Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Rank the NFC South and their likely records

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Rank the NFC South and their likely records

    I'm going to be a risk taker with these records.

    Atlanta Falcons - 10-6
    New Orleans Saints - 10-6
    Tampa Bay Buccaneers - 8-8
    Carolina Panthers - 7-9

    Hoo-rah.

  • #2
    Tampa Bay - 10-6
    New Orleans - 10-6
    Carolina - 8-8
    Atlanta - 5-11

    sig by BoneKrusher

    Comment


    • #3
      1. Saints - 11-5
      2. Falcons - 8-8
      3. Panthers - 7-9
      4. Buccaneers - 5-11
      The Poster Formerly Known As #1SaintsFan

      Sig by jkpigskin

      Comment


      • #4
        Explain your Bucs pick SaintsFan. If we get CJ we will be far from 5-11. The Falcons are not the 2nd best team in the division either.

        sig by BoneKrusher

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by etk View Post
          Explain your Bucs pick SaintsFan. If we get CJ we will be far from 5-11. The Falcons are not the 2nd best team in the division either.
          Don't kid yourself. The Bucs are not a good team at all, and there isn't one single player in the draft that will change that. Your Offensive and Defensive Lines are weak, and your "key players" (Garcia, Brooks, Barber, Quarles, Galloway, Rice) are all entering the twilight of their careers. I'm not sold on any of your offensive players other than Cadillac (and he can't do much behind that weak line), and that once dominant D just doesn't have it anymore. A rookie WR will not change a 4-12 team to 10-6, and they haven't made any significant upgrades over last year's team yet. Jeff Garcia had MUCH more talent surrounding him in Philly, so don't be surprised if and when you get the Detroit or Cleveland version of Garcia.

          The Falcons and Panthers should battle it out for #2, so how can you say they aren't the #2 team in the division?
          The Poster Formerly Known As #1SaintsFan

          Sig by jkpigskin

          Comment


          • #6
            I think the Bucs line is better than you make it out to be. Petitgout is an upgrade at LT, Trueblood/Joseph will have gotten more experience, and Davis likely slides inside, allowing them to better run the ball. Could use another interior lineman perhaps, but history has shown they can be found later. A pickup of, say, Satele or Fry inside at center, with Joseph/Davis at guard, and Petitgout/Trueblood looks like a solid starting 5 to me. An improved running game should help the passing game.

            Not sayiing the Bucs will do anything great this year, as this is the Saints division to lose as of right now, but I think their line is better than you make it sound.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by TPFKA#1SaintsFan View Post
              1. Saints - 11-5
              2. Falcons - 8-8
              3. Panthers - 7-9
              4. Buccaneers - 5-11

              This I agree with at this moment.

              Comment


              • #8
                We have our share of problems, but Gruden is a good coach and he will focus on our key pieces. Simms will be back to his 05 form and so will Cadillac behind an improved and more experienced line. CJ will be a much-needed playmaker. Our defensive line will be brutal I expect, but hopefully Simeon can have another pro-bowl caliber season. Barrett Ruud is stepping in at LB and he is a budding young star, so LB should be a strength with Nece entering his prime and Brooks still in top-shape (age is becoming a problem though). Ronde is getting older, but Phillip Buchanon will get a chance to learn the system this year and use his talents to start over Kelly. Our safeties are entering their prime so they should improve.

                All of this adds up to a playoff contender at the very least, and I can't see our record being lower than 7-9. The Falcons have a ton of weaknesses and are having a bad offseason IMO, so I think they are a lock to finish last in our division. Carolina is not as talented as usual this year, but they could surprise as always.

                sig by BoneKrusher

                Comment


                • #9
                  Sains 10-6
                  Bucs 8-8
                  Falcons 6-10
                  Panthers 5-11 i hate jake and he's gonna sux next year

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Odd, I thought I had posted my "as of now" order ...

                    Anyhow

                    1. Saints - It's their division to lose. They've had a very solid offseason so far acquiring leadership, taking good gambles, and improving key aspects of the team. A good draft, and they could set themselves pretty for the short and long term. Expected win range as of now: 10-12.

