PDA

View Full Version : Trade proposal from a Bucs fan...


bucfan12
04-13-2010, 08:13 PM
I understand you are in need for a Left Tackle after cutting ties with Flozell Adams.

If you haven't read already, the Bucs are not willing to pay donald Penn the money and give him a long term deal. Also, rumor has it that they are shopping him and may unload him come draft day.

He is a very good Left Tackle, but I think the organization just doesn't want to pay him for some reason. Also, they have brought in LT Charles Brown from USC for a 2 day visit, so their seems to be some interest.

My proposal would be is do you Cowboys fans think that Dallas would give up their 1st round pick (27th overall) to Tampa Bay for Donald Penn, a proven Left Tackle?



Feedback is welcome, and again, I am just curious so don't bash this trade idea. I know dallas is in need of a tackle and thoguht they might be the most logical team because they have the money to extend him.

Trogdor
04-14-2010, 09:43 AM
Not buying the NEED for a LT. You don't release your starting LT if you don't have 100% confidence that his backup can out-play him. I don't buy the "we have to draft a LT 1st now" argument either for the same reason. If we didn't believe Doug Free couldn't start we would of waited until AFTER the draft to see if the drafted player was capable of starting over Flozell. Flozell wasn't due a bonus until JULY. So this wasn't a decision that had to be made now. It's a popular knee-jerk overreaction that our LT spot is now manned by a high school cheerleader.

Donald Penn is also 28 years old, solid but NOT spectacular, and has struggled with weight issues in the past. That combination IMHO doesn't add up to a first round pick.

bucfan12
04-14-2010, 11:30 AM
Not buying the NEED for a LT. You don't release your starting LT if you don't have 100% confidence that his backup can out-play him. I don't buy the "we have to draft a LT 1st now" argument either for the same reason. If we didn't believe Doug Free couldn't start we would of waited until AFTER the draft to see if the drafted player was capable of starting over Flozell. Flozell wasn't due a bonus until JULY. So this wasn't a decision that had to be made now. It's a popular knee-jerk overreaction that our LT spot is now manned by a high school cheerleader.

Donald Penn is also 28 years old, solid but NOT spectacular, and has struggled with weight issues in the past. That combination IMHO doesn't add up to a first round pick.

A couple things to list that you might be wrong about. 1. Donald Penn is only 26 years old, so he is relatively young for a LT.

2. He was able to hold his own against premiere pass rushers over the past 2 years. He was missing the mauler of Aaron Sears at LG also. He has shut down guys like Peppers, Jared Allen, Demarcus Ware, John Abraham, and Will Smith. Peppers only had 2 sacks in 1 game agianst the Bucs this past year bc he was lined up against Trueblood, not Penn.

He gave up 7 sacks in the past two seasons, and as much as I'd love for the Bucs to keep him, the Front Office doesn't want to shell the money out for an extension, so I think he would be worth a late first round pick for a top 7 LT in this league.

leroyisgod
04-14-2010, 11:44 AM
I would pass on this, I'd consider a 2nd rounder though.

superfly69
04-14-2010, 06:40 PM
A swap of picks maybe. Tampas 2nd and Penn for Dallas' 1st and a 4th.

bucfan12
04-14-2010, 08:16 PM
A swap of picks maybe. Tampas 2nd and Penn for Dallas' 1st and a 4th.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d8178623b&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true


Read that article. Penn may not be worth a 1st and 3rd, but he certainly is worth a late 1st round pick.

Also, why would the bucs give up donald penn and a 2nd for Dallas 1 and 4th? That might be the worst deal I heard of. Dallas definately would get away with highway robbery on that one.

bluebonnet78
04-14-2010, 09:23 PM
http://www.nfl.com/news/story?id=09000d5d8178623b&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true


Read that article. Penn may not be worth a 1st and 3rd, but he certainly is worth a late 1st round pick.

Also, why would the bucs give up donald penn and a 2nd for Dallas 1 and 4th? That might be the worst deal I heard of. Dallas definately would get away with highway robbery on that one.

Well it would help us feel a little better about our FO after the Roy Williams fiasco at least :)

But really, I just don't see it happening. Dallas appears set with giving Doug Free a shot at left tackle this season and going from there based on his performance. They'll keep an ear out for depth in the draft (i.e. cheap rookie alternatives). It probably won't happen unless the Bucs are willing to give him up at a discount bargain.

You might want to Check the Cardinals forum...I'm pretty sure they are in need of a starting left tackle more than Dallas is.

D-Unit
04-14-2010, 09:27 PM
Feedback is welcome, and again, I am just curious so don't bash this trade idea. I know dallas is in need of a tackle and thoguht they might be the most logical team because they have the money to extend him.


Also, why would the bucs give up donald penn and a 2nd for Dallas 1 and 4th? That might be the worst deal I heard of. Dallas definately would get away with highway robbery on that one.

Look at you man... You come in here asking for opinions and not bash your idea and then you bash someone's response to you???

