Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

all overated team

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Eagles own the NFC East
    started a topic all overated team

    all overated team

    who do you guys think is the most overated at each position?

    QB- Tony RoHOMO
    RB- Shaun Alexander
    FB- Mike Alstott

    WR- Santana Moss
    WR- Randy Moss

    TE- Tony Gonzalez
    no offensive lineman are overated imo

    DE- Dwight Freeney
    DT- Anthony McFarland
    DT- Warren Sapp
    DE- Osi

    LOLB-Shawn Merriman
    MLB- Ray Lewis
    ROLB- Cato June

    CB- Ty Law
    SS- Roy Williams
    FS- ?????
    CB- Charles Woodson

    who would you guys put?

  • draftguru151
    replied
    Originally posted by Shiver View Post
    There is nothing, absolutely nothing, in this world that irritates me more than "overrated" threads. That's the only thing people can come up with, as threads, in the off-season.
    There needs to be a thread about players properly rated.

    Leave a comment:


  • etk
    replied
    Originally posted by Shiver View Post
    There is nothing, absolutely nothing, in this world that irritates me more than "overrated" threads. That's the only thing people can come up with, as threads, in the off-season.
    Quoted For Truth +rep

    Leave a comment:


  • etk
    replied
    Originally posted by excanuck View Post
    Couldn't think of a whole team so i thought of people that havn't been mentioned that imo are overrated
    RB - M Turner
    Wr - Randle El
    TE - V Davis
    OLB - J Porter
    MLB - T brushci
    ??????????

    Leave a comment:


  • JK17
    replied
    Merriman had 17 sacks in 12 games. He missed games against Cleveland, Cincy, Denver and Oakland. He breaks the sack record if he plays all 16 games. Say what you want about steroids, theyre are too many threads on that already, but strictly performing on the field is what constitutes overrated, and Merriman is not overrated, he's the best at what he does (3-4 OLB)

    Leave a comment:


  • Shiver
    replied
    There is nothing, absolutely nothing, in this world that irritates me more than "overrated" threads. That's the only thing people can come up with, as threads, in the off-season.

    Leave a comment:


  • scottyboy
    replied
    i love the philly bias. i mean alot are questionable but Osi? $20 says he cant spell his last name without looking it up lol(trust me i can). i mean the guy played 1 full year, and what? led the NFC in sacks? he got hurt this year, but still played well when healthy despite constant double teams.

    Leave a comment:


  • JoeMontainya
    replied
    QB - Roethlesburger (exsposed after all the true leaders start to leave a great team)
    RB - Willis McGahee (cant block, run inbetween the tackles, horrible YPC)
    WR - Chris Chambers (drops his own first born child because of butter fingers)
    WR - Braylon Edwards (dude is an athlete, but not a great WR, cant catch in any important situation)
    TE - Vernon Davis (nonody has got a true feel for him yet, but hes better without pads and worse with them on (meaning actual games))
    DE - Freeney (can only pass rush, usually runs himself out of 90% of all plays)
    CB - Deangelo Hall (for how fast he is, he talks to much and I allways catch him getting beat)
    S - Roy Williams (cant cover a boat with a tarp)
    S - Sean Taylor (gave up 2nd most TD's out of all the NFL DB's, should be a LB)


    Dont get me wrong, if all these players were on the same team it would be scary, but they get more credit than they deserve and there weaknesses usually hurt there teams as much as there strengths help.

    Leave a comment:


  • neko4
    replied
    Originally posted by Eagles own the NFC East View Post
    who do you guys think is the most overated at each position?

