PDA

View Full Version : Definite 1st Round Grades?


Matthew Jones
10-18-2012, 07:54 AM
Which prospects do you believe have secured first-round grades as a prospect? Here are the ones I'm comfortable enough to assign one to:

QB Matt Barkley, Southern California
QB Aaron Murray, Georgia*
QB Geno Smith, West Virginia
WR Keenan Allen, California*
WR Justin Hunter, Tennessee*
WR Robert Woods, Southern California*
OT Luke Joeckel, Texas A&M*
OT Taylor Lewan, Michigan*
DT Star Lotulelei, Utah
DE Barkevious Mingo, Louisiana St.*
DE Bjoern Werner, Florida St.*
LB Jarvis Jones, Georgia*
LB Manti Te'o, Notre Dame
CB Johnthan Banks, Mississippi St.
CB Dee Milliner, Alabama
CB Xavier Rhodes, Florida St.*
FS T.J. McDonald, Southern California*
FS Eric Reid, Louisiana St.*

Aside from that, a bunch of prospects on the fringes include Tyler Eifert, Barrett Jones, Chance Warmack, Sam Montgomery, etc.

bucfan12
10-18-2012, 02:00 PM
I'm really not impressed with Taylor Lewan. I think he's vastly overrated.

Jonathon Hankins is missing from this list.

MassNole
10-18-2012, 02:27 PM
Only thing with Xavier Rhodes is his perceived lack of speed.

vidae
10-18-2012, 02:36 PM
Surprised to see Aaron Murray on there.

AntoinCD
10-18-2012, 02:37 PM
I wouldn't be overly confident in putting Murray or McDonald as first round grades and I think Reid is a fringe guy.

I would put Tyler Wilson, Montgomery, Jones, Hankins, Warmack and Eifert as definites and get rid of the 3 above

Edit: I am also not sure I would definitely have Robert Woods as a first round talent

wicket
10-18-2012, 02:43 PM
Which prospects do you believe have secured first-round grades as a prospect? Here are the ones I'm comfortable enough to assign one to:

QB Matt Barkley, Southern California
QB Aaron Murray, Georgia*
QB Geno Smith, West Virginia
WR Keenan Allen, California*
WR Justin Hunter, Tennessee*
WR Robert Woods, Southern California*
OT Luke Joeckel, Texas A&M*
OT Taylor Lewan, Michigan*
DT Star Lotulelei, Utah
DE Barkevious Mingo, Louisiana St.*
DE Bjoern Werner, Florida St.*
LB Jarvis Jones, Georgia*
LB Manti Te'o, Notre Dame
CB Johnthan Banks, Mississippi St.
CB Dee Milliner, Alabama
CB Xavier Rhodes, Florida St.*
FS T.J. McDonald, Southern California*
FS Eric Reid, Louisiana St.*

Aside from that, a bunch of prospects on the fringes include Tyler Eifert, Barrett Jones, Chance Warmack, Sam Montgomery, etc.

add jones, warmack, montgomery and damontre moore for me, remove lewan, jones and rhodes

LonghornsLegend
10-18-2012, 02:45 PM
I wouldn't be overly confident in putting Murray or McDonald as first round grades and I think Reid is a fringe guy.

I would put Tyler Wilson, Montgomery, Jones, Hankins, Warmack and Eifert as definites and get rid of the 3 above

Edit: I am also not sure I would definitely have Robert Woods as a first round talent

Fringe 1st round? That's not very likely but I sure would love if he had late 1st round early 2nd round value come draft time.

Cigaro
10-18-2012, 03:14 PM
Completely disagree on Murray. There will be many questions about his height, and he hasn't been dominant in college, the usual thing that would help alleviate such concerns. He is a very fringe first rounder at best, IMO.

Docta
10-18-2012, 03:19 PM
add jones, warmack, montgomery and damontre moore for me, remove lewan, jones and rhodes
Remove Jarvis Jones?...

Imbecile.

Babylon
10-18-2012, 03:30 PM
Out

Aaron Murray
T.J. McDonald

In

Tyler Eifert
Jonathon Hankins
Chance Womack
Barrett Jones

Witten4HOF
10-18-2012, 03:45 PM
Only thing with Xavier Rhodes is his perceived lack of speed.

I think Rhodes will end up running in the high 4.4's which isn't terrible, I think he might be a hair slow in the three cone because he is so high cut but that shouldn't effect his stock. Prototypical press corner or free safety, if he comes out of the season healthy he will be a top 40 pick imo.

Docta
10-18-2012, 04:18 PM
And I actually think Woods could slip to the 2nd. Stock's dropping.

jrdrylie
10-18-2012, 04:29 PM
Aaron Murray is definitely not a first-round lock. He is often compared to Drew Brees, who went in the second. I think those comparisons are a bit kind to Murray. I view him more as a late second.

