PDA

View Full Version : Toy Story Mafia - Town Wins!


Pages : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 [9]

Forenci
08-11-2012, 07:46 PM
Agreed. Waiting around is pointless with no investigators.

fenikz
08-11-2012, 07:48 PM
hell maybe syd had an accomplice, you and brody were the only 2 not to vote for him

edit: nevermind forgot that the prospector guy hasn't been found yet

Brodeur
08-11-2012, 07:49 PM
hell maybe syd had an accomplice, you and brody were the only 2 not to vote for him

I wasn't paying attention at the time people went on a mob to vote against him.

fenikz
08-11-2012, 08:55 PM
how is it possible that no one watched me or investigated me i didn't die by day 3 i had to of been suspicious to someone

going hiking be back in a hour or so

killxswitch
08-11-2012, 09:03 PM
vote fenikz

No better option right now. I am kind of irritated at having to find extra mafia members.

Dr. Gonzo
08-11-2012, 09:06 PM
http://i.imgur.com/8sNOg.gif

Grizzlegom
08-11-2012, 09:12 PM
Sorry, we're out...i won't be at a computer for a few hours either...I've got thoughts and **** so talk in the discussion thread for now. Fenikz is stinky pete

Grizzlegom
08-12-2012, 12:27 AM
Final Vote Count:

Forenci (2): Mrs. Grizz, Fenikz
Vidae (1): Brodeur
Fenikz (4): CMD, Forenci, Vidae, killxswitch

With 7 players alive, 4 votes are needed for majority.

Grizzlegom
08-12-2012, 12:27 AM
As the town gathered for the day, there is uncertainty as to which direction to go in again. Suspicions are cast all around but in the end, killxswitch comes forward with a revelation and fenikz is swiftly taken care of.

http://www.tu-pc.com/fondos/media/5685.jpg

Fenikz (Stinky Pete the Prospector, Hunter) has been lynched.

With his final ounce of energy, fenikz lunges after Brodeur, getting one final blow with his prospector's ax.

http://images.wikia.com/pixar/images/e/e5/Froggie%26WalkingCar.png

Brodeur (The Frog, Miller) has been killed.


TOWN WINS!!!!!!!!!!

vidae
08-12-2012, 12:29 AM
I lived!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Grizzlegom
08-12-2012, 12:31 AM
Night Actions:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AmO4bV-7cmwodGFQbTZ0T3hlNUZtNzQzZllpamxubnc

Roles:

Woody - Cop - http://freedisneyclipartsite.com/images/free_disney_clip_art_woody.jpg

You are Andy’s trusted toy, Sheriff Woody Pride. You are the sheriff in these parts and as such your role is Cop. As a cop, you can look into any other character at night and determine their alignment. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Buzz Lightyear - Role Cop - http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/7/75/Buzz-lightyear-toy-story-3-wallpaper.jpg/200px-Buzz-lightyear-toy-story-3-wallpaper.jpg

You are Andy’s toy Buzz Lightyear, the Space Ranger. You are a Role Cop. Each night you can look into any other character and determine what role they have. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Mr. Spell - Townie - http://www.the-leaping-lamp.com/images/toy-story-mr-spell-character.jpg

You are Mr. Spell. You are a Townie. You are a townie and have no abilities besides your ability to vote and reason. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Mr. Pricklepants - Townie - http://www.disneydreaming.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/Toy-Story-3-Mr-Pricklepants.jpg

You are Mr. Pricklepants. You are a Townie. You are a townie and have no abilities besides your ability to vote and reason. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Hamm/Evil Dr. Porkchop - Vigilante - http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41UWyTZjyAL.jpg

You are Andy’s piggy bank that goes affectionately by the name of Hamm. Using your evil alternate ego, Evil Dr. Porkchop, you are a Vigilante. Each night you have the ability to kill another player but be wary, if you choose to kill another player, you will turn up evil if investigated. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Rex - Rolestopper - http://images.wikia.com/pixar/images/8/8b/RexCameoPartcreditsMonster_Inc..jpg

You are Andy’s mighty dinosaur, Rex. You are a Rolestopper, each night you can target another player and that player will be immune to all other night actions. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Lenny the Binoculars - Watcher - http://www.wearysloth.com/Gallery/ActorsR/28959-19912.jpg

