PDA

View Full Version : March 17th, 1-round mock


Geo
03-18-2007, 01:52 AM
The plan right now is to produce a new mock every two weeks, ultimately leading up to the Draft. I have something of a bare-bones 2nd round that should appear in refined fashion in the next mock. Comments and criticisms, hopefully in tandem, are welcome.
- Geo

2007 NFL DRAFT

ROUND 1


1. Oakland Raiders select WR Calvin Johnson, Georgia Tech

If anyone is a 55-million dollar man for the Raiders, it’s Calvin Johnson, the best wide receiver prospect ever. Literally and figuratively, he’s too good to pass up - especially as Randy Moss is shipped out of town.


2. Arizona Cardinals (f. Detroit Lions) select OT Joe Thomas, Wisconsin

Taking advantage of Detroit’s willingness to trade down, The Cardinals select the franchise left tackle they’ve needed for years in Joe Thomas.

*** Arizona: 1st round (#5), 3rd round (#69) picks; Detroit: 1st round pick (#2)


3. Cleveland Browns select QB Jamarcus Russell, LSU

Phil Savage has long been a fan of Jamarcus Russel, and Cleveland is in desperate need of a quarterback who can actually win games without needing a running game to carry him.


4. Tampa Bay Buccaneers select DT Amobi Okoye, Louisville

The Bucs’ defensive line is barren of playmaking talent and thus retards the rest of the less-than-stellar defense, so the team selects Amobi Okoye in hopes of finally filling the void of Warren Sapp as the dominant 3 tech tackle.


5. Detroit Lions (f. Arizona Cardinals) select QB Brady Quinn, Notre Dame

Mike Martz is the short-term solution until he jumps ship to another team, but Brady Quinn is the long-term solution. The Lions finally have a player to sell to the fans since Barry Sanders and a franchise quarterback since decades before that.


6. Washington Redskins select DE Adam Carriker, Nebraska

The Redskins defense stumbled in 2006, but selecting Adam Carriker gives them the powerful pass-rusher who can also play against the run that they need. Carriker can also slide inside at tackle on passing downs, helping them even more.


7. Minnesota Vikings select DE Gaines Adams, Clemson

Gaines Adams provides the Vikings a semblance of a pass rush, while Tice-era draft picks Erasmus James and Kenechi Udeze try to fully recover from ACL injury and micro fracture surgery respectively.


8. Houston Texans select RB Adrian Peterson, Oklahoma

Reggie Bush may not be able to tote the rock for the Texans 20 to 25 times a game, but Texas-born Adrian Peterson certainly can. All Day, in fact.


9. San Francisco 49ers (f. Miami Dolphins) select DE Jamaal Anderson, Arkansas

Mike Nolan trades up to ensure himself the additional playmaker he needs in his front three in Jamaal Anderson, a physical specimen who amazingly has a great deal of development left before him. With Nolan as his teacher, the results should be promising.

*** San Francisco 49ers: 1st round (#11), 4th round picks; Miami Dolphins: 1st round pick (#9)


10. Atlanta Falcons select S Laron Landry, LSU

New head coach Bobby Petrino isn’t satisfied with the Falcons being soft or complacent, as evidenced by his first draft pick in Laron Landry, a do-everything safety and future defensive captain.


11. Miami Dolphins (f. San Francisco 49ers) select CB Leon Hall, Michigan

Leon Hall is the classic perfect guy. He can play zone and press, attacks against the run, has a sculpted body, tests well in any of the positional measurements, has the collegiate pedigree, and so on - the guy others may hate but the Dolphins and their fans will love.


12. Buffalo Bills select LB Patrick Willis, Mississippi

The Bills’ goal this off-season at the middle linebacker position for their revamped defense is to get younger, quicker and stronger at the point of attack near or at the line of scrimmage, and better in coverage. And more often than not, the middle linebacker sets the tone for the rest of the defense. Mission accomplished in Patrick Willis.


13. St. Louis Rams select DT Alan Branch, Michigan

For the last few years, the Rams have been as soft as linen and run on by every other team in the league, never mind the talented backfields of their division rivals. Enter mammoth tackle with immense potential Alan Branch to help solve their woes in a big way.


14. Carolina Panthers select TE Greg Olsen, Miami

The new Panthers offensive coordinator actually wants to include the tight end in the gamplan, which is a novel idea for the team of late, so the team drafts what they perceive as the undeniable best that this weak class has to offer in Greg Olsen.


