If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
carson palmer can talk to someone about top five when he plays more than one complete game. curt warner can piss off, as he's not, afaik, an actual nfl quarterback.
Yah, as a Bengals fan I might be tempted to put Palmer in top 5 after last game if I was a super homer, but realistically he hasn't played at a top 5 level in 2-3 years now and needs to put together an elite season to get back there.
Anyways, I think we've ranked the top 5 QB's enough this off season that we could wait till next off season to do it :)
After this you could slot in a bunch of guys....A-Rod, Rivers, Roethlisberger etc.
Personally I'd put Rodgers 4th right now but that could be my homerism. The guy is legit though. If he takes this team deep in the playoffs this year all of a sudden everyone will have him ranked 4th.
Rivers was the league leader last year in touchdowns and passer rating with 4000+ yards. 34/11. This year he is on pace to do even better. Rodgers is good but I don't think there's even an argument. He hasn't been around long enough (to do things like win playoff games, or go to them) and the O-line is a weak argument because Rivers' O-line is also completely awful.