PDA

View Full Version : Xio's NHL Draft Voting Thread


Jensen
10-11-2008, 12:18 AM
Team Xiomera

Forwards
Alexander Ovechkin - Eric Staal [A] - Marian Hossa
Alex Tanguay - Jonathan Toews [C] - Johan Franzen
Patrick Elias - Brad Richards - Milan Hejduk
Ryan Malone - Scott Gomez - Dan Cleary
Drew Stafford

Defensemen
Jay Bouwmeester [A] - Niklas Kronwall
Ryan Whitney - Joe Corvo
Wade Redden - Dennis Wideman
Kevin Bieksa

Goaltenders
Marc-Andre Fleury
Ilya Bryzgalov

First Power Play Unit
Alexander Ovechkin - Eric Staal - Marian Hossa
Niklas Kronwall - Ryan Whitney

Second Power Play Unit
Scott Gomez - Jonathan Toews - Johan Franzen
Dennis Wideman - Brad Richards

First Penalty Kill Unit
Jonathan Toews - Johan Franzen
Jay Bouwmeester - Niklas Kronwall

Second Penalty Kill Unit
Brad Richards - Marian Hossa
Ryan Whitney - Joe Corvo
__________________

Team DJP

Dany Heatley - Mike Richards (A) - Jarome Iginla (C)
Mike Cammalleri - Derek Roy - Shane Doan (A)
Patrick O'Sullivan - Jeff Carter - Pierre-Marc Bouchard
Jonathan Cheechoo - Patrick Marleau - Kyle Okposo
Daymond Langkow

Zdeno Chara - Dan Boyle
Kimmo Timonen - Lubomir Visnovsky
Marek Zidlicky - Brooks Orpik
Chris Phillips

Henrik Lundqvist
Mikka Kipprusoff


PP1

Dany Heatley - Mike Richards - Jarome Iginla
_______Zdeno Chara - Dan Boyle_________

PP2

Mike Cammalleri - Derek Roy - Shane Doan
Pierre-Marc Bouchard - Lubomir Visnovsky

PK1

Mike Richards - Shane Doan
Zdeno Chara - Kimmo Timonen

PK2

Patrick Marleau - Jarome Iginla
Marek Zidlicky - Brooks Orpik
__________________

Team Jensen

Brenden Morrow - Sidney Crosby - Nathan Horton
Dustin Brown - Olli Jokinen - Nikolai Zherdev
Tomas Plekanec - Patrice Bergeron - Dustin Byfuglien
Milan Michalek - Sam Gagner - Bobby Ryan
Daniel Carcillo

Nicklas Lidstrom - Duncan Keith
Robyn Regehr - Ryan Suter
Andrej Meszaros - Tom Gilbert
Alex Goligoski

Evgeni Nabokov
Josh Harding

PP1:
Brenden Morrow - Sidney Crosby - Nathan Horton
Nicklas Lidstrom - Duncan Keith

PP2:
Dustin Brown - Olli Jokinen - Nikolai Zherdev
Tom Gilbert - Patrice Bergeron

PK1:
Patrice Bergeron - Brenden Morrow
Nicklas Lidstrom - Duncan Keith

PK2:
Tomas Plekanec - Dustin Brown
Robyn Regehr - Ryan Suter

C - Brenden Morrow
A - Nicklas Lidstrom
A - Robyn Regehr
__________________

Team Eaglez.Fan

Alexander Frolov - Joe Thornton - Martin St. Louis
Steve Bernier - Jason Spezza - Daniel Alfredsson
Brad Boyes - Marc Savard - Kristian Huselius
Dustin Penner - Mike Fisher - Sean Avery
Brian Little

Scott Niedermayer - Sergei Gonchar
Brian Campbell - Sergei Zubov
Erik Johnson - J-M Liles
Karl Alzner

Martin Brodeur
Rick DiPietro

__________________

Team Chucky

Simon Gagne-Vinny Lecavalier- Martin Havlat
Thomas Vanek- Paul Stastny - Patrick Sharp
Jordan Staal- Mats Sundin- Brian Gionta
Chris Drury-Peter Forsberg- Nik Antropov

BENCH: Henrik Sedin

Dion Phaneuf- Anton Volchenkov
Shea Webber- Jack Johnson
Pavel Kubina- Brian McCabe

