PDA

View Full Version : Franchise QBs


simms2clayton
05-03-2007, 03:59 PM
Just thought it would be neat to lay out all 32 NFL Teams to see which ones have a "franchise QB." It is in no particular order and teams without any clear cut QB I will discuss later

AFC East
Buffalo: Looks like JP Losman is their guy after they passed on Brady Quinn. But what if he has a horrible season in 07?
Miami: They drafted John Beck in the 2nd round and tried to sneak into the first to secure him. Beck is their guy.
Patriots: Tom Brady
New York Jets: They have Chad Pennington, but if he gets injured 2006 2nd round pick Kellen Clemens will step in.
Cincinnati: Carson Palmer
Cleveland: Brady Quinn/Charlie Frye (if he plays great)
Pittsburgh: Ben Roethlisberger
Houston: Matt Schuab
Indinapolis: I forgot his name [/sarcasm]
Tennessee: Vince Young
Denver: Jay Cutler
Oakland: Jamarcus Russell
San Diego: Phillip Rivers
Dallas: Tony Romo for now but lets see after 2007
New York Giants: Eli Manning
Philadelphia: It's Donovan McNabb's job to lose
Washington Redskins: Jason Campbell
Chicago Bears: Lets give Rex Grossman another season
Detroit Lions: Drew Stanton
Minnesota Vikings: Tavarius Jackson
Atlanta Falcons: Michael Vick, but I think he is on the hot seat...if he doesn't produce next season will he ever?
New Orleans Saints: Drew Brees
Arizona Cardinals: Matt Leinart
Saint Louis Rams: Marc Bulger
San Francisco 49ers: Alex Smith
Seattle Seahawks: Matt Hasselbeck

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: A big QB battle between Chris Simms and Jeff Garcia will happen in training camp.

Carolina Panthers: Jake Delhomme/David Carr...what a QB battle this will be.

Baltimore: McNair is the starter, but this team doesn't really have someone who will carry them for the next 8-10 years and Troy Smith just isn't an NFL starter imo. This team needs to draft a QB in the first 2 rounds next year.

Kansas City: Idk if Huard really is a franchise QB...is Croyle their future?

Jacksonville: Looks like they are going to stick with Leftwich for another season after passing on Quinn at #21. But who knows? I think they will take a QB in the first round next year if Leftwich plays bad/gets injured.

Green Bay Packers: Lets see how Aaron Rodgers does in 2007...if he does anything...when will Favre retire?

Michigan
05-03-2007, 04:08 PM
Detroit Lions: Drew Stanton

I just threw up in my mouth.

cardsalltheway
05-03-2007, 04:09 PM
I don't get how you can say that Michael Vick might not be a franchise quarterback but Tavaris Jackson is? (If I read this correctly)

neko4
05-03-2007, 04:12 PM
TO answear your question...Favre will never retire
Also I think next year the Jags will take Brennan or Henne. I doubt that they'll do bad enough to get in position to take Brohm

Caddy
05-03-2007, 04:41 PM
If Chris Simms reestablishes himself ala 2005 he will once again be labeled our franchise QB.

bored of education
05-03-2007, 04:44 PM
Brodie Croyle will be MVP just you wait...lol

TouchdownUSC
05-03-2007, 04:59 PM
If JP Losman doesnt produce Buffalo always has Trent Edwards

EdReedUnstoppable
05-03-2007, 05:27 PM
If Drew Stanton, and John Beck are franchise QBs then Troy Smith is a franchise QB.

bsaza2358
05-03-2007, 05:28 PM
I think I hate this thread... Yep, I definitely do.

Splat
05-03-2007, 05:40 PM
I think if Croyle can stay on the field he will be a solid QB for the Chiefs but I'm not ready to say he will be there franchise QB. That being said the Chiefs have only had 3-4 franchise type QB's they have had many solid QB's threw the years but not to many franchise QB's.

ninerfan
05-03-2007, 05:43 PM
If Garcia beats out Simms at TB then right off the season and the short term future of that club. Simms (or next yrs draft pick) is the future at QB and the sooner they realise it the sooner they march towards success

Splat
05-03-2007, 05:52 PM
To me a franchise QB is a guy that can take him team to the SB or at least to the playoffs year in and year out. When I think franchise QB I think of guys like Brady,Manning and McNabb there is a difference between a solid QB and a franchise QB.

princefielder28
05-03-2007, 06:37 PM
Favre is eternal; he'll never retire!

I'mAHustler
05-03-2007, 06:41 PM
This thread tells me people don't realize what a franchise QB really is.

Achilles33
05-03-2007, 06:55 PM
I just threw up in my mouth.

Stanton will be the best QB from the 2007 draft.

Watchman
05-03-2007, 06:59 PM
If Chris Simms reestablishes himself ala 2005 he will once again be labeled our franchise QB.

