Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

All NFLDC FS - Brian Dawkins

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #76
    Originally posted by SeanTaylor21
    Originally posted by DMWSackMachine
    Stephonson86, with all due respect, I am beginning to wonder if you even watch the NFL. You usually get the top 2 or 3 players in a poll, but after that you just start throwing out names as if you are picking them at random.

    There is no way in hell that Bob Sanders should be off this list. He is a better player right this minute than Sean Taylor is (though not nearly as gifted, admittedly).

    By the same token, you have yeomans like Hope, Dwight Smith, Greg Wesley, Bryan Scott etc.

    Again, no offense intended, but your choice of personnel has been off on nearly every poll you've posted.

    With that said, I went with Dawkins. He has mastered the position right now like few players at any other position. He is just so well polished, and also has a lot of juice left. Definitely him.

    Taylor is the new object of affection for fanboys nationwide. He is nowhere near the hype right now, and is wildly overrated by nearly the entire board. He has the tools to be the best safety in the league, and maybe even the best ever, but he has so much to learn that its a joke how much love he gets. Assuming a regular growth curve, though, he will likely be the best in the league by the end of this season or the middle of the next. Just keepin' it real.
    I know you dont like sean taylor but to say sanders is better at the moment is laughable. Sean Taylor is better against the run and in pass coverage. He also makes more plays that Bob Sanders. What did Bob Sanders do for his team in the playoffs, cause sean taylor scored a TD and won the Tampa game for the redskins and in the seahawks game, he perfectly deflected a pass that was in the endzone and the following play a fumble was forced.

    Teams shy away from Taylor and they go at Sanders because he cant cover. Taylor can also hit better and is better at run support. Sanders gets all of that hype because he plays for the colts but he did not deserve to be on that AP team, Troy Polamalu did.....but thats another argument.

    Who said Sean Taylor is worse than Bob Sanders? That's a joke. Sean Taylor is one of the greatest defensive backs to ever play college football, he can play SS and FS, and was a top 10 fs when he came into this league and is Top 5 in his second year in most peoples minds. He'll be challanging Ed Reed, Brian Dawkins, and Troy Polamalu for the best safety spot this year.

    Washington Redskins Mock Draft:
    Round 1: Micheal Oher/OT/Ole Miss
    Round 3: Paul Kruger/DE/Utah
    Round 5: Marcus Freeman/LB/Ohio State
    Round 6: Graham Gano/K/Florida State
    Round 7: Maurice Miller/OG/Ole Miss
    Snyder, get me Gano!

    Comment


    • #77
      I know I am late on this, but it is easily ST. Dawkins isn't as dominant as he once was. Taylor was the perfect safety and doesn't have any holes in his games. He is a top 3 safety at worst, and of those 3, he is the only FS. He is going to be the best after this season.

      That is correct comahan
      I ******* LOVE YOU DG
      <3 dg

      Comment


      • #78
        Draft Guru hit it on the head. The Fact that Dawkins had so many votes over Taylor is crap. Dawkins < ST... I don't understand what everyone sees that I don't. I watched Dawkins a lot growing up because they always played Eagles games on TV and through all that I don't believe that at any time in his career that he was Better that ST is right now. I just don't understand why so many people have a fixation on Bdawk. Sure he is a great safety but he's not in ST's league...

        Comment


        • #79
          Originally posted by SeanTaylor21
          Originally posted by DMWSackMachine
          Stephonson86, with all due respect, I am beginning to wonder if you even watch the NFL. You usually get the top 2 or 3 players in a poll, but after that you just start throwing out names as if you are picking them at random.

          There is no way in hell that Bob Sanders should be off this list. He is a better player right this minute than Sean Taylor is (though not nearly as gifted, admittedly).

          By the same token, you have yeomans like Hope, Dwight Smith, Greg Wesley, Bryan Scott etc.

          Again, no offense intended, but your choice of personnel has been off on nearly every poll you've posted.

          With that said, I went with Dawkins. He has mastered the position right now like few players at any other position. He is just so well polished, and also has a lot of juice left. Definitely him.

          Taylor is the new object of affection for fanboys nationwide. He is nowhere near the hype right now, and is wildly overrated by nearly the entire board. He has the tools to be the best safety in the league, and maybe even the best ever, but he has so much to learn that its a joke how much love he gets. Assuming a regular growth curve, though, he will likely be the best in the league by the end of this season or the middle of the next. Just keepin' it real.
          I know you dont like sean taylor but to say sanders is better at the moment is laughable. Sean Taylor is better against the run and in pass coverage. He also makes more plays that Bob Sanders. What did Bob Sanders do for his team in the playoffs, cause sean taylor scored a TD and won the Tampa game for the redskins and in the seahawks game, he perfectly deflected a pass that was in the endzone and the following play a fumble was forced.

