Stop arguing the logical fallacy. Look at it this way, two cars are very similar. Same safety rating, look a lot alike. etc. All the measurables are near equal. However one of the cars gets better gas mileage while the other is a guzzler. You take the one that gets the good mileage. But that doesn't mean you buy a Geo Metro just because it's better than both on mileage.
A lot more than "he has a ring" goes into that argument. No, Bradshaw isn't better than either of them because he has more rings. He was never comparable in the first place.
If you honestly believe you made a rational argument, I suggest you start studying in English Lit. as soon as you return from that Spring Break you are spending making benign statements on here.