View Full Version : Three Players...

12-21-2010, 07:35 PM
Ok ladies and gents give me three players that you hands down, would put your stamp of approval on. Also give me three players that you hate and if your team drafted you would call a bum if you were driving your car down the street and saw them walking.

1.Stephen Paea- The one DT that everyone loves not to talk about.
2.Ryan Kerrigan- Blue collar, just knows how to get to the QB.
3.Jerrel Jernigan- The next best player from Troy!

1.Cameron Heyward- Not worth where he'll be drafted.
2.Jake Locker- Just don't see what other people do.
3.Dont'a Hightower- People said he was better than McClain... nope.

12-21-2010, 07:51 PM
1.) Andrew Luck - Favorite QB prospect since I began following the draft
2.) AJ Green - I think he's the most polished WR to enter since Larry Fitz
3.) Patrick Peterson - I think he's going to be an animal, even if it is at safety

Not Big Fans Of (Hate is a little too strong)
1.) Anthony Castonzo - Every time I've watched him, he hasn't impressed me. Seems to have too heavy of feet for an NFL LT, and he got bull rushed successfully by smaller guys like Steven Friday too much for me to like him at RT.
2.) Mark Ingram - Great all around RB, but not an all world talent. I wouldn't touch him in the first 25 picks since RBs are easy to find much, much later.
3.) Rodney Hudson - If he really is only 6'2 280, he better hope Mike Shanahan drafts him, because I sure as hell wouldn't.

12-21-2010, 07:52 PM
1 QB Andrew Luck: How could you not? I expect him to be similar to Matt Ryan right now

2 DE Adrian Clayborn: He hasnt had the great senior year like we expected but is still playing at a high level. A for sure starter in my eyes, he makes an impact on the pass and run plays

3 QB Cameron Newton: I am a believer. The kid is simply the best athlete in this draft and probably at his age. 6'6 250lbs 4.5 speed, big arm, SEC experience. He will be a top 10 pick

Hate/Not Like:
1 WR AJ Green: He is a great prospect, but for some reason I see him not living up to his potential. Wont be a bust, but wont be the Randy Moss type guy some are making him out to be.

2 C/G Mike Pouncey: From what Ive seen from him this year, I havent been really impressed. He's not a 1st round type center/guard but will be solid offensive linemen for somebody

3 DL Marcell Dareus: Similar to Pouncey, he has really caught my eye when I watch them play. He is going to be a top 15 pick but will play like a last 1st

12-21-2010, 07:52 PM
2.) AJ Green - I think he's the most polished WR to enter since Larry Fitz

Calvin Johnson says hi

A Perfect Score
12-21-2010, 07:54 PM
You sniped a few of mine. I'm also really high on Paea and Jernigan. I love both of them. I do however like Jake Locker.


1. Cam Jordan - Love the motor, love the versatility
2. Michael Floyd - If he's healthy, he's going to be a very good #1 WR
3. Demarco Murray - I think he's going to be a steal in the second/third
4. Adrian Clayborn - He's going to be a monster in the NFL


1. Jonathon Baldwin - Good luck getting off the jam in the NFL
2. Ras-I Dowling - Too slow, too small, too sloppy
3. Marvin Austin - Still living off high school hype
4. Cam Newton - Cant believe I left him off. C'Mon, man...

12-21-2010, 07:54 PM
Calvin Johnson says hi

Any polish applied to Calvin would have been done by Reggie Ball, and would have been best forgotten.

A Perfect Score
12-21-2010, 07:55 PM
Calvin Johnson says hi

AJ Green is a far more polished receiver then Calvin Johnson was coming out, I dont think there is any debate about that.

12-21-2010, 07:57 PM

1. Colin Kaepernick - Everything about this guy is just awesome.
2. Jerrel Jernigan - Very, very underrated. DeSean Jackson 2.0?
3. Marcus Cannon - One of the best OL prospects I've ever seen.


1. Cameron Newton - Doesn't deserve all the hype.
2. Jake Locker - Not a 1st round talent anymore, sorry.
3. Nah, I don't think there's anyone.

Matthew Jones
12-21-2010, 07:57 PM

1. RB DeMarco Murray, Oklahoma - Supremely talented and would be a beast in a committee, getting touches out of the shotgun formation and especially on draws. Very explosive.
2. OT Anthony Castonzo, Boston College - Has over 50 starts in a row at left tackle, very smart, great technique, should be a pretty safe pick for a team in the first round this year.
3. DE Ryan Kerrigan, Purdue - Has a non-stop motor and is always working to get better. The kind of guy that coaches will love and has versatility in both 3-4 and 4-3 defenses.


