View Full Version : All NFC vs. All AFC

08-21-2007, 01:12 AM
I took three players from each team in both conferences, have made the depth charts and are now putting the rosters out there for you guys to critique. I would like to see if you guys disagree with any of the choices and think that someone else from your team would be a better fit than one of the three already chosen. Also some decisions were made to fill spots for the team. Who has the better team?


Offense Depth Chart

1. Peyton Manning (Colts)
2. Tom Brady (Patriots)
3. Carson Palmer (Bengals)
4. Vince Young (Titans)

Running Backs
1. LaDanian Tomlinson (Chargers)
2. Larry Johnson (Chiefs)
3. Thomas Jones (Jets)
4. Maurice Jones-Drew (Jaguars)

1. Lorenzo Neal (Chargers)

Wide Receiver
1. Marvin Harrison (Colts)
2. Chad Johnson (Bengals)
3. Andre Johnson (Texans)
4. Lee Evans (Bills)

Tight End
1. Kellen Winslow II (Browns)
2. Heath Miller (Steelers)

1. Jonathan Ogden (Ravens)
2. Levi Jones (Bengals)
3.. D'Brickashaw Ferguson (Jets)
4. Vernon Carey (Dolphins)

1. Alan Faneca (Steelers)
2. Brian Waters (Chiefs)
3. Eric Steinbach (Browns)

1. Tom Nalen (Broncos)
2. Kevin Mawae (Titans)

1. Nate Kaeding (Chargers)

Defense Depth Chart

Defensive Ends
1. Dwight Freeney (Colts)
2. Jason Taylor (Dolphins)
3. Terrell Suggs (Ravens)
4. Anthony Weaver (Texans)

Defensive Tackles
1. Vince Wilfork (Patriots)
2. John Henderson (Jaguars)
3. Marcus Stroud (Jaguars)
4. Warren Sapp (Raiders)

1. Ray Lewis (Ravens)
2. Keith Bulluck (Titans)
3. DeMeco Ryans (Texans)
4. Zach Thomas (Dolphins)
5. Donnie Edwards (Chiefs)
6. Kamerion Wimbley (Browns)

1. Champ Bailey (Broncos)
2. Dre' Bly (Broncos)
3. Terrence McGee (Bills)
4. Nnamdi Asomugha (Raiders)

1. Troy Polamalu (Steelers)
2. Kerry Rhodes (Jets)
3. Rodney Harrison (Patriots)
4. Stuart Schweigert (Raiders)

1. Brian Moorman (Bills)

Starting Lineup

QB - P. Manning
RB - L. Tomlinson
FB - L. Neal
WR - M. Harrison
WR - C. Johnson
TE - K. Winslow
LT - L. Jones
LG - B. Waters
C - T. Nalen
RG - A. Faneca
RT - J. Ogden

DE - D. Freeney
DT - V. Wilfork
DT - J. Henderson
DE - J. Taylor
LLB - K. Bulluck
MLB - R. Lewis
RLB - D. Ryans
CB - C. Bailey
FS - T. Polamalu
SS - K.Rhodes
CB - D. Bly

K - N. Kaeding
P - B. Moorman


Offense Depth Chart

1. Drew Brees (Saints)
2. Marc Bulger (Rams)
3. Donovan McNabb (Eagles)
4. Tony Romo (Cowboys)

Running Backs
1. Steven Jackson (Rams)
2. Frank Gore (49ers)
3. Reggie Bush (Saints)

1. Ovie Mughelli (Falcons)
2. Mack Strong (Seahawks)

Wide Receivers
1. Roy Williams (Lions)
2. Anquan Boldin (Cardinals)
3. Steve Smith (Panthers)
4. Plaxico Burress (Giants)
5. Santana Moss (Redskins)

Tight Ends
1. Jeremy Shockey (Giants)
2. Chris Cooley (Redskins)

1. Orlando Pace (Rams)
2. Bryant McKinnie (Vikings)
3. Jordan Gross (Panthers)
4. John Runyan (Eagles)

1. Larry Allen (49ers)
2. Steve Hutchinson (Vikings)
3. Leonard Davis (Cowboys)
4. Davin Joseph (Buccaneers)

1. Olin Kruetz (Bears)

Neil Rackers (Cardinals)

Defense Depth Chart

Defensive Ends
1. Julius Peppers (Panthers)
2. Charles Grant (Saints)
3. Aaron Kampman (Packers)
4. Osi Umenyiora (Giants)

Defensive Tackles
1. Tommie Harris (Bears)
2. Corey Redding (Lions)
3. Grady Jackson (Falcons)

1. Brian Urlacher (Bears)
2. Lofa Tatupu (Seahawks)
3. Ernie Simms (Lions)
4. Julian Peterson (Seahawks)
5. Cato June (Buccaneers)
6. Nick Barnett (Packers)

1. Nate Clements (49ers)
2. Antoine Winfield (Vikings)
3. Charles Woodson (Packers)
4. DeAngelo Hall (Falcons)
5. Ronde Barber (Buccaneers)

