PDA

View Full Version : Cigaro's Holiday One Rounder (W/ Full Explanations & Pictures)


Cigaro
12-23-2008, 11:02 AM
1. Detroit Lions- Sam Bradford, QB, Oklahoma

http://i40.tinypic.com/1490bib.png

Likely the worst team in NFL history, the Lions have no proven talent anywhere minus Calvin Johnson, making almost any pick an upgrade. But place for this lost team to start is quarterback. Bradford, the second straight sophomore to win the Heisman, possesses a great arm, ultra quick release, and the necessary intelligence to start first day.

2. St. Louis Rams- Andre Smith, OT, Alabama

http://i40.tinypic.com/27xh340.png

Smith is one of the few 'elite' talents in this class, and has a great future ahead of him. The Rams desperately need a better offensive line to block for Stephen Jackson, and Smith is the mauler who fits in perfectly. There are some legitimate concerns about his height and weight, but that hasn't stopped Smith from being the best tackle in all of college, and it likely won't stop him from being one of the best in the pros.

3. Kansas City Chiefs- Brian Orakpo, DE, Texas

http://i43.tinypic.com/nz21w8.png

For a team with the number three pick, they aren't all that bad. The Chiefs have lost quite a few games, but they've been in most of them, and with many starters relatively young, they're bound to improve eventually. The one area the Chiefs definately lack in is the pass rush. Orakpo finally achieved his potential this season, and with a likely monster combine performance, should shoot himself up the boards of most teams.

4. Cincinnati Bengals- Chris Wells, RB, Ohio State

http://i41.tinypic.com/b6eu15.png

As it turned out, 2005 was a fluke. The team's first winning season since 1990 was followed by an 8-8 2006 performance, a 7-9 2007 season, and horrible 2-11-1 2008 campaign. The team can have one of the league's premier passing attacks when everyone's healthy and on the same page, but if Cedric Benson is starting for your team, you know you have running troubles. Chris Wells, the local Ohio State product, is undoubtedly the best running back available, and while his injury and lack of great receiving ability keep him from the 'elite' range, he's still unquestionably one of the top talents available.

5. Seattle Seahawks- Michael Crabtree, WR, Texas Tech

http://i41.tinypic.com/11bsx11.png

The Seahawks have suffered through a horrific 4-11 season in Mike Holmgren's last go around as a Hawk, and a lot of that has to do with the passing game. Matthew Stafford would certainly get a long look here, but when healthy, Matt Hasselbeck is still a respectable passer. The Seahawks unquestionably lack receiving talent, however. Crabtree will go down as one of college football's best, even though he only played two years, and while he'll have to break the stereotype of system receivers, he could provide immediate relief for struggling Seattle.

6. Oakland Raiders- Michael Oher, OT, Mississippi

http://i40.tinypic.com/1zwomm0.png

Like the Lions, this team is lost, and no matter how much talent they bring, likely will be as long as Al Davis is running the show. Even Al Davis should realize, however, that Kwame Harris as a starting tackle can and never will be a good sign. Michael Oher sometimes can go cold, but his athleticism and ability to dominate the line when he wants to gets Davis too horny to pass up.

7. Cleveland Browns- Everette Brown, LB, Florida State

http://i43.tinypic.com/25p62yo.png

Brown is one of the nation's premier pass rushers, and the Browns lack any sense of such. Willie McGinest is far past his prime, and for a 3-4 to function properly, both outside backers have to be legitimate threats to strike at any time. Everette Brown brings the prototypical size, speed, and strength to the position, and would be an immediate upgrade.

8. Jacksonville Jaguars- Duke Robinson, OG, Oklahoma

http://i43.tinypic.com/fwt9px.png

Robinson's combination of size, strength, and athleticism makes him one of the best guard prospects in the past few years, but even so, a guard at number eight is a reach, and unluckily for the Jaguars, I don't simulate trades. While it may be quite early for a guard, it can be easily argued that Robinson is worth the pick, however. The Jaguars calling card, when successful, is a dominating offensive line. Destroyed by injuries, the line has been anything but dominant this season, and the Jaguars have seen the results. Robinson would be a day one starter and would easily help the Jaguars line return to it's former glory.

