Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Tennessee under NCAA investigation

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    Originally posted by Cigaro View Post
    What did Corey Miller, Brandon Willis, or the parents say that contradict my conclusion? Please enlighten me. And to add, what did Corey Miller and Brandon Willis say at all? Are you pulling your info from an unstated article, as only the parent and Lattimore are quoted in the ESPN article?
    Oh I don't know specifically about Miller or Willis, but do you honestly think they're gonna say that they committed to Tennessee because of some hostesses and that they might have had sex with them? I figure since people are making baseless assumptions in this thread, I'll just go ahead and assume the Miller and Willis will say that Lattimore is misunderstood. hehe
    Credit to BoneKrusher for the Sig
    RIP themaninblack

    Comment


    • #32
      Originally posted by VoodooMonkey View Post
      Oh I don't know specifically about Miller or Willis, but do you honestly think they're gonna say that they committed to Tennessee because of some hostesses and that they might have had sex with them? I figure since people are making baseless assumptions in this thread, I'll just go ahead and assume the Miller and Willis will say that Lattimore is misunderstood. hehe
      So basically, you have nothing that contradicts my conclusion? What about the parent you said also contradicted my conclusion?

      And I'm guess you're calling my assumption baseless, so please explain how direct quotes from a player involved is not a 'base'.


      Sig by Matthew Jones

      Comment


      • #33
        Originally posted by Cigaro View Post
        So basically, you have nothing that contradicts my conclusion?
        And you have nothing to contradict mine except for your great instincts apparently.

        What about the parent you said also contradicted my conclusion?
        Willis' dad has already said that hostesses had little to no bearing on their commitment. I'll take his word for it over Lattimore's at this point considering there's zero proof at this point except for "intuition".

        And I'm guess you're calling my assumption baseless, so please explain how direct quotes from a player involved is not a 'base'.
        No, how about you explain to me how Marcus Lattimore, firstly, has any more credibility than the father of one of the other players who disagrees with Lattimore. Secondly, please explain why the comments Lattimore made suggest that the hostesses did anything other than hold up a sign at a high school game.
        Credit to BoneKrusher for the Sig
        RIP themaninblack

        Comment


        • #34
          Hostesses have been a part of UT's recruitment program for awhile and we aren't the only school that does it. Everyone wants to put UT under a microscope because Kiffin likes to talk and has had secondary recruiting violations already. Correct me if I'm wrong, but Georgia, Alabama, LSU, and Flordia all had secondary violations too.

          This really isn't a big deal. The way I understand it is that two of the players were already UT commits, and she was there waving a sign for the 3rd player. She probably introduced herself and talked to him as well, no surprise there.

          Students in Orange Pride are paid; but not by the athletic department, it comes straight from the University and its in the form of scholarship, not cash. It's part of the reason I am applying to be part of the ambassador's program next spring. The coaching staff did not arrange this either. I'm in other student groups now and if I went to a game of a recruit singing Rocky Top and telling him to come to Tennessee would that be a violation? For all we know that's all that happened, and until some concrete evidence comes up no assumptions should be made.

          No one cared about these "hostesses" when we were off the map, but now that we're headed in the right direction people want to bring UT back down. And I think its a good thing because recruits all across the nation are going to be watching ESPN and other forms of the media and see our hostesses. I guarantee that draws interest from anyone. Lacey Pearl Earps should be in the Hot Chick Thread.

          This comes straight from www.utk.edu

          Comprised of 55 of the University of Tennessee’s outstanding sophomore, junior, and senior students, the Orange Pride is a group whose primary duty is to promote The University of Tennessee—its strong academic programs, its rich traditions, and its winning athletic programs—to campus visitors and potential student athletes. Members of the Orange Pride welcome UT’s guests, serve as tour guides, and assist the Undergraduate Admissions Office with student recruitment and the campus visit program.

          Orange Pride members are committed to recruiting academic and athletic champions!
          That's clear as day, their job is to promote the University. That's what she was doing. Not a big deal.


          Comment


          • #35
            Originally posted by Hawk View Post
            Hostesses have been a part of UT's recruitment program for awhile and we aren't the only school that does it. Everyone wants to put UT under a microscope because Kiffin likes to talk and has had secondary recruiting violations already. Correct me if I'm wrong, but Georgia, Alabama, LSU, and Flordia all had secondary violations too.

