PDA

View Full Version : Critique this as if it were a mock.


onejayhawk
05-03-2012, 02:12 PM
1. Indianapolis Colts - ANDREW LUCK
2. Washington Redskins - ROBERT GRIFFIN III
3. Cleveland Browns - TRENT RICHARDSON
4. Minnesota Vikings - MATT KALIL
5. Jacksonville Jaguars - JUSTIN BLACKMON
6. Dallas Cowboys - MORRIS CLAIBORNE
7. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - MARK BARRON
8. Miami Dolphins - RYAN TANNEHILL
9. Carolina Panthers - LUKE KUELCHEY
10. Bufffalo Bills - STEPHON GILMORE
11. Kansas City Chiefs - DONTARI POE
12. Philadelphia Eagles - FLETCHER COX
13. Arizona Cardinals - MICHAEL FLOYD
14. St. Louis Rams - MICHAEL BROCKERS
15. Seattle Seahawks - BRUCE IRVIN
16. New York Jets - QUINTON COPLES
17. Cincinatti Bengals - DRE KIRKPATRICK
18. San Diego Chargers - MELVIN INGRAM
19. Chicago Bears - SHEA MCCLELLIN
20. Tennessee Titans - KENDALL WRIGHT
21. New England Patriots - CHANDLER JONES
22. Cleveland Browns - BRANDON WEEDEN
23. Detroit Lions - RILEY REIFF
24. Pittsburgh Steelers - DAVID DECASTRO
25. New England Patriots - DONT'A HIGHTOWER
26. Houston Texans - WHITNEY MERCILUS
27. Cincinatti Bengals - KEVIN ZIETLER
28. Green Bay Pakcers - NICK PERRY
29. Minnesota Vikings - HARRISON SMITH
30. San Francisco 49ers - AJ JENKINS
31. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - DOUG MARTIN
32. New York Giants - DAVID WILSON

Off the top of my head,

The Cowboys didnt pay enought to move up.
I must be a Steeler fan
The Patriots NEVER trade up
Irvin at #15, get real. #30 is a reach
Weeden at #22. Told you so.

J

jackalope
05-03-2012, 02:55 PM
No way Irvin goes that high. There's been talk of him in round one, but I can't see a team taking a situational pass-rusher in the top half of the first, especially ahead of Ingram.

If Cox falls all the way to 12, that'd be a great move by Philadelphia.

McClellin seems much better suited to play in a 3-4. I'd have to think Chicago would go Mercilus, Jones, or Perry if they're going DE there.

Hard to imagine DeCastro falling that far.

Good Green Bay pick. I think Perry or Konz would be the two best/most realistic options considering who's on the board.

Unbiased
05-03-2012, 03:00 PM
The Bengals aren't going to trade down and take Zeitler when they could just stay put and draft DeCastro.

Go **** yourself.

Die. I hate you.

You're dead to me.

Angry words.

Duffman57
05-03-2012, 03:42 PM
Meh for the Chargers. We need pass rush and i dont think that Ingram will ever be that great of a pure pass rusher.

Thats a REAL bold pick for Seattle, but i'm a huge Irvin fan so i dont mind it.

Theres no way in HELL cincy passed up the chance of DeCastro...

SuperPacker
05-03-2012, 03:49 PM
1. Indianapolis Colts - ANDREW LUCK
2. Washington Redskins - ROBERT GRIFFIN III
3. Cleveland Browns - TRENT RICHARDSON
Are you ******* kidding me! Why would the Browns give up a 4th 5th and 7th to move up one spot?
4. Minnesota Vikings - MATT KALIL
5. Jacksonville Jaguars - JUSTIN BLACKMON
6. Dallas Cowboys - MORRIS CLAIBORNE
No way the Rams trade out when Claiborne is on the board. Are you taking drugs?
7. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - MARK BARRON
8. Miami Dolphins - RYAN TANNEHILL
9. Carolina Panthers - LUKE KUELCHEY
10. Bufffalo Bills - STEPHON GILMORE
11. Kansas City Chiefs - DONTARI POE
12. Philadelphia Eagles - FLETCHER COX
13. Arizona Cardinals - MICHAEL FLOYD
14. St. Louis Rams - MICHAEL BROCKERS
15. Seattle Seahawks - BRUCE IRVIN
I just lost all respect for you. Please leave this forum.
16. New York Jets - QUINTON COPLES
17. Cincinatti Bengals - DRE KIRKPATRICK
Have you heard of David DeCasto? You dont pass on a elite guard for a under performing cornerback!
18. San Diego Chargers - MELVIN INGRAM
19. Chicago Bears - SHEA MCCLELLIN
Seriously? McCellin is a Outside Linebacker. The Bears would be stupid to pick him here and its never gonna happen.
20. Tennessee Titans - KENDALL WRIGHT
21. New England Patriots - CHANDLER JONES
22. Cleveland Browns - BRANDON WEEDEN
23. Detroit Lions - RILEY REIFF
24. Pittsburgh Steelers - DAVID DECASTRO
25. New England Patriots - DONT'A HIGHTOWER
26. Houston Texans - WHITNEY MERCILUS
27. Cincinatti Bengals - KEVIN ZIETLER
28. Green Bay Pakcers - NICK PERRY
29. Minnesota Vikings - HARRISON SMITH
30. San Francisco 49ers - AJ JENKINS
Officially the worst mock i have ever seen.
31. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - DOUG MARTIN
32. New York Giants - DAVID WILSON

Off the top of my head,

The Cowboys didnt pay enought to move up.
I must be a Steeler fan
The Patriots NEVER trade up
Irvin at #15, get real. #30 is a reach
Weeden at #22. Told you so.