Chris Simms has never been labeled a franchise QB, and I doubt that he ever will.

There are only a few franchise QBs in the league.

jacoblang91
05-03-2007, 07:06 PM
If Drew Stanton, and John Beck are franchise QBs then Troy Smith is a franchise QB.

I concur with that statement.

neko4
05-03-2007, 07:08 PM
Stanton will be the best QB from the 2007 draft.

I caan see that happening

neko4
05-03-2007, 07:09 PM
Chris Simms has never been labeled a franchise QB, and I doubt that he ever will.

There are only a few franchise QBs in the league.

He did an excellent job in '05. He's got a great chance

doingthisinsteadofwork
05-03-2007, 07:12 PM
How is Drew Stanton considered to be a future for the Lions when Croyle isnt considered a future for the Chiefs?

#1chiefs_fan
05-03-2007, 07:21 PM
why does everyone hate on tauvaris jackson? he didn't play spectacular but he played like any other rookie QB. If he was some 1st round pick, everyone would be saying, give him one more chance.Alex smith threw 11 int his rookie year and look at his improvement last season. All I am tryin to say is lets see how he does when the season starts and then you can make your decsion on him.

etk
05-03-2007, 09:02 PM
If Chris Simms reestablishes himself ala 2005 he will once again be labeled our franchise QB.

Chris Simms is our franchise QB. You call me a pessimist ;)?

BigDawg819
05-03-2007, 09:22 PM
If Drew Stanton, and John Beck are franchise QBs then Troy Smith is a franchise QB.

As much as it pains me to agree with this I must because the logic is sound.

Beans
05-03-2007, 09:28 PM
Simms = Future HOF

(bucs/jersey homerism ftw)

Paranoidmoonduck
05-03-2007, 09:43 PM
Being able to say that my team even has a franchise QB makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside.

Raiderz4Life
05-03-2007, 09:55 PM
I think Troy Smith could be a good QB. I think the only true Franchise QBs in this league are Brady,Manning,McNabb(may be in decline), Palmer, and maybe Hasselbeck..am i missing anyone?

post 1,000 :)

Bengals1690
05-03-2007, 10:28 PM
I think Troy Smith could be a good QB. I think the only true Franchise QBs in this league are Brady,Manning,McNabb(may be in decline), Palmer, and maybe Hasselbeck..am i missing anyone?

post 1,000 :)

get rid of hasselbeck, and you got a good list. congrats on 1000

portermvp84
05-03-2007, 10:41 PM
I figure after this season Rex will be a goner.

Ewing
05-03-2007, 11:24 PM
I think Troy Smith could be a good QB. I think the only true Franchise QBs in this league are Brady,Manning,McNabb(may be in decline), Palmer, and maybe Hasselbeck..am i missing anyone?

post 1,000 :)

Drew Brees?

RaiderNation
05-03-2007, 11:28 PM
when will Favre retire?

never...........

RaiderNation
05-03-2007, 11:29 PM
I figure after this season Rex will be a goner.

your sig is SWEET

Watchman
05-04-2007, 12:45 AM
Chris Simms is our franchise QB. You call me a pessimist ;)?

The franchise doesn't bring in every vet QB it can get its hands on if they have a franchise QB in place.

Simms was ok in 2005, but he was playing his way to the bench in 06 before he got hurt.

nobodyinparticular
05-04-2007, 01:02 AM
Just thought it would be neat to lay out all 32 NFL Teams to see which ones have a "franchise QB." It is in no particular order and teams without any clear cut QB I will discuss later

AFC East
Buffalo: Looks like JP Losman is their guy after they passed on Brady Quinn. But what if he has a horrible season in 07?
Dallas: Tony Romo for now but lets see after 2007
Washington Redskins: Jason Campbell
Chicago Bears: Lets give Rex Grossman another season
Minnesota Vikings: Tavarius Jackson
Saint Louis Rams: Marc Bulger


Depending on the course of events the 2007 season take, I wouldn't put it past any of these teams to be looking for a QB very early in the 2008 draft.

nobodyinparticular
05-04-2007, 01:05 AM
Being able to say that my team even has a franchise QB makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside.

I would say "potential franchise QB." But that's just semantics. For the first time in a while, we won't be looking to add a QB this next offseason

Paranoidmoonduck
05-04-2007, 01:44 AM
I would say "potential franchise QB." But that's just semantics. For the first time in a while, we won't be looking to add a QB this next offseason

Why must you harsh my mellow NIP?

Phrost
05-04-2007, 02:06 AM
ok

LOLLOLOLOLOLOLOLOOLOLLO

Did you not watch ANY games?

Watchman
05-04-2007, 10:55 AM
LOLLOLOLOLOLOLOLOOLOLLO

Did you not watch ANY games?