9. Green Bay Packers- Eugene Monroe, OT, Virginia

http://i42.tinypic.com/30jgv4i.png

The Green Bay Packers have fallen far and hard from last season's 13-3 regular season mark and NFC Championship Game berth, and the offensive line has done anything but help. Eugene Monroe has been beat a few times this year, but has still proven to be one of the top lineman available to NFL teams, and would immediately contend for a starting position.

10. San Francisco 49ers- Taylor Mays, S, Southern California

http://i42.tinypic.com/vskldt.png

Taylor Mays hasn't been the biggest playmaker during his Trojan career, but with all the talent around him, it's hard to be. 49ers would have to look at quarterback and offensive tackle, but Shaun Hill has been playing well, and they invested a first round pick two years ago on Joe Staley. Mays and his breathtaking athleticism would bring and immediate force to the 49ers lackluster secondary.

11. San Diego Chargers- Rey Maualuga, LB, Southern California

http://i41.tinypic.com/287gi0g.png

Inside linebacker may not be the biggest need for this underperforming team, but it's hard to pass up one of college football's deadliest enforcers. Maualuga undoubtedly has the size to play inside, and his nastiness and bloodthirst would make teams thing twice before trying to expose the Chargers in the middle.

12. Houston Texans- Vontae Davis, CB, Illinois

http://i44.tinypic.com/25ku5pu.png

Dunta Robinson was a great young corner before his injury, but's unsure whether he'll ever return to form. Fred Bennett has been a pleasant surprise so far, but with DeMarcus Faggins beat regularly, it'd be hard to pass up a top flight corner. Davis will likely put up a monster combine, which should move him ahead of Jenkins on many boards.

13. Buffalo Bills- Aaron Curry, LB, Wake Forest

http://i39.tinypic.com/2v2jgia.png

The Buffalo Bills thundered out of the gate, but couldn't keep up the pace, which is exactly how they ended up with the thirteenth overall selections. One of the Bills biggest needs is tight end, but in this stacked class, the Bills need for a SAM backer would probably rank higher. Curry is unquestionably the best outside backer available in the draft, and could contribute immediately.

14. Washington Redskins- Jason Smith, OT, Baylor

http://i44.tinypic.com/dwqfjc.png

Like the Bills, the Redskins started off hot only too cool down quickly. One of the Redskins primary needs is offensive line, and Smith vastly helps correct the problem. Chris Samuels would still factor into the equation, meaning the line may need to be shuffled to get the best talent on the field at once if the Skins plan at starting Smith right away, but no matter how it shakes out, Smith should be the long term answer at left tackle.

15. New Orleans Saints- Malcolm Jenkins, CB, Ohio State

http://i42.tinypic.com/fbkp77.png

Another season in New Orleans, and another season Drew Brees leads a deadly offense, only to see it undermined by the defense. Sedrick Ellis is a budding star, and they've got talent in some other areas on defense, but corner is still a concern, even with the drafting of Tracy Porter in the second last year. Malcolm Jenkins is regarded quite highly by the draft community, and it would hard for the Saints to pass him over.

16. Denver Broncos- William Moore, S, Missouri

http://i41.tinypic.com/2hqfnsw.png

The Denver Broncos have a few issues on defense, such as defensive tackle and inside linebacker, but with John Lynch retired, the Broncos lack anything close to a qualified safety. William Moore would be a huge upgrade, and has the versatility to start at either safety spot.

17. Arizona Cardinals- Knowshon Moreno, RB, Georgia

http://i42.tinypic.com/28tjgwm.png

The Cardinals have a high flying ariel attack, but they also have the league's worst run game. Edgerrin James has proven to be past his prime, and Tim Hightower was a nice surprise, but is best suited for running mainly in short yardage situations. Knowshon Moreno doesn't have the greatest straight line speed, but he possesses good agility and strength and could help from the get go.

18. Philadelphia Eagles- Jermaine Gresham, TE, Oklahoma

http://i44.tinypic.com/34grm2a.png

Safety has to be the biggest concern here, but there's no one available here that can't be gotten later. One route the Eagles could go is replacing L.J. Smith, who's been far from a consistent playmaker. Gresham is one of the best tight end prospects to come out recently, possessing prototypical size to go along with great athleticism, and could at the least get a lot of playing time from the reserve role day one.

