Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Miami Dolphins Discussion

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Thank you. Look who is throwing to Chris Chambers. Look at a guy like Calvin Johnson. The completion % for passes thrown to him is around 50%. But he may be the best WR prospect ever. Chambers does not have the caliber QB those other guys have. You talked about Donald Driver. Look who he has throwing to him. Chambers is a #1 receiver in the NFL. There are not 32 WRs better than him. Using stats and thinking is is 100% truth doesn't make sense. You have to look at the situations these guys are in.

    Also if Troy Smith had the best game ever he might have been a late round 1 guy at best.

    That is correct comahan
    I ******* LOVE YOU DG
    <3 dg

    Comment


    • dg, where do u see troy smith being drafted now?

      credit to cardsalltheway

      Comment


      • Originally posted by draftguru151
        Thank you. Look who is throwing to Chris Chambers. Look at a guy like Calvin Johnson. The completion % for passes thrown to him is around 50%. But he may be the best WR prospect ever. Chambers does not have the caliber QB those other guys have. You talked about Donald Driver. Look who he has throwing to him. Chambers is a #1 receiver in the NFL. There are not 32 WRs better than him. Using stats and thinking is is 100% truth doesn't make sense. You have to look at the situations these guys are in.

        Also if Troy Smith had the best game ever he might have been a late round 1 guy at best.
        I detailed that in my talks over and over again. My point though to counter that is there is Not 32 Number 1s in the NFL. Some teams have players that act as their number one target, but they are not an elite WR.

        Chambers is not a top 10 or top 15 WR in the NFL right now. Even though I love the guy on the fins and wouldnt trade him. He is a great number 2

        Comment


        • Originally posted by BehrenMan007
          dg, where do u see troy smith being drafted now?
          Right now second round, maybe third. It really depends on his workouts and how tall he actually is.

          That is correct comahan
          I ******* LOVE YOU DG
          <3 dg

          Comment


          • Originally posted by Finsfan79
            Originally posted by draftguru151
            Thank you. Look who is throwing to Chris Chambers. Look at a guy like Calvin Johnson. The completion % for passes thrown to him is around 50%. But he may be the best WR prospect ever. Chambers does not have the caliber QB those other guys have. You talked about Donald Driver. Look who he has throwing to him. Chambers is a #1 receiver in the NFL. There are not 32 WRs better than him. Using stats and thinking is is 100% truth doesn't make sense. You have to look at the situations these guys are in.

            Also if Troy Smith had the best game ever he might have been a late round 1 guy at best.
            I detailed that in my talks over and over again. My point though to counter that is there is Not 32 Number 1s in the NFL. Some teams have players that act as their number one target, but they are not an elite WR.

            Chambers is not a top 10 or top 15 WR in the NFL right now. Even though I love the guy on the fins and wouldnt trade him. He is a great number 2
            That doesn't make any sense then. He isn't a top 15 guy so he isn't a #1? Chris Chambers is not a #2. He isn't a complementary guy. He has shown he can dominate. He led the AFC in TDs last year. He is one of the best redzone threats in the NFL and with a guy that could actually throw a deep ball last year he got by DBs multiple times. No he isn't going to get 1000 yards or catch 100 balls but he is a very good receiver. This year can not be put all on him. Yes he struggled, but he had Joey Harrington who couldn't throw a deep ball to save his life.

            That is correct comahan
            I ******* LOVE YOU DG
            <3 dg

            Comment


            • Originally posted by Finsfan79
              Originally posted by draftguru151
              Thank you. Look who is throwing to Chris Chambers. Look at a guy like Calvin Johnson. The completion % for passes thrown to him is around 50%. But he may be the best WR prospect ever. Chambers does not have the caliber QB those other guys have. You talked about Donald Driver. Look who he has throwing to him. Chambers is a #1 receiver in the NFL. There are not 32 WRs better than him. Using stats and thinking is is 100% truth doesn't make sense. You have to look at the situations these guys are in.

              Also if Troy Smith had the best game ever he might have been a late round 1 guy at best.
              I detailed that in my talks over and over again. My point though to counter that is there is Not 32 Number 1s in the NFL. Some teams have players that act as their number one target, but they are not an elite WR.