All of them, he shined in a couple and was pretty much average in the rest. He threw for 2,000 yds. 10 TDs and 7 ints in 05. That's ok.

Regardless as I said, he was playing his way to the bench in 06, and the franchise has brought in several vet QBs to compete with the supposed franchise QB they have.

Finsfan79
05-04-2007, 11:07 AM
If Drew Stanton, and John Beck are franchise QBs then Troy Smith is a franchise QB.

possibilities for all 3 to work out but beck and stanton have better tools

Finsfan79
05-04-2007, 11:08 AM
Depending on the course of events the 2007 season take, I wouldn't put it past any of these teams to be looking for a QB very early in the 2008 draft.

specially with the cowboys perhaps having 2 top 10 picks

EdReedUnstoppable
05-04-2007, 11:44 AM
possibilities for all 3 to work out but beck and stanton have better tools

The only thing Beck an Stanton have on Troy is there taller than 6 feet, Troy has just as good if not a better arm than both and he has mobility.

devinhester=R.O.Y 2006
05-04-2007, 01:07 PM
I'll do my take on the AFC starters now, and I'll do the NFC tonight.

AFC East
Buffalo - J.P. Losman = I like him and he has made strides, hopefully he can keep improving and keep his job.

Miami - John Beck = This may be a long learning curve for Beck this year if he is the starter, I think his age and maturity will help, but it may be a long year in Miami.

NY Jets - Chad Pennington = Plays very well when he is on the field, but he has been injury prone, and Kellen Clemens is waiting in the wings.

New England - Tom Brady = 3 Super Bowl rings says alot, but he is a great player who makes below average players into quality players, example...Jabar Gaffney and Reeche Caldwell.

AFC North
Baltimore - Steve McNair = I love him for his toughness, but he is also one who is injury prone, and may not have to much time left in the league. Troy Smith may get a shot there in the future.

Cincinnati - Carson Palmer = A top 5 QB in the league, has great weapons to work with in Johnson and Houshmanzadeh. They could take the next step to the elite level of the league if their teammates could stay out of trouble.

Cleveland - Brady Quinn = I think he will start at some point during the season, and he is my favorite out of the QB that were drafted, if they get some more help on the offensive side he could be a real good one in the future.

Pittsburgh - Ben Roethlisberger = I love Roethlisberger as a game manager, he did a great job with Bettis, Parker, and Ward when they one the Super Bowl two season ago. If he can bounce back from last years tough year he should be fine.

AFC South
Houston - Matt Schaub - The Texans must have seen something for a guy who has only started 2 games. If Houston doesn't solidify their O-line it coulb be a long year for Schaub. They do have the weapons for him in Andre Johnson, Owen Daniels, Ahman Green, and rookie Jacoby Jones.

Indianapolis - Peyton Manning = The best in the game today, and after winning the big one last season there is no doubt in my mind he goes down as the best quarterback to ever play the game.

Jacksonville - Byron Leftwich = Team may be going with him for the 2007 season, but after they could be looking at other options. Leftwich is an average quarterback who is injury prone, and the Jags may not be set with him for 2008.

Tennessee - Vince Young = He is just a winner, and I love that. But I think the Titans needed to bring in some help for him on the offensive side of the ball. Their is need at receiver and uncertainty in the backfield. Young can't do it all on his own right?

AFC West
Denver - Jay Cutler- I love this guy. Cutler has the weapons in Denver and has a very good offensive line. If Culter is having an off day throwing, he will be able to hand it off to one of the workhorse running backs that Denver has in its stable.

Kansas City - Damon Huard - I think it will be Huard's job until Brodie Croyle is ready, and that is just fine for KC. Huard did a great job when Trent Green was injured, and he will be a solid starter for the Chiefs for the near future. All he has to do in hand off to LJ anyway!

Oakland - JaMarcus Russell - He may not start the first game, but he will be under center before the year is over. He is hands down the best QB that was drafted last weekend. In my opinion I think he could have a Vince Young type year this year. He could actually do better since I think the weapons are there in LaMont Jordan, Justin Fargas, Ron Curry, Joey Porter, and Courtney Alexander. If Lane Kiffen can coach this team and get them to buy into his philosophy they will be greatly improved.

San Diego - Philip Rivers - He is another solid game manager. He has tons of weapons around him, and he has the deadliest weapon in LT. Rivers is a good QB, but I am not yet fully sold on him being an elite quarterback.

Here is how I rank the 16 AFC QB's:
1 - Payton Manning
2 - Tom Brady
3 - Carson Palmer
4 - Philip Rivers
5 - Vince Young
6 - Chad Pennington
7 - Ben Roethlisberger
8 - Jay Cutler
9 - Steve McNair
10 - J.P. Losman
11 - Damon Huard
12 - Byron Leftwich
13 - JaMarcus Russell
14 - Matt Schaub
15 - Brady Quinn
16 - John Beck

SuperMcGee
05-04-2007, 03:22 PM
Depending on the course of events the 2007 season take, I wouldn't put it past any of these teams to be looking for a QB very early in the 2008 draft.