You are Andy’s toy Lenny the Binoculars. You are a Watcher, each night you can watch another player, learning the identity of everyone they target. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Mr. Potato Head - Mason - http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41HpAYKlrqL._SL500_AA300_.jpg

You are Andy’s toy Mr. Potato Head. You are a Mason. Each night you can get together with Mrs. Grizz to discuss the game to your heart’s content. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Quicktopic and Zippy: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/KGFy2icNm5UvP and http://zippychat.com/room/ywjrv
Mrs. Potato Head - Mason - http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20120425030433/disney/images/a/a2/Mrs._Potato_Head.jpg

You are Andy’s toy Mrs. Potato Head. You are a Mason, each night you can get together with ImBrotherCain to discuss the game at your heart’s content. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Quicktopic and Zippy: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/KGFy2icNm5UvP and http://zippychat.com/room/ywjrv
Rocky Gibraltar - Townie - http://images3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20111206024834/pixar/images/thumb/e/e0/RockyGibraltar.png/282px-RockyGibraltar.png

You are Rocky Gibraltar. You are a Bodyguard. Each night, you can protect another player from death, however, should they be targeted for death, you will die in their place. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Aliens - Friendly Neighbor - http://www.dan-dare.org/freefun/Images/CartoonsMoviesTV/ToyStory2Wallpaper3800.jpg

You are the Aliens. You are a Friendly Neighbor. Each night, you can compose a message to be sent to another player. The message can say anything you want but it must include “the claw” or “We are eternally grateful” in the writeup somewhere. You simply PM me the player you wish to send it to, as well as the message and I will forward it along with all other night actions just prior to the thread opening. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Barbie - Lover/Voyeur - http://www.dollstuff.net/diary/2010/02/toy-story-3-barbie-2.jpg

You are Barbie. You are a Voyeur. As a voyeur, you can target another player at night and learn all actions performed against that player. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Sarge - Hunter - http://images4.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20091018211539/pixartoystory/images/7/7a/Sarge_toy_story.jpg

You are Sarge. You are a Hunter. Using your superior military technology, upon your death, you are able to select another player to take down with you. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Ducky - Miller - http://images1.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20111206022806/pixar/images/e/e4/Ducky.jpg

You are Ducky. You are a Townie and have no abilities besides your ability to vote and reason. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Babyface/Spider Baby - Miller - http://tanyaeby.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/spider-baby.jpg

You are Babyface, aka Spider Baby. You are a Townie and have no abilities besides your ability to vote and reason. You win when the town is rid of evil.
Wheezy - Townie - http://www.debianiste.org/public/toy_story/1249140360_8824_full.jpeg

You are Wheezy. You are a Townie and have no abilities besides your ability to vote and reason. You win when the town is rid of evil.
The Frog - Miller - http://images.wikia.com/pixar/images/e/e5/Froggie%26WalkingCar.png

You are The Frog. You are a Townie and have no abilities besides your ability to vote and reason. You win when the town is rid of evil.

Bad:

Lotso - Godfather/Role Cop - http://www.cinemablend.com/images/news/17020/_1265932168.jpg

You are Lots-O’-Huggin’ Bear, better known as Lotso. You are the Mafia Godfather/Role Cop. As the godfather, you will come back good in investigations. Each night, you get together with OSUGiants, McGee, Deep, Scotty, Rufus, and ATL to determine who to kill and who to send on the mission. You win when the mafia holds the majority of the town.
Mafia QT and Chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/AQXPkCXLUpL http://zippychat.com/room/ywevh
Character Safeclaim: Jessie the Yodeling Cowgirl
Town Win Condition: You win when the town is rid of evil.
Stinky Pete the Prospector - Hunter - http://www.tu-pc.com/fondos/media/5685.jpg

You are Stinky Pete the Prospector. You are a Mafia Hunter. Upon your death, you can select any other player that you will take with you. Each night, you get together with OSUGiants, McGee, Deep, sbh, Rufus, and ATL to determine who to kill and who to send on the mission. You win when the mafia holds the majority of the town.
Mafia QT and Chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/AQXPkCXLUpL http://zippychat.com/room/ywevh
Character Safeclaim: Trixie the Triceratops
Town Win Condition: You win when the town is rid of evil.
Ken - Lover/Framer/Tailor - http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_E5cSkRNNzuk/TCErze3w1uI/AAAAAAAAJE4/xev3-NPd1JU/s1600/ToyStoryKen.jpg

