Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Helmet to Helmet Hits

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by Mr. Goosemahn View Post
    Were they talking about that same Mendenhall hit? I didn't read those posts.
    C'mon Goose. How would it be that hit being talked about two weeks ago?? You are better than that. :)


    Silverback....still the best.

    +rep to Jakey for the sig

    Comment


    • Originally posted by terribletowel39 View Post
      C'mon Goose. How would it be that hit being talked about two weeks ago?? You are better than that. :)
      Lol, that was actually the reason I asked.

      edit: but I am better than that :P
      Last edited by Mr. Goosemahn; 10-20-2010, 09:23 PM.

      Props to clover_jeez!

      Comment


      • Good article, IMO.

        http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/news;_yl...=lc-hits102010

        Props to clover_jeez!

        Comment


        • Originally posted by wonderbredd24 View Post
          Personally, I think if they removed the Polian rule, there'd be less zone, more man coverage, and less opportunities for these type of hits.
          This is a very underrated factor in all this. The current style of coverage in the NFL is not very conducive to the health of the guys trying to catch the ball.

          R.I.P. Junior Seau

          Comment


          • i wonder are people against the rule or against the suspensions?
            It's a bit of both. The problem I have is that they seem to be making the rules up as they go. I've still found no one or anywhere in the rules that would make Robinson's hit illegal, yet he copped a fine.

            I have a problem with suspensions in general, they punish the fans more than they punish the players, I have no problem with fines for hits like Merriweather's, that was a blatant helmet to helmet hit.

            I do have a problem with a fine for hits like Harrison's. That was a flaggable hit, but in reality, the helmet to helmet is caused as much by Massaquoi deciding to lower his head as well and that was a fine football play. At absolute worst that could be a flag but even then I don't agree, that hit happened because Massaqoi fumbled the catch and then lowered his head, if he doesn't do either of them it wouldn't even be helmet contact, it would be a broken sternum instead.

            Robinson's hit though should not have been anything, that was a good clean football hit(Same as TJ Ward's hit). The problem that I have stems from the fact that these clean hits are being lumped in with debatable hits and dirty hits and they are just football happening and when it was fines only that means nothing to me, I still get to watch the best play and really I don't care if the players are forced to donate to charities for tax deductions or not because the NFL is being ridiculous about what their product is, but when it becomes an issue that I might not get to see the best because defenders are out there playing football, well then I have a problem.

            So basically the "rule" itself is not the issue until you start impacting results and the quality of the game by taking players out of it with suspension. This isn't so much about the Merriweather type hits where it is clear that it was a dirty hit but more about those that are borderline like Harrison or completely fine like Robinson. The NFL has established a track record of being inconsistent with it's treatment and being far more focused on the result of plays rather than the intention or reality of what happened.


            Props to BK on the sig!

            Comment


            • Originally posted by Mr. Goosemahn View Post
              And here's another good article from Rick Reilly:
              http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/news/story?id=5706465

              Good, James Harrison. Please do retire. Make good on your threats and go drive a truck like your father did. And if you have as many head-ons in that job as you do in this one, heaven help you.

              Steelers coach Mike Tomlin defended Harrison, saying he's a "model" for young players to imitate. Oh, yeah, he's a peach. Fined $5,000 for slamming Vince Young into the ground. Fined $5,000 for unnecessary brutality against a Cincinnati Bengal. Had to go to anger management and undergo psychiatric counseling after being charged with assault on his girlfriend. Owned a pit bull that bit his son, the boy's mom and his masseuse. When's he running for Congress?

              Comment


              • LOL @ Channing Crowder who thinks it's all about jersey sales from WRs and QBs.

                Crowder said the NFL is "making a big deal about nothing" and cited money as the motivation.

                "They want to save the receivers and quarterbacks because they sell all the jerseys," Crowder said. "They don't give a damn at all about defensive players because we don't sell as many jerseys as them. ...

                Comment


                • Originally posted by J-Mike88 View Post
                  And here's another good article from Rick Reilly:
                  http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/news/story?id=5706465
                  I'd be very interested to see these big and bad sports reporters back up that talk infront of the athletes they bash.

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by J-Mike88 View Post
                    LOL @ Channing Crowder who thinks it's all about jersey sales from WRs and QBs.

                    Crowder said the NFL is "making a big deal about nothing" and cited money as the motivation.

                    "They want to save the receivers and quarterbacks because they sell all the jerseys," Crowder said. "They don't give a damn at all about defensive players because we don't sell as many jerseys as them. ...
                    Wow, I didn't think it possible for Crowder to actually sound smart especially after the Europe statement he made a few years back.


                    Silverback....still the best.

                    +rep to Jakey for the sig

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by HinesWardJr View Post
                      I'd be very interested to see these big and bad sports reporters back up that talk infront of the athletes they bash.
                      Why, because they would beat up some old timer who did nothing but state the truth?