            This really isn't a big deal. The way I understand it is that two of the players were already UT commits, and she was there waving a sign for the 3rd player. She probably introduced herself and talked to him as well, no surprise there.

            Students in Orange Pride are paid; but not by the athletic department, it comes straight from the University and its in the form of scholarship, not cash. It's part of the reason I am applying to be part of the ambassador's program next spring. The coaching staff did not arrange this either. I'm in other student groups now and if I went to a game of a recruit singing Rocky Top and telling him to come to Tennessee would that be a violation? For all we know that's all that happened, and until some concrete evidence comes up no assumptions should be made.

            No one cared about these "hostesses" when we were off the map, but now that we're headed in the right direction people want to bring UT back down. And I think its a good thing because recruits all across the nation are going to be watching ESPN and other forms of the media and see our hostesses. I guarantee that draws interest from anyone. Lacey Pearl Earps should be in the Hot Chick Thread.

            This comes straight from www.utk.edu



            That's clear as day, their job is to promote the University. That's what she was doing. Not a big deal.
            No! Please! Stop this mindless logic! Surely we can come to the conclusion that Tennessee is wrong in this situation even though there is no proof to support this at all. Surely they deserve the death penalty.
            Credit to BoneKrusher for the Sig
            RIP themaninblack

            Comment


            • #36
              Originally posted by VoodooMonkey View Post
              And you have nothing to contradict mine except for your great instincts apparently.
              If you're referring to your assumptions on what Willis and Miller will said, you also have nothing to bring any credibility to yours, as you admitted, so there's no reason to even attempt to contradict it...

              Originally posted by VoodooMonkey View Post
              Willis' dad has already said that hostesses had little to no bearing on their commitment. I'll take his word for it over Lattimore's at this point considering there's zero proof at this point except for "intuition".
              Originally posted by VoodooMonkey View Post
              No, how about you explain to me how Marcus Lattimore, firstly, has any more credibility than the father of one of the other players who disagrees with Lattimore.
              Please provide the link to the article you're referring to, as surely it's not this one. Why isn't it this one? Willis' dad didn't comment either way on whether the hostesses influenced his son's decision;

              Gary Willis, Brandon Willis' father, said the NCAA had interviewed his son about the hostesses' visit to the game, according to the Times. Gary Willis said the girls met his son at Tennessee's football camp last summer and told him they would be attending one of his games. He also said the trip was not arranged by Tennessee coaches or staff.
              Nope, nothing there about whether the hostesses influenced his son's decision or not. So again, please provide your link to your article.

              Originally posted by VoodooMonkey View Post
              Secondly, please explain why the comments Lattimore made suggest that the hostesses did anything other than hold up a sign at a high school game.
              Maybe I'm a crazy, but I don't think a person with a sign heavily influences a commitment, nor does it show whether they're nice and cool or not. But you're right; signs at HS games are the most effective recruiting tools, and you can completely find out if they're nice and cool by the way they wrote the sign and how they're holding.


              Sig by Matthew Jones

              Comment


              • #37
                I honestly don't believe any of the big programs recruit cleanly, its just who gets caught.

                Comment


                • #38
                  just 'cause she got your dick wet, doesnt mean you have to play there.

                  Pick the Winners Champion 2008 | 2011

                  Comment


                  • #39
                    Originally posted by Hawk View Post
                    Hostesses have been a part of UT's recruitment program for awhile and we aren't the only school that does it. Everyone wants to put UT under a microscope because Kiffin likes to talk and has had secondary recruiting violations already. Correct me if I'm wrong, but Georgia, Alabama, LSU, and Flordia all had secondary violations too.
                    Thank you, I forgot that LSU, Alabama, Georgia, Florida were directly related to whether the hostesses were or weren't violating recruiting rules.

                    Originally posted by Hawk View Post
                    This really isn't a big deal. The way I understand it is that two of the players were already UT commits, and she was there waving a sign for the 3rd player. She probably introduced herself and talked to him as well, no surprise there.
                    You left out the part where allegedly the two commitments you're referring to are as such because of a large contribution(simply talking recruiting, not accusing of anything more ATM) of the hostesses.