19. Chicago Bears- Michael Johnson, DE, Georgia Tech

http://i41.tinypic.com/2lmxpaq.png

Orton appears to have the quarterback spot locked up at least for the short term, but there are still dire needs for the Bears in both trenches. Michael Johnson hasn't been the best pass rusher the past few years, yet he likely post the best measurables. His 6'7 frame, to go along with legitimate 4.6 time and flashes of potential makes him too much to pass up.

20. Tampa Bay Buccaneers- Darrius Heyward-Bey, WR, Maryland

http://i42.tinypic.com/1p9yxd.png

Antonio Bryant has a great year, but the Bucs still need a replacement for the aging playmaker Joey Galloway. Heyward-Bey, like a few other physical freaks coming out, hasn't been the biggest receiving threat, but his combination of 6'3 size, sub 4.4 speed, and knowledge of the West Coast system makes his upside too much to pass up.

21. New York Jets- Matthew Stafford, QB, Georgia

http://i40.tinypic.com/35d3pfm.png

In every draft there is someone who always falls, and in this one, it's Matthew Stafford. Stafford possesses everything you look for physically; a powerful arm, great size, and top notch mechanics. But what Stafford does lack, and what triggers the fall, is the ability to consistently pick apart defenses. Stafford can go into one game and seemingly throw blind, and go into another game and toss four touchdowns. With Favre retiring, and Kellen Clemens not living up to his billing, Stafford is the perfect fit for the Jets.

22. Minnesota Vikings- D.J. Moore, CB, Vanderbilt

http://i39.tinypic.com/1pxh6g.png

Tavaris Jackson has played well, likely good enough to put off a first round quarterback for one more year. Instead, the Vikings go corner in an effort to replace the aging Antoine Winfield long term, and add a legitimate rotation short term. Moore may be the most pro ready corner available, as he can easily bump defenders off the line, and stay with them afterwards, making him the perfect fit for the Vikings defense.

23. Detroit Lions(f/DAL)- James Laurinaitis, LB, Ohio State

http://i41.tinypic.com/23vyucw.png

Acquiring this pick from the Roy Williams trade, the Lions immediately address their middle linebacking issue. In my opinion, Laurinaitis has to be descended from God because of his ability to go throughout an entire game and seemingly make no plays, yet wake up the next day accredited with 20 tackles. However, his stock is still held high in the draft community, and likely by the Lions, making him the pick in this situation.

24. New England Patriots- Brandon Spikes, LB, Florida

http://i41.tinypic.com/25hkff8.png

Jerod Mayo has had a great rookie season, but the Patriots are still relying on the services of 35 year old Tedy Bruschi and 39 year old Junior Seau, so it's obvious they still need youth. Brandon Spikes is underrated and a slight steal at this pick. He's the unquestioned leader of the Florida defense, and possesses the size, strength, athleticism, and demeanor to be an imposing inside backer for years to come.

25. Miami Dolphins- Clint Sintim, LB, Virginia

http://i41.tinypic.com/710glx.png

Usually it's the Patriots who screw over the rest of the NFL and make these picks, but this year it's the division rivals Miami Dolphins who come away with a steal. Sintim might not be the 260 pound, 4.5 running pass rusher that most other top notch 3-4 OLB prospects are, but I hold him to be the most complete outside backer available in the entire draft. Sintim can go after the pass with the best of them, drop back in coverage, but his best feature may be simply his on the field intelligence. The Miami Dolphins continue their turn around with this pick.

26. Baltimore Ravens- Alphonso Smith, CB, Wake Forest

http://i39.tinypic.com/2u5f8rm.png

The Ravens defense is back to it's dominating ways, yet corner is still an issue. Smith is a top notch ballhawk, nabbing 21 interceptions over a four year collegiate career at Wake Forest. He isn't the biggest corner in the world, but his instincts and athleticism still make him a premium corner prospect.

27. Atlanta Falcons- B.J. Raji, DT, Boston College

http://i42.tinypic.com/pvrth.png

The Atlanta Falcons, like the Dolphins, have engineered one of the greatest one year turnarounds ever, thanks to oddly enough a rookie coach and quarterback. One gaping hole, that would be filled literally with this pick, is nose tackle. Grady Jackson has been a good player, but he's far too old to be relied on. Raji is another underrated player, as he's the unquestionably best run stuffer available in the draft, and could immediately factor into the rotation, if not start.