Also, a lot of people are viewing Tyler Wilson as a first round lock. Maybe I'm alone, but part of me thinks GMs are going to look at the mess that is Arkansas and wonder where the leadership from Wilson was. Concussions could also be an issue and I could definitely see him dropping quite a bit.

MassNole
10-18-2012, 04:33 PM
I think Rhodes will end up running in the high 4.4's which isn't terrible, I think he might be a hair slow in the three cone because he is so high cut but that shouldn't effect his stock. Prototypical press corner or free safety, if he comes out of the season healthy he will be a top 40 pick imo.

He'll be lucky to top out at 4.5, but he has game speed which is more important than t-shirt and shorts speed. I'll never understand the logic of timing players in the 40 without pads on, at least a helmet and shoulder pads.

No one at FSU expects him back in 2013, it is doubtful he would have been back in 2012 if not for tweaking his knee in the bowl game.

PeterMurray
10-19-2012, 10:22 AM
When you say someone has absolutely locked in a first round grade, that is saying quite a bit when you factor in all that can change between now and April. From your list I would say,
Out: Murray, Rhodes, McDonald, Reid
In: Warmack, Montgomery, Hankins

Matthew Jones
10-19-2012, 10:32 AM
Aaron Murray is definitely not a first-round lock. He is often compared to Drew Brees, who went in the second. I think those comparisons are a bit kind to Murray. I view him more as a late second.

Also, a lot of people are viewing Tyler Wilson as a first round lock. Maybe I'm alone, but part of me thinks GMs are going to look at the mess that is Arkansas and wonder where the leadership from Wilson was. Concussions could also be an issue and I could definitely see him dropping quite a bit.

A lot of my criticism has to do with his inconsistent mechanics and the Bobby Petrino offense he put up his big numbers in (which was absolutely loaded with Wright, Childs, Adams, and Cobi Hamilton.) I actually thought, strictly based on our evaluations of them as prospects, Brian Brohm was better.

princefielder28
10-19-2012, 10:40 AM
Surprised to see Aaron Murray on there.

Murray is closer to a 3rd round prospect than a 1st rounder...he simply hasn't taken that next step yet

Fringe 1st round? That's not very likely but I sure would love if he had late 1st round early 2nd round value come draft time.

Reid is more of an in-the-box safety and his skills translating as a FS to the NFL may not be there...if that's how he's perceived by teams that'll push down his value, maybe out of the 1st

And I actually think Woods could slip to the 2nd. Stock's dropping.

Woods is a very good receiver, but he could end up being the 4th best receiver, depending on who declares, and considering he doesn't have any physical traits that WOW anyone, slipping out of the first makes sense or is a possibility.

princefielder28
10-19-2012, 10:44 AM
I'm really not impressed with Taylor Lewan. I think he's vastly overrated.

Jonathon Hankins is missing from this list.

I don't see it with Lewan either. He could find his way towards the bottom of round one but I don't see him being a lock. I know it was just the first game but I can't get the struggles against Alabama out of my head with him.

I agree Hankins should on this list...after Star he's gonna be the most coveted DT on the board


Also, a lot of people are viewing Tyler Wilson as a first round lock. Maybe I'm alone, but part of me thinks GMs are going to look at the mess that is Arkansas and wonder where the leadership from Wilson was. Concussions could also be an issue and I could definitely see him dropping quite a bit.


If GMs question Wilson on the mess at Arkansas and place any blame on him that would be absurd. It's not Tyler's fault that Coach Petrino was screwing around with an intern or whatever she was, and then the chaos that followed with it.

Shane P. Hallam
10-19-2012, 11:06 AM
From your list, the only guys I think are LOCKS for the first (barring injury/arrest) are:

QB Geno Smith, West Virginia
WR Robert Woods, Southern California*
DT Star Lotulelei, Utah
DE Barkevious Mingo, Louisiana St.*
LB Jarvis Jones, Georgia*
LB Manti Te'o, Notre Dame
CB Dee Milliner, Alabama
FS Eric Reid, Louisiana St.
DE Sam Montgomery, Louisiana St.

I'm not 100% on Reid either, but think someone would take him.


Also doesn't mean these guys are tops at their position (though most are). Someone like Woods is a lock for production/pedigree/combine #s, while I COULD see Allen/Hunter go early 2nd if they have a bad offseason.

AcheTen (Thumper)
10-23-2012, 12:14 AM
Michael Mauti?

wicket
10-23-2012, 04:44 AM
Remove Jarvis Jones?...

