Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

ChiFan24's Top 10 players on each team

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • ChiFan24's Top 10 players on each team

    I was bored, and since I lack any sort of constructive hobby, this is the sort of thing I do. I posted something like this last year, and all things considered, it wasn't terrible. I tried to think in terms of VORP, though that may be a bit inconsistent with how it turned out.

    Let me know how I did on your team; I wasn't entirely sure on most of these:

    Patriots
    01. Tom Brady, QB
    02. Randy Moss, WR
    03. Vince Wilfork, NT
    04. Richard Seymour, DE
    05. Ty Warren, DE
    06. Wes Welker, WR
    07. Adalius Thomas, LB
    08. Jerod Mayo, LB
    09. Logan Mankins, OG
    10. Dan Koppen, C

    Bills
    01. Lee Evans, WR
    02. Terrell Owens, WR
    03. Terrence McGee, CB/RS
    04. Marshawn Lynch, RB
    05. Marcus Stroud, DT
    06. Kawika Mitchell, SLB
    07. Donte Whitner, S
    08. Aaron Schobel, DE
    09. Langston Walker, OT
    10. Leodis McKelvin, CB/RS
    Rookies: Eric Wood, Andy Levitre

    Jets
    01. Darrelle Revis, CB
    02. Kris Jenkins, NT
    03. Nick Mangold, C
    04. Calvin Pace, OLB
    05. David Harris, ILB
    06. Bart Scott, ILB
    07. Kerry Rhodes, S
    08. Thomas Jones, RB
    09. Alan Faneca, OG
    10. Leon Washington, RS/RB

    Dolphins
    01. Ronnie Brown, RB
    02. Jake Long, OT
    03. Joey Porter, OLB
    04. Phillip Merling, DE
    05. Yeremiah Bell, S
    06. Channing Crowder, ILB
    07. Kendall Langford, DE
    08. Vernon Carey, OT
    09. Chad Pennington, QB
    10. Will Allen, CB

    Steelers
    01. Ben Roethlisberger, QB
    02. James Harrison, OLB
    03. Troy Polamalu, S
    04. Lamarr Woodley, OLB
    05. Casey Hampton, NT
    06. Hines Ward, WR
    07. Ike Taylor, CB
    08. James Farrior, ILB
    09. Santonio Holmes, WR
    10. Aaron Smith, DE

    Bengals
    01. Carson Palmer, QB
    02. Jonathan Joseph, CB
    03. Chad Johnson, WR
    04. Keith Rivers, WLB
    05. Leon Hall, CB
    06. Laveranues Coles, WR
    07. Domata Peko, DT
    08. Andrew Whitworth, OG
    09. Chinedum Ndukwe, S
    10. Robert Geathers, DE
    Rookies: Andre Smith, Rey Maualuga

    Browns
    01. Joe Thomas, OT
    02. Shaun Rogers, NT
    03. Braylon Edwards, WR
    04. Eric Steinbach, OG
    05. D’Qwell Jackson, ILB
    06. Eric Wright, CB
    07. Corey Williams, DE
    08. Brandon McDonald, CB
    09. Brodney Pool, S
    10. Kamerion Wimbley, OLB
    Rookies: Alex Mack

    Ravens
    01. Ed Reed, S
    02. Ray Lewis, ILB
    03. Haloti Ngata. DE/NT
    04. Terrell Suggs, OLB
    05. Kelly Gregg, NT
    06. Derrick Mason, WR
    07. Trevor Pryce, DE
    08. Fabian Washington, CB
    09. Le’Ron McClain, FB
    10. Jared Gaither, OT

    Colts
    01. Peyton Manning, QB
    02. Bob Sanders, S
    03. Reggie Wayne, WR
    04. Dwight Freeny, DE
    05. Dallas Clark, TE
    06. Kelvin Hayden, CB
    07. Antoine Bethea, S
    08. Robert Mathis, DE
    09. Jeff Saturday, C
    10. Joseph Addai, RB

    Titans
    01. Michael Roos, OT
    02. Courtland Finnegan, CB
    03. Chris Johnson, RB
    04. Michael Griffin, FS
    05. Kyle Vanden Bosch, DE
    06. Chris Hope, SS
    07. David Stewart, OT
    08. Kevin Mawae, C
    09. Keith Bullock, WLB
    10. Jacob Ford, DE

