Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Cincinnati Bengals Discussion

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 3/4

    It is not out of reach to think the bengals could move to a 3/4....

    Geathers could be used in the same way that under-sized Terrel Suggs in Baltimore is being used in a DE/OLB, Sam Adams and Shaun Smith would be more than adequate at ng, drafting a 3/4 DE and mixing in Domato would fill the other end(this would leave out John Thornton and Bryan Robinson who are making more than they are worth to the team right now).

    Then at linebacker is where you would need things to happen. IF Odell comes back you have Odell and Simmons in the middle (eventually Brooks for Simmons) with Jeanty (would be a great OLB in a 3/4 and could even line up at end on passing downs like joey porter) and L. Johnson on the outside.

    A couple of things would have to fall into place for the bengals to switch to a 3/4, but none of which is too far-fetched and anything is better than the non-blitzing 4-3 being run now.

    Comment


    • Listening to Marvin today, he made it quite clear that he doesn't expect Odell to be a member of the team. Maybe he's just making him sweat but I think Marvin is still pissed. Then, we go and sign Berryman of Iowa St to the practice squad after the kid has been arrested like 5 times in his Jr yr getting himself kicked out of the school. I don't get it? I don't know if a switch to 3-4 will take place but I do feel we need an upgrade in DT, CB....and now that I think of it, I was likely going to include LB and S too so we need lots of help on defense and unless Mike Brown goes out and gets us Adaluis Thomas, which would be huge, I doubt we can fill all of our needs in the draft.

      Comment


      • Selfishness keeps being mentioned as one of the root causes for our teams problems this season. It is obvious to think that the finger points at Chad but I think it more likely points at Chris Henry, Delta O'Neal and Odell Thurman. These guys let the team down major by their off the field actions that led to suspensions and benchings. If Odell isn't forgiven and brought back (should he meet all league requirements for reinstatement), then hopefully he can be traded and get some value in return. For a rookie LBer, he was tops in tackles, 4 pics, 4 forced fumbles and brought a face of toughness to this defense that was lacking this year. I hope Marvin gives him 1 more chance, but who knows, maybe by next preseason, Odell will be in some alley doing crack, hopefully not. This offseason is really big to see if Chris Henry learned a lesson. I would think that just reading about D-Williams should convince Chris that staying home is the best thing during the season from now on.

        Comment


        • Henry

          No way Henry stops going out, I saw him down in Clifton the day after he got arrested for Marijuana poss.

          Comment


          • Who cares if he goes out as long as he keeps going long for TD grabs.
            Who Dey & Go Bucks
            The Bengals are going to the Super Bowl.

            Comment


            • As far as the 3-4 debate goes... I'll say this, I HOPE against all HOPE that Breshnahan is GONE. He is entirely too careful in his play calling, games when we go at the QB we do well (that is not sending 4 every down), games we send 4 every time (see Indy game) we struggle.

              I highly doubt we go 3-4. Unless a 3-4 guy is brought in, regardless for the defense to reach a top 15 level we need another CB and a new DC.

              As far as the selfishness claims go I think a lot of it has to do with Deltha, Marvin was very PO'd at him before the DUI because he felt he wasn't as injured as he was letting on and the DUI just made it worse. It has to be him, Odell and Henry but clearly Henry has at least some respect from Marvin. Henry will never learn either, I'm full of crazy stories about him (police reports, first hand accounts etc. ).

              I hope Odell gets another shot, if it doesn't work out it doesn't work out but the guy can flat out play. Him at the level he played his rookie year with Brooks beside him (WOW). Jeanty I'm very impressed with, Landon you always know the kind of production you'll get out of him.

              Concerning the draft I see our needs as....

              1a. CB (McCauley round 1, Bennet/Ross round 2).
              1b. DE (Round one we'd likely trade down to get good value, round 2 there will be plenty to be had... I don't see Moses as a good fit).
              2. S (Playmaker like Griffin would be sweet, then address CB round 2)

              Regardless we MUST address 2nd starting CB in either FA or probably the draft. Marvin seems to prefer the draft and after hitting gold with Joseph why shouldn't he?

              Comment


              • A guy I'm really starting to like in Rd 2 is Dan Bazuin DE . It appears that he could really end up being a player and I think the MAC guys kinda go unnoticed or somewhat disrespected to an extent questioning what they accomplished and who they did it against. I like the Fred Bennett kid too as he would be able to team with his old running mate Jonathan Joseph.

                I would hope that if Thurman isn't back, we at l;east trade him rather than release him.