              Chambers is not a top 10 or top 15 WR in the NFL right now. Even though I love the guy on the fins and wouldnt trade him. He is a great number 2
              how can he be a top 15 WR in the nfl if the offense has no continuity

              7 qbs in his 6 year career in the nfl

              gus
              culpepper
              fiedler
              sage
              lemon
              feeley
              harrington

              3 head coaches (about to be 4)

              saban
              bates
              wanndstedt

              offensive coordinators

              mularkey
              linehan
              turner
              gailey

              IMO thats like going to 7 different teams in your career .. theres no CHEMISTRY at all

              Comment


              • Originally posted by Athrun340
                Originally posted by Finsfan79
                Originally posted by draftguru151
                Thank you. Look who is throwing to Chris Chambers. Look at a guy like Calvin Johnson. The completion % for passes thrown to him is around 50%. But he may be the best WR prospect ever. Chambers does not have the caliber QB those other guys have. You talked about Donald Driver. Look who he has throwing to him. Chambers is a #1 receiver in the NFL. There are not 32 WRs better than him. Using stats and thinking is is 100% truth doesn't make sense. You have to look at the situations these guys are in.

                Also if Troy Smith had the best game ever he might have been a late round 1 guy at best.
                I detailed that in my talks over and over again. My point though to counter that is there is Not 32 Number 1s in the NFL. Some teams have players that act as their number one target, but they are not an elite WR.

                Chambers is not a top 10 or top 15 WR in the NFL right now. Even though I love the guy on the fins and wouldnt trade him. He is a great number 2
                how can he be a top 15 WR in the nfl if the offense has no continuity

                7 qbs in his 6 year career in the nfl

                gus
                culpepper
                fiedler
                sage
                lemon
                feeley
                harrington

                3 head coaches (about to be 4)

                saban
                bates
                wanndstedt

                offensive coordinators

                mularkey
                linehan
                turner
                gailey

                IMO thats like going to 7 different teams in your career .. theres no CHEMISTRY at all
                Which adds into my opinion of his lack of being a number 1 in the NFL yet he has the potential to be a good wr. He has not put up the production so far to be worthy of the title of a number 1 elite WR in the NFL. I went into the fact of the lack of continuity and also into the lack of players around CC. But, all together he has no produced in the fashion of being a number 1. Eventually one needs to look at the potential and talent and just decide perhaps it is what it is. Perhaps part of the debate here is how you view a number 1.

                I believe that just because a WR is the top WR on a team does not make him a number 1 WR in the NFL. A number 1 WR in the NFL is an elite WR that stands out above others on their team and could go to almost any team and be the leader of that team.

                Marvin Harrison, Torry Holt, Boldin, Fitzgerald, etc etc etc.

                I dont believe there is 20 or even 30 number 1s in the NFL currently. I see them as being a top elite player at that position. I do not prescribe to the notion that SF has a number 1 type of WR, or atlanta having a number 1.

                I am not trying to bash chris and I am not saying trade chris like another suggested. My premise is simply right now he is really a number 2 type of wr. An above league average WR that can make some big plays but is inconsistent and often shows it as less then an Elite type of guys.

                Comment


                • Hey guys here's a site that has all of the top UFA and RFA.

                  http://www.footballsfuture.com/2007/nfl/freeagents.html

                  Comment


                  • I hope Calvin Johnson somehow falls. :shock:

                    We need to hurry and sign a coach or our organization is going to run itself around in circles
                    Vince Young is going to prove he's the next overrated QB to come out in years.

                    He'll probably end up being a WR or something...

                    Comment


                    • And am I the only person that thinks that drafting a QB would be a terrible decision? Why have so many people given up on Culpepper without him even playing a full healthly season? I don't understand it, he needs to be given a true chance before everyone is ready to throw him under the bus.
                      Vince Young is going to prove he's the next overrated QB to come out in years.

                      He'll probably end up being a WR or something...

                      Comment


                      • people have given up on C-pep because hes been injured the past two years and hes hitting the ripe age of 30 this year. granted i know that isnt old but culpepper is a MUCH worse QB without his mobility and noone knows if he will be able to regain that mobility with the reconstructed knee. in addition, as he gets older, the physical beating hes taken his whole career plus the weight he carries will cause his body to deteriorate faster than others. im not saying he cant have 5 more productive seasons, i just dont know how much faith the organization or fans have in him.

                        i dont think we should draft a QB in the 1st round but i would love drew stanton in round 2 because that way he could sit a couple of years behind culpepper. plus we havent drafted a QB since marino retired (ok we took one in like the 6th round one year i think?) and it would just be nice to see this organization bring in some youth through the draft and commit to developing someone to be the starter that was grown in-house instead of continuing to trade or sign other teams backups. plus there is no depth cause if c-pep goes down i have little faith in lemon or harrington.