You are Ken. You are a combo Mafia Tailor/Framer. Each night, you can select any other player and investigation results on those players will be reversed. Each night, you get together with OSUGiants, McGee, sbh, Scotty, Rufus, and ATL to determine who to kill and who to send on the mission. You win when the mafia holds the majority of the town.
Mafia QT and Chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/AQXPkCXLUpL http://zippychat.com/room/ywevh
Character Safeclaim: RC
Town Win Condition: You win when the town is rid of evil.
Stretch - Mafia Backup - http://www.shoppingblog.com/pics/toy_story_3_stretch.jpg

You are Stretch. You are a Mafia Backup. As a backup, you will take over for the first power role that dies. The roles you can inherit are jailkeeper, role cop, framer, or JOAT. If you inherit the jack of all trades you will only be able to use whatever 1x abilities are left. Should the framer/tailor be the first to die, you would inherit framer only. You would not inherit goon or hunter should they be the first to die. Each night, you get together with OSUGiants, McGee, Deep, Scotty, sbh, and ATL to determine who to kill and who to send on the mission. You win when the mafia holds the majority of the town.
Mafia QT and Chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/AQXPkCXLUpL http://zippychat.com/room/ywevh
Character Safeclaim: Etch
Town Win Condition: You win when the town is rid of evil.
Chunk - Goon - http://screamer.alt-world.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/Chunk.jpg

You are Chunk. You are a Mafia Goon. You have no special abilities aside from your ability to perform the factional kill and talk to your mafia pals. Each night, you get together with OSUGiants, sbh, Deep, Scotty, Rufus, and ATL to determine who to kill and who to send on the mission. You win when the mafia holds the majority of the town.
Mafia QT and Chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/AQXPkCXLUpL http://zippychat.com/room/ywevh
Character Safeclaim: Legs
Town Win Condition: You win when the town is rid of evil.
Big Baby - Jailkeeper - http://www.disneydreaming.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/Toy-Story-3-Big-Baby.jpg

You are Big Baby. You are a Mafia Jailkeeper. Each night, you can choose any other player to place in your jail. While in your jail, they will be immune to any and all night actions, however they will also be role blocked. Each night, you get together with sbh, McGee, Deep, Scotty, Rufus, and ATL to determine who to kill and who to send on the mission. You win when the mafia holds the majority of the town.
Mafia QT and Chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/AQXPkCXLUpL http://zippychat.com/room/ywevh
Character Safeclaim: Bullseye
Town Win Condition: You win when the town is rid of evil.
Emperor Zurg - JOAT (1xStrongman, 1xRole Cop, 1xWatch, 1xTrack, 1xJanitor) - http://mikescollection.files.wordpress.com/2012/02/toy_story_2_-_zurg.jpg

You are Emperor Zurg. You are a Mafia Jack-of-All-Trades. As a jack-of-all-trades, you have multiple abilities at your disposal. Here is a list, they are all 1x:
Watch Track Role Cop Strongman Janitor
Each night, you get together with OSUGiants, McGee, Deep, Scotty, Rufus, and sbh to determine who to kill and who to send on the mission. You win when the mafia holds the majority of the town.
Mafia QT and Chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/AQXPkCXLUpL http://zippychat.com/room/ywevh
Character Safeclaim: Slinky Dog
Town Win Condition: You win when the town is rid of evil.

Neutral:
Sid - Bulletproof Serial Killer - http://images.wikia.com/spongebobandfriendsadventures/images/8/88/Sid_Phillips.jpeg

You are the sick and sadistic Sid Phillips. You have a fascination with destroying toys. You are a Bulletproof Serial Killer. Each night you must select another player to kill. You win when you are the last man standing.
Character Safeclaim: Little Bo Peep
Town Win Condition: You win when the town is rid of evil.


