PDA

View Full Version : Who Would You Pick?


jbooshey
11-20-2008, 07:11 PM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

SMoore
11-20-2008, 07:16 PM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Also, where is Desean Jackson at WR?

BamaFalcon59
11-20-2008, 07:28 PM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Pretty even, gos by position.

CashmoneyDrew
11-20-2008, 07:31 PM
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Sniper
11-20-2008, 07:33 PM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

jbooshey
11-20-2008, 07:33 PM
Also, where is Desean Jackson at WR?

Just went with the first 5 wideouts picked last year...either Desean was the 6th or I missed him...

Yatta!
11-20-2008, 07:39 PM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

jbooshey
11-20-2008, 07:41 PM
Wow Voodoo...no love for last year's DE's....or do you just fancy this years that much?

CashmoneyDrew
11-20-2008, 07:54 PM
Wow Voodoo...no love for last year's DE's....or do you just fancy this years that much?

Eh, I thought about going with Chris Long but changed my mind at the last minute.

PACKmanN
11-20-2008, 08:00 PM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
[/b]Aqib Talib[/b] or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

those are my thoughts.

Why are people taking Brandon over Duke for an OG? IMO, Duke is the better OG.

Also why would you compare Keith to a MLB and Mayo to an OLB? should switch the comparison.

BamaFalcon59
11-20-2008, 08:03 PM
those are my thoughts.

Why are people taking Brandon over Duke for an OG? IMO, Duke is the better OG.

I'm just talking complete prospect. Brandon Albert is a small dropoff at guard from Duke Robinson, but also has the potential to be a great offensive tackle.

SeanTaylorRIP
11-20-2008, 08:13 PM
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson: Strange one? Albert because of his ability to play tackle and guard though
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith: Tough one because huge fan of Smith, but I'll go long
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe: UVA homer but Clady is good
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith: Smith will be a much better pass blocker
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo: Chris Long will be more consistent player, Orakpo more explosive and game breaking. Both are my favorite DE's from their respective draft classes
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson: Don't really like either but Gholston is bigger and stronger and more versatile
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry: Ellis but IMO Jerry is top DT in the draft
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry: Mayo is already good, but Curry is going to be a beast.
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Davis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford: Ryan Easy
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford: Flacco is going to be studly. Not on the Bradford bandwaggon

bigsargefc
11-21-2008, 05:36 AM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Some of these are pretty bad matchups... comparing Sedrick Ellis to Peria Jerry? Kentwan Balmer against George Selvie? That's a UT against a speed rushing DE, you know?

DeathbyStat
11-21-2008, 09:04 AM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?

Branden Albert

Andre Smith

Ryan Clady

Chris Williams

Jason Smith

Jeff Otah

Sam Baker

Duane Brown

Brian Orakpo

Michael Johnson

Greg Hardy

Everette Brown

George Selvie

Glenn Dorsey

Sedrick Ellis

Aaron Curry

Rey Maualuga

Malcolm Jenkins

DRC

Alphonso Smith

Darius Butler

Antoine Cason

Kenny Phillips

Jermaine Gresham

Jeremy Maclin

Michael Crabtree

Jordy Nelson

James Hardy

Eddie Royal

Darren McFadden

Jonathan Stewart

Felix Jones

Rashard Mendenhall

Chris Johnson

Matt Ryan

Sam Bradford

Larry121283
11-21-2008, 09:22 AM
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson -- He is a left tackle, although, Duke is going to be a Pro Bowl G. I'd take both and their draft grade is about even.
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith -- Already proven to be a top flight left tackle. Draft grade about even.
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe -- Already proven to be a top flight left tackle. Draft grade about even.
Chris Williams or Michael Oher -- I'll abstain...but Oher's draft grade is much higher.
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith -- Gosder is a good RT. I'll abstain for now.
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt -- Future Pro Bowl RT.
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith -- Left tackle, as good as Long and Clady, just been injured this season.
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog -- Brown hasn't been good at all. He is taking the D'Brickashaw Fergsuon route, methinks.
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie

I'll abstain on all of these guys. As prospects though...Long, Gholston, and Harvey were better. Jackson and Brown are equal, although I like LoJack better and Selvie I like more than Balmer.
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry -- Even
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy

All of this years wide outs sans, Murphy.
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells -- Even.
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno -- Even.
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller -- Jones.
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis -- Mendenhall.
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer -- Johnson
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford -- Tough to tell.
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford -- Tough to tell.