                    2. Panthers - It's a make or break year, but if they are healthy on the OL, the entire team should be better. Another receiving option (or 2) is needed, so we'll see how that goes. Defensively, they need some help at safety. I think their corners will rebound. It'll be interesting to see if a DL addition is added, and LB, as usual, could use some more work still. Expected win range as of now: 6-9.

                    3. Falcons - Very close with the Panthers, but I'm concerned about the defense. The trenches should be a big concern on either side, especially the defense, with Grady Jackson coming off surgery. Offensively, how fast they adapt to Petrino's schemes will determine how well they do. Expected win range as of now: 6-9.

                    4. Buccaneers - Make or break season for this leadership, so expect them to go full bore. A nice complement of picks will help. The improved offensive line should help protect whoever the QB is. Best guess as of now is the veteran Jeff Garcia. The power run game should be able to get going. They need another key receiving option. Defensive concerns are littered everywhere, especially up front. Can they build a solid enough unit? It's possible, and with extra picks, they can, at the very least, add to the depth. I have a similar win range, as of now, to the other two squads: 6-8.

                    Tis early, and changes will happen and could shake up the order somewhat.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by toonsterwu View Post
                      I think the Bucs line is better than you make it out to be. Petitgout is an upgrade at LT, Trueblood/Joseph will have gotten more experience, and Davis likely slides inside, allowing them to better run the ball. Could use another interior lineman perhaps, but history has shown they can be found later. A pickup of, say, Satele or Fry inside at center, with Joseph/Davis at guard, and Petitgout/Trueblood looks like a solid starting 5 to me. An improved running game should help the passing game.

                      Not sayiing the Bucs will do anything great this year, as this is the Saints division to lose as of right now, but I think their line is better than you make it sound.
                      Eh, the right side of the line has good upside in Joseph & Trueblood, but the rest of the line is still pretty weak if you ask me. Petitgout is average. Davis has been incredibly inconsistent, and Wade is way past his best days. The O-Line has been Tampa's main weakness for a few years now, and even if it performs slightly better next season, it's still far from "good."

                      The main thing is that this is an aging team, big time, and is about to have to enter a rebuilding process.
                      The Poster Formerly Known As #1SaintsFan

                      Sig by jkpigskin

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        We are only entering a rebuilding process on defense, and not at all positions either. Don't get your hopes up, the Bucs will not be an easy out for the Saints and we are not a cakewalk rebuilding team. We still have key young pieces and we are about to draft more.

                        sig by BoneKrusher

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by etk View Post
                          We have our share of problems, but Gruden is a good coach and he will focus on our key pieces. Simms will be back to his 05 form and so will Cadillac behind an improved and more experienced line. CJ will be a much-needed playmaker. Our defensive line will be brutal I expect, but hopefully Simeon can have another pro-bowl caliber season. Barrett Ruud is stepping in at LB and he is a budding young star, so LB should be a strength with Nece entering his prime and Brooks still in top-shape (age is becoming a problem though). Ronde is getting older, but Phillip Buchanon will get a chance to learn the system this year and use his talents to start over Kelly. Our safeties are entering their prime so they should improve.

                          All of this adds up to a playoff contender at the very least, and I can't see our record being lower than 7-9. The Falcons have a ton of weaknesses and are having a bad offseason IMO, so I think they are a lock to finish last in our division. Carolina is not as talented as usual this year, but they could surprise as always.
                          This post was humorous to me. It's littered with optimism, and speculative assumptions. If I wanted to post two paragraphs as to why each player on the Falcons would have their 'best individual seasons ever,' and other conjecture about the team, I could do so easily. The post reached new levels of absurdity when you state your opinion that the Falcons "are a lock to finish last in our division." When all the facts led me to believe that the Saints were likewise going to struggle last year. I was wrong about that, and I admitted such. No team in the NFL is a "lock" for anything.
                          Last edited by Shiver; 03-12-2007, 02:39 PM.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            i tihnk the falcons might have a huge year and they have the opportunity to select who they want to in the draft. i think the falcons will win this division. if vick plays well...

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              1. Saints (11-5)
                              2. Panthers (9-7)
                              3. Falcons (8-8)
                              4. Buccaneers (6-10)

                              BoneKrusher

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X

                              Debug Information