28. Pittsburgh Steelers- Herman Johnson, OL, Louisiana State

http://i41.tinypic.com/2rpwkl5.png

The Steelers have been playing well this season, all except for one area, which possibly the most important; offensive line, the Steelers calling card for numerous years. The Steelers haven't been able to keep defenders off of Roethlisberger, or consistently open holes for runners. Herman Johnson is a step towards the right direction, as his mammouth size (reportedly in the 6'8, 380 pound range), strength, and athleticism makes him an almost immediate starter at one of the guard positions, with the possibility of moving out to right tackle.

29. Indianapolis Colts- Sen'Derrick Marks, DT, Auburn

http://i43.tinypic.com/9uyz28.png

The Colts didn't get the start they wanted, but thanks largely to Peyton Manning, they're now back in title contention. One thing they lack though, is a true playmaker at defensive tackle. They've gotten the job done with a rotation of usual backups, but the defense would improve immensely if they could get a key starter there. Sen'Derrick Marks is such, possessing the elite athleticism to fit perfectly with Indy's smaller but quicker Cover Two scheme, to go along with a bit of nastiness.

30. Philadelphia Eagles(f/CAR)- Ciron Black, OT, Louisiana State

http://i43.tinypic.com/hwampx.png

The Eagles were set to draft Jeff Otah before the Panthers came a calling, so this year they go after his closest comparison. Black is a big, physical mauler who can lock down defenders. He doesn't possess great athleticism, but then again, neither did Jeff Otah.

31. New York Giants- Brian Cushing, LB, Southern California

http://i44.tinypic.com/11uapu1.png

With the win over the Carolina Panthers, the Giants proved they are here to stay. The Giants biggest defensive issue may be nose tackle, but with Raji off the board, there's no one worth reaching for at this spot. The next area for upgrade is linebacker. Mathias Kiwanuka has played well at defensive end, his natural position, vacating his linebacking spot. Cushing is the best fit to fill the hole, and also offers the added versatility of being a great pass rusher if need be.

32. Tennessee Titans- Percy Harvin, WR, Florida

http://i41.tinypic.com/qwwzko.png

Like the Giants, the Titans proved they were the top dog in the conference with a win over the Steelers. The Titans still have holes in their armor, with the main one being the passing game. Vince Young is looking to be a guaranteed bust, but it's too early in his career for the Titans to go ahead and draft another quarterback. The next best bet would be to add a playmaking receiver, which is exactly what Harvin is. It'd be tough for the Titans to choose between Harvin and Maclin, but with Harvin likely to put up a great combine, he gets the nod.

sbh15
12-23-2008, 11:05 AM
Davis before Jenkins? Very interesting pick. I don't really like D.J. Moore as a first rounder... I'd prefer Alphonso Smith, but if Jenkins fell THAT far, I'd be surprised if the Ravens (or someone else for that matter) didn't trade up.

vidae
12-23-2008, 11:20 AM
Good KC pick and great explanation.

thebow305
12-23-2008, 11:21 AM
Wow, seeing Malcolm Jenkins fall all that way and still get picked one slot ahead of us would absolutely break my heart. I guess Sintim would be a nice consolation prize, but that would be terrible! :(

the decider13
12-23-2008, 11:32 AM
Davis was actually someone I thought of as a possibility, but you are the first I've seen with it. Plus with Moore, Mays and Spikes off the board, it makes a lot of sense.

Really nice mock

marshallb
12-23-2008, 11:36 AM
There is no way in hell that Jenkins falls that far, and if he does there are many, many teams that would take him in the teens and early 20s, including the Vikings. I don't mind Davis, but with Jenkins there and the way Jackson has played lately, I couldn't pass up Jenkins.

T-RICH49
12-23-2008, 11:36 AM
great pick and love the explanation for KC

Cigaro
12-23-2008, 12:10 PM
There is no way in hell that Jenkins falls that far, and if he does there are many, many teams that would take him in the teens and early 20s, including the Vikings. I don't mind Davis, but with Jenkins there and the way Jackson has played lately, I couldn't pass up Jenkins.

I know Tavaris Jackson has played well, which made the pick of Davis real iffy for me. But I think eventually Jackson will descend from his cloud, and Minnesota has already shown it would be willing to look elsewhere. Jenkins would be a good fit, and it's a possibility I never really considered, so depending on how Jackson plays, there may be a change up next mock (sometime after Jan. 15th).

