Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Charlie Frye. The real deal?

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • eacantdraft
    started a topic Charlie Frye. The real deal?

    Charlie Frye. The real deal?

    Will Charlie Frye be an above average NFL QB?

    I see him as continuing the long line of sucessful NFL QB's. I think he will have a career similar to Chad Pennington before Pennington injuries. Frye isn't as physically gifted as Big Ben, but will be in the top third of QB's in the league

  • detknowitall
    replied
    Originally posted by bigbluedefense
    up and comers like Ben, Eli, and soon to be Cutler, Leinart and Quinn who will pretty much make up the top tier of qbs of the future.
    Ben and Eli I can understand but your throwing 2 rookies and a kid that hasnt even been drafted yet into that category? ? ?

    Leave a comment:


  • Staubach12
    replied
    Originally posted by Scotty D
    Originally posted by mangini for pres
    i feel bad for him though, because he doesn't have a good line in front of him... namely the center position...
    Just for this year though.
    Yeah, Center will be fine next year. I think the line could play well, they have potential to be good IMO.

    Leave a comment:


  • Scotty D
    replied
    Originally posted by mangini for pres
    i feel bad for him though, because he doesn't have a good line in front of him... namely the center position...
    Just for this year though.

    Leave a comment:


  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest replied
    Not throwing passes into tripple coverage to Northcutt like that.

    Leave a comment:


  • Larry
    replied
    Originally posted by portermvp84
    I think Alex Smith is gonna be a major bust considering he's one a team thats not going any where, any time soon.
    and like the Raiders are going any where with Aaron Brooks,

    Leave a comment:


  • TimD
    replied
    i feel bad for him though, because he doesn't have a good line in front of him... namely the center position...

    Leave a comment:


  • HokiesSkins2621
    replied
    Originally posted by keylime_5
    Give him time and surround him with talent and he'll be a good one. Might make a pro bowl or two kinda like Jake Delhomme or Marc Bulger except potentially better.

    He certainly has all the intangeables

    Kellen Winslow/Tight End
    Braylon Edwards/Wide Reciever
    Rueben Droughns/Halfback
    Joe Jurivicious/Wide Reciever

    That is enough weapons :D

    Leave a comment:


  • Shiver
    replied
    Originally posted by Material Issues
    Originally posted by Shiver
    Is he an above average QB? No. Because I can easily think of 15 other Quarterbacks I would rather have.
    Really? I thought that after this rookie season he was already an above average NFL QB. Now you've just ruined my day.

    I wasn't basing my conclusion off just his rookie season.

    Leave a comment:


  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest replied
    Originally posted by mangini for pres
    Originally posted by Material Issues
    Originally posted by mangini for pres
    yo material issues, you're getting way to defensive about everything... we haven't really seen him as a true NFL starter so no one can really know if he's good or bad... we saw a bit of him last year (with no weapons) and he was a rookie... this year is the test whether he's a above average qb or not...
    I definately agree it''s just that comments like the one above irritate me as they are as unwarranted as would be the comment "He's going to be a for sure Hall of Famer."
    yeh... a thread should be started about Frye a few weeks in, then we can actually have a "smart" conversation about him.... right now everything is up in the air...
    yeah now all we have are his tools and 2006 poise to judge him on.

    Leave a comment:


  • TimD
    replied
    Originally posted by Material Issues
    Originally posted by mangini for pres
    yo material issues, you're getting way to defensive about everything... we haven't really seen him as a true NFL starter so no one can really know if he's good or bad... we saw a bit of him last year (with no weapons) and he was a rookie... this year is the test whether he's a above average qb or not...
    I definately agree it''s just that comments like the one above irritate me as they are as unwarranted as would be the comment "He's going to be a for sure Hall of Famer."
    yeh... a thread should be started about Frye a few weeks in, then we can actually have a "smart" conversation about him.... right now everything is up in the air...

    Leave a comment:


  • portermvp84
    replied
    He should have a good year depending if all of his stay healthy like Winslow.

    Leave a comment:


  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest replied
    Originally posted by mangini for pres
    yo material issues, you're getting way to defensive about everything... we haven't really seen him as a true NFL starter so no one can really know if he's good or bad... we saw a bit of him last year (with no weapons) and he was a rookie... this year is the test whether he's a above average qb or not...
    I definately agree it''s just that comments like the one above irritate me as they are as unwarranted as would be the comment "He's going to be a for sure Hall of Famer."

    Leave a comment:


  • TimD
    replied
    yo material issues, you're getting way to defensive about everything... we haven't really seen him as a true NFL starter so no one can really know if he's good or bad... we saw a bit of him last year (with no weapons) and he was a rookie... this year is the test whether he's a above average qb or not...

    Leave a comment:


  • Guest's Avatar
    Guest replied
    Originally posted by Shiver
    Is he an above average QB? No. Because I can easily think of 15 other Quarterbacks I would rather have.
    Really? I thought that after this rookie season he was already an above average NFL QB. Now you've just ruined my day.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X

Debug Information