Player Rankings Thread

[draftguru151]

Discuss the new rankings. Make sure to keep and clean and no responses like "they suck". Nothing wrong with disagreeing but give reasoning.

[doingthisinsteadofwork]

Sam Keller should be in the top five QB rankings.Keller>Ainge.
Zbikowskie shouldnt be the #1 S.Cant cover.

[Turtlepower]

I like Josh Barrett being in the top 5 safeties in the country, but no love to ASU center Mike Pollack?

[scottyboy]

i just think that Ray Rice should be listed in the underclassmen RB's and Courtney Green with the underclassmen Safety.

[duckseason]

I like Josh Barrett being in the top 5 safeties in the country, but no love to ASU center Mike Pollack?

I was actually just about to post about him. Just wanted to point out that he is much faster than Zbikowski and the majority of the others on that list. But I'm sure those 40 times will be refined and adjusted as the season progresses. Oh, and Scott doesn't have him as top 5 in the country. He has him as a top 5 senior.

[Pittbc7]

Zbikowski runs in the in 4.4s, he is plenty fast. He tries to overcompensate for the lack of other good players in the ND secondary.

[duckseason]

Zbikowski runs in the in 4.4s, he is plenty fast. He tries to overcompensate for the lack of other good players in the ND secondary.

Hmm. Well, he doesn't look as fast as Barrett from where I sit. Zbikowski's speed looks average to me. Barrett looks like a sub 4.4 guy. Could be wrong though.

[bearsfan_51]

Ernie Wheelwright will be a day one pick. That is all.

[soybean]

erik ainge over john david booty? puhlease. Won't matter since Booty is winning the heisman this year.

[princefielder28]

erik ainge over john david booty? puhlease. Won't matter since Booty is winning the heisman this year.

Booty's height cost him there, and Ainge's potential is much greater than Booty's.

[Turtlepower]

Hmm. Well, he doesn't look as fast as Barrett from where I sit. Zbikowski's speed looks average to me. Barrett looks like a sub 4.4 guy. Could be wrong though.

Too bad Zbikowski can't punch people out on the playing field cause that is the only thing he is truly good at. =D

[Fitzgerald11]

Sam Keller should be in the top five QB rankings.Keller>Ainge.
Zbikowskie shouldnt be the #1 S.Cant cover.

No **** on Zbikowski. If Z is the #1 safety, this has to be a very weak class of safeties.

[doingthisinsteadofwork]

Zbikowski runs in the in 4.4s, he is plenty fast. He tries to overcompensate for the lack of other good players in the ND secondary.

Id actually have to say its the S position thats the worst in NDs secondary.He cant cover to save his life which is why he'll either be a boxer or a special teams player.

[Staubach12]

I definately think Colt Brennan should be over Henne And I personally would have Sam Keller over Henne, too. I'm not a big fan of Kyle Wright at all, and I think he's too high. I would have Ali Highsmith higher. He is undersized, but in the right system, he could be a star. I would put Antoine Cason over Terrell Thomas, too. Tom Zbikowski is too high. He's not the #1 senior safety unless he can play the way he did his sophomore yeae, which I'm not too hopeful about.

[BamaFalcon59]

Disagree on...

Frank Okam- #4 overall prospect
Chad Henne- #8 overall prospect
Colt Brennan- #9 overall prospect
John Carlson- #12 overall prospect
Tom Zbikowski- #32 overall prospect/ #1 S
Yvenson Bernard- #9 runningback
Steve Justice- #6 center
Xavier Adibi- #6 outside linebacker
DJ Parker- #17 free safety

Gosder Cherilus over Barry Richardson