619
11-21-2008, 09:44 AM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Davis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

CroomDawgs
11-21-2008, 10:10 AM
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

marshallb
11-21-2008, 10:21 AM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson not really sure about this one. Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry this is very tough
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

My picks are in bold.

dukelionsm
11-21-2008, 11:04 AM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree-liked Devin Thomas tho
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford[/QUOTE]

Mr.Regular
11-21-2008, 11:15 AM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Davis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

ChezPower4
11-21-2008, 11:33 AM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordyzzzzzzzzzzzzzz Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Jordyzzzzzzz>better then all

Michigan
11-21-2008, 02:40 PM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

keylime_5
11-21-2008, 03:32 PM
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

i don't necessarily like the matchups. I think Laurinaitis is gonna be rated higher than maualuga and crabtree higher than maclin and mays higher than moore...and balmer is a DT while Selvie is a small rush end.

Babylon
11-21-2008, 04:12 PM
i don't necessarily like the matchups. I think Laurinaitis is gonna be rated higher than maualuga and crabtree higher than maclin and mays higher than moore...and balmer is a DT while Selvie is a small rush end.

Tough to compare College guys to pro guys too. I would have compared Mayo to Rey Rey and Rivers to Curry also.

One thing that surprised me was the response to Ryan and Stafford. I like Ryan but i'm not sure what he does as good as Stafford.

d34ng3l021
11-21-2008, 04:58 PM
Tough to compare College guys to pro guys too. I would have compared Mayo to Rey Rey and Rivers to Curry also.

One thing that surprised me was the response to Ryan and Stafford. I like Ryan but i'm not sure what he does as good as Stafford.

Read defenses, be a leader, make decisions. And those are all the things he does better.

But this is an unfair comparison because we have had 14 NFL games to evaluate these rookies and the other prospects haven't even finished their college careers.

Babylon
11-21-2008, 05:09 PM
Read defenses, be a leader, make decisions. And those are all the things he does better.

But this is an unfair comparison because we have had 14 NFL games to evaluate these rookies and the other prospects haven't even finished their college careers.


You're right it's totally unfair because you're talking about a 20 year old junior compared to the OROY in the NFL. I love Matt Ryan but i think at a similar stage Stafford is a better prospect, just my opinion.

d34ng3l021
11-21-2008, 05:14 PM
You're right it's totally unfair because you're talking about a 20 year old junior compared to the OROY in the NFL. I love Matt Ryan but i think at a similar stage Stafford is a better prospect, just my opinion.

Yeah I agree. If I were looking at these 2 before the draft and not knowing which goes to which team and how their rookie season goes, I would be inclined to like Stafford as well.

I was crazy about taking Glenn Dorsey and building an OL and then drafting Stafford this season.

Babylon
11-21-2008, 05:18 PM
Yeah I agree. If I were looking at these 2 before the draft and not knowing which goes to which team and how their rookie season goes, I would be inclined to like Stafford as well.

I was crazy about taking Glenn Dorsey and building an OL and then drafting Stafford this season.


Will say that if Stafford does for the Lions (most likely) what Matt has done for the Falcons they'll be doing handstands there in Detroit.

keylime_5
11-21-2008, 05:29 PM
I definitely like Ryan over Stafford right now. ryan looks like he's gonna be the NFC's best quarterback in only a couple years. Stafford has a great arm but he is more of a gunslinger and relies too much on his gun and less on his accuracy and instincts.

d34ng3l021
11-21-2008, 05:35 PM
Will say that if Stafford does for the Lions (most likely) what Matt has done for the Falcons they'll be doing handstands there in Detroit.

I like Stafford in Detroit. If they can get him some protection, he and Calvin Johnson will be hooking up a lot.