1. RB Ryan Williams, Virginia Tech - Everyone blames his poor season on blocking, etc., but it didn't prevent all of the other runners on the team from averaging significantly higher YPC. Goes down way too easily.
2. WR Jon Baldwin, Pittsburgh - The comments he made at the end of the season are a forecast of what's to come once a team decides to draft this diva in the first round.
3. DE Cameron Heyward, Ohio St. - Has looked mediocre this year and is severely overhyped. I'd consider him somewhere in the second round but he's nowhere near the legitimate first-round talent people consider him.

12-21-2010, 08:04 PM
DeMarco Murray - Having watched so much OU football here in Big 12 country, I am a fan.
Andrew Luck - How could one not love him?
Colin Kaepernick - I think he's got serious upside

Mark Ingram - I don't see the big deal.
Cam Newton - IT'S A TRAP!
Allen Bailey - He looks stiff

12-21-2010, 08:12 PM
1. Stephen Paea NT, Oregon State (Pure animal with the strength to match just about any DT in the draft, and uses leverage as good as any prospect i've ever seen. Immediat starter at NT or as a 1 Tech in a 4-3)
2. Cam Jordan DE/DT, Cal (IMO he's a sure thing as a 3-4 DE. He's experienced at that spot and has the perfect build for it. He's really strong, and as you saw, or didn't see, can completely shut a run game down, all but by himself, ala vs, Oregon.
3. Jeremy Beal OLB, Oklahoma (He's a surefire 3-4 OLB. Has consistantly been a great pass rusher the last 3.5 years and is very athletic. He does a LOT of things at Oklahoma, and does a great job in coverage and rushing in the 3 pt stance. He's a ready made 10 sack a year guy without a doubt IMO)

1. Jonathan Baldwin WR, Pitt (Just a player that i really dont like. He looked slow and unwilling to do anything this year, and doesn't get seperation, and then when asked if he's gonna leave, he does nothing but bash the team. I wouldn't touch him with a 10 foot pole.)
2. Von Miller OLB, Texas A&M (He's a one trick pony who will have to do a LOT more to be anything at all in the NFL. All he does is speed rush, and if you watch the film, smart teams just run the ball right under him, and run it for big games. Pretty much a pass rush specialist at best at the next level. No better than Antwan Barnes IMO.)
3. Marvin Austin DE/DT, UNC (He's a bum. Terrible work ethic, although he's not lazy on the field. He's a flat out underachiever, who couldn't use leverage to save his live. And now he cant play any more college ball. He's all but taken off my board till the 3rd or 4th round at absolute best.)

12-21-2010, 08:37 PM
1) Andrew Luck-Best QB prospect IMO since Peyton Manning. Polish AND athletic ability. Still, is he good enough to save a rudderless franchise? That is the million dollar question for every player coming out.
2) Ryan Kerrigan-Great motor, good burst, plays both sides.. and very productive... I hope we get to see him at the Senior Bowl.
3)DE/LB Dontay Moch-Everytime I watch Nevada I tune in to see him and even when he goes sackless I come away impressed. Great speed around the edge, can really run a tight arc, is very versatilie (lining up everywhere), and is stronger than people think,,, jacks OGs backwards when going 1-on-1 with them. Most people see his workout numbers and don't think he is nearly productive enough, I see a terror on the field that offenses have to locate on every play to get two guys on. 1st round might be a bit too soon, but I like Moch in round 2 and as a RDE Dwight Freeney 2.0 type player.

almost forgot who I don't like:

1) Jake Locker-I want to like him, but right now he reminds me of Akili Smith. All athletic ability, no quarterbacking ability. This rematch against Nebraska will be a huge test and indicator if he has learned and can rebound from his dreadful performance.
2) Marvin Austin-I watched DTs all last season and saw Austin far too many times. Far too many times I saw him getting pushed 10 yards off the ball, get no penetration, pretty much do nothing for 60 minutes.. despite playing with Quinn, EJ Wilson, and Alaric Mullins as well as potential 1st round LBs behind him. Just plain terrible.
3a)Adrian Clayborn, I just don't see the quick twitch from him... he could be a good LDE, but as a RDE I just don't see him being a difference maker.
3b) Ras-I Dowling-I wanted him to do well... but he's just a guy. Somebody said he was "too small"... I don't see that at all, too slow, probably, not quick enough, definitely... hurt too often, absolutely. He could be a pretty good FS if he can stay healthy.

12-21-2010, 08:52 PM
Stefen Wisniewski - Very under-rated athleticism. Not saying he's an elite athlete but he's VERY good at pulling and got better and better as the season progressed.
J.J. Watt - For my money, he's the best 34DE prospect I've seen (since 2003) but his skills translate well to the 4-3 as well as he can play all across the line effectively.
Jaiquawn Jarrett - He may not have elite speed but he's a strong tackler in run support, has good ball skills, and has gotten better in coverage every year. In a weak safety class, he's trending upwards as opposed to many other guys that were considered 'top guys' that are trending down.