IF it doesn't go great for JP this year, Trent Edwards is next in line and I don't see us going for a QB next year.

The Unseen
05-04-2007, 03:32 PM
Leftwich is in the last year of his deal, so whatever his fate is will be solely determined by this season. If he has a bad year or is injured again, he likely will not be re-signed. I think he can become a franchise QB, it just depends if he's healthy and if he raise his play to an elite level. As time goes by, I think more and more that he will never be great but merely good. With our defense, that may not be a problem, but a good quarterback usually doesn't stay good forever. Only elite quarterbacks tend to sustain a high level of play.

Shiver
05-04-2007, 03:35 PM
With our defense, that may not be a problem, but a good quarterback usually doesn't stay good forever. Only elite quarterbacks tend to sustain a high level of play.

The Aaron Brooks factor?

skinzzfan25
05-04-2007, 05:18 PM
Depending on the course of events the 2007 season take, I wouldn't put it past any of these teams to be looking for a QB very early in the 2008 draft.

Campbell looked like he could be something special last year. Every game he improved by a pretty good amount. With his first offseason as the solidified starter, and plenty of time with the offense (11/12 starters returning) 07-08 should be amazing. Saunders will make this kid shine.

devinhester=R.O.Y 2006
05-04-2007, 08:15 PM
I'll do my take on the AFC starters now, and I'll do the NFC tonight.

AFC East
Buffalo - J.P. Losman = I like him and he has made strides, hopefully he can keep improving and keep his job.

Miami - John Beck = This may be a long learning curve for Beck this year if he is the starter, I think his age and maturity will help, but it may be a long year in Miami.

NY Jets - Chad Pennington = Plays very well when he is on the field, but he has been injury prone, and Kellen Clemens is waiting in the wings.

New England - Tom Brady = 3 Super Bowl rings says alot, but he is a great player who makes below average players into quality players, example...Jabar Gaffney and Reeche Caldwell.

AFC North
Baltimore - Steve McNair = I love him for his toughness, but he is also one who is injury prone, and may not have to much time left in the league. Troy Smith may get a shot there in the future.

Cincinnati - Carson Palmer = A top 5 QB in the league, has great weapons to work with in Johnson and Houshmanzadeh. They could take the next step to the elite level of the league if their teammates could stay out of trouble.

Cleveland - Brady Quinn = I think he will start at some point during the season, and he is my favorite out of the QB that were drafted, if they get some more help on the offensive side he could be a real good one in the future.

Pittsburgh - Ben Roethlisberger = I love Roethlisberger as a game manager, he did a great job with Bettis, Parker, and Ward when they one the Super Bowl two season ago. If he can bounce back from last years tough year he should be fine.

AFC South
Houston - Matt Schaub - The Texans must have seen something for a guy who has only started 2 games. If Houston doesn't solidify their O-line it coulb be a long year for Schaub. They do have the weapons for him in Andre Johnson, Owen Daniels, Ahman Green, and rookie Jacoby Jones.

Indianapolis - Peyton Manning = The best in the game today, and after winning the big one last season there is no doubt in my mind he goes down as the best quarterback to ever play the game.

Jacksonville - Byron Leftwich = Team may be going with him for the 2007 season, but after they could be looking at other options. Leftwich is an average quarterback who is injury prone, and the Jags may not be set with him for 2008.

Tennessee - Vince Young = He is just a winner, and I love that. But I think the Titans needed to bring in some help for him on the offensive side of the ball. Their is need at receiver and uncertainty in the backfield. Young can't do it all on his own right?

AFC West
Denver - Jay Cutler- I love this guy. Cutler has the weapons in Denver and has a very good offensive line. If Culter is having an off day throwing, he will be able to hand it off to one of the workhorse running backs that Denver has in its stable.

Kansas City - Damon Huard - I think it will be Huard's job until Brodie Croyle is ready, and that is just fine for KC. Huard did a great job when Trent Green was injured, and he will be a solid starter for the Chiefs for the near future. All he has to do in hand off to LJ anyway!

Oakland - JaMarcus Russell - He may not start the first game, but he will be under center before the year is over. He is hands down the best QB that was drafted last weekend. In my opinion I think he could have a Vince Young type year this year. He could actually do better since I think the weapons are there in LaMont Jordan, Justin Fargas, Ron Curry, Joey Porter, and Courtney Alexander. If Lane Kiffen can coach this team and get them to buy into his philosophy they will be greatly improved.