Also on the Davis-Jenkins situation as a whole; I'm not overly high on Jenkins, which is why I had him falling, and I think Vontae's monster combine will propel him past Jenkins on many teams boards.

Wow, seeing Malcolm Jenkins fall all that way and still get picked one slot ahead of us would absolutely break my heart. I guess Sintim would be a nice consolation prize, but that would be terrible! :(

Trust me, with in a few years, you'll see Sintim is much more than a consolation prize.

Davis before Jenkins? Very interesting pick. I don't really like D.J. Moore as a first rounder... I'd prefer Alphonso Smith, but if Jenkins fell THAT far, I'd be surprised if the Ravens (or someone else for that matter) didn't trade up.

I don't get into the mess of simulating trades, which is why a guard is in the top ten, so that's out of the picture. Alphonso Smith is a ballhawk, but I have Moore rated just a bit in front of him.

Don Vito
12-23-2008, 12:18 PM
24. New England Patriots- Malcolm Jenkins, CB, Ohio State

http://i42.tinypic.com/fbkp77.png

Linebacker may be a bigger issue for the Patriots, but Jenkins would be too good to pass up. Like college teammate Laurinaitis, I'm not all that high on Jenkins, but he's held near elite status in the general draft community. His lack of athleticism would be neutralized by the Pats' zone scheme, making the Patriots possibly his best fit.


That is a dream scenario if he falls that far. Jenkins could be the #1 player on the Pats' board. Corner is one of our top needs and Jenkins is a great talent; he is big, athletic, physical, and plays with an attitude.

Edit-The Pats don't really run a zone scheme. They play a lot of man as well as running zone.

bored of education
12-23-2008, 12:18 PM
jenkins to the Pats zomgzzzzz. Top 5 talent at 24 omgzzzzzz

urinemonkey
12-23-2008, 12:34 PM
Laurinaitis should be the Broncos pick.

SeanTaylorRIP
12-23-2008, 12:46 PM
Spikes over Jason Smith, no way. We need O or D-line. And if we do go LB only way is we go OLB like Curry. HB Blades is our MLB of the future.

Tha Boss
12-23-2008, 12:51 PM
Thats a poor explanation for the broncos pic...
Champ Bailey has played superb, the only downtime hes had was this year when he was hurt and missed 7 games. Asside from that i really dont think you have a clue as to why you stated that...

Also CB is a terrible pick for Denver as even you stated in your explination that DT, MLB, and even S are much greater positions of need...

Cigaro
12-23-2008, 12:58 PM
Thats a poor explanation for the broncos pic...
Champ Bailey has played superb, the only downtime hes had was this year when he was hurt and missed 7 games. Asside from that i really dont think you have a clue as to why you stated that...

Also CB is a terrible pick for Denver as even you stated in your explination that DT, MLB, and even S are much greater positions of need...

Rey Maualuga and Brandon Spikes are gone, and Laurinaitis, lol. Mays and Moore are also gone so unless you want Chung at 16, that position is out as well. Marks is a possibility, but Jerry and/or Hood should be available in the second. I still think Davis would fit in nicely in Denver.

RaiderNation
12-23-2008, 01:00 PM
Nice raider pick

Menardo75
12-23-2008, 02:53 PM
Awesome 49er pick nice work.

fenikz
12-23-2008, 02:55 PM
give us Stafford, completely unrealistic, terrible mock

Dr. Gonzo
12-23-2008, 02:57 PM
Without a doubt I think the Vikings go with Jenkins over Nate Davis. Jenkins is fits the Vikings system perfectly and I think he would be a tremendous player with the Vikes. At this point I think the highest round the Vikings look at QB is 2.

Babylon
12-23-2008, 03:13 PM
I'll take 3 of your picks in the 20s (Stafford, JL and Jenkins) and you can have any other 3 guys in the draft and we'll see who makes out better. Like the effort though.

Cigaro
12-23-2008, 03:16 PM
I'll take 3 of your picks in the 20s (Stafford, JL and Jenkins) and you can have any other 3 guys in the draft and we'll see who makes out better. Like the effort though.

Sam Bradford, Andre Smith, Michael Crabtree.

