PDA

View Full Version : Dirty Thirty O Rankings


DiG
03-12-2009, 10:17 AM
Just finished these up yesterday and thought I would share. Comments appreciated.

Defense:
http://draftcountdown.com/forum/showthread.php?p=1544561#post1544561

QB - RD Value
1. Matt Stafford - Top 5
2. Mark Sanchez - Top 15
3. Nate Davis - 2
4. Josh Freeman - 2
5. Rhett Bomar - 2/3
6. Pat White - 3
7. Curtis Painter - 4
8. Stephen McGee - 4/5
9. Tom Brandstater - 5
10. Hunter Cantwell - 5
11. John Parker Wilson - 5/6
12. Nathan Brown - 5/6
13. Graham Harrell - 5/6
14. Cullen Harper - 6/7
15. Mike Reilly - 6/7
16. Chase Daniel - 6-UFA
17. Chase Holbrook - 6-UFA
18. Brian Hoyer - 7-UFA
19. Rudy Carpenter - 7-UFA
20. Todd Boekman - 7-UFA

Most Overrated: Rhett Bomar
Most Underrated: Stephen McGee

RB - RD Value
1. Beanie Wells -Top 15
2. Knowshon Moreno - 1
3. Donald Brown - 1/2
4. LeSean McCoy - 1/2
5. Shonn Greene - 2/3
6. Andre Brown - 2/3
7. Rashad Jennings - 2/3
8. Mike Goodson - 3
9. Javon Ringer - 3/4
10. Devin Moore - 4
11. Korey Sheets - 4/5
12. James Davis - 4/5
13. Glenn Coffee - 5
14. Cedric Peerman - 5/6
15. Jeremiah Johnson - 5/6
16. Arian Foster - 6/7
17. Ian Johnson - 6/7
18. Tyrell Sutton - 6/7
19. Aaron Brown - 6-UFA
20. Bernard Scott - 6-UFA

Most Overrated: Mike Goodson
Most Underrated: Korey Sheets

WR - RD Value
1. Michael Crabtree - Top 10
2. Darrius Heyward Bey - 1
3. Jeremy Maclin - 1
4. Kenny Britt - 1/2
5. Hakeem Nicks - 1/2
6. Percy Harvin - 1/2
7. Brian Robiskie - 2
8. Pat White - 2/3
9. Juaquin Iglesias - 2/3
10. Derrick Williams - 3
11. Brandon Tate - 3
12. Louis Murphy - 3
14. Ramses Barden - 3
13. Mohamed Massaquoi - 3/4
15. Jarett Dillard - 4
16. Mike Thomas - 4
17. Austin Collie - 4
18. Marko Mitchell - 4/5
19. Brooks Foster - 4/5
20. Kenny McKinley - 4/5
21. Demetrius Byrd - 5
22. Sammie Stroughter - 5
23. Kenny McKinley - 5
24. Mike Wallace - 5/6
25. Brandon Gibson - 5/6
26. Deon Butler - 6
27. Aaron Kelly - 6/7
28. Quan Cosby - 6-UFA
29. Brian Hartline - 6-UFA
30. Dominique Edison - 6-UFA

Most Overrated: Mohamed Massaquoi
Most Underrated: Jarett Dillard

TE - RD Value
1. Jared Cook - 2
2. Shawn Nelson - 2
3. Brandon Pettigrew - 2
4. James Casey - 3
5. Cornelius Ingram - 3
6. Chase Coffman - 3/4
7. Travis Beckum - 3/4
8. Cameron Morrah - 4/5
9. Bear Pascoe - 5/6
10. John Phillips - 6

Most Overrated: Brandon Pettigrew
Most Underrated: Chase Coffman

OT - RD Value
1. Jason Smith - Top 5
2. Eugene Monroe - Top 10
3. Andre Smith - Top 15
4. Michael Oher - 1
5. William Beatty - 1/2
6. Ebben Britton - 1/2
7. Jamon Meredith - 2
8. Troy Kropog - 2/3
9. Phil Loadholt - 3
10. Jason Watkins - 3
11. Gerald Cadogan - 3/4
12. Cornelius Lewis - 4
13. Fenuki Tupou - 4
14. Xavier Fulton - 4
15. Augustus Parrish - 5
16. Andrew Gardner - 5/6
17. Alex Boone - 5/6
18. TJ Lang - 5/6
19. Garrett Reynolds - 7-UFA
20. Joel Bell - 7-UFA