San Diego - Philip Rivers - He is another solid game manager. He has tons of weapons around him, and he has the deadliest weapon in LT. Rivers is a good QB, but I am not yet fully sold on him being an elite quarterback.

Here is how I rank the 16 AFC QB's:
1 - Payton Manning
2 - Tom Brady
3 - Carson Palmer
4 - Philip Rivers
5 - Vince Young
6 - Chad Pennington
7 - Ben Roethlisberger
8 - Jay Cutler
9 - Steve McNair
10 - J.P. Losman
11 - Damon Huard
12 - Byron Leftwich
13 - JaMarcus Russell
14 - Matt Schaub
15 - Brady Quinn
16 - John Beck

Here is what I have for the NFC

NFC East
Dallas - Tony Romo = Romo had a very good start to the time he was under center for the Cowboys. Teams started to figure out Romo towards the end of the year, and it showed. However, I think that Romo will have the chance at a very good season. He has good weapons on offense with Owens, Glenn, Witten, Jones, and Barber. The Cowboys also believe they have solidified their o-line with the signing of Leonard Davis. I see a very good year for Tony Romo.

NY Giants - Eli Manning = For some reason I think that Eli will just never be able to get out of Peyton's shadow. He has weapons on offense in Burress, Toomer, and Shockey, who are all good receivers. Eli may be better suited as a game manager. He will be able to hand the ball off to Droughns and Jacobs enough during the year that he may be able to take some of the pressue off of himself. Unfortunatly, I don't think that Eli will ever become an elite level quarterback.

Philadelphia = Donovan McNabb/AJ Feeley = When McNabb is healthy he is arguably the best QB in the NFC. The problem is that McNabb has been injury prone over the past few years. McNabb has done a great job with adequate receivers over the last few seasons, with Terrell Owens being the exception. McNabb more than likely will not be 100% when the season starts, so I hope that the Eagles hand the reins to Feeley over Kolb. Feeley did an solid job when he started a few years ago when McNabb was injured. I feel that Feeley could be a quality starter given the opportunity. However, I think the Eagles would be considered very foolish to let McNabb go after this season. If McNabb comes back fully healed it will be a very good season for the Eagles.

Washington - Jason Campbell = Campbell was solid in the 7 games he started for the Skins last season. I think that with a little more experience he may turn into a very good starter in the NFL. The Redskins have many weapons in place for him including Moss, Lloyd, and Randle El at receiver, Cooley at H-back, and Portis and Betts in the backfield. Campbell has enough weapons that he only needs to be a game manager. The teams has many game breakers on the roster. Why can this team just not put it together? I see good things in Campbell's future.

NFC North
Chicago - Rex Grossman = I saw almost all of the Bears games last year, and me being a Bears fan I am not impartial to him at all. When Rex was on he was very good as we saw during the first month of the season. But when Rex was off he was good awful, as we saw in the games against New England, Miami, Minnesota, and Green Bay. Rex just doesn't seem to have it when it comes to being a starter in the NFL. The kid can play, but he is just way to sporatic in his play. In my opinion his biggest weapon, Thomas Jones, is now gone and he will rely on Cedric Benson to get the job done when he is having one of his bad games. I can't see good things in Rex's future, and I can see the teams looking for another option at QB after this year.

Detroit - John Kitna = Kitna is a solid NFL starter who has a nack at holding down the fort until the QB of the future is ready, as we saw when Kitna was in Seattle and Cincinnati. Kitna has help on offense with Kevin Jones, Roy Williams, and Calvin Johnson and I personally hope he gets the ball to Johnson alot. Kitna will be the starter until Drew Stanton is ready, which may not be until 2008. I think Kitna will be fine as the starter, but I don't see alot of success for the Lions this year.

Green Bay - Brett Favre = I have no words to describe him but iron man. He goes out there week after week after week and plays at a very high level and makes plays. He has been the cornerstone of the franchise for the last 17 years and will continue to be until he feels fit to stop, which may never happen if he has anything to say about that. Brett has two solid weapons in Driver and Jennings, but I am unsure of how Bubba Franks, Vernand Morency, and Brandon Jackson will help the offense this year. Favre will either have a great season or a terrible one. I forsee a great year for him, and I think the Pack may be able to steal one of those wild card spots.

Minnesota - Tarvaris Jackson = He is a guy that I really can't comment on because he has only started 2 games. I personally do not think he is what Minnesota needs, but Childress seems to be very high on him. Jackson still needs time to develop, and he will do so throughout this season. Jackson can be more of a game manager this year because he will be able to hand off to their two headed running attack of Chester Taylor and Adrian Peterson. I can see Sidney Rice becoming a huge part of the offense and becoming Tarvaris's top receiver.