Link to Dead Quicktopic: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/BdfS9dAJCdEL

Grizzlegom
08-12-2012, 01:23 AM
Notes on the game setup:

As you all know, I wanted to make a game that caused people to rely more on scum-hunting than simply having people come up with investigations that nailed mafiosos. Obviously, I didn’t want to completely leave power roles out of the game so I put measures in place that would cause a bit of mayhem with investigations. Originally I had a lot more power roles on the town side but then I had the idea of allowing character claims and dropping a number of power roles, replacing them with more townies and millers and then opening up character revealing. Slink was a tracker, Bullseye was a bodyguard, and Jessie was a Deputy but I decided to drop them and make them safe-claims so that the mafia would have some major characters to use as safe-claims, to go along with some minor toys that would allow them to blend in with the townies as well. To counteract the Cop, I gave the mafia a framer/tailor and then had three millers (mutant toys) and made it so that if Hamm killed and was investigated in the same night, he’d come up as evil (miller-vigilante!). To counter the Role Cop, I gave the mafia a number of roles that could be seen as town-aligned in backup, JOAT, hunter, and jailkeeper (and of course the godfather comes back as townie). I also added voyeur, easily the weakest “investigative” role by far, to the game to make the town feel like they had a “power” role there, and I had to have either tracker or watcher and decided to keep Lenny in as a watcher because, frankly, what else would a binoculars toy be? To further weaken the investigative roles, I added the rolestopper and jailkeeper in as potential mass role-blockers as their targets would essentially role block everyone else, something that ended up happening on more than one occasion. In all, not a single baddie was lynched due to an investigator catching him so I was happy with the fact that this game forced people to use a more traditional method of scum hunting.

I had two triggers, one was Spanish Buzz, which happened if he was successfully jailkept. The other was if the Aliens would have chosen Mr. or Mrs. Potato Head to use their friendly neighbor ability on, they would have been adopted and became masoned.

I thought the return of character claiming was a success. I felt that the options I gave the mafia and SK were good character claims and gave them good options on what kinds of roles to come up with when they claimed them.

Notes on The Game itself:

I felt that the town got really lucky to start out and then really came together at the end. ATL’s death was caused by sheer luck and of course it came after the mafia essentially killed one of their own and Rufus inherited the worst possible role he could as the backup. Then Renji killed McGee. That put the mafia in a massive hole that proved to be too deep to get out of.

I would have thought that the DDN game would have taught you guys to read what the mods write but apparently not. I realize that most death writeups don’t really mean a whole lot and that most of the time its just a semi-creative outlet for those of us that mod but I am still in shock that you all thought that Todd killed McGee. McGee was killed in the same way as Cain and Gonzo and I wrote in Todd’s writeup that his final act was in vain. It was obvious that Todd was most suspicious of Renji that day before and most of those watching at that time were sure that someone would put 2 and 2 together. It probably ended up being a good thing in the end as the prolonged day led to sbh and OSU essentially outing themselves and Renji still ended up being the lynch but still, that was one thing that surprised me.

Town

What the Town did Wrong: In all honesty, the town as a whole performed extremely well in this game. While there were individual failures along the way, the town survived with 5 members despite the odds being stacked against them with probably the highest scum-to-town ratio we’ve had in one of these games with 7 mafiosos and a SK. That being said, the SuperPacker and D-Unit lynches were mind-boggling. Don’t get me wrong, SP and D did themselves no favors in their defenses (and I’ll never understand how easy it is to persuade people to vote for them) but both seemed pretty clearly good at the time they were lynched.

What the Town did Right: Honestly, there’s a lot they did right. Different people stepped up at different times to really lead the lynch party on the baddies. Those who had night actions were (mostly) solid with them across the board.

LVP: This one is tough considering the town won. CMD and Brody deserve mention here as they were both good but spent most of the game just going at each other. This is probably the worst game I’ve ever seen vidae play but he said RL got in the way this week and I can understand that. So that leaves SuperPacker. Not using your ability as a friendly neighbor really doesn’t make any sense. His lackluster defense the following day also added suspicions but at the end of the day, I still think it was a major town failure to lynch him.

MVP: D-Unit and Killxswitch both deserve mention here. D-Unit was indirectly responsible for ATL’s death, brought the hammer on OSU, and was one of the few trying to make logical arguments in the middle of the game. That being said, his failure to protect JR the night he died was mind-boggling to me and cost him the title. Killxswitch was the opposite of D-Unit in that he started off with a big-time mistake, killing Wooty but then finished strong, killing OSU and Rufus and being the one to actually put together an argument that took fenikz down. That being said, the MVP to me was Bulldogs. He dispelled the notion that he doesn’t play when he’s a townie and he nailed almost all of his suspicions and, most importantly, he made himself a target as a townie despite there being known town-aligned players and other known roles out there because the mafia was afraid of being caught.

