PDA

View Full Version : G-Men call about Kris Jenkins, still interested in Al Wilson


GiantRutgersFan
04-09-2007, 05:12 PM
from MVN. http://mvn.com/nfl-giants/


Basically it seems like Reese is willing to deal our 5th-7th round picks in exchange for either of these guys.


I would like it either way, especially nabbing Jenkins. I would like Al Wilson, providing it doesnt effect our draft plans at all. I would still want to grab a LB in Round 1.


Thoughts?

Damix
04-09-2007, 05:49 PM
If we grab Wilson (which I am for if its for a conditional pick next year) then we likely have Pierce-Wilson-Mitchell as our starters (Pierce WLB, Wilson MLB, Mitchell SLB) thats 3 mikes on the field, does our coverage suffer? If this happens, it makes safety more of a need.

bigbluedefense
04-09-2007, 05:53 PM
Reese is seeing if he can get any of these guys for cheap. I think its pretty clear that we will not give up a day 1 pick for any of these guys, as Reese has been holding those for dear life.

Jenkins or Wilson for a day 2 pick is ok with me. I don't like them as long term solutions, and I would view them strictly as depth purposes, and feel that we should still look at DT and LB in the draft.

I just dont like aging/injury prone players. We should stay away.

LTgiants
04-09-2007, 05:59 PM
If we grab Wilson (which I am for if its for a conditional pick next year) then we likely have Pierce-Wilson-Mitchell as our starters (Pierce WLB, Wilson MLB, Mitchell SLB) thats 3 mikes on the field, does our coverage suffer? If this happens, it makes safety more of a need.

if we were to get wilson he would be playing wlb not pierce

hugegmenfan
04-09-2007, 06:34 PM
im sorry but even tho he has injury problems, a 5th round pick for jenkins is a total steal. i mean we released our 5th round pick last year in peprah, the guy we choose wouldnt start and would most likely not make a huge impact. I think that would b a great trade

scottyboy
04-09-2007, 06:54 PM
damix- i think if we got wilson, we would fit him in on either side(wherever we feel he would best suit us) and then start Gerris for coverage purposes. Mitchell is also a pretty good cover LB, either would fit in at OLB.

trading for jenkins for a 5th or 6th would be outstanding, but i dont see it happening. He, cofield and robbins would make a great rotation and robbins, cofield and willy would be great depth at DT if jenkins happened to go down.

Damix
04-09-2007, 07:26 PM
Hm, no Wilson would play Mike, while Pierce moves to the weakside, just like every writer wrote during the trade talks.

scottyboy
04-09-2007, 07:30 PM
true, true, my bad damix. it's been a while since the whole wilson thing. I'd rather jenkins over wilson right now. We need to keep pierce at mike and build with young talent next to him.

Jughead10
04-10-2007, 07:24 AM
For two years Kris Jenkins was the best DT in the NFL. He had that one bad injury and because of it had despression problems I believe because he had to stay home and couldn't play. I would definately take a chance on him with a 4th round pick. He is only 27.

NY+Giants=NYG
04-10-2007, 12:12 PM
Marshawn Lynch RB California
51. New York Giants Marcus McCauley CB Fresno St
New York Giants Paul Williams WR Fresno St
116. New York Giants Derek Landri DT Notre Dame
153. New York Giants Daren Stone S Maine
189. New York Giants Clark Harris TE Rutgers
224. New York Giants Nick Folk KS Arizona
250. New York Giants (compensatory) Jeremy Clark DT Alabama

What do people think of this Scout.com mock draft. I think it's a piece of s.. but want to hear your opinions.

A side note, apparently we passed on Beason, Timmons, and Nelson to pick Lynch.

http://nflexperts.scout.com/3/2007MockDraft.html

Jughead10
04-10-2007, 12:13 PM
I can't imagine Landri going that high.

scottyboy
04-10-2007, 01:06 PM
i saw this on BBI and my eyes almost started to bleed- especially on who we'd be passing up

GiantRutgersFan
04-10-2007, 01:12 PM
Marshawn Lynch RB California
51. New York Giants Marcus McCauley CB Fresno St
New York Giants Paul Williams WR Fresno St
116. New York Giants Derek Landri DT Notre Dame
153. New York Giants Daren Stone S Maine
189. New York Giants Clark Harris TE Rutgers
224. New York Giants Nick Folk KS Arizona
250. New York Giants (compensatory) Jeremy Clark DT Alabama

What do people think of this Scout.com mock draft. I think it's a piece of s.. but want to hear your opinions.

A side note, apparently we passed on Beason, Timmons, and Nelson to pick Lynch.

http://nflexperts.scout.com/3/2007MockDraft.html



I would definitly pass on Timmons for Lynch. I wouldnt pass on Nelson or Beason though. and i DEFINITLY WOULDNT PASS ON ALAN BRANCH.

edit- just noticed this

160. Kansas City Quinn Pitcock




If Pitcock is available in the 3rd round, we gotta bite. Even in the second I would consider it a bit.

hugegmenfan
04-10-2007, 04:58 PM
I would definitly pass on Timmons for Lynch. I wouldnt pass on Nelson or Beason though. and i DEFINITLY WOULDNT PASS ON ALAN BRANCH.

edit- just noticed this

160. Kansas City Quinn Pitcock




If Pitcock is available in the 3rd round, we gotta bite. Even in the second I would consider it a bit.

I would def NOT pass on timmons for lynch. A HB 1st round, unless its adrian peterson who somehow falls to 20, would b a bad idea. I would not pass on beason either. Pitcock 2nd round is a bad idea. hes very small, short arms and is posied to b a poor nfl pro. 3rd round possibily for the value but 2nd round is a terrible idea.