Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Cowboys 2008 Draft Grades

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #46
    Originally posted by D-Unit View Post
    On Jenkins: Almost committed some physical harm on myself and my TV when we passed on Jenkins at 22. Sat in silence boiling with anger with my eyes closed for what seemed like eternity... in actuality 3 or 4 minutes. Only extreme self control prevented me from punching a hole through the TV and cursing Jerry Jones. After cooling down, I hoped to Dear Jesus that Jenkins would somehow slip to 28. When we moved up for Jenkins at 25, I was happy as ... well, Glen Dorsey said it best ... I was happy as all outside! :)
    Sorry but this **** was hilarious lmao...Had me rolling for a good bit, Dorsey and his country self lol.





    Originally posted by Scott Wright
    I guarantee that if someone picks Cam Newton in the Top 5 they will regret it.

    Comment


    • #47
      Originally posted by M.O.T.H. View Post
      Okay...now I can answer this lol. I just got back from getting GTA 4 and now my cpu just restarted like 3 times, WTF?!? lol. Anyway...

      As for some of the Safeties...

      Taylor Mays
      William Moore
      Emanuel Cook
      Courtney Green
      Myron Rolle
      Kam Chancellor
      Nic Harris
      Kevin Ellison
      Mike Hamlin

      Among others, it's a solid group...one of the draft's strengths, and we may need one next year. Taylor Mays or Emanuel Cook would be a dream selection.

      Ah, how is GTA? lol. I'm thinking of getting it but i might have a hard time finding it.

      Back to the topic at hand, lol, i just hate being good sometimes because of the draft (unless you're the patriots) and it's system. I wanna have top 10 picks too lol. I doubt we get any of those elite guys, but we'll have to do some serious trading up to do so.

      But looking at the way some of these teams were trading this year, I honestly feel some of them just completely throw out trade/value charts and just go by feel. I mean really, sometimes it makes sense to play it that way, like in the Saints/Patriots scenario, and sometimes you get the chance to shaft a team like Philly did to Carolina. I mean, how else could anyone explain the Jaguars moving into the top ten with 3rd and 4th rounders? That trade had me saying WTF from the ravens standpoint. But maybe we can find ourselves a deal like this next year to get that elite player to finish the puzzle and keep us good for many years

      Comment


      • #48
        I havent actually played it yet...just got the plastic off a second a go. My cpu has been messing up for some reason, so thats been keeping me busy...I'll fire up the 360 soon enough, though. :)

        Thanks BoneKrusher^

        http://youtube.com/watch?v=6_j52DziMy4 (the man)
        http://youtube.com/watch?v=2g6S3Anto7c
        KO KNOWS

        Comment


        • #49
          Robert, I really love your historic comparisons, and I'm serious. "Jerry like the indians who sold manhattan" and "Parcells is Mozart while Jerry is Salieri (I think you were referring to him)" are two gems.
          I'd also use Jerry is Hitler (random decisions, selfish personality, wanna have the last word on every decision...) while Parcells is Churchill (understands what is going on, know what it's better even if it doesn't sound that good, conservative)


          In Bob We Trust

          John Madden's wedding video business

          http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ddPHJWkPvU

          Comment


          • #50
            Originally posted by MetSox17 View Post
            Ah, how is GTA? lol. I'm thinking of getting it but i might have a hard time finding it.

            Back to the topic at hand, lol, i just hate being good sometimes because of the draft (unless you're the patriots) and it's system. I wanna have top 10 picks too lol. I doubt we get any of those elite guys, but we'll have to do some serious trading up to do so.