                Comment


                • CHUCK

                  I completely agree that chuck needs to be relieved of his defensive play calling job. He may be a great motivator and a good disciplinarian(military background) but he does not call the game well. He plays too much cover two man that requires a ton of skill to be effective. We need a coordinator that will actually have the other team's offense questioning what kind of defense will be called next. Right now there is just not any mystery to what defense is going to be called and you do need to mix up your defensive play calls to be good(Ravens).....

                  Comment


                  • Re: CHUCK

                    Originally posted by deyebc
                    I completely agree that chuck needs to be relieved of his defensive play calling job. He may be a great motivator and a good disciplinarian(military background) but he does not call the game well. He plays too much cover two man that requires a ton of skill to be effective. We need a coordinator that will actually have the other team's offense questioning what kind of defense will be called next. Right now there is just not any mystery to what defense is going to be called and you do need to mix up your defensive play calls to be good(Ravens).....
                    Agreed completely. Our defense is very predictable and I think even with players like on the Ravens and Bears we still wouldn't have a top 5 D given Breshnahans terrible play calling. In the few games he brought heat on the QB from safties and LB's we won other than Denver but that was the fault of the offense.

                    In a dream offseason...

                    Breshnahan gets fired
                    Justin Smith leaves BUT we draft Quentin Moses
                    2nd round Aaaron Ross, Josh Wilson or Fred Bennett
                    Odell is allowed to stay, Pollack is able to recover

                    Comment


                    • Now that it seems like there's actually some regular posters in here...


                      What's your top 4 out of these guys that could be there round 1 of the draft (DE's we'll assume Justin Smith is gone)

                      Darrelle Revis
                      Marcus McCauley
                      Quentin Moses
                      Victor Abiamiri
                      Charles Johnson
                      Reggie Nelson
                      Michael Griffin

                      My list:

                      1. Reggie Nelson - Versitile, could play CB or S and Marvin likes those guys.
                      2. Darrelle Revis - Tory James is done, Deltha is average at best we need a #2.
                      3. Quentin Moses - I'd like him to be better in run support plus there are studs to be had round 2.
                      4. Marcus McCauley - Raw but so was Joseph.


                      Round 2 I like Tim Crowder, Fred Bennett and Aaron Ross.

                      Comment


                      • 1 Marcus McCauley - if he is still there at 18 we should grab him (he has the ability to be lockdown CB and those don't come around very often)
                        2 Victor Abiamiri - Solid player in college a lot like Geathers when he came out, but more matured.
                        3 Charles Johnson - great year but it's tough to call whether that will translate well into the pros
                        4 Michael Griffin - If he is still around there is a legitimate argument that they take him as the SS of the future (one year learning behind Dexter Jackson will work wonders). The downside is that you lose out on a position that is more needed such as DE or CB.


                        Quentin Moses won't be there when we pick and he is more of a 3/4 OLB than DE.
                        Darrelle Revis will be interesting with what time he runs at the combine. If he runs in the 4.35 range he is top 20.
                        Reggie Nelson - we already have a FS

                        Comment


                        • The reason I like Nelson is he could be potentially swapped to CB if needed and Marvin doesn't like the use of a FS and SS... Just two safties that can both stop the run and cover well.

                          I'm growing on Abiamiri, I haven't seen anything from Johnson so I don't have much of an opinion on him.

                          I agree with you about taking a saftey, I think the only way we can is if they're a can't miss type player. I like Nelson because he could potentially start a year at corner then we could draft another and eventually he could replace Jackson (it'd be asking a lot but still he has the ability).

                          Comment


                          • Have you all heard the rumor that Justin Smiths locker and everything has already been cleaned out? I had a friend tell me it but I'm not sure of it.

                            Given Anderson coming out the draft plays right into our hands with the great CB's and DE's to be had.

                            Comment


                            • yeah it sucks to lose someone that is as solid as Justin Smith but with the talent at DE in this draft we have the possibility of bringing in a more explosive DE to team with Geathers.

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by PalmerToCJ
                                Have you all heard the rumor that Justin Smiths locker and everything has already been cleaned out? I had a friend tell me it but I'm not sure of it.

                                Given Anderson coming out the draft plays right into our hands with the great CB's and DE's to be had.
                                I have yet to see an Anderson vs. Moses comparison. I am not sure who would be the better pro at this point. Two of the top 3 DE's and CB's will on the board when we pick at 18. We are set up to have a great first round no matter what.
                                Justin's locker is cleared out. Sports talk in Cincinnati said so last week.
                                Who Dey & Go Bucks
                                The Bengals are going to the Super Bowl.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information