PDA

View Full Version : Whos Better?


doingthisinsteadofwork
01-08-2008, 07:46 PM
We havent done one of these in a while.
this is based mostly off of Scotts rankings.

Andre Woodson or Matt Ryan
Peyton Hillis or Owen Schmitt
Malcom Kelly or Desean Jackson
Martin Rucker or Fred Davis
Jake Long or Jeff Otah
Roy Scheuning or Eric Young
Steve Justice or Cody Wallace
Chris Long or Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey or Sedrick Ellis
Keith Rivers or Dan Connor
Goff or Lehman
Mike Jenkins or Leodis McKelvin
Thomas Decoud or Craig Steltz

Thunder&Lightning
01-08-2008, 07:53 PM
Andre Woodson* or Matt Ryan
Peyton Hillis or Owen Schmitt*
Malcom Kelly or Desean Jackson*
Martin Rucker or Fred Davis*
Jake Long* or Jeff Otah
Roy Scheuning or Eric Young*
Steve Justice* or Cody Wallace
Chris Long* or Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey* or Sedrick Ellis
Keith Rivers* or Dan Connor
Goff* or Lehman
Mike Jenkins* or Leodis McKelvin
Thomas Decoud or Craig Steltz*

Tampa 2 4 life
01-08-2008, 07:55 PM
Ryan
Hillis
Jackson
Rucker
Long
Scheuning
Justice
Long
Dorsey
Connor
Lehman
Mike Jenkins
Decoud

mqtirishfan
01-08-2008, 08:21 PM
Andre Woodson
Peyton Hillis
Desean Jackson
Fred Davis
Jake Long
Eric Young
Cody Wallace
Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey
Keith Rivers
Goff
Mike Jenkins
Thomas Decoud

energizerbunny
01-08-2008, 08:30 PM
Ryan
Hillis
Jackson
Davis
Long
Young
Push
Dorsey
Rivers
Jenkins
Decloud

Turtlepower
01-08-2008, 08:37 PM
Andre Woodson or Matt Ryan* (but Brohm is better than both)
Peyton Hillis* or Owen Schmitt
Malcom Kelly* or Desean Jackson
Martin Rucker or Fred Davis*
Jake Long* or Jeff Otah
Roy Scheuning* or Eric Young (not as close as most people believe)
Steve Justice* or Cody Wallace
Chris Long* or Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey or Sedrick Ellis*
Keith Rivers* or Dan Connor
Goff* or Lehman
Mike Jenkins or Leodis McKelvin*
Thomas Decoud or Craig Steltz (I choose neither cause they both suck)

toonsterwu
01-08-2008, 08:39 PM
My personal preferences

Andre Woodson or Matt Ryan
Peyton Hillis or Owen Schmitt
Malcom Kelly or Desean Jackson
Martin Rucker or Fred Davis
Jake Long or Jeff Otah
Roy Scheuning or Eric Young
Steve Justice or Cody Wallace
Chris Long or Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey or Sedrick Ellis
Keith Rivers or Dan Connor
Goff or Lehman
Mike Jenkins or Leodis McKelvin
Thomas Decoud or Craig Steltz

P-L
01-08-2008, 08:51 PM
Andre Woodson or Matt Ryan
Peyton Hillis or Owen Schmitt
Malcom Kelly or Desean Jackson
Martin Rucker or Fred Davis
Jake Long or Jeff Otah
Roy Scheuning or Eric Young
Steve Justice or Cody Wallace
Chris Long or Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey or Sedrick Ellis
Keith Rivers or Dan Connor
Goff or Lehman
Mike Jenkins or Leodis McKelvin
Thomas Decoud or Craig Steltz

Rich Jr
01-08-2008, 08:59 PM
Andre Woodson or Matt Ryan
Peyton Hillis or Owen Schmitt
Malcom Kelly or Desean Jackson
Martin Rucker or Fred Davis
Jake Long or Jeff Otah
Roy Scheuning or Eric Young
Steve Justice or Cody Wallace
Chris Long or Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey or Sedrick Ellis
Keith Rivers or Dan Connor
Goff or Lehman
Mike Jenkins or Leodis McKelvin
Thomas Decoud or Craig Steltz

CARDIAC CAT 7
01-08-2008, 09:03 PM
Andre Woodson or Matt Ryan ( Sorry Andre :( )
Peyton Hillis or Owen Schmitt
Malcom Kelly or Desean Jackson
Martin Rucker or Fred Davis
Jake Long or Jeff Otah
Roy Scheuning or Eric Young
Steve Justice or Cody Wallace
Chris Long or Vernon Gholston (Closest Value)
Glenn Dorsey or Sedrick Ellis
Keith Rivers or Dan Connor
Goff or Leman
Mike Jenkins or Leodis McKelvin
Thomas Decoud or Craig Steltz

art vandelay
01-08-2008, 09:24 PM
Andre Woodson or Matt Ryan
Peyton Hillis or Owen Schmitt
Malcom Kelly or Desean Jackson
Martin Rucker or Fred Davis
Jake Long or Jeff Otah
Roy Scheuning or Eric Young
Steve Justice or Cody Wallace
Chris Long or Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey or Sedrick Ellis
Keith Rivers or Dan Connor
Goff or Lehman
Mike Jenkins or Leodis McKelvin
Thomas Decoud or Craig Steltz

keylime_5
01-08-2008, 09:31 PM
Andre Woodson (close one)
Owen Schmitt (definitely)
Desean Jackson
Martin Rucker
Jake Long
Eric Young
Steve Justice
Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey
Dan Connor
Lehman
Mike Jenkins
Thomas Decoud

princefielder28
01-08-2008, 09:35 PM
Andre Woodson or Matt Ryan
Peyton Hillis or Owen Schmitt
Malcom Kelly or Desean Jackson
Martin Rucker or Fred Davis
Jake Long or Jeff Otah
Roy Scheuning or Eric Young
Steve Justice or Cody Wallace
Chris Long or Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey or Sedrick Ellis
Keith Rivers or Dan Connor
Goff or Lehman
Mike Jenkins or Leodis McKelvin
Thomas Decoud or Craig Steltz

cardsalltheway
01-08-2008, 09:39 PM
Andre Woodson or Matt Ryan
Peyton Hillis or Owen Schmitt
Malcom Kelly or Desean Jackson
Martin Rucker or Fred Davis
Jake Long or Jeff Otah
Roy Scheuning or Eric Young
Steve Justice or Cody Wallace
Chris Long or Vernon Gholston
Glenn Dorsey or Sedrick Ellis
Keith Rivers or Dan Connor
Goff or Lehman
Mike Jenkins or Leodis McKelvin
Thomas Decoud or Craig Steltz