Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Dallas Cowboys Discussion

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by FreshBoy! View Post
    Sense played very well....why would you hope for a 2nd rounder? We'd be incredibly thin and young at safety(assuming Hamlin gets replaced with a rookie)
    Cause I think there are guys that will have much better NFL careers than Sensy who will be drafted in the 2nd round.

    Sensy was ok. He wasn't irreplaceably good, imo.

    Comment


    • Sensy is more of a sure thing though. I think you could have your cake and eat it to with him. They could draft a young guy with some potential, but keep him there so that a rookie isn't thrown to the wolves early.
      "If you have one finger pointing at somebody, you have three pointing towards yourself."
      ~Nigerian Proverb

      Da riddum is too much for you.
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5nKx27QrgO0

      Comment


      • Originally posted by E-Man View Post
        Sensy is more of a sure thing though. I think you could have your cake and eat it to with him. They could draft a young guy with some potential, but keep him there so that a rookie isn't thrown to the wolves early.
        There's plenty of reasons to believe a rookie can have a more positive impact. Louis Delmas, Sean Smith, Jairus Byrd were all 2nd round safeties last year who burst on the scene. This year's safety class is talented too.

        In fact, in some ways the top tier scare me more than the 2nd tier. Berry isn't a Top 3 prospect in most years. He's being highly overrated. Honestly, I don't think he separates himself that much from Delmas, Smith and Byrd. Also, Earl Thomas and Taylor Mays both have glaring weaknesses of their own.

        The 2nd tier is where we may find more substance... I wouldn't be shocked at all if Reshad Jones, Chad Jones, and Nate Allen outshined their more highly touted peers.

        Comment


        • Originally posted by D-Unit View Post
          In fact, in some ways the top tier scare me more than the 2nd tier. Berry isn't a Top 3 prospect in most years. He's being highly overrated. Honestly, I don't think he separates himself that much from Delmas, Smith and Byrd. Also, Earl Thomas and Taylor Mays both have glaring weaknesses of their own.
          I would agree that Taylor Mays and Earl Thomas have some question marks, but Eric Berry is the real deal. I don't think there has been this blend of intelligence, athleticism, and instinct in a DB prospect in years. His combine workouts were exemplary, and the great film on him is a mile long.

          The dropoff from Eric Berry to all of the other safeties is pretty steep, imho. Whoever gets this kid is getting a real prize.

          Comment


          • D has been down on Eric Berry for over a year...ever since the hype train started and he argued that Taylor Mays was a better safety. His views aren't going to change this late into the process. All you have to do to love this kid is listen to him talk. His physical attributes and on the field play speak for themselves. But an educated smart kid who has a good head on his shoulders...I see a Warrick Dunn type NFL contribution out of this kid...I love every single thing about him.

            Comment


            • Originally posted by D-Unit View Post
              There's plenty of reasons to believe a rookie can have a more positive impact. Louis Delmas, Sean Smith, Jairus Byrd were all 2nd round safeties last year who burst on the scene. This year's safety class is talented too.

              In fact, in some ways the top tier scare me more than the 2nd tier. Berry isn't a Top 3 prospect in most years. He's being highly overrated. Honestly, I don't think he separates himself that much from Delmas, Smith and Byrd. Also, Earl Thomas and Taylor Mays both have glaring weaknesses of their own.

              The 2nd tier is where we may find more substance... I wouldn't be shocked at all if Reshad Jones, Chad Jones, and Nate Allen outshined their more highly touted peers.
              Byrd played as a cover 2 safety....I don't think cover 2 safeties can really be judged against other teams. They almost always cover half the field and are never in man situations....Byrd in our scheme was as big of a concern if not more than Earl Thomas coming out...

              I don't get all the 2nd tier love. I'm fine with Mays and Berry question marks...but Reshad was JAG in college...to be completely honest I didn't even know there was a Georgia safety in this class until the postseason started...that is how little I noticed the guy on the field. Atleast Berry and Mays and Thomas appeared on the camera....I can't get hyped up about a prospect from watching highlight videos....so maybe I'm missing the boat but I don't see anything from him.

              Chad Jones...palease....this is the same guy that was suppose to blow up at the combine....hell he is a better baseball player then football and even voiced that baseball was his true love...a guy who can't even be in top shape for the combine that has a true love for another sport...no thanks.