            But looking at the way some of these teams were trading this year, I honestly feel some of them just completely throw out trade/value charts and just go by feel. I mean really, sometimes it makes sense to play it that way, like in the Saints/Patriots scenario, and sometimes you get the chance to shaft a team like Philly did to Carolina. I mean, how else could anyone explain the Jaguars moving into the top ten with 3rd and 4th rounders? That trade had me saying WTF from the ravens standpoint. But maybe we can find ourselves a deal like this next year to get that elite player to finish the puzzle and keep us good for many years
            Ya if Crabtree has another season like last yr and declares its going to be another DMAC situation. Top five talent def isn't easy to go up and get... Especially with only one first rounder. Thats why I had hoped the Jerry would take Jenkins at #22 and try to bank #28 for '09 since there was good RB value in the 2nd rnd, but it didn't happen. Hopefully Harvin, and Heyward-bey light it up so he gets pushed down the board a little. IT would be nice to bring back a hometown game changer.

            With the likes of B.J. Raji and Terrance Taylor any chance we may actually have interest in a legit NT prospect??? or is that to much to ask for.

            Comment


            • #51
              I'm still sold that Chad Johnson is a Cowboy by the start of the season. I'm not sure how it's going to work capwise...be curious to hear if he could eat his bonus much like Pacman did to get the move to happen...because that is what it's going to come down two.

              The funny thing is...looking ahead to the 2009 draft, depending on comp picks given out...we could have as many as 14 picks...which is plenty of ammo to go after any target we want.

              Comment


              • #52
                Felix Jones

                I like the pick of Jones. I was a member of the ones who thought we shouldn't have passed on Mendenhall but the Cowboys FO has made an intersting point about drafting Felix instead of Mendenhall: Felix is perfect for a RB-by-commitee approach, he's used to play in this role, while Mendenhall could be the type of RB who needs a lot of carries to be effective, like Julius Jones. Since I'm a huge fan of Marion and I fully believe in him I think Felix is the perfect guy to share carries with him.

                Mike Jenkins

                Clearly the best pick of our draft. Nothing more to say about it, Jenkins is amazing.

                Martellus Bennet

                Well, not my favorite pick at all. I was in favor of drafting a WR but last year we had the second best offense in the NFL with these guys. It seems that Jerry wanted to trade up to pick Hardy but his scouts told him that the value wasn't there. I think Garrett wanted Bennet and I hope he will be what Fasano was supposed to be.

                Tashard Choice

                Good pick. Tashard is a great guy with a great attitude and he give us some insurance. I think he can be for us what Adrian Peterson is for the Bears, and I really like our three-headed monster at the RB position.

                Orlando Scandrick

                Kiper says that he could've been a second round pick. I don't know much about him, but our CB depth is now pretty good and the CB position could become from a weakness to a strenght of this team, just like the OL last year.

                Eric Walden

                Wade knows how to draft and develope OLB's so maybe Walden can become a good player. Right now I don't know anything about him.

                As far as drafting OL prospects in the later rounds, well, we drafted two olinemen last year in Marten and Free so I couldn't really see us targeting another tackle or guard in rounds 4th-7th because we already have two young guys with potential on roster.

                Final grade: B+

                Our biggest needs were CB and RB and now we have a great depth at both these positions. As LSU said, you can't have a perfect team in the salary cap era, you will always have some needs, just like every team that won the Super Bowl the last couple of years.
                I just think that there are some player that you can't replace, if they get injured your season is screwed no matter what. Having depth is always good, but is often not that much helpful. You can replace your starting CB if you have good depth, but you can't replace, for example, your QB (unless he's a game manager and he's not asked to win games but not to lose them). If Manning or Brady go down, Indianapolis and New England don't have a chance to win the Super Bowl, and we can make the same argument for us with Romo.


                In Bob We Trust

                John Madden's wedding video business

                http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ddPHJWkPvU

                Comment


                • #53
                  Originally posted by MetSox17 View Post
                  Become a dolphins fan then.

                  Bobby Carpenter, Anthony Fasano, Skyler Green, Montavious Stanley, E.J Whitley, Justin Beriault, Julius Jones, Jacob Rogers, Stephen Peterman, Bruce Thornton, Sean Ryan, Nate Jones, Jacques Reeves, Al Johnson, BJ Tucker, Zuriel Smith.