    QB- Tony RoHOMO
    RB- Shaun Alexander
    FB- Mike Alstott

    WR- Santana Moss
    WR- Randy Moss

    TE- Tony Gonzalez
    no offensive lineman are overated imo

    DE- Dwight Freeney
    DT- Anthony McFarland
    DT- Warren Sapp
    DE- Osi

    LOLB-Shawn Merriman
    MLB- Ray Lewis
    ROLB- Cato June

    CB- Ty Law
    SS- Roy Williams
    FS- ?????
    CB- Charles Woodson

    who would you guys put?
    Romo...oh yeah he only led a team back on the brink of extinction basically. I can agree w/ Alexander. Alstott is considered as great as he was so hes not exactly overated. Santana Moss? he makes Brunell look good and jumps over people 2to3 inches taller than him. Randy Moss is older and is no longer considerd great like Alstott, maybe TO. Gonzalez? Seriously, the best TE since Winslow I. I can see Freeny and June, but they did win the super bowl. Ray Lewis? Where did you come up w/ that idea? I can see Williams, but not Woodson, the guys been hurt and the Packers D was better partly because of him.

    Leave a comment:


  • Shiver
    replied
    Originally posted by bigbluedefense View Post
    Ok, I can specifically point out the few times Jacobs got the ball against you guys this past year. If you look back at it, he went untouched several times. In fact, he said he would run right at Urlacher during the week, and he kept his promise. He did run right at him, and Urlacher didn't even challenge him. He just let him go right up the gut. K know, I know, we lost. Got our butts kicked in the 2nd half. Why on earth did Jacobs get so few touches that game, only Tom Coughlin knows.

    Ive also seen Duckett get the best of him.

    From what I recall, Lewis would usually win the war against George. Maybe Im basing my opinions too heavily on their playoff games, but from what I saw, Ray held it down.

    When did that happen? I don't remember it.

    Leave a comment:


  • MP123
    replied
    Michael Vick. He sucks, but yeat he makes the Pro Bowl every year.

    Leave a comment:


  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest replied
    Couldn't think of a whole team so i thought of people that havn't been mentioned that imo are overrated
    RB - M Turner
    Wr - Randle El
    TE - V Davis
    OLB - J Porter
    MLB - T brushci
    Last edited by excanuck; 03-25-2007, 07:20 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • The Legend
    replied
    bears fan why you have to make him a dawkins sig :(

    Leave a comment:


  • The Legend
    replied
    Originally posted by Eagles own the NFC East View Post
    who do you guys think is the most overated at each position?

    QB- Tony RoHOMO
    RB- Shaun Alexander - BAD
    FB- Mike Alstott - BAD

    WR- Santana Moss - BAD
    WR- Randy Moss

    TE- Tony Gonzalez - BAD
    no offensive lineman are overated imo

    DE- Dwight Freeney - BAD
    DT- Anthony McFarland
    DT- Warren Sapp - BAD
    DE- Osi

    LOLB-Shawn Merriman - BAD
    MLB- Ray Lewis - BAD
    ROLB- Cato June

    CB- Ty Law - BAD
    SS- Roy Williams - BAD
    FS- ?????
    CB- Charles Woodson - BAD

    who would you guys put?
    well i dont like half your list

    Leave a comment:


  • etk
    replied
    Originally posted by Eagles own the NFC East View Post
    who do you guys think is the most overated at each position?

    QB- Tony RoHOMO
    RB- Shaun Alexander
    FB- Mike Alstott

    WR- Santana Moss
    WR- Randy Moss

    TE- Tony Gonzalez
    no offensive lineman are overated imo

    DE- Dwight Freeney
    DT- Anthony McFarland
    DT- Warren Sapp
    DE- Osi

    LOLB-Shawn Merriman
    MLB- Ray Lewis
    ROLB- Cato June

    CB- Ty Law
    SS- Roy Williams
    FS- ?????
    CB- Charles Woodson

    who would you guys put?
    So basically you are saying that every player that used to be a star and has declined is overrated? Do you ignore past achievements? Most of that list is filled with guys who are over 30 and still start but have declined a bit, and I think that is an unfair way to rate someone. The rest of the list is guys who are far from overrated, except for maybe Romo & June.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X

Debug Information