Originally posted by bearsfan_51
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Eli, Rivers, or Big Ben
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by Number 10It seems now that the running game is being contained, Ben is not even sniffing the success he had the past couple years.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Smooth CriminalIn the end it is winning that matters and not stats. We'll see what QB leads his team to the most success.
As of now, I'll take the guy witha 5-1 playoff record and a ring over a guy that hasn't ever won , or scored a point in, a playoff game.Originally posted by PaulEli's opportunity to become a legend.Originally posted by Vikes99ejThese last 50 seconds will define Eli Manning.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Smooth CriminalIn the end it is winning that matters and not stats. We'll see what QB leads his team to the most success.
As of now, I'll take the guy witha 5-1 playoff record and a ring over a guy that hasn't ever won , or scored a point in, a playoff game.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ricky bobbyOriginally posted by Smooth CriminalIn the end it is winning that matters and not stats. We'll see what QB leads his team to the most success.
As of now, I'll take the guy witha 5-1 playoff record and a ring over a guy that hasn't ever won , or scored a point in, a playoff game.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ricky bobbyOriginally posted by Smooth CriminalIn the end it is winning that matters and not stats. We'll see what QB leads his team to the most success.
As of now, I'll take the guy witha 5-1 playoff record and a ring over a guy that hasn't ever won , or scored a point in, a playoff game.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Basileus777Originally posted by ricky bobbyOriginally posted by Smooth CriminalIn the end it is winning that matters and not stats. We'll see what QB leads his team to the most success.
As of now, I'll take the guy witha 5-1 playoff record and a ring over a guy that hasn't ever won , or scored a point in, a playoff game.
Answer: his backup.
Comment
-
Originally posted by ricky bobbyOriginally posted by Basileus777Originally posted by ricky bobbyOriginally posted by Smooth CriminalIn the end it is winning that matters and not stats. We'll see what QB leads his team to the most success.
As of now, I'll take the guy witha 5-1 playoff record and a ring over a guy that hasn't ever won , or scored a point in, a playoff game.
Answer: his backup.
Comment
-
Hey, what year did the Steelers win the Superbowl? Oh wait, that was last year, before Ben got hurt and started playing like crap. Wasn't that the same year that they struggled when Ben was injured and were a completely different team with him?
Comment
-
Originally posted by ricky bobbyHey, what year did the Steelers win the Superbowl? Oh wait, that was last year, before Ben got hurt and started playing like crap. Wasn't that the same year that they struggled when Ben was injured and were a completely different team with him?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Smooth CriminalOriginally posted by Jughead10Originally posted by Smooth CriminalOriginally posted by Jughead10Originally posted by Smooth CriminalOriginally posted by Number 10Originally posted by Smooth CriminalI'll take Ben. Sure its me being a homer but look at the way he led us through the playoffs last season. He did alot more than just "manage" games in the playoffs. He single handedly took us to the superbowl. I'll take a superbowl win over a stat record any day.
1-Be honest with yourself. Do you really believe that Ben single handeldly took you to the Super Bowl?
2-Would you take Trent Dilfer, Kurt Warner, Phil Simms, Jeff Hostetler, Brad Johnson...etc over Dan Marino because of a ring?
And to your question, No I would take Marino. But to be fair, Ben is better than all of those guys and Manning and Rivers will never be as good as Marino.
The thought of him being a fluke was acceptable after one good year but after playing good his first two seasons its pretty obivous he will be a great QB for along time. Sure he is in s lump right now but you can't expect him to stay there with the way he has played his first two years.
Ben and Simms are almost polar opposites to me. Simms had probably the greatest single Super Bowl performance for a winning QB, while Ben had the worst.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Basileus777Originally posted by ricky bobbyHey, what year did the Steelers win the Superbowl? Oh wait, that was last year, before Ben got hurt and started playing like crap. Wasn't that the same year that they struggled when Ben was injured and were a completely different team with him?
last years stats do matter. you cant just base everything on the few games he has played this year.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Windy City Big Gamer UnoOriginally posted by Basileus777Originally posted by ricky bobbyHey, what year did the Steelers win the Superbowl? Oh wait, that was last year, before Ben got hurt and started playing like crap. Wasn't that the same year that they struggled when Ben was injured and were a completely different team with him?
last years stats do matter. you cant just base everything on the few games he has played this year.
Comment
Comment