              Nate Allen is the only guy I see a legit arguement for....I'd also add Burnett to the discussion as they seem to be the clearcut 4-5 at this point. However I don't think either is available at our 2nd pick....and neither warrants 27. Allen had 2 premier NCAA pass rushers on his team yet still faded down the stretch? He didn't do anything to help/hurt his stock in the post season...I'm just not sold.

              Burnett is the odd ball...yet him not going on the combine leaves some question marks at this point. He definitely has it on tape....so those numbers are pretty important for him...that said it's a pretty clear talent drop off from the top tier to the 2nd tier. That second tier looks like trash to me. I'd rather go into the season with Hamlin/Sensy/Ball/Hamlin/Watkins again...I don't see the increase in talent on the roster with those 2nd tier guys.

              Comment


              • Originally posted by thule View Post
                D has been down on Eric Berry for over a year...ever since the hype train started and he argued that Taylor Mays was a better safety. His views aren't going to change this late into the process. All you have to do to love this kid is listen to him talk. His physical attributes and on the field play speak for themselves. But an educated smart kid who has a good head on his shoulders...I see a Warrick Dunn type NFL contribution out of this kid...I love every single thing about him.
                Why would you say that? I have changed my views. I don't sit here talking about how much Mays is better than Berry anymore.

                I'm just being honest. Maybe Berry will have a great career, but it's hard for me to think he'll have a better rookie year than Delmas and Bryd. ...and if I can't think that, then hoping for a better career over the long term is also a reach.

                ...and honestly... Berry might not be a Top 3 pick this year. He's definitely not a Top 3 pick in most other years.

                I'm not being down on the guy... but the hype on him is TOO much.

                Comment


                • Originally posted by thule View Post
                  Byrd played as a cover 2 safety....I don't think cover 2 safeties can really be judged against other teams. They almost always cover half the field and are never in man situations....Byrd in our scheme was as big of a concern if not more than Earl Thomas coming out...

                  I don't get all the 2nd tier love. I'm fine with Mays and Berry question marks...but Reshad was JAG in college...to be completely honest I didn't even know there was a Georgia safety in this class until the postseason started...that is how little I noticed the guy on the field. Atleast Berry and Mays and Thomas appeared on the camera....I can't get hyped up about a prospect from watching highlight videos....so maybe I'm missing the boat but I don't see anything from him.

                  Chad Jones...palease....this is the same guy that was suppose to blow up at the combine....hell he is a better baseball player then football and even voiced that baseball was his true love...a guy who can't even be in top shape for the combine that has a true love for another sport...no thanks.

                  Nate Allen is the only guy I see a legit arguement for....I'd also add Burnett to the discussion as they seem to be the clearcut 4-5 at this point. However I don't think either is available at our 2nd pick....and neither warrants 27. Allen had 2 premier NCAA pass rushers on his team yet still faded down the stretch? He didn't do anything to help/hurt his stock in the post season...I'm just not sold.

                  Burnett is the odd ball...yet him not going on the combine leaves some question marks at this point. He definitely has it on tape....so those numbers are pretty important for him...that said it's a pretty clear talent drop off from the top tier to the 2nd tier. That second tier looks like trash to me. I'd rather go into the season with Hamlin/Sensy/Ball/Hamlin/Watkins again...I don't see the increase in talent on the roster with those 2nd tier guys.
                  The difference is basically this: hype.

                  That's all. Berry had the large benefit of being overly hyped up in the beginning of the year. Heisman they said. So everything he did well, got exemplified 100 times over. ...every mistake was candy coded, and every invisible game gets attributed to the excuse that teams didn't come at him. Another guy could do exactly the same thing, but it would go unnoticed. It doesn't surprise me at all that you think Reshad is a JAG and he didn't do anything to stick out. Maybe you think I'm sold of Reshad based off a few highlight plays. To me it isn't about his "youtube highlight plays" as much as it is seeing the way he moves, thinks, reacts, hits and covers. I could watch a clip of 2 different guys coming away with INTs, but could come away with 2 totally different opinions. It's why I don't want to put Morgan Burnett in my 2nd tier. He has fantastic "youtube highlights"... but imo, he doesn't move well. He'll end up being more of that JAG type, imo. He doesn't have that x factor that makes him nasty like Resahd.