NFC South
Atlanta - Michael Vick = Vick is hands down the best running quarterback in NFL history. However, all that runnning he does can hurt the team at some times. Vick has a good amount of weapons on offense with the likes of Dunn, Norwood, Jenkins, White, and Crumpler. The problem is that Vick likes to do it all on his own, he needs to let his teammates become involved and take some of the pressure off of him. I can't wait to see what type of offensive schemes that new head coach Bobby Petrino has whipped up for Atlanta. If Vick lets the rest of the team take some more of the workload I can see a good year for him, but if tries to do too much it will be another mediocre year.

Carolina - Jake Delhomme = Jake seems to have not been the same QB that he was when Carolina went to the Super Bowl a few seasons ago. And now that Carolina has added David Carr to the mix I think their is the possibilty of a quarterback controversy before the year is over. Delhomme needs to be a good game manager because Carolina has the weapons on offense in Steve Smith, Dwayne Jarrett, Keary Colbert, DeAngelo Williams, DeShaun Foster, and Michael Gaines. If Delhomme can manage the offense the Panthers will be fine, but if he has a rough start I can see Carr getting an opportunity.

New Orleans - Drew Brees = In my opinion Brees is the best quarterback in the NFC. Bress has had back to back terrific season the last two years, and over exceeded expectations after having surgery on his torn labrum following his final season in San Diego. Brees threw for almost 4500 yards last year, and that was done with one of the better running back tandems in the league with Reggie Bush and Deuce McAllister. The receiving corps is solid with Colston, Henderson, Copper, and Meachem. I see great things for Brees and the Saints offense this season.

Tampa Bay - Jeff Garcia = Garcia is an on/off quarterback. He is good when he has talent around him, as when he was in Philly and San Francisco. But when he doesn't have the talent his performance drops, as in Cleveland and Detroit. Tampa is a team that is still rebuilding, but does have good weapons in Cadillac Williams and an aging Mike Alstott. Garcia may have troubles with this offense, and I can see a quarterback competition with Chris Simms before the year is over.

NFC West
Arizona - Matt Leinart = Leinart will have a much better year this year for a few reasons. The first reason is the addition of Russ Grimm as offensive line coach. Grimm will coach up a line that has been the problem of th franchise for the last few years. Once the line can keep Leinart off his backside, Leinart has a plethora of weapons to choose from on offense including Boldin, Fitzgerald, Pope, James, and Patrick. The addition of Levi Brown to the O-line will also be a great step in keeping Leinart healthy. I see a very good year for Matt Leinart and the Cardinals.

San Francisco - Alex Smith = Smith has improved leaps and bounds since being selected #1 overall in the 2005 draft, most of that success can be attributed to the tutelage of Norv Turner. Turner has moved on, but Smith will be fine. The addition of Darrell Jackson should help the passing game. And the 49ers will always have Frank Gore, the NFL rushing leader from last year, to fall back on. The 49ers are a team on the rise, and I can see good thngs for Alex Smith this year.

Seattle - Matt Hasselbeck = Hasselbeck is a solid quarterback, but he seems like he may be on the downside of his career. They have lost a few weapons, but still have Deion Branch and Shaun Alexander, but they are lacking other quality receivers and a tight end. Production may be down for the Seahawks and Hasselbeck this year, and I can see one of the other teams in the West taking the division.

St.Louis - Mark Bulger = Bulger is one of the most underrated QBs in the league. Bulger puts up solid numbers with two aging receivers in Holt and Bruce, and he also has a workhorse back in Steven Jackson. Bulger and the Rams could be in for a very nice season, as long as the receivers keep producing and Jackson stays healthy.

Here is how I rank the 16 NFC QB's:
1 - Drew Brees
2 - Donovan McNabb
3 - Brett Favre
4 - Mark Bulger
5 - Tony Romo
6 - Alex Smith
7 - Eli Manning
8 - Michael Vick
9 - Matt Hasselbeck
10 - Matt Leinart
11 - Jeff Garcia
12 - Jake Delhomme
13 - John Kitna
14 - Rex Grossman
15 - Jason Campbell
16 - Tarvaris Jackson

Raiderz4Life
05-04-2007, 09:26 PM
Drew Brees?

idk...i think Brees has to prove once more he can be the man. He got off to a bit of a slow start and for right now i kinda have him borderline. He's been really good true, but not like Manning, Palmer, Brady good..know what i mean

skinzzfan25
05-04-2007, 10:16 PM
Here is how I rank the 16 NFC QB's:
1 - Drew Brees
2 - Donovan McNabb
3 - Brett Favre
4 - Mark Bulger
5 - Tony Romo
6 - Alex Smith
7 - Eli Manning
8 - Michael Vick
9 - Matt Hasselbeck
10 - Matt Leinart
11 - Jeff Garcia
12 - Jake Delhomme
13 - John Kitna
14 - Rex Grossman
15 - Jason Campbell
16 - Tarvaris Jackson

All homerism aside, how can you have Jason Campbell below Grossman, Kitna, Leinart, and Delhomme?

