Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Prospect Comparison Thread

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • double postttttttttttt

    Bone Krusher, the best

    Comment


    • Originally posted by ElectricEye View Post
      That's a complete lol worthy one.
      Ugh, I am done trying to explain Taylor Mays is an excellent cover safety, I mean really I give up. People need to watch a little USC. :(

      The only thing Roy Williams and Mays have in common is that they hit hard and are first round picks.

      Bone Krusher, the best

      Comment


      • Originally posted by Malaka View Post
        Ugh, I am done trying to explain Taylor Mays is an excellent cover safety, I mean really I give up. People need to watch a little USC. :(

        The only thing Roy Williams and Mays have in common is that they hit hard and are first round picks.
        Yeah, the fifteen page threads get a little old. He'll probably get away with it, but it's total, total, total ********.

        R.I.P. Junior Seau

        Comment


        • Would like some more imput in here...

          Just a few of my own...

          Derrick Morgan - Ray Edwards
          Brandon Graham - Lamarr Woodley
          Toby Gerhart - Shonn Green (questionable)
          Bryan Bulaga - Jordan Gross (again questionable)
          Jason Pierre-Paul - Manny Lawson
          Vladamir Ducasse - Carl Nicks

          Comment


          • If anything, I think Ben Tate projects to be more like Shonn Greene than Gerhart does.

            Comment


            • Originally posted by Jakey View Post
              Would like some more imput in here...

              Just a few of my own...

              Derrick Morgan - Ray Edwards
              Brandon Graham - Lamarr Woodley
              Toby Gerhart - Shonn Green (questionable)
              Bryan Bulaga - Jordan Gross (again questionable)
              Jason Pierre-Paul - Manny Lawson
              Vladamir Ducasse - Carl Nicks
              I'd add:
              Rolando McClaiin-Carl Banks
              Russell Okung-Willie Anderson
              Taylor Mays-Steve Atwater
              CJ Spiller-Chris Johnson
              Riley Cooper-Ed McCaffery

              Comment


              • Originally posted by Bob Sanders Dreadlock View Post
                How close are Troy Polamalu and Taylor Mays as prospects? Obviously Mays has the size and speed advantage. For what its worth their stats from college are fairly similar

                Polamalu 281 tackles, 6 interceptions 17 deflections
                Mays 265 tackles, 6 interceptions 18 deflections(thru junior year)
                Where did you get your stats from? Mays had 268 tackles and 5 picks through his senior year.

                Polamalu was a 3 year starter(Mays as all 4). Polamalu was a backup as a freshman and and played in 8 games, he had 12 tackles, but blocked a punt and caused to forced fumbles(Mays caused 1 in 4 years).

                Despite not starting as a freshman, he had more tackles still, he only had 1 more pick, but he had 8 blocked punts, 7 forced fumbles(to Mays 1), and 6 sacks(to Mays 0). Oh, and he had 3 touchdowns too. I'd say Polamalu had a nice advantage as a playmaker.

                Mays is a taller laRon Landry, with lesser instincts.

                How strong is Ducasse? I hear he is fairly strong, but Nicks is a monster.
                Last edited by Saints-Tigers; 01-30-2010, 12:31 PM.
                Originally posted by SNIPER26
                fwiw, i amz deunks ofs myt ass. ilo vez drinmoinz befotre i post. wha t a hreat ideas.z.

                Comment


                • Originally posted by Babylon View Post
                  I'd add:
                  Rolando McClaiin-Carl Banks
                  Russell Okung-Willie Anderson
                  Taylor Mays-Steve Atwater
                  CJ Spiller-Chris Johnson
                  Riley Cooper-Ed McCaffery
                  No. They're both fast, that's about it. Chris Johnson is 10x more physical than Spiller. C.J. Spiller compares the most to Reggie Bush.


                  Sig by Matthew Jones

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by Cigaro View Post
                    No. They're both fast, that's about it. Chris Johnson is 10x more physical than Spiller. C.J. Spiller compares the most to Reggie Bush.
                    Like to keep the comparisons to players at a similar stage, you're probably right.

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by Cigaro View Post
                      No. They're both fast, that's about it. Chris Johnson is 10x more physical than Spiller. C.J. Spiller compares the most to Reggie Bush.
                      What? Chris Johnson is a much better comparison than Reggie Bush granted neither are perfect comparisons for Spiller. But Spiller does not dance anywhere near as much as Bush did at this point in their careers, Spiller is much tougher than Reggie Bush.

                      CJ might be 10x tougher than Spiller (questionable) but Spiller is 10x tougher than Bush (obviously IMO).

                      Bone Krusher, the best

                      Comment


                      • CJ Spiller - Felix Jones

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by TACKLE View Post
                          CJ Spiller - Felix Jones
                          Bingo! Not perfect, of course, but a good approximation of what to expect.

                          Comment


                          • I thought of these when I was thinking about who the Jags should take.

                            Derrick Morgan = Aaron Kampman
                            Brian Price = Tommie Harris

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by Unbiased View Post
                              I thought of these when I was thinking about who the Jags should take.

                              Derrick Morgan = Aaron Kampman
                              Brian Price = Tommie Harris
                              How about this...

                              Derrick Morgan = Trent Cole
                              Brian Price = Mike Patterson

                              Comment


                              • Might as well start with the Quarterbacks...

                                1) Jimmy Clausen - Jay Cutler
                                2) Sam Bradford - Trent Edwards
                                3) Colt McCoy - David Carr
                                4) Zac Robinson - Brodie Croyle
                                5) Jevan Snead - Kyle Boller
                                6) Tim Tebow - Bobby Douglass
                                7) Tony Pike - Jason Campbell
                                8) Jarrett Brown - Omar Jacobs
                                9) Dan LeFevour - Drew Stanton
                                10) Armati Edwards - Pat White
                                + Weak QB Class
                                Last edited by GoRavens; 01-30-2010, 09:03 PM.
                                GO RAVENS

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information