                  All guys that were drafted by Parcells in the four drafts he did, that have done absolutely jack squat for the team.

                  He's not necessarily Mozart once you notice that the only pick remaining on the team from the 04 draft was 6th rounder Patrick Crayton.

                  I don't know if that makes up for butchering the rest of the draft.

                  Three in 03, One in 04, five in 05, and four in 06.

                  We have 13 players left from four drafts. Take that as you wish
                  How many Pro Bowlers did Parcells "Tyranical, Too Controlling Team" develop????????????????? How many millions did Jone sput out for Parcells projects like Ratliff, Romo, MBIII, etc. Even Reeves and Jones, two seventh rounders, cashed in during FA.

                  Quite frankly, a thinking man would say you need to weed out failures in a selection process such as these. Not keep them around like Hutch, Henson, get it??????????

                  How soon we forget how bad Jones is by celebrating his high profile, attention seeking boondoogles. Please, don't even start comparing Jones to Parcells. It really discredits any serious football discussion.

                  And yes, I am rooting for Miami now. In two years truly running that show, I know where they will be. Not so sure here in Dallas.

                  FYI, it was KEVIN WILLIAMS over Newman to whoever forgets. Williams is a Pro bowler by the way and younger than TNew..............

                  Comment


                  • #54
                    Originally posted by D-Unit View Post
                    Parcells is Mozart except when it comes to selecting offensive lineman. He can coach them, sure. But I don't buy that he's got the best eye for evaluating OL talent.

                    Here is the difference between Parcells and Jerry. Parcells will go with his true and tested forumula every single time. He will not stray from it one inch. If the direction goes that way, he doesn't want to be associated with it. ie. TO coming to Dallas. He acts the way old guys typically act. They don't like change. They like knowing how things work and when it's working, they don't want to mess with it. Parcells has a philosophy and he'll always play safe and feel safe by following it.

                    Jerry is the forever adapting, forever changing risk taker. He'll go for the gusto. If he swings and misses, it doesn't bother him. He wants to hit the home run. Mistakes are an accepted result. He'll try to learn from it and move on. There is no one written formula that works for him. There is no rules which will tell him what to do or how to act. He'll take a little from here, a little from there, see what he likes and puts his own little tweak to it. That way he can call it his in the end. There is no method to follow. He'll fly by the seat of his pants.

                    Which is the better method? Playing safe doesn't alway equal ultimate success. It will increase your chances of improvement, but will it help you reach the top? It's more a preventative method to ensure you don't hit the low lows. Your chances are just about the same as the risk taker who runs by no rules. The highs and troughs are more extreme with the risk taker, but in the end, if you only have one goal of winning the SB, Jerry's method is probably the better method. If you have a goal of maintaining a string of winning seasons, Parcells method is probably more effective, but there's a reason why he's only won 2 SBs in his entire career while Jerry has won more in much less time, even though Jerry has lost more too.

                    I don't think it's fair to call Jerry an idiot and praise Bill. It's just two different approaches. Jerry will take you on high highs and low lows. Bill will give you more stability and try to keep you satisfied, but don't hate him if he doesn't take you to the top. That's not what his philosophy is built for.
                    I still have yet to see Jerry's "High High" D. He is not a good bus driver. He is an entertaining passenger however.

                    Seriously man, he does not know what he is doing in terms of building a team top-to-bottom that is consisent over timewith schemes and philosaphy.

                    As crazy as Al Dvis is -- you know exactly what he wants all the time and he just wants coaches to execute the vision.

                    Jones does not have a vision of what kind of football he wants the team to play so we are forever accumulating talent but none of it fits.