And what are Alex Smith and Eli doing to high?

skinzzfan25
05-04-2007, 10:24 PM
My list of NFC QBs:

1 - Drew Brees
2 - Mark Bulger
3 - Donovan McNabb
4 - Matt Hasselbeck
5 - Brett Favre

Power Gap

6 - Tony Romo
7 - Eli Manning
8 - Michael Vick
9 - Jason Campbell
10 - Jeff Garcia
11 - Alex Smith
12 - Matt Leinart

Power Gap

13 - Jake Delhomme
14 - John Kitna
15 - Rex Grossman
16 - Tarvaris Jackson

Watchman
05-04-2007, 10:25 PM
All homerism aside, how can you have Jason Campbell below Grossman, Kitna, Leinart, and Delhomme?

And what are Alex Smith and Eli doing to high?

If you are putting homerism aside you wouldn't have to ask that question.

Raiderz4Life
05-04-2007, 10:27 PM
vick is not a franchise QB not even close. Vick is like a Franchise Athlete. He plays the QB position poorly, he just has freakish athleticism to make up for it

portermvp84
05-04-2007, 11:21 PM
I'm not sold on Tavaris Jackson yet, he just doesn't seem like he is a franchise QB. I know he was only a rookie last year, and he didn't have the greatest stats. I think the Vikings will end up to draft somebody in the 2008 draft and keep Jackson as a backup at best.

devinhester=R.O.Y 2006
05-05-2007, 12:18 AM
All homerism aside, how can you have Jason Campbell below Grossman, Kitna, Leinart, and Delhomme?

And what are Alex Smith and Eli doing to high?

Where is my homerism?

I am a Bears fan and I put Grossman at #14.

doingthisinsteadofwork
05-05-2007, 01:17 AM
Oakland - JaMarcus Russell - He may not start the first game, but he will be under center before the year is over. He is hands down the best QB that was drafted last weekend. In my opinion I think he could have a Vince Young type year this year. He could actually do better since I think the weapons are there in LaMont Jordan, Justin Fargas, Ron Curry, Joey Porter, and Courtney Alexander. If Lane Kiffen can coach this team and get them to buy into his philosophy they will be greatly improved.LJ really isnt a weapon.He just dances around in the backfield.
All VY did was run the ball.Please dont compare the two.
Its Jerry not Joey.
I think you meant to say Zach Miller but you said Courtney Anderson instead.;)

devinhester=R.O.Y 2006
05-05-2007, 12:58 PM
LJ really isnt a weapon.He just dances around in the backfield.
All VY did was run the ball.Please dont compare the two.
Its Jerry not Joey.
I think you meant to say Zach Miller but you said Courtney Anderson instead.;)

I did not mean that JaMarcus Russell was going to run all over defenses, I meant that he may suprise some teams and win a few games as Vine Young did last season.

I did mean Zach Miller, that was my bad.

ChefMike
05-07-2007, 09:53 AM
I don't get how you can say that Michael Vick might not be a franchise quarterback but Tavaris Jackson is? (If I read this correctly)

Will agree with the Jackson side of the debate... but Vick is a novelty at best...I think someone should sit him down and tell him he needs to put on 15lbs and move to RB.. quite frankly if he would have done that from the get go... he might be a better runner then LT will be. The guy has moves that make you think of Barry Sanders and he is as fast if not faster then Deion was, plus he is not a small guy he could take the pounding if he put on a lil more weight... then we can start a thread about franchise RB's !!

ChefMike
05-07-2007, 09:57 AM
I think Troy Smith could be a good QB. I think the only true Franchise QBs in this league are Brady,Manning,McNabb(may be in decline), Palmer, and maybe Hasselbeck..am i missing anyone?

post 1,000 :)

Well I think the term used for Brady and Manning and McNabb would be Superstars not franchise.. those 3 can put their Teams on their backs and carry them to the Super Bowl... To me a FRANCHISE QB is someone that has the potential to be a Pro Bowler and can put up the results that gives you confidence that you wont need to draft a QB for 8-10 years.

keylime_5
05-07-2007, 10:18 AM
Being able to say that my team even has a franchise QB makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside.