          Teams shy away from Taylor and they go at Sanders because he cant cover. Taylor can also hit better and is better at run support. Sanders gets all of that hype because he plays for the colts but he did not deserve to be on that AP team, Troy Polamalu did.....but thats another argument.
          Hey I got a bone to pick with you. He did pretty good in the playoffs. He had 10 tackles. that's pretty good. Ye didn't have a turnover, but he did help his team. Sean Taylor is much better, but check stats before you say he didn't do anything ion the playoffs. This is another reason he should be on the poll.

          In the season Bob Sanders had 91 tackles, 1 pick, 1FF, and no sacks.

          In the season Sean Taylor had 70 tackles, 2 picks, 2 FF, and 1 sack.

          Sure Sean Taylor has had more turnovers, but saying Bob Sanders isn't worthy to be on here is ridiculous.

          Sean Taylor is better, but Bob Sanders has great skill.

          Sig by BoneKrusher
          Originally posted by killxswitch
          Bill Polian is cancer wrapped in AIDS delivered in an XXL enema so please don't expect me to disagree with you.

          Comment


          • #80
            Sean Taylor is, but Dawkins got it :evil:
            | Hawkeyes || Rams || Lakers || Braves || Avalanche |

            Comment


            • #81
              Originally posted by nathan
              Originally posted by SeanTaylor21
              Originally posted by DMWSackMachine
              Stephonson86, with all due respect, I am beginning to wonder if you even watch the NFL. You usually get the top 2 or 3 players in a poll, but after that you just start throwing out names as if you are picking them at random.

              There is no way in hell that Bob Sanders should be off this list. He is a better player right this minute than Sean Taylor is (though not nearly as gifted, admittedly).

              By the same token, you have yeomans like Hope, Dwight Smith, Greg Wesley, Bryan Scott etc.

              Again, no offense intended, but your choice of personnel has been off on nearly every poll you've posted.

              With that said, I went with Dawkins. He has mastered the position right now like few players at any other position. He is just so well polished, and also has a lot of juice left. Definitely him.

              Taylor is the new object of affection for fanboys nationwide. He is nowhere near the hype right now, and is wildly overrated by nearly the entire board. He has the tools to be the best safety in the league, and maybe even the best ever, but he has so much to learn that its a joke how much love he gets. Assuming a regular growth curve, though, he will likely be the best in the league by the end of this season or the middle of the next. Just keepin' it real.
              I know you dont like sean taylor but to say sanders is better at the moment is laughable. Sean Taylor is better against the run and in pass coverage. He also makes more plays that Bob Sanders. What did Bob Sanders do for his team in the playoffs, cause sean taylor scored a TD and won the Tampa game for the redskins and in the seahawks game, he perfectly deflected a pass that was in the endzone and the following play a fumble was forced.

              Teams shy away from Taylor and they go at Sanders because he cant cover. Taylor can also hit better and is better at run support. Sanders gets all of that hype because he plays for the colts but he did not deserve to be on that AP team, Troy Polamalu did.....but thats another argument.
              Hey I got a bone to pick with you. He did pretty good in the playoffs. He had 10 tackles. that's pretty good. Ye didn't have a turnover, but he did help his team. Sean Taylor is much better, but check stats before you say he didn't do anything ion the playoffs. This is another reason he should be on the poll.

              In the season Bob Sanders had 91 tackles, 1 pick, 1FF, and no sacks.

              In the season Sean Taylor had 70 tackles, 2 picks, 2 FF, and 1 sack.

              Sure Sean Taylor has had more turnovers, but saying Bob Sanders isn't worthy to be on here is ridiculous.

              Sean Taylor is better, but Bob Sanders has great skill.
              SEAN TAYLOR DIDNT DO ANYTHING IN THE PLAYOFFS!?!??!?!?WHAT WERE YOU WATCHING??????????


              Without Sean Taylor we would not of beaten Tampa Bay.


              EDIT: Read it wrong sorry :P

              Washington Redskins Mock Draft:
              Round 1: Micheal Oher/OT/Ole Miss
              Round 3: Paul Kruger/DE/Utah
              Round 5: Marcus Freeman/LB/Ohio State
              Round 6: Graham Gano/K/Florida State
              Round 7: Maurice Miller/OG/Ole Miss
              Snyder, get me Gano!

              Comment


              • #82
                Alright an Eagle is on the team. :D

                Comment


                • #83
                  im glad to see this

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X

                  Debug Information