                    Comment


                    • #55
                      Originally posted by pocketaces View Post
                      Pretty universal that we had a good to very good draft except for a few short sighted "fans". These same "fans" were saying the same thing about the Eagles and how great their front office was/is as they are this year about the Dolphins. Seems theres alot of great GM's/ front office people in the league not named Jerrah but have yet to win the titles he has, not to mention we went 13-3 last year with inferior talent and little hope for the future. :roll: :roll:
                      Um, D, here we go again. All I know is I tend to get the last laugh.

                      How did Tony look last year once the weather got colder and the Defense picked up????? How about that Roy Williams? How about calling out our need to rebuild the DB corps LAST YEAR? Which we just did this offseason. Spears to NT? Henry to FS? Calling last year's draft a waste b/c all we got where back-ups that would not really contribute? See what the G-Men did with Rookies??????????????????

                      Anyway. You can talk all you want about how wonderful Jerry is as an Owner but you can not point to any meaningful success with him as GM. Reid rebuilt the Eagles. When did Jones ever build anything in football? It was Johnson and Parcells.

                      So go be Wade Phillips and celebrate 13-3 and playoff losers if you want. I am sure you probably wore your Cowboys Jersey of Roy Williams the Sunday after the Super Bowl. Hey, celebrate Pro Bowls.

                      Argue with facts all you want because you will continue to have to live with the results on the field. No playoff wins in forever ...........

                      Comment


                      • #56
                        Why are you a fan of a team whose Owner you hate? Do you realize how stupid that is? Jerry isn't going anywhere, complaining about him is about as dumb as a Steelers fan complaing about the Rooney's.


                        Just move on to something else other then Jerry's incompetence and Roy Williams, thats all your post are ever about...I realize your a pessimist, and thats what you do is point out the negatives, because with some people they like the negativity more so then anything else, but its OLD, you make post after post saying the same thing...Jerry's not going anywhere, if you want, the Dolphins will accept you as a fan, then you can be happy about every move you make.


                        Somebody needs to remind me how to use the ignore function again, if your not going to offer anything new to the argument other then the same two arguements its a waste of everyones time.
                        Last edited by LonghornsLegend; 04-29-2008, 11:37 AM.





                        Originally posted by Scott Wright
                        I guarantee that if someone picks Cam Newton in the Top 5 they will regret it.

                        Comment


                        • #57
                          Originally posted by LonghornsLegend View Post
                          Why are you a fan of a team whose Owner you hate? Do you realize how stupid that is? Jerry isn't going anywhere, complaining about him is about as dumb as a Steelers fan complaing about the Rooney's.


                          Just move on to something else other then Jerry's incompetence and Roy Williams, thats all your post are ever about...I realize your a pessimist, and thats what you do is point out the negatives, because with some people they like the negativity more so then anything else, but its OLD, you make post after post saying the same thing...Jerry's not going anywhere, if you want, the Dolphins will accept you as a fan, then you can be happy about every move you make.


                          Somebody needs to remind me how to use the ignore function again, if your not going to offer anything new to the argument other then the same two arguements its a waste of everyones times.
                          agreed, gotta take the bad with with the good Bob, Jerry will never change, and is not leaving anytime soon.

                          Comment


                          • #58
                            Originally posted by Or Moyal View Post
                            To me, the Choice pick was a little depressing. I look at that guyís scouting report and see a poor manís MB3 (keeping in mind that MB3 was himself perceived to be a poor manís MB3 as a fourth round draft pick in Ď05) which signals the departure of the Barbarian. The team tried to offer Barber a reasonable contract, and now that he has declined they are preparing for contingency plans. I like Choice the player, but the pick was not necessarily a need at that point unless one subscribes to the theory that MB3 will be wearing a different jersey. B-.
                            I don't know why im wasting my time on this post, but seriously, Tashard Choice in the 4th round means Barber is gone? If that was the thought process, we would of never took Felix Jones, Choice isn't a guy we plan on running 20+ times a game, if that was the thought process we just take Mendenhall since he can carry the load.