And Ryan was called a gunslinger too (gunslinger mentality without the physical tools). I don't know if being called a gunslinger is the worst thing for a QB. You have to get your QB to go out there and make plays.

Babylon
11-21-2008, 05:39 PM
I definitely like Ryan over Stafford right now. ryan looks like he's gonna be the NFC's best quarterback in only a couple years. Stafford has a great arm but he is more of a gunslinger and relies too much on his gun and less on his accuracy and instincts.

60% accuracy this year is as good or better than Ryan's was at BC so i would say his accuracy is good. I think he reads coverage exceptionally well and can make a series of reads on every play. I think there is a feeling because a guy has a great arm he has nothing else, don't think that's the case here.

d34ng3l021
11-21-2008, 05:46 PM
60% accuracy this year is as good or better than Ryan's was at BC so i would say his accuracy is good. I think he reads coverage exceptionally well and can make a series of reads on every play. I think there is a feeling because a guy has a great arm he has nothing else, don't think that's the case here.

Yeah. I like him a lot. He makes some good reads and spectacular throws.

keylime_5
11-21-2008, 06:00 PM
60% accuracy this year is as good or better than Ryan's was at BC so i would say his accuracy is good. I think he reads coverage exceptionally well and can make a series of reads on every play. I think there is a feeling because a guy has a great arm he has nothing else, don't think that's the case here.

i don't really pay attention to completion pct. in college. Terrelle Pryor leads the big ten with 65%, but he doesn't throw passes with that much precision. Ryan has some pretty good precision, Stafford's isn't quite that good.

P-L
11-21-2008, 06:05 PM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson (Robinson at OG, Albert at OT. Overall? Albert)
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith (I love Andre Smith, but the homer in me is hard to control at this moment)
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson (I don't like Johnson much, but based on what I've seen from Gholston as a Jet, I have to take M.J.)
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie (Balmer is a 3-4 DE or 4-3 DT, Selvie is a 3-4 LB or 4-3 DE. Odd comparison, but give me Selvie)
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Picks bolded.

d34ng3l021
11-21-2008, 06:11 PM
STAFFORD OVER RYAN!?

Preposterous.

Babylon
11-21-2008, 06:25 PM
STAFFORD OVER RYAN!?

Preposterous.

Blasphemous even.:)

Cigaro
11-21-2008, 06:31 PM
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Had the toughest time with Smith-Long, Stewart-Moreno, and Phillips-Moore.

Pokeys
11-21-2008, 09:49 PM
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

regoob2
11-21-2008, 10:34 PM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher cough homer cough
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Davis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford
The only reason I picked last years QBs is cause they've have success in the NFL.

regoob2
11-21-2008, 10:37 PM
those are my thoughts.

Why are people taking Brandon over Duke for an OG? IMO, Duke is the better OG.

Also why would you compare Keith to a MLB and Mayo to an OLB? should switch the comparison.
Cause Albert can also Play LT, RT as well as OG.

regoob2
11-21-2008, 10:38 PM
You're right it's totally unfair because you're talking about a 20 year old junior compared to the OROY in the NFL. I love Matt Ryan but i think at a similar stage Stafford is a better prospect, just my opinion.Is he a better prospect or does he have more upside? Id say upside.

Edit sorry about triple post.

Staubach12
11-22-2008, 12:33 AM
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Dam8610
11-22-2008, 12:58 AM
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore Can I pick both?
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Mr. Stiller
11-22-2008, 06:45 AM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson ~ Gholston for a 4-3, perhaps Johnson for a 3-4 OLB.. depending on Combine/workouts.
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie ~ Balmer is a DE ONLY Because he plays for a 3-4 Team. This should be Quentin Groves vs. Selvie.. I take Selvie.
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry ~ Mayo was a MLB, Curry an OLB. This should be Rivers vs. Curry.
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga ~ Rivers is an OLB, Maualuga is a MLB? Where's the comparison? Mayo vs. Maualuga? I take Mayo and Curry.
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford


Gotta take into account that last years crop had Combine/Senior bowl results and this one hasn't. As for defense you have to take into account scheme as well.

You'd probably also be better off comparing them to similar players the previous years.