J

Great idea. Would be comments in red.

fenikz
05-03-2012, 04:48 PM
lol i hope the other nfc west teams do that

solid pick for AZ

HeavyLeggedWaistBender
05-03-2012, 04:56 PM
Chicago wouldn't pass on DeCastro.

JaxJag_1
05-03-2012, 05:20 PM
No way we trade up for Justin Blackmon.

We'd take him at 7, but not trade up.

phlysac
05-03-2012, 05:23 PM
30. San Francisco 49ers - AJ JENKINS

What? With Hill, Fleener, and Silatolu still on the board? Cmon!

Pat Sims 90
05-03-2012, 07:26 PM
The Bengals making a trade won't happen.

ChiFan24
05-03-2012, 08:12 PM
Good mock. Looks like something that might actually happen.

vidae
05-03-2012, 08:53 PM
Weeden at #22. Told you so.
J

Congratulations. You're on the same level as Browns management when it comes to the evaluation of prospects. You should be proud.

V

DeepThreat
05-03-2012, 08:54 PM
Congratulations. You're on the same level as Browns management when it comes to the evaluation of prospects. You should be proud.

V

I thought you loved me.

TACKLE
05-03-2012, 09:32 PM
Congratulations. You're on the same level as Browns management when it comes to the evaluation of prospects. You should be proud.

V

Bro, the Browns locked in their board so long ago that Weeden's age wasn't a concern back then.


T

hagy34
05-03-2012, 11:52 PM
There is no chance Spielman actually pulls of a trade and passes on Claiborne. Kalil isn't worth the 4 pick. He will take Claiborne. He loves Claiborne.

onejayhawk
05-04-2012, 06:02 AM
Congratulations. You're on the same level as Browns management when it comes to the evaluation of prospects. You should be proud.

V

When it fits, it fits.

This will not go down on the list of busts.

J

Caddy
05-04-2012, 06:08 AM
I thought you loved me.

You'd be a better GM than what is currently in place.

C

K Train
05-04-2012, 09:05 AM
1. Indianapolis Colts - ANDREW LUCK
2. Washington Redskins - ROBERT GRIFFIN III
3. Cleveland Browns - TRENT RICHARDSON
4. Minnesota Vikings - MATT KALIL
5. Jacksonville Jaguars - JUSTIN BLACKMON
6. Dallas Cowboys - MORRIS CLAIBORNE
7. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - MARK BARRON
8. Miami Dolphins - RYAN TANNEHILL
9. Carolina Panthers - LUKE KUELCHEY
10. Bufffalo Bills - STEPHON GILMORE
11. Kansas City Chiefs - DONTARI POE
12. Philadelphia Eagles - FLETCHER COX
13. Arizona Cardinals - MICHAEL FLOYD
14. St. Louis Rams - MICHAEL BROCKERS
15. Seattle Seahawks - BRUCE IRVIN
16. New York Jets - QUINTON COPLES
17. Cincinatti Bengals - DRE KIRKPATRICK
18. San Diego Chargers - MELVIN INGRAM
19. Chicago Bears - SHEA MCCLELLIN
20. Tennessee Titans - KENDALL WRIGHT
21. New England Patriots - CHANDLER JONES
22. Cleveland Browns - BRANDON WEEDEN
23. Detroit Lions - RILEY REIFF
24. Pittsburgh Steelers - DAVID DECASTRO
25. New England Patriots - DONT'A HIGHTOWER
26. Houston Texans - WHITNEY MERCILUS
27. Cincinatti Bengals - KEVIN ZIETLER
28. Green Bay Pakcers - NICK PERRY
29. Minnesota Vikings - HARRISON SMITH
30. San Francisco 49ers - AJ JENKINS
31. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - DOUG MARTIN
32. New York Giants - DAVID WILSON


decastro at 24? gtfo. i love you though you make me really happy by reading this

Poz51
05-04-2012, 11:06 AM
10. Bufffalo Bills - STEPHON GILMORE

Makes perfect sense to me, fits Nix's drafting history and philosophy and I happen to have Gilmore going 10th to Buffalo in my mock as well, nice pick!

P

Nalej
05-04-2012, 11:48 AM
Pats trade up TWICE? You understand BB has traded up in the 1st only twice... EVER!
Not going to happen.

eaglesalltheway
05-04-2012, 12:11 PM
I'd love the Eagles pick in this scenario.

Holy **** would the Browns be stupid to take a ******, old QB at 22...

EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

killxswitch
05-04-2012, 12:40 PM
Colts get Luck, that is obvious.

McClellin to the Bears seems like a weird fit. I think he's a LB prospect only.

I really can't see 3 RBs going in the first.

I would LOVE it if guys like Irvin, Weeden, Wilson, and AJ Jenkins (who?) all went in the first, it just pushes more talent into the 2nd where we can get a stud defensive player or Rueben Randle or Stephen Hill! Just as long as it's not Fleener.