PDA

View Full Version : NFL History Draft Team 1 vs Team 2


Brothgar
05-21-2010, 03:02 AM
Since this is the championship I'd like to hear some explanations with the votes.


Team 1

QB - Kurt Warner (++++, MM, 111, SM, S) > Sonny Jurgensen (+++++, 11111, HOF, Washington Ring of Fire, Eagles Honor Roll) > Randall Cunningham (++++, 1111)
RB - Marshall Faulk (7+, 111, 222, OOO) > Floyd Little ( +++++, HOF, Broncos Ring of Fame)
FB - Jim Brown (9+, 8x(1), 2, MMM, ATT, HOF)
WR1 - Jerry Rice (13+, 11x(1), 2, SSS, OO, ATT, 90DT, 80DT, HOF) > Andre Reed (7+, 22, Buffalo Bills Wall of Fame)
WR2 - Tommy McDonald (6+, Eagles Honor Roll, HOF) > Steve Tasker (7+)
TE -Jay Novacek (+++++, 11111)
OT- Lomas Brown (7+, 7(1), S) D'Brickashaw Ferguson (+)
OG- Gene Hickerson[ (6+, 11111, 22, 60DT, HOF) > John Nisby (+++)
C- Nick Mangold (++, 1) > Joe Fields (++)
OG- Larry Allen (11+, 6(1), 2, S, 90DT, 00DT) > Guy McIntyre (+++++, 111)
OT- Rayfield Wright ( 6+, 1111, 22, SS, HOF, Dallas Ring of Honor) > Eric Winston

DE - Reggie White (13+, 10(1), 222, S, DD, ATT, 80, 90DT, Eagles Honor Roll, GB Hall of fame, HOF) > Fred Dean (++++, 11, SS, HOF)
DT - Henry Jordan (++++, 7(1), Green Bay HOF, HOF)
DT - Alan Page (9+, 6(1), 222, D, M, HOF) > Michael Carter (+++)
DE - Randy White (9+, 9(1), S, SM, HOF) > Elvis Dumervil (+, 1)
OLB - Kevin Greene (5+, 3(1), 90DT) > Bob Breunig (+++)
MLB - Willie Lanier (8+, 8(1), ATT, HOF) > Jack Del Rio (+, 1, S)
OLB - Wilber Marshall (+++, 11, 2, D) > Jason Gildon (+++, 1) > John Grimsley (+, 1)
CB - Louis Wright (+++++, 11, ATT) > Cortland Finnegan (+, 1)
FS - Ken Houston (12+, 70DT, ATT, HOF) > Antoine Bethea (++, S) > Dawan Landry
SS - Rodney Harrison (++, 11, 2, SS) > Tony Peters (+)
CB - Abe Woodson (+++++) > Devin Hester (++, 11, 00DT)

K - Paul McFadden
P - Mitch Berger (++, 1, S)
KR - Abe Woodson
PR - Devin Hester

+ = Probowl (1 + for each probowl)
1 = All-Pro
2 = 2nd team all pro
M = League MVP (1 M for each)
O = OPOY
SM = Super Bowl MVP
S = Super Bowl Ring
HOF = Hall of Fame
Underlined = Will be HOF
ATT = NFL's 75th Anni All time team
#DT = # decade team


Team 2

Joe Montana (8+, 111,222,SSS, SMSMSM, MM, O, CoPY, ATT , 80DT) |Brett Favre (11+,111,222,MMM, S, 90DT) | Dan Fouts (6+,111,2, 80DT, O)
RB Bo Jackson (+) |Steven Jackson (++,22) | Ron Springs
FB John Henry Johnson(++++, 11)
LT Bob St Clair (+++++, 9x1, 50DT) | Paul Miller (++)
RT Stan Jones (7+,111) | Bruce Armstrong (6+) | Clarence Jones
LG John Hannah (9+,10x1, ATT , 80DT, 70DT) | Ed Newman (++++)
RG Joe DeLamielleure (++++++, 6x1, 22, 70DT) | Jake Scott (S)
C Jim Ringo (10+, SS, 6x1, 222, 60DT)
WR Cris Carter (8+,11,2, 90DT) | Herman Moore (++++,111,2)| Dwight Clark (++,11,SS)
WR Charlie Joiner (+++) | Wes Welker (++,1, 22) | Roy Green (++,11)| Mark Carrier (+,1)
TE Kellen Winslow (+++++, 111,2,ATT , 80DT) |Ben Coates (+++++,11,2, 90DT, S)

