View Full Version : 2013 Browns Coaching Candidates

Brown Leader
10-24-2012, 11:40 PM
Who do you want or see coaching for the Browns next season?

The number one thing for me is I'd like to see this offense stay in place. Surest route to ruining a new QB is throwing different systems at them every other year-and Weeden doesn't have as long as an ordinary new QB. That means retaining Childress as OC and ruling out an offensive minded HC. At this point in his career I think Chilly will be fine being an OC for the foreseeable future. For a defensive-minded coach this ought to be a pretty attractive position in that the key parts on offense are already in place. Of the defensive oriented coaches that should get a shot at a HC after the season, #1 on my list right now is Ray Horton.

It's interesting to debate whether Banner/Haslem will look for a proven guy or a first time HC. Cowher is only 3 yrs older then Horton, unbelievably, and if he's finally serious about getting back in, I think this is a good situation for him. He's made some public comments on Fox this season praising the Browns and Weeden.

Defensively, Horton or Cowher mean going back to a 34 but we've definitely got the interior line depth for it and many of our key guys are familiar with the scheme. Switching back, our front 7 depth chart would look something like:

DE Athyba Rubin - Frostee Rucker
NT John Hughes - Ishmaa'ily Kitchen
DE Phil Taylor - Billy Winn
RILB Gocong - Michael -Johnson
LILB Jackson
LOLB Sheard - Stephens

That's a lot to work with upfront and the upcoming draft has a bunch of highly rated DE/OLB to choose from.[Jarvis Jones - Dion Jordan - Damontre Moore - Bark Mingo - Corey Lemonier] My preference though, if it was a defensive coach, would be to finish out the offense by taking the beast that is Keenan Allen and not have to worry about that side of the ball for the next five years. Right now, the only vet FA WR I'd take over Allen would be Bowe.

The DC is almost as important. First choice would be San Fran DL coach Jim Tomsula.

Share your thoughts.

10-25-2012, 11:58 AM
I really like David Shaw but I'm not sure the new regime is going to want a rookie HC. He does have ties to Banner though.

I do agree though if the dream of Cowher comes to fruition that the overhaul in switching to a 3-4 wouldn't be as complicated as our first switch was when Romeo got to town. Taylor/Rubin would be a nice rotation at NT while we could snag the OLB prospect you mention, and perhaps we snag a late-round gem at rusher.

Brown Leader
10-25-2012, 12:06 PM
That Fewell has got to be Rosebud.

11-04-2012, 03:28 PM
Personal opinion, but I wouldn't want to switch back to a 3-4. If we do, I feel we're in for a complete Defensive overhaul once again.

Rubin and Taylor would be NTs. I don't feel either could give you the production they give now at DE in the 3-4 as they do right now in the 4-3.

We have no DEs, no LBers outside Gocong to fit the 3-4. Jackson plays his best in space, not at the POA like you want from ILBers in the 3-4.

So no 3-4, please.

I do know we can't go into next season with Shurmur as our HC, I wouldn't be surprised to see him fired after he coached the game away to the Ravens. An interim HC would be fine with me coming outta the bye. At least it'd be a legit reason for not winning anymore games instead of the debacle that is Shurmur right now.

I want a HC who can adjust to what he has and not a guy who needs his "type" of guys. I know our record doesn't show it, but I feel like we do have some talented young guys who just aren't being coached correctly right now. I don't want to see a roster overhaul.

11-05-2012, 09:22 AM
3-4 transition wouldn't be as hard as you think. Rubin and NT. Taylor at DE (and he could play NT as well). Winn at DE. Kitchen back up NT, Hughes backing up at DE. Sheard at OLB. Gocong and Jackson at ILB like under Ryan. Of course they'd need another pass rushing OLB, but we need another pass rusher regardless of scheme.

3-4 switch wouldn't be so hard this time. That said it'd be much easier to stay in the 4-3. It doesn't really make that much of a difference b/c most teams play some sort of hybrid a lot of the time and few play the true 2-gap 3 man front even if they are a 3-4 team. We need more good pass rushers on the edge or else it won't matter what scheme we run.

11-05-2012, 02:16 PM

11-14-2012, 09:58 PM
I often wonder what stability in the front office/coaching staff would feel like.

Brown Leader
11-17-2012, 12:56 PM
Throw two more names in the hat. Rex Ryan. Mike Holmgren. Personally I'd love Rex here-more than Horton. Holmgren stepping down to coach? Idk but he's got the resume and it would keep continuity on both sides.

11-20-2012, 05:00 PM
I often wonder what stability in the front office/coaching staff would feel like.

Let's hope the new owner solves all that.

01-07-2013, 01:48 AM
Let's hope the new owner solves all that.

really starting to like him

what are your guys thoughts on lovie smith dont think he has been talked about as in option from what i have read

01-07-2013, 01:55 AM
really starting to like him

what are your guys thoughts on lovie smith dont think he has been talked about as in option from what i have read

If we attach him to a Proven offensive mind, I suppose.

Hope we interview Mike Mccoy.

Brown Leader
01-07-2013, 06:06 PM
Agreed. If you could find a top notch OC to pair with Lovie, that could work. Chan Gailey's older but he's a proven good offensive coach.

I don't have a problem with Whisenhunt either. Pair him with a good to great QB and he'd be Tom Coughlin.

01-08-2013, 02:49 PM
really starting to like him

what are your guys thoughts on lovie smith dont think he has been talked about as in option from what i have read

Lovie is a great defensive mind but he runs a Cover 2 defense and I'm not sure our personnel suits that defense. It might set our defense back quite a bit as he tries to find the personnel for his system.