                            Lets quit all the conspiracy theories, you don't use a mid 4th rd pick to replace a pro bowler.





                            Originally posted by Scott Wright
                            I guarantee that if someone picks Cam Newton in the Top 5 they will regret it.

                            Comment


                            • #59
                              Originally posted by bobindallas View Post
                              Um, D, here we go again. All I know is I tend to get the last laugh.

                              How did Tony look last year once the weather got colder and the Defense picked up????? How about that Roy Williams? How about calling out our need to rebuild the DB corps LAST YEAR? Which we just did this offseason. Spears to NT? Henry to FS? Calling last year's draft a waste b/c all we got where back-ups that would not really contribute? See what the G-Men did with Rookies??????????????????

                              Anyway. You can talk all you want about how wonderful Jerry is as an Owner but you can not point to any meaningful success with him as GM. Reid rebuilt the Eagles. When did Jones ever build anything in football? It was Johnson and Parcells.

                              So go be Wade Phillips and celebrate 13-3 and playoff losers if you want. I am sure you probably wore your Cowboys Jersey of Roy Williams the Sunday after the Super Bowl. Hey, celebrate Pro Bowls.

                              Argue with facts all you want because you will continue to have to live with the results on the field. No playoff wins in forever ...........
                              At this point, you're not even a Cowboys fan. You're rooting for them to lose so you can be right. It's sad.

                              If you get the last laugh, why is Roy still on the team? Why is Spears still at DE? Why is Henry still at CB?

                              Nobody ever said Roy is good for the team. We simply acknowledge that we MUST live with him. Nobody will trade for him and we can't cut him. The best we can hope for is for him to take a pay cut and try to improve himself. I don't see how you get the last laugh.

                              Last I checked Spears was our best run stuffing DL. I'd love to at least try him out at NT, but I don't think he has the mentality for it. He's a "me first" guy. He wants his stats. He doesn't want the dirty work of a NT without any glory. That's why he was upset with Parcells' style of Defense... saying it held him back. While he didn't have a bad year under Phillips, he didn't have a breakout year which many were hoping for. But as far as last laughs go, Parcells made a mistake selecting Spears. It's a good thing Jerry convinced him that DWare needed to be taken at 13.

                              Henry was our Defensive MVP at CB before he got hurt. He can still play the position. The fact that he could potentially play FS is only a plus. It's been an option for several years now. What last laugh do you have? You think you were the first one to come up with that idea? Get over yourself.

                              Comment


                              • #60
                                That's the problem with you, rob. When we do something negative, it's Jerry's fault, when we do something right not. For you Jerry has no merit in our three super bowl wins (all the merit is to attribute to Jimmy Johnson who, btw, was pretty unsuccesfull after he left Dallas) in the 90's, but all the blame for the lack of success in the 00's.

                                You're acting like Parcells has all the merit for the talented team we have. I think Parcells was very important for us, he helped us A LOT. But at the same time we have to consider the negative aspects too. First of all, our offense would have never been that good with him and if our offense was the second best in the NFL part of the merit goes to TO, who was a Jerry's choice, not Parcells'. Our defense also progressed under Wade's scheme. Yes, a lot of our guys were brought in by Parcells and he deserves a lot of merit for doing that. He brought a lot of talent to this team but we should also consider that he was far from perfect. He was hopeless at drafting offensive linemen (except for Gurode) and I'm sure that he would have not been favor of bringing Bigg Davis (another Jerry's choice) who is, as of now, the second best guard in the NFC. Also, you hate Kosier, and Kosier was a Parcells' choice.
                                And the list goes on...
                                So, in conclusion, we all have to be grateful to Parcells because he was able to fill this team with talent and to begin the turn-around, but we also have to consider his mistakes and the fact that the team progressed last year and become a real contender.


                                In Bob We Trust

                                John Madden's wedding video business

                                http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ddPHJWkPvU

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information