15. Pittsburgh Steelers select DE Jarvis Moss, Florida

Having wisely rid themselves of Joey Porter, the Steelers take the opportunity to select Jarvis Moss as their pass-rusher of the future, initially as a 3-4 outside linebacker and eventually as the all-important 4-3 defensive end.


16. Green Bay Packers select RB Marshawn Lynch, Cal Berkeley

Can you say slam dunk? Marshawn Lynch is the franchise back who fits perfect in head coach Mike McCarthy’s Packers offense, regardless of who is at quarterback.


17. Jacksonville Jaguars select S Reggie Nelson, Florida

Acquire a younger ballhawk with higher ceiling at free safety? That’s a check for head coach Jack Del Rio this off-season.


18. Cincinnati Bengals select CB Chris Houston, Arkansas

Last year’s 1st round pick Jonathan Joseph showed the most promise of the rookie cornerbacks, and now he and superb man-corner Chris Houston will play opposite each other for the Bengals for years to come.


19. Tennessee Titans select WR Dwayne Bowe, LSU

Dwayne Bowe gets the nod as the second receiver taken thanks to being the most complete of the lot. A physical receiver with an excellent build, Bowe can strike down the field as well as attack the middle, and might be the best run-blocking receiver of the class. He can handle the load of a #1.


20. New York Giants select OT Levi Brown, Penn State

The Giants luck out here landing a franchise left tackle prospect at the 20th overall pick, thanks to Levi Brown delivering less-than-flattering numbers in tests that mean nothing towards his proven ability to protect the quarterback and block for runningbacks.


21. Denver Broncos select WR Ted Ginn Jr., Ohio State

It’s ridiculous how often Mike Shanahan strikes gold. Ted Ginn, Jr. is the perfect complement to Javon Walker and Brandon Marshall, making for what could be the league’s most dangerous receiving core for years to come. Of course, Ginn adds an unequaled playmaker in the return game of the Broncos.


22. Dallas Cowboys select CB Aaron Ross, Texas

Aaron Ross brings youth and a considerable amount of talent to the Cowboys, initially providing excellent depth for their secondary until eventually becoming a future starter opposite cover man Terrence Newman.


23. New Orleans Saints (f. Kansas City Chiefs) select CB Darrelle Revis, Pittsburgh

The Saints trade up to get the last of their draft board’s 1st round cornerbacks, and are ecstatic to bring Darrelle Revis into their fold. In fitting fashion, the Saints give up the Chiefs’ 4th round pick back to the very same team.

*** New Orleans Saints: 1st round (#27), 4th round pick; Kansas City Chiefs: 1st round pick (#23)


24. New England Patriots (f. Seattle Seahawks) select DB Michael Griffin, Texas

Michael Griffin can play either safety position, as a nickel back, and is an excellent special teams player - if he hasn‘t already earned a starting spot, he‘ll find a way to get on the field regardless. Griffin is perfect for the Patriots as they revamp their secondary somewhat, especially at strong safety, in the next few years.

*** New England Patriots: WR Deion Branch; Seattle Seahawks: 1st round pick (#24)


25. New York Jets select DE Anthony Spencer, Purdue

The Jets defense improved in 2006, but needs more talent in all three levels to continue that trend. Anthony Spencer gives them a promising 3-4 outside linebacker who can assist by leaps and bounds in their attempts to get to the opposing quarterback.


26. Philadelphia Eagles select LB Paul Posluszny, Penn State

For years Jeremiah Trotter has undeniably been one who helped set the tone for the rest of the Eagles defense, but with his career on the downslide, Andy Reid wisely selects the man who can carry that mantle from Trotter in Pennsylvania hero Paul Posluszny.


27. Kansas City Chiefs (f. New Orleans Saints) select OT Joe Staley, Central Michigan

The Chiefs re-acquired their 4th round pick for trading down and still landed their future left tackle in the athletic Joe Staley. Staley will likely not start at left tackle from day one, but the team did sign Damien McIntosh in free agency to be their immediate starter and can use Staley elsewhere on the line (especially if Will Shields retires) in the meantime.


28. New England Patriots select LB Jon Beason, Miami

Jon Beason gives the Patriots much-needed youth at the inside linebacker position, especially in the form of the talented striker who is always around the ball. Beason will eventually taking over as a starter when stalwarts Junior Seau and Tedy Bruschi hang them up.


