PDA

View Full Version : PF28 Offensive Rankings (at least a little bit)


princefielder28
10-07-2008, 06:22 PM
2009 Senior Rankings

QB
1. Cullen Harper | Clemson
2. Chase Daniel | Missouri
3. Chase Holbrook | New Mexico State
4. Rudy Carpenter | Arizona State
5. Brian Hoyer | Michigan State
6. Hunter Cantwell | Louisville
7. Nathan Brown | Central Arkansas
8. Tom Brandstater | Fresno State
9. Rhett Bomar | Sam Houston State
10. Curtis Painter | Purdue

RB
1. James Davis | Clemson
2. Javon Ringer | Michigan State
3. Devin Moore | Wyoming
4. Jeremiah Johnson | Oregon
5. Rashad Jennings | Liberty
6. Kory Sheets | Purdue
7. Arian Foster | Tennessee
8. Brandon Ore | West Liberty State
9. Andre Brown | North Carolina State
10. Ian Johnson | Boise State

WR
1. Brian Robiskie | Ohio State
2. Brandon Tate | North Carolina
3. Juaquin Iglesias | Oklahoma
4. Brandon Gibson | Washington State
5. Derrick Williams | Penn State
6. Jarett Dillard | Rice
7. Louis Murphy | Florida
8. Jaison Williams | Oregon
9. Demetrius Byrd | Louisiana State
10. Tiquan Underwood | Rutgers

TE
1. Chase Coffman | Missouri
2. Travis Beckum | Wisconsin
3. Brandon Pettigrew | Oklahoma State
4. Shawn Nelson | Southern Miss
5. Cornelius Ingram | Florida

OL
1. Eugene Monroe | Virginia
2. Michael Oher | Mississippi
3. Alex Mack | California
4. Duke Robinson | Oklahoma
5. Jason Smith | Baylor
6. Jamon Meredith | South Carolina
7. Phil Loadholt | Oklahoma
8. Jonathan Luigs | Arkansas
9. Herman Johnson | Louisiana State
10. Max Unger | Oregon

Matthew Jones
10-07-2008, 06:41 PM
Man, this senior QB crop is miserable. Brandstater should be higher, IMO. Like where Chase Daniel is. I think I'd put Cantwell a bit higher. I think Derrick Williams is in the top three for senior WRs, making a push for the #1 spot. What do you dislike so much about Pettigrew? Is it on a legal or talent basis?

princefielder28
10-07-2008, 06:42 PM
Man, this senior QB crop is miserable. Brandstater should be higher, IMO. Like where Chase Daniel is. I think I'd put Cantwell a bit higher. I think Derrick Williams is in the top three for senior WRs, making a push for the #1 spot. What do you dislike so much about Pettigrew? Is it on a legal or talent basis?

Cantwell's mechanics are just too questionable for me to place him higher

With Pettigrew it's the overall package that I don't like. Character has a bit of an influence and I think his overall ability is a bit overrated

neko4
10-07-2008, 07:16 PM
Chase Daniel and Cullen Harper are far and away the best senior QBs imo.

SuperKevin
10-07-2008, 07:49 PM
Isn't Cullen Harper's shoulder dead right now? I'm hearing rumors of him going undrafted because of it

Your QB rankings are the only ones I really disagree with

princefielder28
10-07-2008, 08:01 PM
Isn't Cullen Harper's shoulder dead right now? I'm hearing rumors of him going undrafted because of it

Your QB rankings are the only ones I really disagree with

sprained AC joint in the right shoulder

Sniper
10-07-2008, 08:06 PM
Man, this senior QB crop is miserable. Brandstater should be higher, IMO. Like where Chase Daniel is. I think I'd put Cantwell a bit higher. I think Derrick Williams is in the top three for senior WRs, making a push for the #1 spot. What do you dislike so much about Pettigrew? Is it on a legal or talent basis?

Derrick Williams is ******* terrible. Stop. Just stop. YPC of 11.0 for his career and six career touchdowns receiving. I should slap you for saying he's even in the top 10.

abaddon41_80
10-07-2008, 08:09 PM
Top 2 senior QBs are Daniel and Carpenter, imo. Harper and Brandstater have played themselves to the bottom of the top 10 if you ask me.

Sniper
10-07-2008, 08:11 PM
2009 Senior Rankings

5. Brian Hoyer | Michigan State


Uberfail on that one, PF.

princefielder28
10-07-2008, 08:13 PM
Top 2 senior QBs are Daniel and Carpenter, imo. Harper and Brandstater have played themselves to the bottom of the top 10 if you ask me.