Not so High on (which turned into my list of players who should stay in school)
Aaron Williams - Williams had an absolutely awful season. He was outplayed by both Curtis and Chykie Brown (prior to his injury) and both of them saw their stock drop based on poor play. Williams still has the size and athleticism that makes teams drool but his play dropped off enough that I would have trouble taking him in the top 2 rounds.
Don'ta Hightower - After being granted a medical redshirt and only being a sophomore this season, there really is no rush for him to declare early but he was vastly outplayed by his running mate, Courtney Upshaw, and just looked like a totally different player than his pre-injury form. He began to come back a bit towards the end of the season but not enough to make me ignore the lack of speed and playmaking ability from the rest of the season. He needs to go back and rebuild his stock.
Akeem Ayers - Ayers is a man without a position. He has really poor hand placement and his pass rush repertoire is lacking so he's not a good fit at 34OLB. He struggles mightily to get off blocks so he's not the best fit at 34ILB. I think he needs to get into a 43 rushbacker type of role a la LaVar Arrington or Clint Sintim but even then I consider him a project because, while he has elite athleticism and speed, he struggles in coverage and isn't really a sound tackler.

Brown Leader
12-21-2010, 09:12 PM
Subject to change :D

High on:

Greg Little - Best yac WR in this class

Rashad "Rock" Carmichael - Ball skills and a solid, physical tackler despite size

DJ Williams - Not just a great receiving TE

Down on:

Michael Floyd - could show up slow and lacking in his expected biggest strength. (jump ball ability) Basically another Crabtree. (yac ability)

Justin Houston - looks much less explosive to me than he's being touted as

Andrew Luck - Because his stock is so high. Might have a fast mind but is slow with his mechanics.

12-21-2010, 10:27 PM
Love : Luck, Herzlich, Paea

Don't hate anybody but I don't see Cam Newton being any good as an NFL QB.

12-21-2010, 10:34 PM
1. Greg Jones
Great instinct, and a good leader on the field.
2. Drake Nevis
Impressed by his ability to rush the passer and put pressure in the middle, if this year wasn't so stacked at DT he would be higher.
3. Nick Fairley
Beast tackle.

1. Cameron Newton
Slated up too high, he floats the ball, and I don't think has what it takes to become a great NFL quarterback (running abilities).
2. Jake Locker
Another QB that is overrated. Several passing problems from decision making to arm strength to accuracy.
3. Ryan Mallet
Jay Cutler 2.0. Not in a good way.

12-22-2010, 12:35 AM
Stamp of Approval:

A.J. Green - This kid is the truth.

Ryan Kerrigan - His relentless motor and effort translates.

Lance Kendricks - <3

Bum walking down the street:

Jonathan Baldwin - Overrated bum.

Cam Newton - I agree. It's a trap.

Nate Solder - How this guy doesn't get dizzy and pass out from spinning around and chasing is incredible on it's own.

12-22-2010, 04:08 AM
1. Prince Amukamara - I didn't want to put top ten guys, but words can't describe how much I love him as a prospect. I like him almost as much as I liked Revis, and I knew Revis was going to be as good as he is (one of my best calls as a draftnik).

2. Derek Sherrod - Too much love for the new prototype converted TE type left tackles that don't get push in the run game, and not enough for guys that are straight up great blockers. Sherrod is a great blocker.

3. Christian Ponder - Definitely a starter IMO, and a safer pick than Locker and Mallett. Has more than enough in every area, though hopefully his height is what is actually being reported. I still love the way he approaches the game and the confidence he exudes.

1. DeMarcus Love - Just seems soft, and really not talented enough to be a starter.

2. Nate Solder - Ugh. See the Sherrod comment.

3. LaMichael James - I don't see what he offers. He's a pretty good cutback runner, but he doesn't really run well between the tackles, he's not that fast or physical, and he's got character concerns. I wouldn't touch him until well into day 3.

12-22-2010, 09:31 AM

1. Stefen Wisniewski
2. Benjamin Ijalana
3. Sam Acho


1. Julio Jones
2. Demarcus Love
3. Any of the Texas CBs

12-22-2010, 11:11 AM

1. Cam Heyward - Has become incredibly underrated recently.

2. Cameron Jordan - Awesome play. I like him more than Alualu.

3. John Moffitt - Arguably the biggest, baddest player on a pretty BA college O-line? Love this guy as a G prospect.

Non-Day 1 guys will include Markus White, Cliff Matthews, and Colby Whitlock. Ryan Kerrigan is the man too.

Don't love:

1. Allen Bailey - I still see him as this draft's equivalent of Vernon Gholston.

2. Stephen Paea - I'm being a douche about size, but I'm not sure what role he'd play for my team's D. Nor do I think he's got the size or ability to become a starter. I would not mind having to eat my words.