29. Baltimore Ravens select OT Tony Ugoh, Arkansas

Tony Ugoh is impressively athletic and promising as a potential left or right tackle, the caveat however is that he’s something of a project to get there. But Ugoh is a perfect fit for the Ravens as he can initially contribute elsewhere on a highly revamped offensive line and eventually take over at either tackle position. Ozzie Newsome knows his talent.


30. San Diego Chargers select WR Robert Meachem, Tennessee

Excellent value pick by the Chargers in acquiring Robert Meachem, a top-flight receiving prospect who can impressively gain yards after the catch when he gets the ball in his hands, at the 30th overall pick. Meachem will be a great complement to Vincent Jackson.


31. Chicago Bears select WR Dwayne Jarrett, Southern Cal

Dwayne Jarrett’s flattering pro comparison is Muhsin Muhammed, and courtesy of the Bears’ draft pick, Jarrett now gets to learn from the man himself if not eventually replace him as the large-bodied receiver who can make the tough catch and play big in big games.


32. Indianapolis Colts select LB Lawrence Timmons, Florida State

The Colts haven’t selected a 1st round linebacker since Rob Morris in the 2000 NFL Draft, but then again rarely came across a Lawrence Timmons in that time and there‘s currently no established starter at weakside, a critical position in Tony Dungy’s defense, to dissuade them from selecting an outstanding candidate in Timmons who could outplay the 32nd overall pick.

RaiderNation
03-18-2007, 02:07 AM
great raider pick and description

Bills2083
03-18-2007, 08:10 AM
Great Bills pick

princefielder28
03-18-2007, 08:12 AM
Lynch is a Slam-Dunk! :)

T-RICH49
03-18-2007, 08:48 AM
Great KC pick and trade

21ST
03-18-2007, 09:02 AM
There is no way the redskins dont take gaines adams

hugegmenfan
03-18-2007, 12:07 PM
good giants pick

Sveen
03-18-2007, 12:46 PM
Good Saints pick, but I hope we don't have to trade up to get Ross, Revis or Houston.

Xiomera
03-18-2007, 01:02 PM
A third round pick doesn't come close to what it would take for Arizona to move up to #2. They would absolutely have to include their 2nd rounder in any deal.

superfly69
03-18-2007, 01:10 PM
Good mock and solid trades, but I don't see Carriker going ahead of Adams and I am not so sure that Spencer is a 1st rounder as of right now, more likely an early 2. Other then that I like what you did here, most picks fit team needs.

Im_a_Romosexual
03-18-2007, 01:34 PM
Ross is OK, but if we went corner in that situation I think we chose Revis, but Ross might be able to play at FS

ninerfan
03-18-2007, 07:42 PM
Not sure the 9ers would trade up for 2 spots - likely if they did it would be to an earlier pick

Hurricane Ditka
03-18-2007, 07:46 PM
Jarrett to the Bears=fantastic.

KCJ58
03-18-2007, 07:46 PM
Solid Rams Pick

Pit Bull #53
03-18-2007, 07:55 PM
Drafting Dwayne Bowe would make me very happy.

Smooth Criminal
03-18-2007, 08:18 PM
Thats my favorite pick for us at this point. I think Moss is a good fit for the 3-4 and the 4-3 and would be perfect for the transition.

Saints67
03-18-2007, 08:26 PM
GREAT saints pick!

i hope that's how it goes...on draft day.

MP123
03-18-2007, 11:50 PM
I like Okoye to Tampa Bay, Willis to Buffalo, Spencer to New Jork, and Griffin to the Patriots. However, I dislike the Redskins pick of Carriker. It's a dumb selection for defensive end. Anderson is a better 4-3 end than Carriker. And also, I don't see Anderson playing in the 3-4.

Caddy
03-19-2007, 03:27 AM
Bit of a reach for the Bucs but I guess it does make bit of sense

eaglesalltheway
03-19-2007, 06:36 AM
Good pick for the Eagles in that situation, we need LB and SS, but SS is gone, so we get our LB help in Poz.

UK Patriot
03-19-2007, 08:57 AM
I would be a happy Patriot fan if we drafted Griffin and Beason. Very happy!

Geo
03-19-2007, 10:55 AM
A third round pick doesn't come close to what it would take for Arizona to move up to #2. They would absolutely have to include their 2nd rounder in any deal.
You're absolutely right, by the draft value chart, it would take much more than the Cardinals' 3rd round pick to trade up from the 5th overall pick to the 2nd overall pick.