Bench: Luke Schenn


Roberto Luongo
Pascal Leclaire
__________________

Team HChu

Lines:
1: Kovalchuk - Datsyuk (A) - Kovalev (A)
2: Semin - Backstrom - Perry
3: Vermette - Ribeiro - Lucic
4: Laich - Stamkos - Kessel

Defensemen Pairings:
1: Green - Rafalski (A)
2: Enstrom - Jovanovski (A)
3: Niskanen - Blake (C)

Goalies:
1: Price
2: Rask

Healthy Scratch: Voracek - Pietrangelo

PP1:
Kovalchuk - Datsyuk - Semin
Green - Kovalev

PP2:
Ribeiro - Backstrom - Perry
Jovanovski - Blake

PK1:
Datsyuk - Vermette
Niskanen - Rafalski

PK2:
Stamkos - Lucic
Blake - Enstrom

3-Man PK1:
Datsyuk
Niskanen - Rafalski

3-Man PK2:
Vermette
Blake - Enstrom

4 on 4 1:
Datsyuk - Kovalchuk
Green - Rafalski

4 on 4 2:
Backstrom - Kovalev
Enstrom - Jovanovski
__________________

Team SuperMcGee

Rick Nash - Henrik Zetterberg (A) - Marian Gaborik
Ryan Smyth (C) - Daniel Briere - Patrick Kane
Daniel Sedin - Shawn Horcoff - Ales Hemsky
Erik Cole - Mikko Koivu - JP Dumont
..............David Booth

Chris Pronger (A) - Tomas Kaberle
Dan Hamhuis - Nick Schultz
Sheldon Souray - Braydon Coburn
............Alexander Edler

Marty Turco
Jean-Sebastien Giguere

PP1:
Rick Nash - Daniel Briere - Marian Gaborik
......Chris Pronger - Tomas Kaberle

PP2:
Patrick Kane - Henrik Zetterberg - Ales Hemsky
........Sheldon Souray - Braydon Coburn

PK1:
Henrik Zetterberg - Shawn Horcoff
Chris Pronger - Dan Hamhuis

PK2:
Mikko Koivu - Erik Cole
Tomas Kaberle - Nick Schultz
__________________

Team Woot

Zach Parise - Evgeni Malkin - Jason Pominville
Andrei Kostitsyn - Ryan Getzlaf - Peter Mueller
Wojtek Wolski - Anze Kopitar - Joffrey Lupul
Mikkel Boedker - Kyle Turris - Sergei Kostitsyn
Jiri Tlusty

Andrei Markov - Mike Komisarek
Brent Burns - Brent Seabrook
Drew Doughty - Kris Letang
Zach Bogosian

Ryan Miller
Jonathan Bernier

Xiomera
10-11-2008, 12:13 PM
I like DJP and Jensen's teams the best . . . besides mine that is.

Chucky
10-11-2008, 12:15 PM
My team FTW. My team would definately win 2 of the next 3 years

Eaglez.Fan
10-11-2008, 12:23 PM
My team FTW. My team would definately win 2 of the next 3 years

My team would ruin your team in the 1st two years.

Xiomera
10-11-2008, 12:39 PM
Woot, I mean no offense to you here, but you're gonna win without having the best team. All your pals will vote you in without looking at the other teams.

You drafted so many young players (lots of 18-19 year old rookies?). If people were actually looking at the parameters for voting, then obviously picking guys like Bogosian and Boedker should hurt your chances. Those guys are gonna be very good in 5 years. But they aren't gonna be better than most regular NHL defenseman the next couple years.

And your goaltending is easily the worst. Miller isn't a top 8 starter in this league, and Bernier isn't a top 25 goalie in this league. Not the kind of combination you would want for the next three seasons.

Again, Woot's team is nice, but as usual, you picked way too many young, prospect-types.

djp
10-11-2008, 12:57 PM
I say we do the Jensen voting system. That was awesome, when we ranked the teams 1-7. This poll thing never works correctly.

Xiomera
10-11-2008, 01:04 PM
I say we do the Jensen voting system. That was awesome, when we ranked the teams 1-7. This poll thing never works correctly.

Yes, we shall do that.

Draft participants, please send me your rankings via PM. Rank them from 1-7 (excluding your own team). 1 is the best, 7 is the worst. Lowest composite score wins.