    Jaguars
    01. Maurice Jones Drew, RB
    02. John Henderson, DT
    03. Rashean Mathis, CB
    04. Daryl Smith, WLB
    05. Justin Durant, MLB
    06. Torry Holt, WR
    07. Vincent Manuwai, OG
    08. Brad Meester, C
    09. Brian Williams, CB
    10. David Garrard, QB
    Rookies: Eugene Monroe

    Texans
    01. Andre Johnson, WR
    02. Mario Williams, DE
    03. Demeco Ryans, MLB
    04. Dunta Robinson, CB
    05. Steve Slaton, RB
    06. Owen Daniels, TE
    07. Matt Schaub, QB
    08. Amobi Okoye, DT
    09. Eric Winston, OT
    10. Antonio Smith, DE
    Rookies: Brian Cushing

    Chargers
    01. Phillip Rivers, QB
    02. Antonio Gates, TE
    03. Marcus McNeill, OT
    04. Luis Castillo, DE
    05. Shawne Merriman, OLB
    06. Quentin Jammer, CB
    07. Jamal Williams, NT
    08. LaDainian Tomlinson, RB
    09. Nick Hardwick, C
    10. Vincent Jackson, WR

    Broncos
    01. Brandon Marshall, WR
    02. Ryan Clady, OT
    03. Champ Bailey, CB
    04. Brian Dawkins, S
    05. Eddie Royal, WR
    06. D.J. Williams, ILB
    07. Ryan Harris, OT
    08. Elvis Dumervil, OLB
    09. Casey Weigman, C
    10. Tony Scheffler, TE
    Rookies: Knowshon Moreno, Robert Ayers

    Chiefs
    01. Brandon Flowers, CB
    02. Dwayne Bowe, WR
    03. Derrick Johnson, ILB
    04. Glenn Dorsey, DE/DT
    05. Matt Cassel, QB
    06. Jarrad Page, S
    07. Larry Johnson, RB
    08. Brandon Albert, OT
    09. Mike Vrabel, OLB
    10. Bernard Pollard, S
    Rookies: Tyson Jackson

    Raiders
    01. Nnamdi Asomugha, CB
    02. Thomas Howard, WLB
    03. Chris Johnson, CB
    04. Kirk Morrison, MLB
    05. Derrick Burgess, DE
    06. Zach Miller, TE
    07. Johnnie Lee Higgins, RS/WR
    08. Darren McFadden, RB
    09. Stanford Routt, CB
    10. Tommy Kelly, DT

    Eagles
    01. Donovan McNabb, QB
    02. Brian Westbrook, RB
    03. Asante Samuel, CB
    04. Jason Peters, OT
    05. Shawn Andrews, OG/OT
    06. Broderick Bunkley, DT
    07. Trent Cole, DE
    08. Stewart Bradley, MLB
    09. Desean Jackson, WR/RS
    10. Quintin Mikell, SS

    Giants
    01. Justin Tuck, DE
    02. Osi Umenyiora, DE
    03. Eli Manning, QB
    04. Corey Webster, CB
    05. Brandon Jacobs, RB
    06. Michael Boley, WLB
    07. Mathias Kiwanuka, DE
    08. Chris Snee, OG
    09. Shaun O’Hara, C
    10. David Diehl, OT

    Cowboys
    01. DeMarcus Ware, OLB
    02. Jason Witten, TE
    03. Tony Romo, QB
    04. Terrance Newman, CB
    05. Jay Ratliff, NT
    06. Bradie James, ILB
    07. Roy Williams, WR
    08. Marion Barber, RB
    09. Greg Ellis, OLB
    10. Ken Hamlin, S

    Redskins
    01. Albert Haynesworth, DT
    02. Clinton Portis, RB
    03. Carlos Rogers, CB
    04. Laron Landry, S
    05. Chris Cooley, TE
    06. DeAngelo Hall, CB
    07. Chris Samuels, OT
    08. Santana Moss, WR
    09. London Fletcher, MLB
    10. Rocky McIntosh, WLB
    Rookies: Brian Orakpo, SLB

    Bears
    01. Jay Cutler, QB
    02. Lance Briggs, WLB
    03. Brian Urlacher, MLB
    04. Matt Forte, RB
    05. Tommie Harris, DT
    06. Devin Hester, RS/WR
    07. Charles Tillman, CB
    08. Greg Olsen, TE
    09. Olin Kreutz, C
    10. Orlando Pace, OT

