled a bit the past two days. He has not looked as sharp as one might expect, missing some short throws, and making some ill advised throws when his first option is covered.

Not exactly what you want to be hearing about your backup, who was the man his senior year in HS, but should be further along as a player heading into his 3rd year in the program.

I'm thinking Sanchez is strugging and Pete may be losing confidence in him, which would explain some of his QB recruiting moves. Like others have said, there's no way Mustain goes to USC unless he thinks he has a good chance to start, which means beating out Sanchez. Corp, IMO, is no match for Mustain.

soybean
08-10-2007, 12:56 AM
Ok I don't agree with soybean's earlier point. But lack of depth at QB or pretty much any position is not a problem with SC.

i wasn't serious i meant it as an exaggeration obviously they don't get all the players they want (ie. desean jackson) I just meant I didn't think pete wanted those qbs so bad. But who knows, i admit i don't know that much about recruiting.

Also, michael mcdonald is a more than capable backup.

JayP
08-10-2007, 01:31 AM
i wasn't serious i meant it as an exaggeration obviously they don't get all the players they want (ie. desean jackson) I just meant I didn't think pete wanted those qbs so bad. But who knows, i admit i don't know that much about recruiting.

Also, michael mcdonald is a more than capable backup.

Nice backpedaling. Sure you didn't mean it...you just didn't think people were gonna call you an idiot for a stupid thought. I bet it even sounded smart when you were typing it too.

Sure...Pete's goal was to settle for Corp because he's so much better than Clausen. Who was USA Today's Offensive POY? The Army All American POY? The Parade POY? I'm pretty sure it wasn't Corp.

Michael McDonald a capable backup? You're obviously kidding. I'm sure that if Carroll had to put McDonald in a game this year that wasn't a blowout, the brown stain on the back of Pete's pants would be noticeable to all of America.

Sniper
08-10-2007, 01:33 AM
Nice backpedaling. Sure you didn't mean it...you just didn't think people were gonna call you an idiot for a stupid thought. I bet it even sounded smart when you were typing it too.

Sure...Pete's goal was to settle for Corp because he's so much better than Clausen. Who was USA Today's Offensive POY? The Army All American POY? The Parade POY? I'm pretty it wasn't Corp.

Michael McDonald a capable backup? You're obviously kidding. I'm sure that if Carroll had to put McDonald in a game this year that wasn't a blowout, the brown stain on the back of Pete's pants would be noticeable to all of America.

But that's the thing. He wouldn't have to because he's got good depth at the position. Mark Sanchez is a beast.

And I do find it ironic that Clausen got all those awards, yet when he went against elite competition he didn't look very good. Surprising? Probably not. But more fodder for the anti-Clausen debate.

JayP
08-10-2007, 11:13 AM
But that's the thing. He wouldn't have to because he's got good depth at the position. Mark Sanchez is a beast.

And I do find it ironic that Clausen got all those awards, yet when he went against elite competition he didn't look very good. Surprising? Probably not. But more fodder for the anti-Clausen debate.

Once again, I'll say this: Sanchez, to this point, has not panned out the way USC expected. That line I quoted isn't the first I've heard of that. I live in So. Cal, and I know a fair share of USC fans, two of which have family members on the team, and I mean scholarship players, not walk-ons. They've told me the same thing in conversations about the team. It's not really like its a secret around So Cal. People started questioning Sanchez after he didn't beat Booty out for the starting job last year.

Clausen played fine in the AA game, if that's what you're referring to.

soybean
08-10-2007, 12:38 PM
EDIT: delete post.

619
08-21-2007, 03:08 AM
all i gotta say bout jimmy clausen is he wont pan out to be much better then his bros did

http://i57.photobucket.com/albums/g203/keepnitgangsta1/Sigs%202/Reggie-Bush.gif

mqtirishfan
08-21-2007, 04:35 PM
What I do love is the fact that although one might not think Clausen is the best QB prospect in his class, but maybe 2nd or 3rd, that all of a sudden makes him awful. I'll say this right now, Mallett is a better QB prospect than Jimmy Clausen. Heck, I think I like Cam Newton more than JC. However, I think JC is a top 5 QB prospect and at worst a 4 star prospect. That's still very good. If he busts, everyone will jump out and say they predicted this. If he doesn't bust, nobody will talk about their former doubts. Every top prospect gets this treatment. People will doubt a prospect, others will defend him. There's a reason that JC got scholarship offers from every freaking school in the NCAA: He's a talented prospect who anyone would like to have on their team. Might he fail? Of course! Look back at every recruiting class since the beginning of Rivals.com and you'll see a bunch of top prospects who never made it. It's a fact of life that some will rise to the top and others will sink to the bottom. However, college scouts at this level know what they're doing, and if every scout wants to sign a prospect, it isn't because of ESPN covering his workouts. It's because he is talented and the scouts recognize that.