Wootylicous
10-11-2008, 01:18 PM
Woot, I mean no offense to you here, but you're gonna win without having the best team. All your pals will vote you in without looking at the other teams.

You drafted so many young players (lots of 18-19 year old rookies?). If people were actually looking at the parameters for voting, then obviously picking guys like Bogosian and Boedker should hurt your chances. Those guys are gonna be very good in 5 years. But they aren't gonna be better than most regular NHL defenseman the next couple years.

And your goaltending is easily the worst. Miller isn't a top 8 starter in this league, and Bernier isn't a top 25 goalie in this league. Not the kind of combination you would want for the next three seasons.

Again, Woot's team is nice, but as usual, you picked way too many young, prospect-types.

Someone is mad because I'm winning :)

Xiomera
10-11-2008, 01:20 PM
Someone is mad because I'm winning :)

Fortunatly for all of us the voting method won't mean a damn thing. We're doing ranked lists from participants to decide.

Woot, if you could make a good argument as to why your team justify's the most votes then I could accept that. But seriously, what is the strength and appeal of your team exactly?

Xiomera
10-11-2008, 01:21 PM
I have received one list of Rankings. I need 6 more.

Eaglez.Fan
10-11-2008, 01:40 PM
I have received one list of Rankings. I need 6 more.

Do we have to send in lists or is it only the judges?

SuperMcGee
10-11-2008, 02:20 PM
I think this poll is pretty much backwards. Not that woot is the worst, but that djp, Xio, and I have the best teams, imo. This time around I just took good players that I like (minus Pronger, Souray, Sedin; and surprisingly no Sabres). I think I ended up with a very good all-around squad. No elite goalie but a solid pair. I might've been better off taking a guy like Setoguchi as my reserve forward, but I'm too big a fan of Booth.

DJP is probably the best, but it would've been Chucky if he had Radulov.

djp
10-11-2008, 02:22 PM
My top 3 was Xio, Mcgee, Jensen in that order.

It's honestly laughable that woot is leading the poll.

HChu
10-11-2008, 02:25 PM
You all just sleep on my team! I rule! But seriously I like djp's team the best.

princefielder28
10-11-2008, 02:55 PM
Jensen = winner

Xiomera
10-11-2008, 07:41 PM
I have received 4 lists (mine included). And so far, three different teams are ranked #1.

Woot, EF, HChu and Chucky need to give me 1-7 lists.

Xiomera
10-11-2008, 09:13 PM
Still waiting on 3 more lists . . .

We actually have one team that is ranked first on one list and last on another. haha

Church0099
10-12-2008, 05:41 PM
DJP for sure. And Xio you gotta give Ovie an "A."

djp
10-12-2008, 07:03 PM
DJP for sure. And Xio you gotta give Ovie an "A."

Thanks, but why did you vote for EF then? haha.

Jensen
10-12-2008, 07:07 PM
I also had DJP #1 excluding my team.

Church0099
10-12-2008, 07:16 PM
Thanks, but why did you vote for EF then? haha.

I felt bad because no one else voted for him and Iwanted to rewards a fellow Eagles fan.

Xiomera
10-12-2008, 07:18 PM
DJP wins.

I only received 6 rankings (Chucky and Woot slacking), but it was clear he is the winner.

Congrats man.

Jensen, Xiomera, and SuperMcGee were consistantly ranked 2-4 in various orders.

Eaglez.Fan
10-12-2008, 08:12 PM
I felt bad because no one else voted for him and Iwanted to rewards a fellow Eagles fan.

wow churchy. My team is the best and you know it. Your just jealous because I'm beating you in accounting.

HChu
10-12-2008, 09:11 PM
Yeah, I voted djp. Although, what did people not like about my team out of curiosity?

Xiomera
10-12-2008, 09:14 PM
Yeah, I voted djp. Although, what did people not like about my team out of curiosity?

You had a pretty solid team all around. I think I had you 3rd on my list.

To be honest, I don't think there is a clear cut winner here. DJP has the best team, but his team isn't nearly as good as some winning teams have been in the past.

Church0099
10-12-2008, 11:35 PM
wow churchy. My team is the best and you know it. Your just jealous because I'm beating you in accounting.

How can you beat 100%?