The "He's Not That Good" Thread

[PACKmanN]

Nick Barnett, AJ Hawk, Atari Bigby. Pick one of those three.

[TACKLE]

Matthew Stafford.

[ironman4579]

People still think Ernie Sims is very good?

I have to agree with you there. He's looked basically lost for about the last two seasons really.

[stephenson86]

i cant really think of an overrated starter on the titans ermmmm, Bo Scaife most likely, he was franchised this year but hes nothing more than an average HB who could easily be replaced

[Leon Sandcastle]

Paul Posluszny and Donte Whitner.

[GBahDunka]

Antonio Pierce, he's gotten chubby which has made him really slow.

he gets beat in coverage almost every play.

[RaiderNation]

Kirk Morrison. Is a great in coverage as MLB but is just average in run defense. This might be because our dline cant eat up blocks though. If we get a decent NT, our d will be good

[ElectricEye]

James Sanders. Nobody thinks he's amazing or anything, but he's a fringe starter.

Ellis Hobbs as well. Same deal, except he's actually a starting caliber guy...just not one you should have any kind of comfort level matching up with a teams number one receiver.

[DI]

Antonio Pierce is nowhere near the same player he used to be.. Another player who was a Giant last year who people were kind of interested in free agency this year was James Butler.. he is absolutely horrible. Gets undressed in coverage all the time and will make Sinorice Moss look like Steve Smith, the Panther one

[Mr. Hero]

Antonio Pierce is nowhere near the same player he used to be.. Another player who was a Giant last year who people were kind of interested in free agency this year was James Butler.. he is absolutely horrible. Gets undressed in coverage all the time and will make Sinorice Moss look like Steve Smith, the Panther one

To be fair Butler had a really good year, I mean he didn't get burned every game in coverage and was strong against the run.

[GB12]

Nick Barnett, AJ Hawk, Atari Bigby. Pick one of those three.

If you picked AJ Hawk you are correct.

Barnett was very good his first 5 years. This past season he looked horrible at the start and then was placed on IR halfway through, but he definitely doesn't belong in this thread. I think Packer fans have gotten way too down on him.

Bigby was bothered by injuries all season long. He only started 6 games and in the ones he did start maybe 2 of them he was 100%. I'm not going to judge him on 2008. In 2007 he showed some real promise especially towards the end. Maybe put him up as an unkown still, but again he doesn't belong in this thread.

Hawk is the one that fits perfectly.

[dabears10]

Urlacher. He has gone from an Elite Linebacker to a very good one. He gets blocked out of plays has stopped making plays in the passing game.

[GBahDunka]

Urlacher. He has gone from an Elite Linebacker to a very good one. He gets blocked out of plays has stopped making plays in the passing game.

to his defense he is getting up there in age

[Woody56]

Alan Faneca

He is still good, but definately not worth what he got and could argue he was the 5th best lineman on the team last year

[no love]

Alan Faneca

He is still good, but definately not worth what he got and could argue he was the 5th best lineman on the team last year

Nate Clements. For a supposed top tier corner, he can get absolutely lit-up by smaller wrs