3. Von Miller - Earliest he should go is late 2nd or early 3rd.

12-22-2010, 01:08 PM

1. Cameron Jordan-Experienced in 3-4, solid tools/measurables
2. Jake Locker-Has all the tools, just needs the coaching
3. Gabe Carimi-Road Grader at Tackle who should lock down the Right Side, possibly Left

1. Cam Newton-Don't buy the hype, project QB who will take some time
2. Nate Solder-1st round consideration is a little high, good run blocker, but for "athletic" as he is-his pass pro should be elite
3. Akeem Ayers-shys away from contact, and doesn't seem to be a game changer

12-22-2010, 01:29 PM

1. Demarcus Love OT Arkansas -- Whether its outside or inside, I like Love's versatility and mobility at the line of scrimmage.

2. Demarco Murray RB Oklahoma -- If not for his injury history, Murray would have been a Top 15 pick in last year's draft. He has three different gears as a running back and, like previously said, he would be a stud in a running back duo.

3. Stephen Paea DT Oregon State -- Had to get a defensive guy in here, but Paea is a safe bet as an UT and should be a beast for years to come.


Ryan Williams RB Virginia Tech -- I don't see the same type of player that I did last year and whether it was due to injuries or just plain talent, it's still a scary thing to worry about.

Adrian Clayborn DE Iowa -- He doesn't have the athleticism or ability to be the stud type of player that everyone is making him out to be. I like his determination and hand usage but other than that, he's nothing special.

Nate Solder OT Colorado -- He has the height and athleticism, but I'm not sure if he has the physical nature to be a stud OT at the next level.

12-22-2010, 01:48 PM
I'll skip Lukc and Patrick Peterson because thos are obvious

1. Derek Sherrod: I keep hopint he slips for some reason so the Bears can get him at the end of the first round.
2. Julio Jones: He gets a lot of hate on this forum but I think he'll end up being the most productive skill position player of this draft.
3. Christian Ponder: He isn't ready to start next year, but in three or four years, I think he's the second best QB from this draft.

1. Cam Newton: Bad character. Bad offensive scheme. Nothing he does translates to the pros. No thanks.
2. Ryan Mallett: He has a huge arm and... well nothing else really. I imagine he'll be somewhere between Jamarcus Russell and Byron Leftwich.
3. Aaron Williams: Texas' defense has been bad this year. If the secondary of the Longhorns was anywhere near as talented as they are hyped to be, that wouldn't happen.

bored of education
12-22-2010, 01:49 PM
Justin Houston
Ryan Kerrigan
Johnathan Baldwin


12-22-2010, 02:07 PM
Patrick Peterson- How can you not love the measurables and talent here? All world potential.

Drake Nevis- Pure beast this year. Didn't get enough love...he may have been the best defensive player in the nation this season. A tad undersized, but his motor is non stop.

Brandon Harris- He had such a sick year and didn't get a lot of attention for it. May be the best run stopping corner in the class. Love him, have a hard time seeing him fail.

Akeem Ayers- What do people see in this guy? His passrushing skills are weak, and he doesn't fit in the middle either. I wouldn't touch him unless it was late.

Nate Solder- He's all hype. He's big, athletic, and strong...unfortunately he also gets beaten on the edge a ton and lacks polish and technique. He's a project. Definitiely not the first rounder some think.

Allen Bailey- He's a freak athlete, but the more I see, the more question marks arise. His first step is awful, he lacks pass rush moves, and he disappears at times. He's not worth hype. More of a project.

12-22-2010, 02:09 PM
Andrew Luck
AJ Green
Lance Kendricks

Not convinced....

Nick Farley
Adriane Clayborn
Cam Newton

12-22-2010, 02:20 PM
Patrick Peterson - Obvious choice.
Cam Newton - Like RN, I'm a believer.
Derrick Sherrod - He is just so balanced, good at everything.
Julio Jones - I think he is gonna own at the NFL level.
Allen Bailey - Love him.

Mark Ingram - He is not Emmitt Smith, I don't see anything special about this guy, just gonna be another average-above average RB. Not worth a top 20 pick.
Dont'a Hightower - Just don't think he is very good.
Ryan Mallet - Even though I just got him in the forum mock, I am not convinced that he is going to be a good NFL quarterback.

12-22-2010, 02:23 PM
1. Rodney Hudson - will be a great guard/center for a long time, especially in a ZBS.
2. Julio Jones - Has all the physical tools, and his understanding of route running has always impressed me. I remember even as a freshmen it stood out.
3. Mark Ingram - Has elite balance and vision, you can argue if RB's are worth taking high but he will be a Ray Rice type player.

1. Castonzo - Don't buy him as anything more than a borderline starter.
2. Kerrigan - Don't think he will switch well to 3-4 OLB and don't buy him as anything more than an average player in the 4-3.
3. I don't really know, I will admit im not sold on Patrick Peterson (though I wouldn't say hate).