Most Overrated: Cornelius Lewis
Most Underrated: William Beatty

OG - RD Value
1. Duke Robinson - 1/2
2. Andy Levitre - 2/3
3. Trevor Canfield - 3/4
4. Kraig Urbik - 4
5. Herman Johnson - 4
6. Louis Vasquez - 5/6
7. Roger Allen - 5/6
8. Tyronne Green - 6-UFA
9. Greg Isander - 6-UFA
10. Cedric Dockery - 6-UFA

Most Overrated: Herman Johnson
Most Underrated: Andy Levitre

C - RD Value
1. Alex Mack - 1/2
2. Max Unger - 2
3. Eric Wood - 2
4. Jonathan Luigs - 3
5. Antoine Caldwell - 3/4
6. AQ Shipley - 4/5
7. Edwin Williams - 5/6
8. Blake Schlueter - 6
9. Jon Cooper - 6/7
10. Alex Fletcher - 6-UFA

Most Overrated: N/A
Most Underrated: Eric Wood

eaglesalltheway
03-12-2009, 11:05 AM
Good lists, a few I'm interested in wondering.

Why DHB over Maclin?

Why Harvin under Britt/Nicks? I agree with you, just want to see if you feel the same way I do.

Why so low on Pettigrew?

I really like Coffman, and I think he is vastly underrated right now. i think he may be a solid starter very early into his career.

A lot of people, including myself, think Loadholt could eek out a second round draft pick, do you see that as possible, or don't you like him until the thrid round?

There's just one "b" in Eben Britton's first name, probably a typo, just letting you know..

I especially like your linemen rankings/value, those are very good and i agree with pretty much all of it...

abaddon41_80
03-12-2009, 11:11 AM
You seem to be forgetting Drew "Dr." Wily on your QB list. He'll let it slide this time but next time you will be hearing from Guts Man.

Brent
03-12-2009, 11:19 AM
Most Underrated: Stephen McGee
Hell yes haha

DiG
03-12-2009, 12:47 PM
Good lists, a few I'm interested in wondering.

Why DHB over Maclin?

Most everyone here knows that I love DHB. I think he has what it takes to be a very good #1 receiver in the NFL whereas I see Maclin more as a #2. DHB is bigger, stronger, faster and has great hands The ONLY knock on DHB is that he is still inexeperienced and needs to polish his route running but Maclin only has 2 years experience playing at Mizzou and the same can be said for him.

Why Harvin under Britt/Nicks? I agree with you, just want to see if you feel the same way I do.

I think Harvin can be successful in the NFL but not in as many systems/offenses as Britt and Nicks. Hes probably a high risk high reward guy but I just dont see him as a great all around wide receiver prospect. As a return man and a big play threat hes great but I want more than that in rd 1.

Why so low on Pettigrew?

There is very little that really excites me about Pett. He is a good tight end but I really don't think that he has the tangibles to be a first rounder. He does everything pretty well but doesn't blow me away in any one category.

A lot of people, including myself, think Loadholt could eek out a second round draft pick, do you see that as possible, or don't you like him until the thrid round?

In any other draft maybe, but, the depth at OT this year is incredible. He could still sneak into the second because he is one of the best available RTs in the draft but personally I will usually draft a possible franchise LT over RT 9 times out of 10.

eaglesalltheway
03-12-2009, 02:00 PM
I understand the logic, and see what you mean on your explanations. The only thing I disagree on is Pettigrew's blocking. That is something that does stick out, for a college TE especially, nowadays. One could argue the fact that he is so balanced as a TE that will help him stick out. His hands are very good too, catches the football well, a natural receiver. As I said, good lists, and I like what you gave as rebuttles.