Think bro, think.

thule
04-14-2010, 09:27 PM
hahaha...the simple quick answer for you is NO. We have Doug Free and he is going to be given every opportunity to be our future LT. Contrary to popular belief, Dallas is set at OT at the moment both positions have a backup...interior OL is actually a slightly bigger need imo.

TitanHope
04-14-2010, 09:40 PM
Teams would trade a 1st RD'er for Jared Gaither waaaay before they'd trade it for Donald Penn. If the Bucs end up trading him, I doubt they get a 1st RD'er in return.

*skulks back to the Titans forum*

bucfan12
04-14-2010, 10:26 PM
Look at you man... You come in here asking for opinions and not bash your idea and then you bash someone's response to you???

Think bro, think.

Don't mean to "bash" your trade idea, but isn't that deal, Penn and a 2nd round pick, for a 1st and 4th, sound unreasonable? I mean, why would the Bucs trade a quality LT, whom is proven and most likely better than any other LT at 27, and their 2nd round pick for a 1st?

I think it sounds more reasonable for that deal straight up, maybe the Bucs can throw a late round pick in their, who knows. I am just explaining is that Penn, even though he did gain that much weight, still was able to hold off pass rushers like Ware, Peppers, Clay Matthews, Will Smith, John Abraham, Justin Tuck. Only was accounted for giving up 4 sacks total this year.

D-Unit
04-14-2010, 10:48 PM
Don't mean to "bash" your trade idea, but isn't that deal, Penn and a 2nd round pick, for a 1st and 4th, sound unreasonable? I mean, why would the Bucs trade a quality LT, whom is proven and most likely better than any other LT at 27, and their 2nd round pick for a 1st?

I think it sounds more reasonable for that deal straight up, maybe the Bucs can throw a late round pick in their, who knows. I am just explaining is that Penn, even though he did gain that much weight, still was able to hold off pass rushers like Ware, Peppers, Clay Matthews, Will Smith, John Abraham, Justin Tuck. Only was accounted for giving up 4 sacks total this year.
It wasn't my idea or post that you bashed. But that's besides the point. Even if you think it's a bad deal, why would you say something like "That might be the worst deal I heard of", when you were the one who said to be kind to your idea.

Jared Gaither and Brandon Marshall couldn't get a 1st rounder in return. Do you think Donald Penn is a higher caliber player, that he would command it? The link to nfl.com was cute, but I bet some writer out there thought Santonio Holmes was worth more than a 5th rounder too...

JoeyHeisman
04-15-2010, 02:00 AM
Don't mean to "bash" your trade idea, but isn't that deal, Penn and a 2nd round pick, for a 1st and 4th, sound unreasonable? I mean, why would the Bucs trade a quality LT, whom is proven and most likely better than any other LT at 27, and their 2nd round pick for a 1st?

I think it sounds more reasonable for that deal straight up, maybe the Bucs can throw a late round pick in their, who knows. I am just explaining is that Penn, even though he did gain that much weight, still was able to hold off pass rushers like Ware, Peppers, Clay Matthews, Will Smith, John Abraham, Justin Tuck. Only was accounted for giving up 4 sacks total this year.

Sounds to me like you're just a little too proud of Penn, and think a lot more of him than anyone else around here.

Me Likey Rookies
04-15-2010, 02:10 AM
Not me, I love Penn and think he deserves a big contract because he is our best o-lineman. Then again, I'm a Bucs fan...

LonghornsLegend
04-18-2010, 04:31 PM
LOL@this.


Jared Gaither probably isn't going to garner a 1st round pick, so why would Donald Penn? It doesn't really matter because it's not going to happen, but trust me when I say we would much rather keep our picks and go with Doug Free.


Everyone keeps coming up with all these trade proposals for a LT when we had the guy we liked already which led to Flozell being cut. Were not trading for a LT, so we can stop with the proposals for #27 for a LT.

D-Unit
04-19-2010, 03:59 PM
http://www.profootballfocus.com/by_position.php?tab=by_position&season=2009&pos=T&stype=r&runpass=&teamid=-1&numsnaps=25&numgames=1

Look how horrible Donald Penn was last year. Coincidentally, look how good Doug Free was.

GB12
04-19-2010, 04:04 PM
A couple things to list that you might be wrong about. 1. Donald Penn is only 26 years old, so he is relatively young for a LT.

2. He was able to hold his own against premiere pass rushers over the past 2 years. He was missing the mauler of Aaron Sears at LG also. He has shut down guys like Peppers, Jared Allen, Demarcus Ware, John Abraham, and Will Smith. Peppers only had 2 sacks in 1 game agianst the Bucs this past year bc he was lined up against Trueblood, not Penn.

He gave up 7 sacks in the past two seasons, and as much as I'd love for the Bucs to keep him, the Front Office doesn't want to shell the money out for an extension, so I think he would be worth a late first round pick for a top 7 LT in this league.

Alright, so if all this is true why the hell would Tampa trade him?