                    Originally posted by Hawk View Post
                    Students in Orange Pride are paid; but not by the athletic department, it comes straight from the University and its in the form of scholarship, not cash. It's part of the reason I am applying to be part of the ambassador's program next spring. The coaching staff did not arrange this either. I'm in other student groups now and if I went to a game of a recruit singing Rocky Top and telling him to come to Tennessee would that be a violation? For all we know that's all that happened, and until some concrete evidence comes up no assumptions should be made.
                    As for whether the girls were more than friends with the recruits or whether or not the coaches knew/sanctioned the meetings, yes, you're correct, no assumptions should be made. But I believe it to be completely reasonable for anyone to assume that the hostesses and recruits certainly knew each other well.

                    Originally posted by Hawk View Post
                    No one cared about these "hostesses" when we were off the map, but now that we're headed in the right direction people want to bring UT back down. And I think its a good thing because recruits all across the nation are going to be watching ESPN and other forms of the media and see our hostesses. I guarantee that draws interest from anyone. Lacey Pearl Earps should be in the Hot Chick Thread.
                    Regardless of whether you are or aren't on the map, any potential violation should be investigated, which is exactly what is happening.

                    Originally posted by Hawk View Post
                    This comes straight from www.utk.edu



                    That's clear as day, their job is to promote the University. That's what she was doing. Not a big deal.
                    If they're promotion was within the rules, you're correct, no big deal. But it's now being questioned, and so the investigation should hopefully clear up the truth of the matter.


                    Sig by Matthew Jones

                    Comment


                    • #40
                      Originally posted by JT Jag View Post
                      Please find me any proof that Alabama was ever charged with this specifically.
                      On June 11, 2009, Alabama was sanctioned over textbook-related infractions which stretched across 16 of 19 sports. Students used their athletic scholarships to improperly obtain free use of textbooks for friends. They were forced to vacate 21 wins during the Mike Shula and Nick Saban coaching eras and were put on three years probation, ending in June 2012.[105] The university stated "none of the textbooks or materials was used for profit or to get items not related to academics, and that the athletes involved who still have eligibility remaining have had to pay restitution."[106] Alabama is currently appealing the NCAA ruling.

                      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alabama...NCAA_sanctions
                      Penalties Disappoint Alabama Leaders - Scout

                      NCAA alleges Alabama committed major violations because of violations of its textbook disbursement policy - The Birmingham News

                      Alabama admits to NCAA violations over textbooks - CBS Sports

                      Alabama admitted to the violations, and even self-reported them. The NCAA sanctioned the university which included 3 years probation and vacating wins. Bama is currently appealing the sanctions.

                      Originally posted by Cigaro View Post
                      How so? I'm pretty sure Lattimore did that all by himself.

                      Now it's the biased media...
                      The media actually loves Kiffin because he's good for a quote. He obviously rubs some people the wrong way, but I don't think this is the case. I never said this was biased. I was moreso insinuating that leading the reader to a more scandalous conclusion made for a better story. It is the New York Times, after all.

                      Either way, the only link to this being a scandal is one comment made by one recruit in an unknown context. I'll wait for more information before I jump to the extreme of an inappropriate relationship/prostitution.
                      Still Team The Ke$ha!!!

                      [@TDWinstead]
                      Originally posted by MichaelJordanEberle (sabf)
                      Damn Ke$ha is sexy.

                      Comment


                      • #41
                        Originally posted by TitanHope View Post
                        The media actually loves Kiffin because he's good for a quote. He obviously rubs some people the wrong way, but I don't think this is the case. I never said this was biased. I was moreso insinuating that leading the reader to a more scandalous conclusion made for a better story. It is the New York Times, after all.

                        Either way, the only link to this being a scandal is one comment made by one recruit in an unknown context. I'll wait for more information before I jump to the extreme of an inappropriate relationship/prostitution.
                        Perhaps you could pose a context that would change the meaning of Lattimore's quotes? I really don't see how it's open to that much interpretation. Truthfully, to me, it seems like the reporter would be practically lying in order for the context to be so off base that it changed the meaning.
                        Last edited by Cigaro; 12-09-2009, 07:54 PM.


                        Sig by Matthew Jones

                        Comment


                        • #42
                          Originally posted by Cigaro View Post
                          Please provide the link to the article you're referring to, as surely it's not this one. Why isn't it this one? Willis' dad didn't comment either way on whether the hostesses influenced his son's decision
                          Buuuuuut, he did say that UT made no arrangements to send the hostesses there which is the illegal thing that the NCAA would be investigating anyways.