Brandstater is falling in my eyes as well. Harper's tools are greater than any other senior prospect's, and I am giving him a pass due to the injury to his right shoulder; if it turns out to be a long term problem then Harper will drop drastically.

princefielder28
10-07-2008, 08:20 PM
Uberfail on that one, PF.

I think that ranking is more of an insult to the class of QBs rather than what my rankings are. Hoyer has some more tools to work with than those below him and he is more fundamentally sound as well. There is not one QB that is worthy of a first round grade and probably only two worthy of a 2nd/early 3rd round grade.

georgiafan
10-08-2008, 09:06 AM
Brandstater is falling in my eyes as well. Harper's tools are greater than any other senior prospect's, and I am giving him a pass due to the injury to his right shoulder; if it turns out to be a long term problem then Harper will drop drastically.

Brandster does seem to be getting worse he looked pretty bad agianst Hawaii.

SuperKevin
10-08-2008, 05:48 PM
Chris Pizzotti of Harvard is a guy I've moved up my Quartback rankings quite a bit. He has excellent size at 6'6" 225 lbs and he seems to have plenty of tools. I hope he goes to one of the all star games so I can see more of him

regoob2
10-08-2008, 05:59 PM
Derrick Williams is ******* terrible. Stop. Just stop. YPC of 11.0 for his career and six career touchdowns receiving. I should slap you for saying he's even in the top 10.
Where was this post when Scott had a blog on him?

princefielder28
10-08-2008, 06:33 PM
Chris Pizzotti of Harvard is a guy I've moved up my Quartback rankings quite a bit. He has excellent size at 6'6" 225 lbs and he seems to have plenty of tools. I hope he goes to one of the all star games so I can see more of him

I've struggled to find footage of him playing so I have been unable to make an assessment of his play thus I did not rank him.

SuperKevin
10-08-2008, 06:45 PM
I've struggled to find footage of him playing so I have been unable to make an assessment of his play thus I did not rank him.

Yeah I saw one Harvard game early in the season and he looked impressive. I'm a big fan of the tall pocket passers which is why I like Brandstater as well

princefielder28
10-11-2008, 10:13 AM
DE

1. Brian Orakpo | Texas
2. Michael Johnson | Georgia Tech
3. Tyson Jackson | Louisiana State
4. Pannel Egboh | Stanford
5. Larry English | Northern Illinois
6. Matt Shaughnessy | Wisconsin
7. Tim Jamison | Michigan
8. Antwain Robinson | Arkansas
9. Brandon Swain | West Texas A&M
10. Will Davis | Illinois

DT

1. Peria Jerry | Ole Miss
2. B.J. Raji | Boston College
3. Terrance Taylor | Michigan
4. Vance Walker | Georgia Tech
5. Fili Moala | USC
6. Darryl Richard | Georgia Tech
7. Evander Hood | Missouri
8. Myron Pryor | Kentucky
9. George Hypolite | Colorado
10. Jake Visser | Ferris State

OLB

1. Aaron Curry | Wake Forest
2. Marcus Freeman | Ohio State
3. Brian Cushing | USC
4. Tyrone McKenzie | South Florida
5. Cody Brown | UCONN
6. Jonathan Casillas | Wisconsin
7. Clint Sintim | Virginia
8. Ian Campbell | Kansas State
9. Anthony Heygood | Purdue
10. Brian Toal | Boston College

ILB

1. Rey Maualuga | USC
2. James Laurinaitis | Ohio State
3. Darry Beckwith | Louisiana State
4. Dannell Ellerbe | Georgia
5. Scott McKillop | Pittsburgh

CB

1. Malcolm Jenkins | Ohio State
2. Darius Butler | UCONN
3. Domonique Johnson | Jackson State
4. Alphonso Smith | Wake Forest
5. Victor Harris | Virginia Tech
6. Mark Parson | Ohio
7. Mike Mickens | Cincinnati
8. Kevin Barnes | Maryland
9. DeAngelo Smith | Cincinnati
10. Wopamo Osaisai | Stanford

S

1. William Moore | Missouri
2. Derek Pegues | Mississippi State
3. Patrick Chung | Oregon
4. Rashad Johnson | Alabama
5. Michael Hamlin | Clemson
6. Curtis Taylor | Louisiana State
7. Chip Vaughn | Wake Forest
8. Courtney Greene | Rutgers
9. David Burton | Notre Dame
10. Kevin Ellison | USC