Mafia

Where the Mafia Went wrong: Fenikz said it best, this might have been the most suspicious mafia we’ve seen in a long time. It seemed that just about all of them had suspicions on them early and often. They also broke my cardinal rule number 1. When you know the identity of a protector, you kill said protector. They rolecopped CJ night one but then chose to leave him alive. While some may argue that leaving a bodyguard alive isn’t that big of a deal because they will die if they use their ability right, I would argue that this still prevents you from killing the person you really want to kill. If they had killed CJ night two, there would have been a much different landscape moving forward as they wouldn’t have lost Deep and who knows where the game would have gone from there. The decision to have ATL sitting on all his JOAT roles was something else I didn’t understand. I get that you don’t want to be caught by a watcher or tracker but with 5 abilities and these things typically only lasting 7ish nights, you gotta use em or you risk losing them.

What the Mafia Did Right: I felt that they did really well with their investigations. They had some good overall plans at times but some bad luck (or well-placed townie night actions) tore up their plans.

MVP: I actually thought fenikz played a good game and thought he was going to have a chance at the end but I didn’t play close attention to the vote record and killxswitch nailed him. Sucks that fenikz had the one role that dying would have actually helped them and he was the one that managed to stay alive the longest/had the least amount of suspicions.

LVP: I’m giving it to ATL for not even defending himself. I know you hate and won’t role reveal but I feel like simply claiming you were Slink would have been enough to back some people off. D-Unit looked like he was ready to come to your aid had you put up even a semi-believable defense and that could have changed the whole game.

Serial Killer

What Renji Did Right: I felt the first two kills were good choices. Cain was suspicious of him the first day and seemed to be town-aligned so I liked that kill. Gonzo wouldn’t have gotten off Renji had he kept him alive and was clearly good Gonzo so another good kill. From there, I would have done things differently, which leads me to...

What Renji did Wrong: While I understand the idea of going after “high-profile” players, leaving confirmed townies alive is alway a recipe for failure when you are bad (this can be said to the mafia as well but they had a role cop that was giving them better options to target). The idea behind McGee was the same as the other two, kill a higher-profile player that you consider a threat, but I felt that McGee wasn’t playing an obviously town-aligned game and you can’t win as an SK by killing mafiosos. I think going with a revealed town-aligned player like Mrs. Grizz or Killxswitch was the better choice there. That being said, the mafia knew he was the SK so it was only a matter of time before he would have been killed.

In all, I was very happy with the way this game turned out. I think the Dead QuickTopic was a major success and I really enjoyed having people to talk to while the game was still going on. This game caused people to brush off their investigative skills and actually think about who is and isn't mafia nad it did not disappoint me. I have to be honest, I tried to make the mafia OP because it has become way too hard to win as mafia. I know a lot of people were questioning the 7 mafiosos but with one being a lover, I felt it was legit (plus it still fell below the 33% maximum). I would love to run this setup again sometime as I felt it turned out to be a well-balanced game that could go either way. I hope everyone had fun!

Alright, your turn to chime in!

Brodeur
08-12-2012, 01:26 AM
I want a post game duel with CMD, RIGHT THE **** NOW.

CashmoneyDrew
08-12-2012, 01:28 AM
I want a post game duel with CMD, RIGHT THE **** NOW.

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m8623nsS2j1qf1116o1_400.gif

RufusMcDaniel
08-12-2012, 01:29 AM
Grizz ****** up. I declined the framer role and accepted the JOAT, but he refused to acknowledge that.

If he disagrees, well it is a lie.

sbh15
08-12-2012, 01:30 AM
my goal as GF was to avoid being LVP, so I guess I'm happy.

I hope I'm never mafia again - it's such a pain to come up with fake suspicions and defend myself so desperately.

also, Bulldogs deserves some shoutout for town MVP for the way he played me. when he asked me what I did last night and said I lied, I thought I was toast. I managed to wiggle my way out of that, but when Mrs. Grizz came around she closed the door on my claim

Bulldogs
08-12-2012, 01:33 AM
my goal as GF was to avoid being LVP, so I guess I'm happy.