                          Maybe I'm a crazy, but I don't think a person with a sign heavily influences a commitment, nor does it show whether they're nice and cool or not.
                          Well, firstly we can establish that you aren't a recruit, so your opinion on whether or not the sign would influence your recruitment doesn't matter. The nice and cool thing is your opinion as well. Other people would think a college host or hostess showing up at their game and cheering for them is nice or cool.

                          But you're right; signs at HS games are the most effective recruiting tools
                          I never said that. Lattimore did say that no other school has done that and that it was crazy. I doubt he means crazy as in a bad way. That's my assumption.

                          and you can completely find out if they're nice and cool by the way they wrote the sign and how they're holding.
                          No, probably not. But if you're lattimore you could probably find that out from your teammates who have taken official visits there or if he happened to see them on his unofficial visit. I don't think it's crazy to assume that.
                          Credit to BoneKrusher for the Sig
                          RIP themaninblack

                          Comment


                          • #43
                            Originally posted by VoodooMonkey View Post
                            Buuuuuut, he did say that UT made no arrangements to send the hostesses there which is the illegal thing that the NCAA would be investigating anyways.
                            And that has absolutely nothing to do with Lattimore's comments, which you say it refuted. So again, what did his parent say that refuted Lattimore's comments?

                            To add, it has nothing to do with my conclusion either.

                            Originally posted by VoodooMonkey View Post
                            Well, firstly we can establish that you aren't a recruit, so your opinion on whether or not the sign would influence your recruitment doesn't matter.
                            So are you saying because I'm not a five star recruit, I have absolutely no idea what a five star recruit may finding influencing? Seriously? You're reaching bro.

                            Originally posted by VoodooMonkey View Post
                            The nice and cool thing is your opinion as well. Other people would think a college host or hostess showing up at their game and cheering for them is nice or cool.
                            Riiiiiiigggggghhhhhttttt. I could see the nice thing maybe, but when he said, " and just real cool", I'm pretty sure 99% of people wouldn't say that about a person they don't know. But you're right, I'm not a five star recruit, I couldn't possibly understand their completely different state of mind.

                            Originally posted by VoodooMonkey View Post
                            I never said that. Lattimore did say that no other school has done that and that it was crazy. I doubt he means crazy as in a bad way. That's my assumption.
                            Yep, it was definitely the homemade signs that separated them from other schools.

                            Originally posted by VoodooMonkey View Post
                            No, probably not. But if you're lattimore you could probably find that out from your teammates who have taken official visits there or if he happened to see them on his unofficial visit. I don't think it's crazy to assume that.
                            Yeah, because people call people that they don't know nice and cool because their friends met them. Up, oh wait, there I go again assuming I understand the different species that are five star recruits. I forgot that they don't think like normal people. My bad.


                            Sig by Matthew Jones

                            Comment


                            • #44
                              Lacey Pearl should be a paid member of the Tennessee staff. I know for a fact that she was a big part of Bryce Brown's recruitment and would not be surprised if she was involved with the Byrnes guys

                              Comment


                              • #45
                                Originally posted by Cigaro View Post
                                Perhaps you could pose a context that would change the meaning of Lattimore's quotes? I really don't see how it's open to that much interpretation.
                                It stems from him saying, "a lot." Those two words were what was quoted. The writer filled in "thinks they had ... of influence on his team mates making oral commitments." Was Lattimore like winking, nudge-nudge kind've expression when he said that. Was he joking and just making fun of his team mates being girl crazy.

                                He never said anything exact. It could mean countless things, so it's all left up to the reader's perspective. And I hate to say it, but having the word "oral" to follow his quote kind've sends a guy's mind into the gutter ("Oh yeah, I'd give an oral commitment to her anyday" kinda deal, lol). Maybe helps lead guy who isn't already thinking dirty thoughts about the notion of using hot hostesses for recruiting.

                                But yeah, that's really all I have on this topic. Just gotta wait to see if the NCAA performs a major ****-block. :D
                                Still Team The Ke$ha!!!

                                [@TDWinstead]
                                Originally posted by MichaelJordanEberle (sabf)
                                Damn Ke$ha is sexy.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information