    Vikings
    01. Adrian Peterson, RB
    02. Kevin Williams, DT
    03. Jared Allen, DE
    04. Pat Williams, DT
    05. E.J. Henderson, MLB
    06. Antoine Winfield, CB
    07. Chad Greenway, WLB
    07. Steve Hutchinson, OG
    09. Bryant McKinnie, OT
    10. Bernard Berrian, WR

    Packers
    01. Charles Woodson, CB
    02. Greg Jennings, WR
    03. Aaron Rodgers, QB
    04. Aaron Kampman, DE/OLB
    05. Al Harris, CB
    06. Nick Barnett, ILB
    07. Nick Collins, S
    08. A.J. Hawk, ILB
    09. Donald Driver, WR
    10. Ryan Grant, RB
    Rookies: B.J. Raji, Clay Matthews

    Lions
    01. Calvin Johnson, WR
    02. Ernie Sims, WLB
    03. Julian Peterson, SLB
    04. Kevin Smith, RB
    05. Phillip Buchanon, CB
    06. Anthony Henry, CB
    07. Cliff Avril, DE
    08. Dewayne White, DE
    09. Dominic Raiola, C
    10. Larry Foote, MLB
    Rookies: Brandon Pettigrew, Louis Delmas

    Falcons
    01. Michael Turner, RB
    02. Tony Gonzalez, TE
    03. John Abraham, DE
    04. Roddy White, WR
    05. Matt Ryan, QB
    06. Jonathan Babineaux, DT
    07. Curtis Lofton, MLB
    08. Justin Blalock, OG
    09. Chris Houston, CB
    10. Erik Coleman, S
    Rookies: Peria Jerry

    Saints
    01. Drew Brees, QB
    02. Jonathan Vilma, MLB
    03. Marques Colston, WR
    04. Jahri Evans, OG
    05. Jammal Brown, OT
    06. Reggie Bush, RS/RB
    07. Jeremy Shockey, TE
    08. Lance Moore, WR
    09. Roman Harper, S
    10. Will Smith, DE
    Rookies: Malcolm Jenkins

    Panthers
    01. Steve Smith, WR
    02. DeAngelo Williams, RB
    03. Julius Peppers, DE
    04. Jordan Gross, OT
    05. Jon Beason, MLB
    06. Chris Gamble, CB
    07. Chris Harris, SS
    08. Jonathan Stewart, RB
    09. Jeff Otah, OT
    10. Richard Marshall, CB

    Buccaneers
    01. Barrett Ruud, MLB
    02. Antonio Bryant, WR
    03. Kellen Winslow, TE
    04. Gaines Adams, DE
    05. Davin Joseph, OG
    06. Tanard Jackson, S
    07. Arron Sears, OG
    08. Angelo Crowell, WLB
    09. Derrick Ward, RB
    10. Earnest Graham, RB

    Cardinals
    01. Larry Fitzgerald, WR
    02. Anquan Boldin, WR
    03. Darnell Dockett, DE/DT
    04. Karlos Dansby, LB
    05. Kurt Warner, QB
    06. Adrian Wilson, SS
    07. Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie, CB
    08. Levi Brown, OT
    09. Bryant McFadden, CB
    10. Chike Okeafor, DE/OLB
    Rookies: Chris Wells

    Seahawks
    01. Lofa Tatapu, MLB
    02. Marcus Trufant, CB
    03. T.J. Houshmandzadeh, WR
    04. Leroy Hill, WLB
    05. Walter Jones, OT
    06. Patrick Kerney, DE
    07. Brandon Mebane, DT
    08. Matt Hasselbeck, QB
    09. Sean Locklear, OT
    10. Cory Redding, DE/DT
    Rookies: Aaron Curry

    49ers
    01. Patrick Willis, ILB
    02. Frank Gore, RB
    03. Nate Clement, CB
    04. Eric Heitman, C
    05. Justin Smith, DE
    06. Joe Staley, OT
    07. Takeo Spikes, ILB
    08. Parys Haralson, OLB
    09. Walt Harris, CB
    10. Isaac Bruce, WR
    Rookies: Michael Crabtree