                      Nothing in the rules is changing its exactly the same as always. Now they are just enforcing them to a greater degree. Its not like there is 20,000 helmet to helmet hits a game. Ive seen exactly one from the Packers. it was Frank Zombo hitting Cutlers chin unintentionally with the top of his helmet. I will hold judgement until I see if even something like that earns a suspension.

                      Sick Sig By BoneKrusher

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by J-Mike88 View Post
                        And here's another good article from Rick Reilly:
                        http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/news/story?id=5706465
                        Oh, there's no doubt denying that Harrison is an extremely aggressive person, but that's part of the reason why he's a good player. As an avid fan of what he does on the field, I've been witness to many of the things he's done, both on and off the field. Some of them are dirty, some not.

                        - Punched his girlfrield.

                        - Pitbull incident.

                        - Slammed a Browns fan onto the ground.


                        - Was very physical when blocking a Cardinals player on ST during the Superbowl.

                        Supposedly the guy punched his balls and tried to hit him on the knees on previous plays, don't know what really happened, only that this did.

                        - Vince Young suplex.

                        He grabbed Vince Young, but if you see clearly, it was actually Aaron Smith and Brett Keisel who flip Young, also flipping Harrison in the process.

                        - Various good plays and big hits.


                        - Decking Correll Buckhalter.


                        - More good plays, big hits.


                        Every single Steelers fan on these boards, and elsewhere for that matter, will tell you that James Harrison is a tenacious player who always manages to lay the lumber. He's a hard-hitter, just like many other LB's have been before him. Some people will argue he's a dirty player, other will argue his hits are legal, the point is he's simply aggressive and physical. And that's exactly what people love seeing in players. People who say they don't like physical players are lying.

                        Jags fans loved seeing MJD sit Merriman on his ass. Vikings fan loved seeing Peterson run over William ***. Bengals fans loved seeing Chris Crocker light up Santonio Holmes. And I won't lie, I've enjoyed seeing Harrison deliver some of the hits seen above.

                        I just never hope a player gets injured, no matter who he plays for, and you'll never see me celebrating an injury coming from a devastating hit. In fact, people rarely do that. But those injuries happen, it's part of the sport. There are injury risks for every single sport, but that doesn't stop players from doing them. Boxers have risks for extremely serious injuries, just like MMA fighters do. Soccer players can suffer devastating knee and leg injuries. Basketball players can seriously damage their knees. Pitchers can suffer serious shoulder and elbow injuries. It's just a part of the game. And players know that. Harrison knows he could get knocked out if he delivers a big hit, as do all other players.

                        That's why Harrison and Ray Lewis and Rodney Harrison and Brian Urlacher and others say what they do. They learned to play the game one way and then they can't play that way in the pros.

                        There are differences between dirty hits and big hits. Most of the hits the league is fining are simply big hits. Robinson on Jackson was a big hit. Dirty hits are like the one where Gosder Cherilus launched himself at Jared Allen's knees while he was running and facing the other side.

                        But that's just my opinion. I've seen many hard hits and people reacting to them, both positively and negatively. The point is that people who root for the guy who got lit up usually cry "dirty!" while the fans of the hitter usually cries "fair!"

                        People just need to learn to accept big hits, they happen.
                        Last edited by Mr. Goosemahn; 10-20-2010, 10:45 PM.

                        Props to clover_jeez!

                        Comment


                        • I actually don't think JH's "tackle" of the fan was bad at all... he did that very gently. On purpose. He just subdued him. He could have crushed him if he wanted to.

                          Again, would guys like Harrison use their heads as weapons if they didn't have the rock hard shell helmets? Would they tame it down a bit if they knew their own head would be smashed up and not just the opponents skull?

                          If Harrison was wearing these old school helmets, I can assure you he'd only use his head as a weapon one time, and never again after that. Fines & suspensions wouldn't be needed.

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by yourfavestoner View Post
                            Weren't all the Browns fans defending TJ Ward and doing cut ups on here to show how it wasn't a dirty hit, like, two weeks ago?
                            No, which is hilarious considering it went on forever and apparently no one paid any attention to what was being said.

                            I said it wasn't a helmet to helmet hit, i said i was okay with the fine and the penalty, didn't say anything besides it wasn't helmet to helmet.

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by WinslowBodden View Post
                              No, which is hilarious considering it went on forever and apparently no one paid any attention to what was being said.

                              I said it wasn't a helmet to helmet hit, i said i was okay with the fine and the penalty, didn't say anything besides it wasn't helmet to helmet.

                              It was illegal according to defenseless WR act of 2010. NFL considers shoulder to helmet just as bad or it should. The helmet and shoulder pads are made out of the same polycarbonate material, and the force each delivers is the same.

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by Mr. Goosemahn View Post
                                - Vince Young suplex.

                                He grabbed Vince Young, but if you see clearly, it was actually Aaron Smith and Brett Keisel who flip Young, also flipping Harrison in the process.
                                The refs didn't throw a yellow flag right? The media didn't even care. If this was Peyton Manning or Tom Brady or Brett Favre the media/peter king and john madden would be asking for smith,harrison and keisel head.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information