What Non-QB would you take at QB?

[Staubach12]

You have to choose one non-QB to play QB for your team. Who would you take?

[Byrd430]

Well, I think you gotta take a college quarterback converted to a new position in the NFL..

I liked Antwaan Randle-El at Indiana, so I'll take him above Matt Jones.

[TheGreatEscape]

Brandon Jacobs He's huge so he'll see the field well and have an arm once you teach him to throw.

[BeerBaron]

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v613/BeerBaron/hester.jpg

Devin ******* Hester.

put Mike Vike to shame.....who cares if he can even throw, just put 10 blockers and Hester out there, and have him run QB draws the whole game. Maybe 9 blockers, Hester and a good option running back.....

Every play would have serious highlight reel potential

[619]

Lemme think ex-QBs .. Anquan Boldin.

[Jensen]

Anquan Boldin.

[RaiderFan]

Vince young

[JT Jag]

LaDainian Tomlinson.

[d34ng3l021]

Michael Vick

[Chucky]

Vince young

Why not Brady or manning?

[neko4]

As Emitt Smiff would say: Brad Smiff, dey lik cuzins!

Candidates:
Brad Smith
Reggie McNeal
Antwan Randle El
Ladannian Tomlinson
Carlyle Holiday
Darren McFadden
Matt Jones
Marcus Vick
Hines Ward

More im sure

[islandboy843]

http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/media/images/42037000/jpg/_42037850_miami.jpg

[nfrillman]

That's easy, the Missouri great Brad Smith.

[skinzzfan25]

Randle El

He's actually got a pretty big arm, it should be interesting to see how Zorn can incorporate this into the offense.

[Chucky]

As Emitt Smiff would say: Brad Smiff, dey lik cuzins!

Candidates:
Brad Smith
Reggie McNeal
Antwan Randle El
Ladannian Tomlinson
Carlyle Holiday
Darren McFadden
Matt Jones
Marcus Vick
Hines Ward

More im sure

REggie McNeal is the argos third string QB

[SuperMcgee]

http://cache.daylife.com/imageserve/06P01d78Oob6R/610x.jpg


It's not every day you find a black Brett Favre

[d34ng3l021]

http://media.scout.com/media/image/33/334006.jpg

[TheGreatEscape]

http://cache.daylife.com/imageserve/06P01d78Oob6R/610x.jpg


It's not every day you find a black Brett Favre

I think we tell the world what buffalo has learned. Marshawn Lynch is JORDYZZZZZZZZZZZ' father, god.

[BeerBaron]

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v613/BeerBaron/hester.jpg

Devin ******* Hester.

put Mike Vike to shame.....who cares if he can even throw, just put 10 blockers and Hester out there, and have him run QB draws the whole game. Maybe 9 blockers, Hester and a good option running back.....

Every play would have serious highlight reel potential

eh-heh-hem.....

I have not yet been convinced otherwise.

[GB12]

eh-heh-hem.....

I have not yet been convinced otherwise.
Well he can't be worse than the QBs you do have

[TheGreatEscape]

eh-heh-hem.....

I have not yet been convinced otherwise.

Buffalo's #23 > Chicago's #23

[BeerBaron]

Well he can't be worse than the QBs you do have

i've been petitioning that we run the option with hester as QB since he started.....

i mean really, that plus the defense....we'd be better already!

[TheGreatEscape]

i've been petitioning that we run the option with hester as QB since he started.....

i mean really, that plus the defense....we'd be better already!

That'd actually be pretty cool to see, the bears bringing back the option.

[Pb&j]

Obviously Joshua Cribbs, "the Michael Vick of the MAC". He really does have an arm on him too.

[BeerBaron]

That'd actually be pretty cool to see, the bears bringing back the option.

i mean, and i say this in a completely serious way, absolutely nothing that happens should they try that can really be worse that what theyve had recently......

everyone would tune in to see those games, am i wrong? hester, some speed backs and some big blockers run around like maniacs for a little while, maybe they score or something, and then the D comes out.