                  Chad Jones is near the same size as Taylor Mays, but it never got advertised, so that news might even shock people. Difference is Mays is ripped like a mother and had been locking guys out of the endzone up until this year. So the guy likes baseball and that's a bad thing? Why? If you want to question his passion for the game, then I think you'd be sorely mistaken. Jones oozes athleticism in his own right, and some scouts had him rising up the first round before our 27th pick as of late. This is the time of year when scouts put aside hype and start putting out their legit grades. That's why.

                  Nate Allen is in the same boat as Earl Thomas imo. Both self made this year off a stream of big plays. They emerged from the unknown into the known. To say Allen cooled off is a fair statement, but only because the guy was RED HOT. Teams learned to stay away from his direction as the season progressed. Read anything about him at the Senior Bowl and the guy outplayed a lot of corners and looked more fluid than them in drills. If we strictly want a man cover Safety, then Allen is a DEFINITE guy we want to target. The guy reminds me of Darren Sharper. He uses his head on the field. Intelligent player.

                  All 3 guys have weaknesses of their own, but is it that much of a difference? I would never pay the price of a Top 3 pick for Berry with how deep this safety class is. Put me in the boat that says these 2nd tier safeties could be equally good or better than their 1st tier counterparts in the NFL.

                  Comment


                  • Ok, it's officially time to be excited about this being a realistic possibility:


                    After assigning him just a first-round tender, the Ravens are believed to be willing to move restricted free agent LT Jared Gaither.
                    Gaither would've gotten the first- and third-round tender if the Ravens were truly intent on keeping him. The Ravens want to move Michael Oher to left tackle. The Baltimore Sun suggests four possible destinations for Gaither: San Francisco, Indianapolis, Dallas, and Seattle. Teams targeting Gaither could probably work out a deal for less than the first-round pick.
                    Source: Baltimore Sun


                    What do you guys think? Gaither at LT, Free at RT? Gaither is exactly the type of lineman we love in Dallas, young, and definately a franchise LT. Is he worth 27 to you? Also key to note he could be had for a 2nd and something else.


                    I want it done, consider me sold, I'm on board :D


                    edit:


                    It's also been reported we have already contacted them regarding him:


                    According to NFL Network and ESPN last night, the 49ers, Cowboys and Seahawks and contacted the Ravens with regards to Jared Gaither.
                    Last edited by LonghornsLegend; 03-07-2010, 01:35 PM.





                    Originally posted by Scott Wright
                    I guarantee that if someone picks Cam Newton in the Top 5 they will regret it.

                    Comment


                    • Originally posted by D-Unit View Post
                      There's plenty of reasons to believe a rookie can have a more positive impact. Louis Delmas, Sean Smith, Jairus Byrd were all 2nd round safeties last year who burst on the scene. This year's safety class is talented too.

                      In fact, in some ways the top tier scare me more than the 2nd tier. Berry isn't a Top 3 prospect in most years. He's being highly overrated. Honestly, I don't think he separates himself that much from Delmas, Smith and Byrd. Also, Earl Thomas and Taylor Mays both have glaring weaknesses of their own.

                      The 2nd tier is where we may find more substance... I wouldn't be shocked at all if Reshad Jones, Chad Jones, and Nate Allen outshined their more highly touted peers.
                      There are reasons to think that a rookie can have a more positive impact than Sensy, but there still is a large lack of a guarantee. Those guys you listed had good rookie years, but that's not always a certain thing. You also have to remember who is on the Cowboys' defense. You've got two pretty good corners, and an experienced safety. The rookie is going to get picked on far more than Jenkins, Newman, and Hamlin or Sensy. I want a safety picked high, but there needs to be some vet insurance in case he isn't ready yet. I think Sensy is pretty valuable in that regard, because he's a good starter that could help ease the transition if they aren't going to cut Hamlin.
                      "If you have one finger pointing at somebody, you have three pointing towards yourself."
                      ~Nigerian Proverb

                      Da riddum is too much for you.
                      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5nKx27QrgO0

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by LonghornsLegend View Post
                        Ok, it's officially time to be excited about this being a realistic possibility:






                        What do you guys think? Gaither at LT, Free at RT? Gaither is exactly the type of lineman we love in Dallas, young, and definately a franchise LT. Is he worth 27 to you? Also key to note he could be had for a 2nd and something else.


