Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Leinart vs. Young vs. Cutler revisited

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    I'll admit Young is making me look someone foolish. He is playing good ball right now, but he still has a way to go. I never doubted his talent, just his ability to take that talent and use it.

    That is correct comahan
    I ******* LOVE YOU DG
    <3 dg

    Comment


    • #32
      VY has always been #1 on my list even before the Draft. I gotta stick with him he is going to be amazing. Leinart is also gonna be up there but he also has 2 of the leagues best WR's on his team, it's close but Vince Young gets my vote. I see Jay being solid but nothing special.

      Comment


      • #33
        In response to what someone said earlier, I know it will kinda suck to not be able to get CJ, but getting someone like Tedd Ginn Jr. will definately give Vince a gamebreaker at WR. Ginn has much better explosiveness and speed than CJ, and will be a great starter along with Brandon Jones and David Givens as the future starting WRs for the Titans.

        -No doubt Vince Young has looked the best overall right now. Sure Leinart is still probably the most polished passer, but Vince wins games at whatever cost, whether its running the football to convert 3rd downs, or throwing for them. I believe Vince will probably be the best QB out of these three and this draft could be one of the best ever possibly for QBs.

        Comment


        • #34
          Originally posted by cunningham06
          Vince Young is the best easily he is amazing. And Draftguru ^^^ wtf?
          Jay cutler......

          Jay Cutler>Matt Leinart>>>>danman253
          XBL GT smitty js Go Vandy!!!!!!
          Chris Johnson son!!!!!!!!
          http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JoUr82vUx60
          http://www.bangcartoon.com/2007/pacman.htm

          Comment


          • #35
            VYisaGOD and JC FTW!!!!!!!!!!

            Jay Cutler>Matt Leinart>>>>danman253
            XBL GT smitty js Go Vandy!!!!!!
            Chris Johnson son!!!!!!!!
            http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JoUr82vUx60
            http://www.bangcartoon.com/2007/pacman.htm

            Comment


            • #36
              1. Lienart

              2. Young

              3. Cutler


              Thats how i had them out of college, and I will keep it that way. Young has been impressive and its a lot closer between him and Lienart then it was preseason


              But then again, Young plays on the Titans. who knows what will happen when teams start to learn his tendencys.


              Lienart is good, but then again hes an Arizona Cardinal and I cant say anyone there is sure to be good

              Comment


              • #37
                Originally posted by Moses
                Vince Young has impressed me. The guy is just a winner. I'm glad he's proving his critics wrong. This board was treating him pretty unfairly for most of the predraft process.
                i agree with you
                V.Y received some serious hating before the draft

                even some titans fan did not what him on their team
                Michael Vick 2.0 = Part 2 - 2011 NFL Season

                Comment


                • #38
                  Originally posted by 2drama
                  Originally posted by Moses
                  Vince Young has impressed me. The guy is just a winner. I'm glad he's proving his critics wrong. This board was treating him pretty unfairly for most of the predraft process.
                  i agree with you
                  V.Y received some serious hating before the draft

                  even some titans fan did not what him on their team
                  That happens every year, you can't please everybody....

                  Jay Cutler>Matt Leinart>>>>danman253
                  XBL GT smitty js Go Vandy!!!!!!
                  Chris Johnson son!!!!!!!!
                  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JoUr82vUx60
                  http://www.bangcartoon.com/2007/pacman.htm

                  Comment


                  • #39
                    Originally posted by 2drama
                    Originally posted by Moses
                    Vince Young has impressed me. The guy is just a winner. I'm glad he's proving his critics wrong. This board was treating him pretty unfairly for most of the predraft process.
                    i agree with you
                    V.Y received some serious hating before the draft

                    even some titans fan did not what him on their team
                    and thus, since some people decided not to jump on the vince young bandwagon, he is the best QB?

                    I still like cutler to be the best one. Namely cause he's got the best team around him. (Let's not forget Leinart is in Arizona and VY in Tennessee, whilst Jay's sitting pretty in Denver.)

                    Sig by Fenikz

                    I remember NFLDC
                    don't tell anyone, but Charlie Casserly is a dope fiend

                    Comment


                    • #40
                      Originally posted by Addict
                      Originally posted by 2drama
                      Originally posted by Moses
                      Vince Young has impressed me. The guy is just a winner. I'm glad he's proving his critics wrong. This board was treating him pretty unfairly for most of the predraft process.
                      i agree with you
                      V.Y received some serious hating before the draft

                      even some titans fan did not what him on their team
                      and thus, since some people decided not to jump on the vince young bandwagon, he is the best QB?