Imbecile.

health issues could cause him to drop easily

georgiafan
10-23-2012, 07:32 AM
Murray shoudnt be a 1st round lock

Shane P. Hallam
10-23-2012, 07:33 AM
Murray shoudnt be a 1st round lock

He isn't. He isn't a 2nd round lock even unfortunately, though I still like him.

georgiafan
10-23-2012, 07:48 AM
He isn't. He isn't a 2nd round lock even unfortunately, though I still like him.

This weeks game is huge for him bc he has yet to be a good team in his career and always piles on stats vs the weak teams. I think he needs to come back for his senior year but I could be biased.

Matthew Jones
10-23-2012, 08:35 AM
He isn't. He isn't a 2nd round lock even unfortunately, though I still like him.

He may not be a first-round lock, but he's earned a first-round grade from me. Outstanding footwork, mechanics, release, pocket movement, tight spiral, strong arm, generally accurate ball placement, SEC pedigree, long-time starter playing in a pro-style scheme. If he was 6'3" instead of 6'1", I don't think there'd be any question that he was a first round pick.

wI1eALvjtu4

georgiafan
10-23-2012, 09:19 AM
There is a big diffrence between saying someone has a 1st round grade an calling them a 1st round lock atleast in my eyes.

descendency
10-23-2012, 10:17 AM
There is a big diffrence between saying someone has a 1st round grade an calling them a 1st round lock atleast in my eyes.
QBs with first round grades go in the first round. Teams aren't that dumb. Murray doesn't have the coke problem that Mallett did. He'll go in round 1, especially given how poor this QB class is.

georgiafan
10-23-2012, 10:25 AM
QBs with first round grades go in the first round. Teams aren't that dumb. Murray doesn't have the coke problem that Mallett did. He'll go in round 1, especially given how poor this QB class is.

And they would be making a mistake and this is from the biggest UGA fan around.

AntoinCD
10-23-2012, 10:30 AM
QBs with first round grades go in the first round. Teams aren't that dumb. Murray doesn't have the coke problem that Mallett did. He'll go in round 1, especially given how poor this QB class is.

Eh, Murray doesn't have the size or close to the arm that Mallett does either. With a good offseason I can see him making his way up, but right now I would not call him a first round QB

Shane P. Hallam
10-23-2012, 11:26 AM
QBs with first round grades go in the first round. Teams aren't that dumb. Murray doesn't have the coke problem that Mallett did. He'll go in round 1, especially given how poor this QB class is.

I'd take that bet. Murray doesn't have a Round 1 grade right now even. Size will be a big issue. He's more Russell Wilson than Ryan Mallett.

Brown Leader
10-23-2012, 11:55 AM
I'd go...

QB
Geno Smith
Tyler Wilson
Matt Barkley
E.J. Manuel

RB
Joseph Randle

WR
Keenan Allen
Stedman Bailey
Robert Woods
DeAndre Hopkins

TE
Jordan Reed
Tyler Eifert

OT
Luke Joeckel
Oday Aboushi
Jake Matthews
Taylor Lewan

OG/OC
Chance Warmack
Barrett Jones

DE
Damontre Moore
Dion Jordan
Bark Mingo
Sam Montgomery
Corey Lemonier

DT
Star Lotulelei
John Hankins
Sheldon Richardson

LB
Manti Teo
Jarvis Jones

DB
Johnthan Banks
Dee Milliner

Shane P. Hallam
10-23-2012, 12:02 PM
I'd go...

QB
Geno Smith
Tyler Wilson
Matt Barkley
E.J. Manuel

RB
Joseph Randle

WR
Keenan Allen
Stedman Bailey
Robert Woods
DeAndre Hopkins

TE
Jordan Reed
Tyler Eifert

OT
Luke Joeckel
Oday Aboushi
Jake Matthews
Taylor Lewan

OG/OC
Chance Warmack
Barrett Jones

DE
Damontre Moore
Dion Jordan
Bark Mingo
Sam Montgomery
Corey Lemonier

DT
Star Lotulelei
John Hankins
Sheldon Richardson

LB
Manti Teo
Jarvis Jones

DB
Johnthan Banks
Dee Milliner

Good to know 29 of the 32 picks are spoken for! lol.

Brown Leader
10-23-2012, 12:09 PM
This thing helps.

http://www.gemselect.com/other-info/graphics/smoky-quartz-crystal-ball_1.jpg

Thefudge
10-24-2012, 07:45 PM
My first round locks are :Chance Warmack, Jarvis Jones,Luke Joeckel, Dee Milliner, Keenan Allen, Keke Mingo, Sam Montgomery, and Lotulele. I don't see Geno being a first round pick if he keeps up on this slump.

Guys who I believe are first round talents include Jesse Williams, Barret Jones at LG or C, Jonthan Banks, Kawann Short, Kevin Reddick, Johnathan Cooper, Dion Jordan and Mike Gillislee is the bomb and reminds me of a working class mans Arian Foster.