    Rams
    01. Steven Jackson, RB
    02. Ronald Bartell, CB
    03. Will Witherspoon, WLB
    04. Jason Brown, C
    05. O.J. Atogwe, S
    06. Adam Carriker, DT
    07. Chris Long, DE
    08. Donnie Avery, WR
    09. Jake Bell, OG
    10. Leonard Little DE
    Rookies: Jason Smith, James Laurinaitis

  • #2
    Originally posted by ChiFan24 View Post
    Cardinals
    01. Larry Fitzgerald, WR
    02. Anquan Boldin, WR
    03. Darnell Dockett, DE/DT
    04. Karlos Dansby, LB
    05. Kurt Warner, QB
    06. Adrian Wilson, SS
    07. Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie, CB
    08. Levi Brown, OT
    09. Bryant McFadden, CB
    10. Chike Okeafor, DE/OLB
    Rookies: Chris Wells
    I'd move Wilson higher #2 or #3, just bumping everyone else down, and I would put Steve Breaston, Gabe Watson, Reggie Wells, Tim Hightower, Gerald Hayes and Matt Leinart ahead of Chike

    but good work overall

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by ChiFan24 View Post
      Panthers
      01. Steve Smith, WR
      02. DeAngelo Williams, RB
      03. Julius Peppers, DE
      04. Jordan Gross, OT
      05. Jon Beason, MLB
      06. Chris Gamble, CB
      07. Chris Harris, SS
      08. Jonathan Stewart, RB
      09. Jeff Otah, OT
      10. Richard Marshall, CB
      Switch out Marshall for Kalil and then switch him with Chris Harris.

      1. Steve Smith
      2. DeAngelo Williams
      3. Julius Peppers
      4. Jordan Gross
      5. John Beason
      6. Chris Gamble
      7. Ryan Kalil
      8. Johnathan Stewart
      9. Jeff Otah
      10. Chris Harris

      Comment


      • #4
        STEELERS:

        1: Lamarr Woodley
        2: Lamarr Woodley
        3: Lamarr Woodley
        4: Big Ben
        5: Troy Polamalu
        6: James Harrison
        7: Santonio Holmes
        8: Lawrence Timmons
        9: Aaron Smith
        10: Ike Taylor

        Maybe abit oddball...but in terms of current skill, i'd say its about right. In reallity, i'd put Woodley just behind Harrison.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by ChiFan24 View Post

          Lions
          01. Calvin Johnson, WR
          02. Ernie Sims, WLB
          03. Julian Peterson, SLB
          04. Kevin Smith, RB
          05. Phillip Buchanon, CB
          06. Anthony Henry, CB
          07. Cliff Avril, DE
          08. Dewayne White, DE
          09. Dominic Raiola, C
          10. Larry Foote, MLB
          Rookies: Brandon Pettigrew, Louis Delmas
          Looks about right. Not as high on Henry, and if you included rookies I'd definitely include Pettigrew on the list. Jason Hanson should be on there too.

          my list:
          1. Calvin Johnson, WR
          2. Jason Hanson, K
          3. Julian Peterson, LB
          4. Ernie Sims, LB
          5. Kevin Smith, RB
          6. Dominic Raiola, C
          7. Dwayne White, DE
          8. Cliff Avril, DE
          9. Brandon Pettigrew, TE
          10. Phillip Buchanon, CB
          Last edited by Michigan; 05-07-2009, 12:05 PM.
          I'm a state.

          Comment


          • #6
            I don't really know what this list achieves, but Crowell is not one of Tampa Bays 10 best players.

            Comment


            • #7
              Wilson should be higher on the Cards' list and Okeafor should not be on there at all, but overall it was a very good list.

              My Top 10 list for the Cards:
              1. Larry Fitzgerald
              2. Anquan Boldin
              3. Adrian Wilson
              4. Darnell Dockett
              5. Karlos Dansby
              6. Kurt Warner
              7. Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie
              8. Levi Brown
              9. Bryant McFadden
              10. Gabe Watson

              BoneKrusher

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by ChiFan24 View Post
                Steelers
                01. Ben Roethlisberger, QB
                02. James Harrison, OLB
                03. Troy Polamalu, S
                04. Lamarr Woodley, OLB
                05. Casey Hampton, NT
                06. Hines Ward, WR
                07. Ike Taylor, CB
                08. James Farrior, ILB
                09. Santonio Holmes, WR
                10. Aaron Smith, DE
                I would do it this way.