                        I want it done, consider me sold, I'm on board :D


                        edit:


                        It's also been reported we have already contacted them regarding him:
                        I like this idea a lot better than the idea of trading or signing for A. Bethea which has also been floating around. I guess with any restricted signing we have to consider then what linemen might be available if we picked in the late 1st. That list might include Iupati, Campbell, Pouncey, and Williams. Predicting their potential for development and Gaither's current skill set makes this a little complex. Gaither is a solid pass blocker and could hold down the left side adequately for another 6-8 years, but one of those four might reach a higher ceiling at their position down the road. All in all, signing Gaither makes a lot of sense especially if we can somehow still hold onto our first.

                        By the way, the Ravens are looking for a Defensive End aren't they? If by trade we can get him for say Marcus Spears and maybe a third or fourth rounder or something of that nature, hell I'd definately be on board too.
                        Last edited by bluebonnet78; 03-07-2010, 02:48 PM.

                        Comment


                        • Good find LL. I'm all for Gaither.

                          Comment


                          • Can someone explain what the go is with something like that. Say this situation where three teams are willing to trade there first to sign the player. Does the offering team just take the highest draft pick or does the player get any say in the decision for trade?

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by shane_man View Post
                              Can someone explain what the go is with something like that. Say this situation where three teams are willing to trade there first to sign the player. Does the offering team just take the highest draft pick or does the player get any say in the decision for trade?
                              Alright i'm going to try my hand on this and hopefully not muck it up. From my understanding of how NFL.com explains restricted free agency the player can negotiate with teams for a contract as any other free agent can. the player has the right to accept any offer of their choosing, but the catch is that the owning team first has a chance to match that offer. In this case I believe it would just come down to the team that makes Gaither the best offer...(Hopefully Jerry would make Gaither an offer he couldn't refuse, but that Final 8 crap might restrict matters.)

                              Now my understanding is kind of hazy in the situation where the player accepts an offer and during the window of time (a week i think) when the owning team can match the offer they instead try to quickly trade him to another team that also wants him and could offer more than what they would get for compensation from the team who is making the offer for the RFA. Theoretically it seems like the owning team could pull off a trade during this time period since they still own the rights to the player.

                              Of course if nobody offers him a contract that he accepts, it would be dependent on who makes the best trade offer with the team...

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by bluebonnet78 View Post
                                Alright i'm going to try my hand on this and hopefully not muck it up. From my understanding of how NFL.com explains restricted free agency the player can negotiate with teams for a contract as any other free agent can. the player has the right to accept any offer of their choosing, but the catch is that the owning team first has a chance to match that offer. In this case I believe it would just come down to the team that makes Gaither the best offer...(Hopefully Jerry would make Gaither an offer he couldn't refuse, but that Final 8 crap might restrict matters.)

                                Now my understanding is kind of hazy in the situation where the player accepts an offer and during the window of time (a week i think) when the owning team can match the offer they instead try to quickly trade him to another team that also wants him and could offer more than what they would get for compensation from the team who is making the offer for the RFA. Theoretically it seems like the owning team could pull off a trade during this time period since they still own the rights to the player.

                                Of course if nobody offers him a contract that he accepts, it would be dependent on who makes the best trade offer with the team...
                                If the Cowboys have contacted the Ravens about Gaither, it's likely that the way they'd acquire him would be by trading for his rights with the Ravens, rather than signing him to an offer sheet.

                                If, as you suggest, it comes down to offer sheets, then the pick that the Ravens acquire obviously would depend on the team whose offer sheet Gaither signs.

                                I believe, according to recent history, that directly trading for Gaither's rights would be much more likely, as we've seen very few teams give up high round picks in offer sheet-type deals. There have been some examples of teams signing players to an offer sheet for whom the compensation is a lower round pick, but for players who have been tendered in the top 3 tiers (that is, usually non-draft level tenders), trades have been the rule. The obvious example is Wes Welker to the Patriots a couple of years back where the Dolphins tendered Welker at the 2nd round level, and the Patriots, rather than signing Welker to an offer sheet and then sending the 2nd round pick to the Dolphins, instead traded with the Phins to acquire Welker's rights. In that case they thought Welker valuable enough to even send along a 7th round pick to facilitate things.

                                Edit: Just for clarification, the Final 8 rule does not apply here, because we're talking about Restricted Free Agents, and the rule only applies to unrestricted free agents. If Gaither had not been tendered by the Ravens, he would become unrestricted, and then the Final 8 rule would come into play.
                                Last edited by JJJ888; 03-08-2010, 07:26 PM.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information