Mendenhall and James Davis have 0 in common.

wicket
11-22-2008, 07:21 AM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson neither
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordyzzzzzzzzzzzz Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Pokeys
11-22-2008, 09:19 AM
Vontae Davis ain't better than DRC. Same goes for Moreno.

Babylon
11-22-2008, 11:16 AM
Is he a better prospect or does he have more upside? Id say upside.

Edit sorry about triple post.

I think individually Ryan probably accomplished more although playing SEC competition is a little tougher than the ACC. It has to be all about upside otherwise all those Big-12 QBs would be the first ones off the board.

jbooshey
11-23-2008, 06:20 PM
You'd probably also be better off comparing them to similar players the previous years.

Mendenhall and James Davis have 0 in common.

Not sure why you think comparing players who have only things in common is necessary...James and Mendenhall do share one BIG similarity in that they play the same position. The choice then comes down to what type of running back you prefer or just who you think is going to be better.

etk
11-23-2008, 06:24 PM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
both were very close....I like all 4.
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

That was fun.

etk
11-23-2008, 06:28 PM
Vontae Davis ain't better than DRC. Same goes for Moreno.

DRC shouldn't even be mentioned in the same breath as Vontae Davis. Sorry.

Agree about Moreno though.

Brothgar
11-23-2008, 06:39 PM
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

RaiderNation
11-23-2008, 07:02 PM
Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert
OT
Andre Smith
Ryan Clady
Chris Williams
Jason Smith
Jeff Otah
Sam Baker
Duane Brown
DE
Chris Long
Michael Johnson
Greg Hardy
Everette Brown
George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey
Sedrick Ellis
OLB
Aaron Curry
ILB
Rey Maualuga
CB
Malcolm Jenkins
Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib
Mike Jenkins
Antoine Cason
S
Kenny Phillips
TE
Dustin Keller
WR
Jeremy Maclin
Michael Crabtree
Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy
Eddie Royal
RB
Darren McFadden
Jonathan Stewart
Felix Jones
Rashard Mendenhall
Chris Johnson
QB
Matt Ryan
Sam Bradford

Habibi
11-23-2008, 07:37 PM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Some of those comparisons are just weird.

Aftermath
11-23-2008, 09:52 PM
This is based on what you've seen this year from rookies and the prospects coming out. (Based on Last year's first round and Scott's prospect rankings with some underclassmen sprinkled at some positions to make it interesting)

Who would you rather have playing on your team?
OG
Branden Albert or Duke Robinson
OT
Jake Long or Andre Smith
Ryan Clady or Eugene Monroe
Chris Williams or Michael Oher
Gosder Cherilus or Jason Smith
Jeff Otah or Phil Loadholt
Sam Baker or Jamon Meredith
Duane Brown or Troy Kropog
DE
Chris Long or Brian Orakpo
Vernon Gholston or Michael Johnson
Derrick Harvey or Greg Hardy
Lawrence Jackson or Everette Brown
Kentwan Balmer or George Selvie
DT
Glenn Dorsey or Sen'Derrick Marks
Sedrick Ellis or Peria Jerry
OLB
Jerod Mayo or Aaron Curry
ILB
Keith Rivers or Rey Maualuga
CB
Leodis McKelvin or Malcolm Jenkins
DRC or Vontae Davis
Aqib Talib or Alphonso Smith
Mike Jenkins or Darius Butler
Antoine Cason or Mike Mickens
S
Kenny Phillips or William Moore
TE
Dustin Keller or Jermaine Gresham
WR (I know there were no 1st rounders but oh well)
Donnie Avery or Jeremy Maclin
Devin Thomas or Michael Crabtree
Jordy Nelson or Darrius Heyward Bey
James Hardy or Percy Harvin
Eddie Royal or Louis Murphy
RB
Darren McFadden or Beanie Wells
Jonathan Stewart or Knowshon Moreno
Felix Jones or CJ Spiller
Rashard Mendenhall or James Dvis
Chris Johnson or Javon Ringer
QB
Matt Ryan or Matthew Stafford
Joe Flacco or Sam Bradford

Whoop, there it is.