                      I still like cutler to be the best one. Namely cause he's got the best team around him. (Let's not forget Leinart is in Arizona and VY in Tennessee, whilst Jay's sitting pretty in Denver.)
                      People hating on Vince Young and saying that he doesn't have the mental capacity to play at the pro level is not why I think he's the best. It's simply why I'm glad that he's proven that he's the best. Young has shown that his style does convert well to the pros and has played exceptionally well on a less-than-stellar team. Plus, Young's intangibles are through the roof. He's a winner.

                      Comment


                      • #41
                        You'll have to excuse me, but I can't help smirking a bit as I watch the world backpedaling on their opinions of Vince Young. The anti-VY crowd was so obsessed with critiquing his idiosyncrasies, they paid little credence to the one thing that stands above any measurable attributes: Vince Young knows how to win, period. And he's only gonna get better.

                        I feel the same way about Cutler. He's a gritty, gutsy kid, and his arm is a friggin' cannon...as he gains experience, he's going to be a very formidable QB. Anyone who judges Cutler by his poor showing last week needs to get in line behind the VY-haters....you're next up in the "Boy-Don't-I-Look-Like-An-Idiot-Now" sweepstakes.

                        Not to be outdone, Leinart has been developing into another slice-and-dice QB....he doesn't have athleticism or mojo of Vince Young, or Cutler's bazooka, but he's been remarkably efficient. I'm hardly the first to draw this comparison, but I see Leinart as another Tom Brady...a maddeningly consistent QB who picks defenses apart, and rarely makes the kind of mistakes that lose games.

                        I'm not one of these bandwagon jumpers that falls in love with every high-rated prospect. I never thought much of Alex Smith or Aaron Rodgers last year, and I still doubt either will ever live up to his draft status. But 2006's QB crop was incredible....I firmly believe it may be the best we've seen since the class of 1983. That year, it was John Elway, Jim Kelly, and Dan Marino.....don't think it couldn't happen again.

                        In fact, I think it already has.

                        Comment


                        • #42
                          Originally posted by Addict
                          Originally posted by 2drama
                          Originally posted by Moses
                          Vince Young has impressed me. The guy is just a winner. I'm glad he's proving his critics wrong. This board was treating him pretty unfairly for most of the predraft process.
                          i agree with you
                          V.Y received some serious hating before the draft

                          even some titans fan did not what him on their team
                          and thus, since some people decided not to jump on the vince young bandwagon, he is the best QB?

                          I still like cutler to be the best one. Namely cause he's got the best team around him. (Let's not forget Leinart is in Arizona and VY in Tennessee, whilst Jay's sitting pretty in Denver.)
                          you have got a point there Addict

                          if jay has a chance to make the playoff - out of the three.

                          but V.Y over M.L based on amount of games played
                          Jay culter has not had enough games under his belt

                          my ranking order
                          V.Y ( what more can i say)
                          Jason C ( played better than Matt.L in oly 2 games)
                          Matt L ( i am somewhat disappointed)
                          Jay Cutler ( needs more games)
                          Michael Vick 2.0 = Part 2 - 2011 NFL Season

                          Comment


                          • #43
                            My rankings now.

                            Vince Young: Shows Michael Vick how to be Michael Vick. Thought he would struggle and be a bust with the Titans.

                            Jay Cutler: Is in the best situation. Class organization with a two time winning Super Bowl coach.

                            Matt Leinart: Stuck with the worst organization in the NFL (The Raiders are also bad, but the Cardinal have been bad for 50 years). No offensive line and no defense. This is also a snakebit franchise that had injuries that end the careers of other promising QB's early like Neil Lomax and Timm Rosenbach.

                            Comment


                            • #44
                              It's too early to tell, but I feel like all 3 of them will be great... Not real sure who will be the best, but I feel all will be probowl quarterbacks in the future.

                              VY: Just a winner... the guy can win games by himself. I thought he was going to be great in the NFL after his showing against USC, and he is doing just that. Good for him. He's gonna be special.

                              Jay Cutler: Great physical tools and learning under Shannahan. Also, the Broncos (while it has been somewhat of a down year), have a great running game so it will take some pressure off of Cutler once he gets used to thes peed of the game.

                              Matt Leinart: Very poised QB and makes very good decisions. Most efficient out of the three. Also has the best playmakers on offense in Boldin, Fitz, and James. However, his line sucks and so does the organization. It may be awhile before the Cardinals start winning even w/all that talent.

                              Projected win total: 55+

                              Comment


                              • #45
                                The thing about Leinart, honestly if he would've went to New York, Tennessee or Oakland he'd look like a bust. The situation in Arizona is perfect for him to succeed. They run a short-mid range passing attack, with two awesome receivers, in a warm weather division, in a dome. Still, I do not think he will ever be one of the elite, game-breaking, Quarterbacks. His upside is considerably less than Cutler and Young. The two other Quarterbacks have the ability to throw the 15-18 pass plays, down the field, on a rope. Where Leinart will never be able to make the 18 yard comeback or out.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information