I hope I'm never mafia again - it's such a pain to come up with fake suspicions and defend myself so desperately.

also, Bulldogs deserves some shoutout for town MVP for the way he played me. when he asked me what I did last night and said I lied, I thought I was toast. I managed to wiggle my way out of that, but when Mrs. Grizz came around she closed the door on my claim

Ahhhh, the old fake track.

Cigaro
08-12-2012, 01:36 AM
The two major criticisms I have for the town are the not reading death write-ups and not really using any sort of personal investigations. Grizz stated plainly the obvious fact that everyone missed about Todd's attempt failing, but even with missing it, if the town simply looked into who Todd was suspicious they would have had something to go on. I know Renji was lynched that next day, but to be honest that seemed a bit lucky as the arguments that were made were not that great. To me, it seems common sense that if someone dies, you should do at least some investigating into who they were naming as suspicious. There is nothing guaranteeing they were not killed randomly or to frame, but you should still acknowledge that they were suspicious of people. And although a lot of hunches were correct, the lynching could have gone a lot smoother if people had taken their hunches and actually applied a little effort to investigate people. Only a few times this happened(D with OSU, BD with Rufus, KS with fenikz). BTW, on D, did you all really think he was evil after making that huge post against OSU? That just makes no sense to me. OSU was certainly not destined for a lynch at that point.

Also, I thought the dead thread was a good idea. Was not the first time I have seen it here, but it was definitely the most used.

Grizzlegom
08-12-2012, 01:41 AM
I guess I never died or wasn't playing in the game when it was used before. That's two things that I thought were "new" in this game that apparently existed before (the character safeclaims being the other).

Cigaro
08-12-2012, 01:42 AM
I guess I never died or wasn't playing in the game when it was used before. That's two things that I thought were "new" in this game that apparently existed before (the character safeclaims being the other).

It was used in either the Gladiator game or the ES game, one of the arena setups. But there were a lot less posts in that one. I am not sure it was created initially by the mods though, I sort of remember someone else sending me the PM with the mods permission.

Gay Ork Wang
08-12-2012, 03:54 AM
Im still no fan of revealing that a hunter hit or didnt hit.

Todd Bertuzzi
08-12-2012, 04:08 AM
Im still no fan of revealing that a hunter hit or didnt hit.

1. If they get lynched during the day it will be very obvious anyways.
2. If they get killed at night and miss it will likely be obvious in games with no vigilante because there will only be the usual SK and mafia kills.

Gay Ork Wang
08-12-2012, 07:05 AM
yes, but dont put it in the writeups.

Grizzlegom
08-12-2012, 07:44 AM
Yea, I actually agree with you. Nobody noticed it but, in retrospect, probably shouldn't have mentioned it anyway.

ATLDirtyBirds
08-12-2012, 09:02 AM
I still think sitting on my abilities was the right move. I was going to start using them the next night, but damn you DUnit.

Gay Ork Wang
08-12-2012, 09:39 AM
if you had just tried to defend yourself a little bit you would have survived

Wootylicous
08-12-2012, 10:51 AM
Goddamn you killx!!!

ATLDirtyBirds
08-12-2012, 11:34 AM
if you had just tried to defend yourself a little bit you would have survived


The last person to escape a cop coming out against them that early in the game? Not a chance in the world. I thought it would be wiser to just fall on my sword and not have any of my teammates implicate themselves.

Bulldogs
08-12-2012, 11:50 AM
Whatever you says ATLbrololdogs.

vidae
08-12-2012, 12:23 PM
It definitely wasn't my strongest game early but I think I held my own in the late game. I had no plans or obligations before it started but I was slammed with rl stuff once the thread opened. I was hardly active at all this game and that was upsetting.

vidae
08-12-2012, 12:25 PM
And on SP: He failed to use his power which made no sense and then when we tried to set a plan for the next day he basically refused to follow it. It looked suspicious as hell. I don't feel bad for that lynch.

Now for D-Unit, I wasn't on (I was at Arrowhead) but I can't say what I would have done in that situation. It's usually pretty easy to get a D lynch train going.

D-Unit
08-12-2012, 12:31 PM
I still think sitting on my abilities was the right move. I was going to start using them the next night, but damn you DUnit.
I thought you were good in the beginning of the game. That's why I protected you. Even when people were lynching you, I was certain that you were good until you basically caved in.

Was I blocked on the night CJ died? I protected him but it didn't work.