1. Sean Taylor (Redskins)
2. Adrian Wilson (Cardinals)
3. Brian Dawkins (Eagles)

1. Mat McBriar (Cowboys)

Starting Lineup

QB - D. Brees
RB - S. Jackson
FB - O. Mughello
WR - R. Williams
WR - A. Boldin
TE - J. Shockey
LT - B. McKinnie
LG - S. Hutchinson
C - O. Kreutz
RG - L. Allen
RT - O. Pace

DE - J. Peppers
DT - T. Harris
DT - C. Redding
DE - C. Grant
LLB - L. Tatupu
MLB - B. Urlacher
RLB - E. Simms
CB - N. Clements
FS - S. Taylor
SS - A. Wilson
CB - A. Winfield

K - N. Rackers
P - M. McBriar

08-21-2007, 01:19 AM
I really don't get this.

08-21-2007, 01:20 AM
My disagreements with the NFC Roster
How can you leave out Walter Jones
Make Ernie Simms a starter
I dont think Plax should be in there (Donald Driver would be my pick ofcourse considering he's been statistically better than Plax over the last few years)

08-21-2007, 01:28 AM
There's still room for a Seahawk.

08-21-2007, 01:36 AM
Schobel and McAlister would be much better than Suggs and McGee

Rob S
08-21-2007, 01:39 AM
Schobel and McAlister would be much better than Suggs and McGee

agreed, McGee should not be on the list if there is no KR.

Rob S
08-21-2007, 01:41 AM
And Jason Peters is better than both Carey and D'Brick.

08-21-2007, 02:01 AM
Julian Peterson is on the Seahawks

08-21-2007, 10:08 AM
Those would likely be my 3 choices for Lions players as well.

Though they are spelled incorrectly . . . it's Ernie Sims and Cory Redding

he he

08-21-2007, 10:32 AM
No love for Donald Driver????

08-21-2007, 11:01 AM
kaeding over rivers, merriman, and jamal williams? hell, antonio gates is the best TE in the game, and he's not even on here?

plax over torry holt? why would williams and bolden be starting over steve frickin smith?

my head hurts...

Eagles own the NFC East
08-21-2007, 01:51 PM
That is unbelievable that u dont have Shawn Andrews on there and u have DAVIN JOSEPH? For eagles Runyan shouldnt be on there and Andrews should.

08-21-2007, 01:58 PM
ummm has no one noticed that antonio gates isnt on the AFC squad? what the hell is with that? he is better than heath miller... i would take him above K2 aswell

08-21-2007, 01:58 PM
What is the purpose of this again???

08-21-2007, 01:59 PM
Charles Woodson should start...

08-24-2007, 04:47 AM
QB's:Tony Romo shouldn't be on the list yet Matt Hasselbeck should be the fourth QB

Rbs:Reggie Bush definatly doesn't belong either Shaun Alexander should be on here

WRs:should go like this
1.Torry Holt
2.Steve Smith
3.Larry Fitzgerald
4.Anquan Boldin
5.Roy Williams
6.Terrel Owens

TE:Alge Crumpler over Cooley

O-line:Walter Jones & Shaun Andrews should be on here in place of Jordan Gross and Davin joesph

D-line:Id put Will Smith on Rather than Grant. for the DT's Kevin Williams and Pat Williams should be in there with Tommie Harris

LBs:Cato June just does not belong on this list at all... Lance Briggs shold be on here

CBs:seems good to me

S:Good but wrong order

Heres what Starting lineup should look like for the NFC

QB: Donavan McNabb(When healthy no question he's the best QB in the NFC)
RB:Steven Jackson
FB:Mack Strong
TE:Jeremy Shockey
WR:Torry Holt
WR:Steve Smith
LT:Walter Jones
LG:Steve Hutchinson
C:Olin Kreutz
RG:Shaun Andrews

DE:Julius Peppers
DT:Kevin Williams
DT:Tommie Harris
DE:Will Smith
OLB:Lance Briggs
MLB:Brian Urlacher
OLB:Julian Peterson
CB:Nate Clements
FS:Brian Dawkins
SS:Adrian Wilson
CB:Antione Winfield

08-24-2007, 05:05 AM
LEONARD ******* DAVIS OVER SHAWN ANDREWS? Are you out of your goddamn mind?

08-24-2007, 05:08 AM
Overall NFC Gripes


3. Leonard Davis (Cowboys) Absolutely unforgivable over Shawn Andrews

5. Cato June (Buccaneers)
6. Nick Barnett (Packers)

No, just no.

1. Nate Clements (49ers)
2. Antoine Winfield (Vikings)
3. Charles Woodson (Packers)
4. DeAngelo Hall (Falcons)
5. Ronde Barber (Buccaneers)

Um Lito Sheppard and Terrence Newman wanted to know what conference they play in since it's clearly not the NFC.

1. Sean Taylor (Redskins)
2. Adrian Wilson (Cardinals)
3. Brian Dawkins (Eagles)

Dawkins at 3? Taylor at 1? Are you KIDDING me?