Babylon
12-23-2008, 03:21 PM
Sam Bradford, Andre Smith, Michael Crabtree.

I like my guys better. I can see a seperate thread coming on this down the road.

BeerBaron
12-23-2008, 03:22 PM
Whoa......man.......hold up. DE is a major need but I don't see Selvie hacking it as a 43 DE in the pros to anyone other than the Colts.

If Stafford is going to fall that far, I'll take him. Orton isn't that locked in.

urinemonkey
12-23-2008, 03:27 PM
Rey Maualuga and Brandon Spikes are gone, and Laurinaitis, lol. Mays and Moore are also gone so unless you want Chung at 16, that position is out as well. Marks is a possibility, but Jerry and/or Hood should be available in the second. I still think Davis would fit in nicely in Denver.

What is so "lol" about the Broncos picking Laurinaitis?

Sniper
12-23-2008, 03:34 PM
24. New England Patriots- Malcolm Jenkins, CB, Ohio State

http://i42.tinypic.com/fbkp77.png
His lack of athleticism would be neutralized by the Pats' zone scheme

Any and all credibility this mock had just flew out the window with that comment.


And I hate Ohio State.

DiG
12-23-2008, 04:02 PM
Skins pass on Jason Smith for Spikes?! Thats craziness. And we need an OLB a lot more than a MLB. Fletcher is still palying at a very high level and HB Blades is more suited for the middle anyway, although he has looked good outside too. Nonetheless, I can't see the Skins passing on positions of much higher need to draft a MLB that early unless it was a top 5 type guy that dropped. I'd give Spikes a grade of a C- right now.

Cigaro
12-23-2008, 07:13 PM
To appease the masses, I present the new, edited version.

BmoreBlackByrdz
12-23-2008, 10:10 PM
great raven pick since Heyward-Bey is gone.

the decider13
12-24-2008, 03:09 AM
There...I like the new version much moore. Get it? haha funny stuff

I still think Malcom falls rather far, but it makes much more sense.

wicket
12-24-2008, 08:31 AM
15. New Orleans Saints- Malcolm Jenkins, CB, Ohio State[/B]

http://i42.tinypic.com/fbkp77.png

Another season in New Orleans, and another season Drew Brees leads a deadly offense, only to see it undermined by the defense. Sedrick Ellis is a budding star, and they've got talent in some other areas on defense, but corner is still a concern, even with the drafting of Tracy Porter in the second last year. Malcolm Jenkins is regarded quite highly by the draft community, and it would hard for the Saints to pass him over.


This makes me kinda sad. Corner is fine for the saints with Mckenzie and Porter. Since moore is still on the board this should be easy. I'll say it blunt again. THE SAINTS DO NOT NEED A FIRST ROUND CORNER!!!!!!!!. They are in to much need of a safety, a weakside linebacker and more picks to even consider picking a corner in the first if they can get something even only resembeling good value on a trade or at wlb or fs. Overall a good effort though, a shame that for my team it just doesnt work.

Whistler6
12-24-2008, 08:58 AM
If Green Bay doesn't pick up O-line in free agency, I like the OT pick... If they do though, I seem them going D-line.

TT if you trade down, I swear to jude

CJSchneider
12-24-2008, 01:44 PM
10. San Francisco 49ers- Taylor Mays, S, Southern California

This is a logical pick and I like Mays as I am a big USC fan, but, don't be surprised if the reach for Jason Smith here. Albeit I'm starting to let O-line slide as one of our top needs, I'm not sure the front office will.


15. New Orleans Saints- Malcolm Jenkins, CB, Ohio State

The possibility of this presented itself in a mock I didn't post and it is an idea I may be warming up to. I still hope we find a way to trade down though.

Menardo75
12-24-2008, 01:56 PM
10. San Francisco 49ers- Taylor Mays, S, Southern California

This is a logical pick and I like Mays as I am a big USC fan, but, don't be surprised if the reach for Jason Smith here. Albeit I'm starting to let O-line slide as one of our top needs, I'm not sure the front office will.


15. New Orleans Saints- Malcolm Jenkins, CB, Ohio State

The possibility of this presented itself in a mock I didn't post and it is an idea I may be warming up to. I still hope we find a way to trade down though.

We shouldn't be reaching for Jason Smith he is a bad fit for RT.