Also, yeah... not protecting JRD was done on purpose, but really... at that point, I knew the town would win even if he died and I died. I was just ready for a challenging finish. That's basically it. I knew the numbers were greatly favoring the town at that point. I love a challenge and I loved having a chance to throwing a twist in things. That's also part of why I didn't role reveal. I wanted to see if I could finish the game w/out doing it. I know I told folks I was going to do it the next day, but I wasn't. lol. I thought if the town lynched me then my game play must not have been good enough to convince them I was good.

vidae
08-12-2012, 12:37 PM
Reading the dead thread has made me lose respect for a few of you in these games. How pompous and conceited some of you are really astounds me.

Bulldogs
08-12-2012, 12:38 PM
Haha there was plenty of douchebaggery in the Dead Thread.

vidae
08-12-2012, 12:47 PM
It isn't just that there was douchebaggery, but the levels at which some people took it. It really is quite sad to see.

Bulldogs
08-12-2012, 12:49 PM
I only had five posts, all of which said, "**** you Vidae."

vidae
08-12-2012, 12:51 PM
When the mod of the game you're playing openly states that he hopes you get lynched.. yeahhhh. Classy ****, haha.

Bulldogs
08-12-2012, 12:55 PM
http://0-media-cdn.foolz.us/ffuuka/board/vg/image/1338/44/1338443303668.jpg

vidae
08-12-2012, 01:02 PM
Nah not rustled, just wish people weren't so condescending/rude. It would make these games so much more enjoyable.

ATLDirtyBirds
08-12-2012, 01:04 PM
Jump off a cliff vidae.

Wootylicous
08-12-2012, 01:06 PM
Bulldogs is an ass!

RufusMcDaniel
08-12-2012, 01:13 PM
Jump off a cliff vidae.

Maybe you should be the one jumping off the cliff.

ATLDirtyBirds
08-12-2012, 01:26 PM
Maybe you should be the one jumping off the cliff.

Only if you and McGee reveal, I mean, go first. I'll follow. For sure.

Raiderz4Life
08-12-2012, 01:39 PM
I hate you McGee....you bastard haha night 2 and done

CJSchneider
08-12-2012, 02:04 PM
Was I blocked on the night CJ died? I protected him but it didn't work.



Had you done it two nights in a row, I would have lived. The time you did protect me, it kept me from being jailkept.

SuperMcGee
08-12-2012, 02:10 PM
I hate you McGee....you bastard haha night 2 and done

Dont shoot the messenger! Even if I did physically kill you. I wanted to kill Bulldogs. But I can't say I was comfortable with you around. You were very talkative this game. Who knew you'd take one of us with you.

Cigaro
08-12-2012, 02:14 PM
People should not take the dead thread personally.

Bulldogs
08-12-2012, 02:16 PM
Dont shoot the messenger! Even if I did physically kill you. I wanted to kill Bulldogs. But I can't say I was comfortable with you around. You were very talkative this game. Who knew you'd take one of us with you.

Can't touch this.

Grizzlegom
08-12-2012, 02:22 PM
When the mod of the game you're playing openly states that he hopes you get lynched.. yeahhhh. Classy ****, haha.

If you were that busy you could have asked to be replaced. Openly stating in the thread that you hated the trivia, that you aren't even reading/participating, and questioning the amount of baddies is spitting in the face of the mod. Sorry that I didn't want you in my game anymore.

vidae
08-12-2012, 02:31 PM
If you were that busy you could have asked to be replaced. Openly stating in the thread that you hated the trivia, that you aren't even reading/participating, and questioning the amount of baddies is spitting in the face of the mod. Sorry that I didn't want you in my game anymore.

When did I say I wasn't reading or participating? Please show me where I said that. And I was busy but I still had over 100 posts in your game. But sure, questioning two things (one I disagreed with completely and one that was really just me being surprised that the game was still going) is reason enough for you to be a douchebag. Well played sir.

edit:

Is that all that these gifts are going to be? Trivia? Cuz if I wait until noon:30 every day and it's just more trivia I'll be sad. I don't remember these movies well, and those "tests" don't give everyone equal footing.

Ah well.

I wasn't a jerk, I said I would be sad since these don't give everyone equal footing, to which you replied:


I'm sorry to disappoint vidae but everyone else seems to be able to use Google just fine.

You jumped out and started being bitchy at me when I was being respectful.