Ditto. When we had Tim Couch he was supposedly our "franchise QB" but he didn't feel like it to me. For some reason I felt that he was gonna be decent at best as a pro, never good or great. Brady Quinn makes me feel like he's gonna be good or great like Carson Palmer and Donovan McNabb (or at least in his prime)

tom
05-07-2007, 10:39 AM
Teams with a Franchise QB:

New England
Cincy
Pittsburgh
Indianapolis
Tenessee
Denver
San Diego
Dallas
Philly
New York Giants
Green bay
Atlanta
New Orleans
San Francisco
Seattle
St. Louis
Arizona
Baltimore

Teams with a possible franchise qb

Buffalo
New York Jets
Cleveland
Oakland
Houston
Chicago

NIN1984
05-07-2007, 10:40 AM
I would say "potential franchise QB." But that's just semantics. For the first time in a while, we won't be looking to add a QB this next offseason

This is why Im so glad we drafted JaMarcus Russell. Next year we wont be running around looking for a QB, instead we will be building around Russell getting him help etc

Raiderz4Life
05-07-2007, 08:53 PM
Well I think the term used for Brady and Manning and McNabb would be Superstars not franchise.. those 3 can put their Teams on their backs and carry them to the Super Bowl... To me a FRANCHISE QB is someone that has the potential to be a Pro Bowler and can put up the results that gives you confidence that you wont need to draft a QB for 8-10 years.

Well Manning Brady and McNabb do/did that. They put up the results to win...theyre pro bowlers...and you dont have to draft another QB until they hit decline or retire. Unless youre talking about a young QB that is considered a "Franchise" QB and when he reaches that turns into a superstar

eacantdraft
05-08-2007, 10:01 AM
Stanton will be the best QB from the 2007 draft.


Take off the homer glasses and lay down the crack pipe please.

And I think many posters don't seem to know the difference between a starting QB and a franchise QB.

Scar
05-08-2007, 01:01 PM
Trent Edwards will take the Bills job from Losman by the start of next season.

Shiver
05-08-2007, 01:03 PM
Take off the homer glasses and lay down the crack pipe please.

And I think many posters don't seem to know the difference between a starting QB and a franchise QB.

You've said a lot of crazy things, but I wouldn't question Mike Martz' resume at developing Quarterbacks. He hasn't had any that have Stanton's pure talent level. I actually don't think what he said was so crazy.

Trent Edwards will take the Bills job from Losman by the start of next season.

Losman played very well last year. I don't understand why no one recognizes that fact. Maybe it's because no one sees Bills games all the way there in 'almost' Canada.

P-L
05-08-2007, 01:49 PM
I'm a Lions fan and I don't think that Drew Stanton will be better than JaMarcus Russell.

Shiver
05-08-2007, 01:52 PM
I'm a Lions fan and I don't think that Drew Stanton will be better than JaMarcus Russell.

But you never liked Stanton anyway.

awfullyquiet
05-08-2007, 02:25 PM
this thread is pure ridiculousness.

i don't even know where to start. probably by saying that the notion of 'franchise QB's' is capped by brett favre and his lifetime contract to the packers. i'm pretty sure he wins. that's a franchise QB. on the other end. marc bulger is still franchise QB nomenclature worthy, seeing as the rams probably won't look to upgrade from bulger for at least a few more years, and that's basically what i think the tag boils down to. not 'hey, this kid is the future, he's gonna be our franchise QB.' but, hey this guy is a solid starter who we want playing for the next five years. in that catagory, manning2, grossman, ben, delhomme, VY, cutler, leniart, et al. don't necessarly have i'm positive (barring injury) that you'll be starting in five years. but, you can say that about manning, brady, hasselbeck, brees, and palmer. right now. their consistancy over the past few years has shown with good care, these guys are worthy of the name.

Addict
05-08-2007, 02:33 PM
Teams with a Franchise QB:

New England
Cincy
Pittsburgh - Big Ben was horrible last year, although that was to be expected with the accident and all, but he's not 'franchise' quite yet
Indianapolis
Tenessee VY is what we call a 'potential franchise QB'
Denver
San Diego
Dallas - Tony Romo... yeah... I'd say 'possible franchise QB
Philly
New York Giants - sure, Eli 'Clutch' Manning, that's a franchise QB for ya!
Green bay
Atlanta
New Orleans
San Francisco - Alex Smith? you should have put this one under 'potential'
Seattle
St. Louis
Arizona - same old story potential franchise QB
Baltimore

Teams with a possible franchise qb

Buffalo
New York Jets
Cleveland
Oakland
Houston
Chicago

There's just a few things wrong with your list. Plus you didn't mention 7 (or eight, I'm too lazy to count again) teams.

awfullyquiet
05-08-2007, 02:36 PM
There's just a few things wrong with your list. Plus you didn't mention 7 (or eight, I'm too lazy to count again) teams.

that's the point. they don't have franchise quarterbacks. just merely servicable players filling a position: read: jon kitna

Addict
05-08-2007, 02:58 PM
that's the point. they don't have franchise quarterbacks. just merely servicable players filling a position: read: jon kitna

Well you could argue that they should be on the list with Possibles...

Detroit -> Stanton
Miami -> Beck
Vikes -> Jackson

Washington's nowhere to be found even though they've got Campbell under center...