^^^^ = awesomeness

[Brent]

Arnaz Battle

[The Dynasty]

Sidney Rice.

[Im_a_Romosexual]

LaDanian Tomlinson

[TitanHope]

I'll throw out a name not used yet and say Michael Robinson, RB for SF who played QB for Penn State.

[keylime_5]

Either Josh Cribbs or Antwan Randle El. College QBs who can throw and run. I pick Cribbs b/c he is a Brown :), Randle El is an ex-Steeler :( and Redskin :(

[kalbears13]

Megaman

http://www.dan-dare.org/Dan%20Megaman/MegamanBig2.jpg

He's got a cannon for an arm.

[BrownsTown]

I would probably take Brad Smith...he was one of those guys who could have caught on as a backup QB somewhere.

As far as non former QBs go I might actually go D-Mac, he was great when they occasionally used him at QB in college.

[MetSox17]

Run DMC.

I'd run the Wild Hog all day.

[DHVF]

http://media.scout.com/media/image/33/334006.jpg
OMG, i think i just threw up in my mouth a little.

[Menardo75]

Definitly love to see Michael Robinson running the spread option again laying people out :)

[no love]

Definitly love to see Michael Robinson running the spread option again laying people out :)

I second that, athletic qb, great leader and tough. He wasn't half bad as a passer either.

[YAYareaRB]

Jamarcus Russell, since he plays NT now.

[GermanSaint]

Isaiah Stanback

[WMD]

Darren Sproles.

[CJSchneider]

Run DMC.

I'd run the Wild Hog all day.

I'm gonna have to agree with you on that one.

[eaglesalltheway]

I'd go with Randal El. He does have a more than decent arm and is mobile. I'd still much rather have a QB as my QB though:(

[eaglesalltheway]

I'll throw out a name not used yet and say Michael Robinson, RB for SF who played QB for Penn State.

I like that, but to be honest, he wouldn't maked it as a QB. There are many valid reasons he was moved to RB.

[wicket]

Randy Moss, showed his arm against pitt, good size, good arm and a winner

[ATLDirtyBirds]

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v613/BeerBaron/hester.jpg

Devin ******* Hester.

put Mike Vike to shame.....who cares if he can even throw, just put 10 blockers and Hester out there, and have him run QB draws the whole game. Maybe 9 blockers, Hester and a good option running back.....

Every play would have serious highlight reel potential



He doesn't put Vick to shame. Vick was just like Hester. He might not run a 4.25 but no one on the field had the same speed and quickness. Vick even makes Hester look slow. Too bad he was a lazy dogfighter, otherwise he could have done some big things.


Back on topic: From the Falcons? I'd have to say Joey Harrington. His play isn't deserving of calling him a quarterback.

[Bob Sanders Dreadlock]

http://www.masterpiecepumpkins.com/Graphics/ESPN-TonyKornheiser%20%20_photo.jpg

[abaddon41_80]

Probably Michael Robinson, he was pretty good at Penn St

[BeerBaron]

I like that, but to be honest, he wouldn't maked it as a QB. There are many valid reasons he was moved to RB.

he was better than Anthony "Deer in the Headlights" Morelli....

[eaglesalltheway]

he was better than Anthony "Deer in the Headlights" Morelli....

Very true, which is why Morelli isn't in the NFL right now... I meant that his play for a QB wouldn't translate theat well in the NFL, which is why it was smart for him to be moved to RB.

[critesy]

I'll throw out a name not used yet and say Michael Robinson, RB for SF who played QB for Penn State.

Definitly love to see Michael Robinson running the spread option again laying people out :)

Probably Michael Robinson, he was pretty good at Penn St


exactly who i was going to say, loved him at PSU, was definetly a beaut.

[draftguru151]

Brad Smith. Michael Robinson makes some sense as well.

[LTgiants]

Brandon Jacobs He's huge so he'll see the field well and have an arm once you teach him to throw.

http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd195/HammyAiello/IGN/GIFS/6obug69.gif

i think he knows how to throw http://www.nfldraftcountdown.com/forum/images/icons/icon10.gif

[Smokey Joe]

Paul McQuistan.

http://img66.imageshack.us/img66/2955/patmcqiz9.jpg
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/e/ed/Paul_McQuistan.jpg/200px-Paul_McQuistan.jpg

No one could take him down. He is 6'6", 315 lbs. of pure ugly-ness. I bet he smells to.