6 Mafia and a SK already dead and we're still going? wtf..

Yep. I'm surprised we're still here considering that 6 Mafia and a SK are already dead. I'm in the process of catching up on what I missed yesterday.

Wow, look how rude that was Grizz. You have every right to be pissed at me. I'm so sorry I "spit in your face" there.

Raiderz4Life
08-12-2012, 02:49 PM
Dont shoot the messenger! Even if I did physically kill you. I wanted to kill Bulldogs. But I can't say I was comfortable with you around. You were very talkative this game. Who knew you'd take one of us with you.

What can I say? I was too cute haha

Grizzlegom
08-12-2012, 02:59 PM
It was more the trivia thing that pissed me off, nobody else seemed to have any issue with it and tried to make the best of it even if they didn't know the answers off the top of their heads. I toyed around with other ideas but seeing that this was a themed game, I didn't think having a theme-based trivia was that big of a deal and the prizes were pretty minute anyway. If you had an issue with it, you could have mentioned something to me via PM or Gchat instead of in the thread. I actually had other ideas on ways to give out prizes but I decided on the trivia thing. I honestly was more annoyed with it because you are someone else who has modded games and you know how much effort it takes and you know what its like to have people bash your ideas/game in the thread so I guess I held you to a bit higher standard.

I went back and looked but I was wrong, it was Brody that was saying he wasn't reading but for some reason I was thinking you did as well. At the end of the day it looks like I over-reacted to the other stuff and I was just being stupid about the whole trivia thing. Sorry about that.

vidae
08-12-2012, 03:02 PM
Well I apologize too then. Maybe it was a little harsh, I was just hoping that it would have been something else for prizes, and I could have expressed that to you via PM or gchat instead of the thread. That was my fault, and I know better.

I honestly don't think I was being dickish about the Mafia numbers thing but obviously the way I phrased it made you angry so I apologize for that too.

Grizzlegom
08-12-2012, 03:08 PM
You weren't the only person that was surprised by the number of mafia members. The whole lovers thing made me feel comfortable giving them an extra member and I shouldn't have reacted like I did to that. Like many others, I planned on taking a break after this, getting too into these games messes with our heads too much and makes us angry at people we normally like haha

vidae
08-12-2012, 03:11 PM
I wasn't pissed at the Mafia numbers, just surprised. I honestly didn't even think about the lovers thing at the time but it makes sense for the numbers to be what they were. I didn't realize it until the end of the game when you posted your thoughts.

Forenci
08-12-2012, 03:37 PM
I thought the Death thread as pretty hilarious. It's funny how much Gonzo bitches that we all suck as town and we did pretty damn well to win this game without him.

And Gonzo, don't say I don't care or don't participate. You're so full of ****. I haven't criticized the way you play like most people, because I understand everyone has different ways of playing the game and there is no wrong way unless you're blatantly foolish about it. Unlike a crap ton of people I DO read the thread, completely. And I also send in my night actions in a timely manner if I have them. I contribute and vote. I don't always vote because sometimes I don't agree with the person being lynched and I don't like to throw my votes around recklessly because it can come back and haunt you later. This is how I play. I don't like making huge arguments for somebody unless I'm confident they're evil. By the end of the game I had ruled out Vidae and narrowed my choice to fenikz or Brody and ultimately chose the right person. For somebody who plays like a maniac and gets nailed for it by most people, I do think it's funny how you insult others so willingly.

I play my style. I don't need to post 500 times and accuse everyone of being evil to learn information about them. And it doesn't mean I'm not active.

It's so funny how for a mafia game genius like yourself you didn't realize that I was trying to sacrifice myself for a night kill in the hopes (somebody) with a power role or ability might live. It's a pretty good strategy, I think, and is helpful to the town. Unfortunately, nobody understood what I was doing, even though BD was spelling out very clearly.

CJSchneider
08-12-2012, 03:40 PM
I wasn't pissed at the Mafia numbers, just surprised. I honestly didn't even think about the lovers thing at the time but it makes sense for the numbers to be what they were. I didn't realize it until the end of the game when you posted your thoughts.

I thought that was a pretty cool twist. I like seeing surprises like that in the games.

Raiderz4Life
08-12-2012, 03:50 PM
See who says women won't lead you to an early grave??

fenikz
08-12-2012, 08:38 PM
Ha Gonzo is so jealous of my skill he wishes he was as good as me