But that's what makes the trade work. If the Lions ask for any more, even an additional 4th round pick, the Cardinals immediately balk and instead plan to take Gaines Adams and acquire a tackle prospect later in the Draft. Millen isn't getting fair value according to the draft value chart, but he covets that early 3rd round pick (especially in a class loaded with CBs and DEs, among other positions, in that area) enough that he'll take the deal. Plus he still gets his guy with the benefit of paying for the 5th overall pick as opposed to a 2nd overall pick, which may not seem like much but consider there's a figurative mark-up in price relative to other positions given Quinn is a (franchise) quarterback.

There is no way the redskins dont take gaines adamsGood mock and solid trades, but I don't see Carriker going ahead of AdamsHowever, I dislike the Redskins pick of Carriker. It's a dumb selection for defensive end. Anderson is a better 4-3 end than Carriker. And also, I don't see Anderson playing in the 3-4.
I thought Carriker being the first DE off the board might raise a few eyebrows. ;)

I think Gibbs might fall in love with Carriker and what he can immediately offer to his team, which is important as this could very well be Gibbs' last year. Anderson may have flashed more potential in 2006 but Carriker has been playing much more consistently over the past two years however the Cornhuskers asked him to play. And if Washington feels Carriker is a much more balanced DE than Adams and can additionally slide inside at DT with his impressive frame at times, especially given how porous their run defense was in 2006 giving up over 137 rushing yards per game on average, then Carriker might ultimately get the nod.

The 49ers would love to get their hands on Carriker, so I'm sure they are hoping that Washington chooses someone else. It surprised me as well that Carriker was the first DE off the board, as I finally worked out my mock. I'll of course revisit this as the Draft nears, and it might very well change.

goonie61
03-19-2007, 11:20 AM
I guess the Bills will be looking to take a RB in RD 2.

49ersfan_87
03-19-2007, 11:21 AM
It sucks to see carriker gone so high. I dont mind the trade up as well because its peanuts, but if we traded up id rather get laron landry. Jamaal anderson fills a position of need, but Landry is the BPA and i think he would be the pick.

Geo
03-19-2007, 11:30 AM
I guess the Bills will be looking to take a RB in RD 2.
2nd round is very likely, 3rd at the worst. Antonio Pittman is the likely selection in the 2nd round, he gives the Bills McGahee's home-run threat but catches the ball better and follows his blockers better. I'm sure Fairchild would love to have Lynch in his offense, but I don't think he'd be disappointed much at all with Pittman.

Though for a moment, I strongly considered having the Bills trade up with Washington (who wants more draft picks) for Peterson. I even wrote up the description detailing how it would be like having The Juice again, it was beautiful. *sniff*

Acreboy
03-19-2007, 11:35 AM
I wouldn't complain if it happened but I would bet the Saints stay put and take Meachem, Jarrett, or trade one spot up one more spot and take Ross.

Nice pick and explination though.

Diehard
03-20-2007, 03:32 PM
I hate the Denver pick, but recognize it could happen given the team's pathetic showing on returns last year.

Your assessment of Ginn is rather optimistic. He's pure speed, but that's about it. He doesn't have the shiftiness/moves of Hester or the ability to break tackles. He's also a pretty raw receiver, which is a little alarming considering even skilled college WR's can have a hard time with the transition to the NFL.

Severe Punishment
03-23-2007, 01:14 PM
LOVE, just LOVE the Vikings pick. The only way it could've been better is if we traded down and still took him.

Jay
03-23-2007, 02:28 PM
Griffen and Beason would be fine with me...

Geo
03-24-2007, 11:23 PM
Much appreciated on all of the input, everyone. I'll try to put it to use on future mocks.

I hate the Denver pick, but recognize it could happen given the team's pathetic showing on returns last year.

Your assessment of Ginn is rather optimistic. He's pure speed, but that's about it. He doesn't have the shiftiness/moves of Hester or the ability to break tackles. He's also a pretty raw receiver, which is a little alarming considering even skilled college WR's can have a hard time with the transition to the NFL.
I suppose we can agree to disagree, as I love Ginn Jr. and think he's a playmaker with room to grow. Not sure if I'll have the Broncos take him in my next mock though, given the likelihood of Al Wilson being traded (eventually).

JCutlery
03-28-2007, 03:33 PM
Brilliant Broncos pick.