[BeerBaron]

McQuistan even looks like the kind who would smell.....

and doesn't he have a twin brother from the cowboys? he could play RB....have a nasty, ugly smelly backfield, lol

[kalbears13]

Ethan Albright- In Madden 07 he apparently had 17 throwing power and 16 throwing accuracy.

[BeerBaron]

Ethan Albright- In Madden 07 he apparently had 17 throwing power and 16 throwing accuracy.

there has been an Ethan Albright mention!

that means we get to whip this bad boy out:

http://www.thephatphree.com/features.asp?StoryID=3159&SectionID=2&LayoutType=1

[bhaarat316]

Aahha I love that, they think I am 2 ******* stupid 2 breath and walk.

Well he did send the letter to john madden rather than EA makes we wonder why he is so angry they got his awerness right of like 5

[locseti]

Out of the former college QB's it has to be MRob.

For the best of the rest, I'll take a Dark Horse - Michael Bush. He was a fantastic high school QB, and met Brian Brohm's team in the Kentucky State championship game. He threw for 468 yards and six touchdowns, running for 116 yds and another score in a narrow 59-56 defeat. Stud.

[Pittsburghs_finest]

Just to throw a curve ball into this... I will take Allen Iverson

[tylerb929]

Got to be different, how about Hunter Smith, the Colts' punter. He was originally recruited by ND as a QB, and he has a set of wheels on him, he's ran down punt returners multiple times.

[MetSox17]

Just to throw a curve ball into this... I will take Allen Iverson

Allen Iverson was beastly in High School..

[Xonraider]

Ronald Curry

[Hwoarang]

http://s3.amazonaws.com/coolspotters2_development/photos/1535/Hines_Ward_profile.jpg

[TheGreatEscape]

DeMarcus Ware cause he knows how pass rushers think.

[Hwoarang]

DeMarcus Ware cause he knows how pass rushers think.That would go for any defensive player.

[Hwoarang]

Paul McQuistan.

http://img66.imageshack.us/img66/2955/patmcqiz9.jpg


http://freshgear.net/gallery/movies/thumbs/odoyle_rules.jpg

[kalbears13]

That would go for any defensive player.

Except for Ted Washington. I don't think he's had a pass rush in decades.

[Byrd430]

McQuistan even looks like the kind who would smell.....

and doesn't he have a twin brother from the cowboys? he could play RB....have a nasty, ugly smelly backfield, lol

Pat McQuistan, yeah...


Btw, completely off the subject, but I just had to rack my brain trying to figure out who MRob is...

Does everybody in the world do the 'first letter of the first name, first syllable of the last name' nickname nowadays?

CJohn, JCut, JRus, TRo, MBul, JTay, RLew, DMac, JCam, LLan, RGro, DHes! WHERE DOES THE MADNESS END!!!

[kalbears13]

Pat McQuistan, yeah...


Btw, completely off the subject, but I just had to rack my brain trying to figure out who MRob is...

Does everybody in the world do the 'first letter of the first name, first syllable of the last name' nickname nowadays?

CJohn, JCut, JRus, TRo, MBul, JTay, RLew, DMac, JCam, LLan, RGro, DHes! WHERE DOES THE MADNESS END!!!

It ends at Dre Bly.

[RaiderNation]

http://bushcheney2004.blogspot.com/BushQB.jpg

[TheGreatEscape]

http://bushcheney2004.blogspot.com/BushQB.jpg

We know he's a decider, but is he cool sticking his hands into some big smelly dudes gooch?

[Byrd430]

George W. would be a great QB for Carolina, Atlanta, or TB.

He'd destroy New Orleans...

Oh wait, he already has....

[yourfavestoner]

http://www.dailypress.com/media/photo/2004-09/14386856.jpg

Allen Iverson