                01. Ben Roethlisberger, QB
                02. Troy Polamalu, S
                03. Aaron Smith, DE
                04. James Harrison, OLB
                05. Lamaar Woodley, OLB
                06. Ike Taylor, CB
                07. James Farrior, MLB
                08. Casey Hampton, NT
                09. Hines Ward, WR
                10. Heath Miller, TE


                Silverback....still the best.

                +rep to Jakey for the sig

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by ChiFan24 View Post
                  Chiefs
                  01. Brandon Flowers, CB
                  02. Dwayne Bowe, WR
                  03. Derrick Johnson, ILB
                  04. Glenn Dorsey, DE/DT
                  05. Matt Cassel, QB
                  06. Jarrad Page, S
                  07. Larry Johnson, RB
                  08. Brandon Albert, OT
                  09. Mike Vrabel, OLB
                  10. Bernard Pollard, S
                  Rookies: Tyson Jackson
                  Bernard Pollard should not be on the list and Brain Waters should be I'm not going to even start with the order.:)

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Chargers
                    01. Phillip Rivers, QB
                    02. Antonio Gates, TE
                    03. Marcus McNeill, OT
                    04. Luis Castillo, DE
                    05. Shawne Merriman, OLB
                    06. Quentin Jammer, CB
                    07. Jamal Williams, NT
                    08. LaDainian Tomlinson, RB
                    09. Nick Hardwick, C
                    10. Vincent Jackson, WR
                    Hm not the greatest order.

                    1. Rivers
                    2. Merriman
                    3. Jamal Williams
                    4. Tomlinson (this hurts me, but not as much as 8
                    5. Gates
                    6. Jammer
                    7. Jackson
                    8. Dielman
                    9. McNeill
                    10. Castillo

                    Floating around in here somewhere too is a healthy Chris Chambers.
                    Last edited by CC.SD; 05-07-2009, 10:26 AM.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      For the pats i would have the top 4 the same but i would put welker above warren and would have merriweather on the list instead of koppen. A few comments about it all would be aaron smith is way too low and imagine if the vikings had a qb. Winfield, Greenway and Hutchinson at 5 6 and 7. Thats impressive


                      BoneKrusher killing it with the sig

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        01. Maurice Jones Drew, RB
                        02. John Henderson, DT
                        03. Rashean Mathis, CB
                        04. Daryl Smith, WLB
                        05. Justin Durant, MLB
                        06. Torry Holt, WR
                        07. Vincent Manuwai, OG
                        08. Brad Meester, C
                        09. Brian Williams, CB
                        10. David Garrard, QB
                        Rookies: Eugene Monroe
                        John Henderson is too high. I'd replace Brian Williams or Justin Durant with Greg Jones - he's a Pro Bowl caliber FB. I'd move up Manuwai.

                        Good list overall, though. Why did you put rookies on some teams and not on others?

                        by BoneKrusher
                        <DG> how metal unseen
                        <TheUnseen> Drunken Canadian Bastard: There's an APS for that

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Packers
                          01. Charles Woodson, CB
                          02. Greg Jennings, WR
                          03. Aaron Rodgers, QB
                          04. Aaron Kampman, DE/OLB
                          05. Al Harris, CB
                          06. Nick Barnett, ILB
                          07. Nick Collins, S
                          08. A.J. Hawk, ILB
                          09. Donald Driver, WR
                          10. Ryan Grant, RB
                          Al Harris is far too high and at this point in his career I don't think he's a Top 10 player on the team. I think you could place a healthy Cullen Jenkins in the Top 10.


                          Follow me on Twitter! http://twitter.com/#!/aMo_Captain

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            For the Colts:

                            1. Peyton Manning (QB)
                            2. Bob Sanders (SS)
                            3. Dwight Freeney (DE)
                            4. Reggie Wayne (WR)
                            5. Robert Mathis (DE)
                            6. Dallas Clark (TE)
                            7. Joseph Addai (RB)
                            8. Kelvin Hayden (CB)
                            9. Jeff Saturday (OC)
                            10. Marlin Jackson (CB)

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Greg Ellis is NOT top ten on our team. Bradie James gets there on leadership only, i'd rather have put Leonard Davis and Marc Colombo/Andre Gurode.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X

                              Debug Information