RE Doug Atkins (8+, SS, 1111, 222222, 60DT) |Jared Allen (+++,111)
LE L.C. Greenwood (++++++,11, 70DT) | Mark Gastineau (+++++, 1111, 2, NYJ All time team, Four decades team) | Michael Sinclair (+++, 2)
UT Joe Greene (10+, 11111,222, SSSS, DD, 70DT) | Leon Lett (++, SSS) | Earl Edwards
NT Dan Hampton (++++, 1111, 22, 80DT) | Ted Washington (++++, S)
LOLB Ted Hendricks (8+, 1111, 22222, ATT, 70DT) | Tom Jackson (+++, 11, Broncos Ring of Fame) | Dwayne Woodruff (S)
ROLB Greg Lloyd (+++++, 111) | HardyNickerson (++++, 90DT)
MLB Brad Van Pelt (+++++)
CB Roger Wehrli (7+, 11111, 2, 70DT) | Ken Riley (1111) | Joseph "Joe" Lavender (++)
CB Rod Woodson (11+, 6x1, 22, D, S, ATT , 90DT) | Bill Thompson (+++, 1, Broncos Ring of Fame)
SS Bob Sanders (++,11, S, D) | Tim McDonald ( 6+, 2222)
FS Aeneas Williams (8+, 1111, 2, 90DT) | Sean Taylor (++,1, Redsikns Ring of Fame)

P Andy Lee (++,1)
K Nate Kaeding (++,1,2)

Bolded: HoF
+: Pro Bowl
1: All Pro
2: 2nd Team All Pro
M = League MVP (1 M for each)
O = OPoY
D = DPoY
SM = Super Bowl MVP
S = Super Bowl Ring
ATT = NFL's 75th Anni All time team
#DT = # decade team
1: All Pro
Underlined: to be HoF

prock
05-21-2010, 10:26 AM
This was a tough choice, but how sick would it be to watch the Team 1 D-line vs the Team 2 O-line?

Gay Ork Wang
05-21-2010, 03:16 PM
I feel like my interior would dominate despite the opponents. DeLamielleur played 8 games in his career against Joe Greene (who is also on my team) and he allowed a combined 15 tackles. I think everyone of my OL could at least handle the opponents. Joe Montana is not gonna get sacked and Bo jackson would have a field day. even if not, id say his DBs are not as good as they could be.

Defensively i think i got his numbers with 3 HoF and a blitz heavy scheme with Ted hendricks and Greg Lloyd. With great teams like this, i think it comes down to the Lines and id say i have the better matchups.

Brothgar
05-21-2010, 04:15 PM
I feel like my interior would dominate despite the opponents. DeLamielleur played 8 games in his career against Joe Greene (who is also on my team) and he allowed a combined 15 tackles. I think everyone of my OL could at least handle the opponents. Joe Montana is not gonna get sacked and Bo jackson would have a field day. even if not, id say his DBs are not as good as they could be.

Defensively i think i got his numbers with 3 HoF and a blitz heavy scheme with Ted hendricks and Greg Lloyd. With great teams like this, i think it comes down to the Lines and id say i have the better matchups.

I disagree I believe team 1 has the edge. My D-Line has 3 of the greatest D-Linemen of all time and two of them can play multiple positions on the line. I also have HOF backup in Fred Dean which allows me to sub frequently keeping an extremely high level front while keeping my line fresh for the full 4 quarters.

As for your Blitz heavy scheme I'm pretty sure that Jim Brown and Jay Novacheck have more than enough ability to block your blitzing linebackers. even if he doesn't Marshall Faulk is a more than adequate safety valve and Kurt Warner knows that very well.

wicket
05-21-2010, 05:12 PM
team 2 for me but damn it was tough to choose

RaiderNation
05-21-2010, 06:24 PM
A healthy Bo Jackson> than all

Brothgar
05-22-2010, 03:24 AM
Bump for MOAR VOTES!

Gay Ork Wang
05-26-2010, 02:11 PM
I win? K THX BYE

Brothgar
05-26-2010, 02:36 PM
I win? K THX BYE

You won because of a raiders homer! We should have tied damn it!