                        sig by BoneKrusher

                        Comment


                        • on the coaching search, martz was invterviewed and it looks like brian schottenheimer and mike singletary are next up. and maybe an official interview for bates.

                          A source said the Dolphins will meet with Detroit Lions offensive coordinator Mike Martz, and the Newark Star-Ledger reported that they'll also meet with Jets offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer, son of San Diego Chargers coach Marty Schottenheimer, in the next few days.
                          Bailey also lauded San Francisco 49ers assistant head coach and linebackers coach Mike Singletary, hinting at an upcoming interview. Former Dolphins interim head coach Jim Bates is also believed to be under consideration.

                          http://www.sun-sentinel.com/sports/s...a-sports-front

                          sig by BoneKrusher

                          Comment


                          • My favorite possible offseason/draft would be the following:

                            Sign Samuels CB NE in the offseason away

                            (saw this recently in the mock area I like the idea)
                            Trade back to the 15th pick with Pitt and pick up a 2nd and 5th rounder.


                            1st Ginn Jr WR - We will most likely lose Welker to FA, Booker could be a cap loss. Ginn gives us a speedburner which we havent had for a while and a return man as well. Brohm if he is there also.

                            2nd Jared Gaither - LT - Monsterously huge left tackle, just like houck likes them. He gave up 2 sacks in 2 years there in college. He is a big beast and would be perfect for ronnie to run behind. Mac is a FA, James a cap loss. Toledo seems a good canidate for LG and Shelton has fit in well at RG and Carey is a good RT. Gaither will sure up the line which is key for the future of the fins.

                            2nd Josh Beekman - OG - Powerful guard that could make an instant impact for the team joining us to fill up the other guard position, it allows us to dump James (4+ million next year) and not depend on toledo getting healthy.

                            3rd Brandon Merriweather - S - Gives us another great secondary player. Dropped for problems on and off the field with the fight and all but he is a top flight safety and would be a late 1st otherwise perhaps early 2nd.

                            This draft would give us a WR Core with Chambers and Ginn Jr, Hagan and Vick and others. A nice young core of WRs and save money from booker being gone (traded for a 5th or cut, save 4 million for FA).

                            New Oline

                            RT Carey
                            RG Shelton
                            C Rex
                            LG Beekman
                            LT Gaither

                            Keep Macintosh for a backup, Toldeo as well in there as well.

                            Secondary

                            CB W Allen
                            CB A Samuels
                            S Y Bell
                            S B Merriweather

                            J Allen as well fits in wherever we can get him playing time. Daniels as a nickel/dime.

                            thoughts? Saves us a large amount of money and also gets us a young good oline and defensive secondary.

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by Finsfan79
                              My favorite possible offseason/draft would be the following:

                              Sign Samuels CB NE in the offseason away

                              (saw this recently in the mock area I like the idea)
                              Trade back to the 15th pick with Pitt and pick up a 2nd and 5th rounder.


                              1st Ginn Jr WR - We will most likely lose Welker to FA, Booker could be a cap loss. Ginn gives us a speedburner which we havent had for a while and a return man as well. Brohm if he is there also.

                              2nd Jared Gaither - LT - Monsterously huge left tackle, just like houck likes them. He gave up 2 sacks in 2 years there in college. He is a big beast and would be perfect for ronnie to run behind. Mac is a FA, James a cap loss. Toledo seems a good canidate for LG and Shelton has fit in well at RG and Carey is a good RT. Gaither will sure up the line which is key for the future of the fins.

                              2nd Josh Beekman - OG - Powerful guard that could make an instant impact for the team joining us to fill up the other guard position, it allows us to dump James (4+ million next year) and not depend on toledo getting healthy.

                              3rd Brandon Merriweather - S - Gives us another great secondary player. Dropped for problems on and off the field with the fight and all but he is a top flight safety and would be a late 1st otherwise perhaps early 2nd.

                              This draft would give us a WR Core with Chambers and Ginn Jr, Hagan and Vick and others. A nice young core of WRs and save money from booker being gone (traded for a 5th or cut, save 4 million for FA).

                              New Oline

                              RT Carey
                              RG Shelton
                              C Rex
                              LG Beekman
                              LT Gaither

                              Keep Macintosh for a backup, Toldeo as well in there as well.

                              Secondary

                              CB W Allen
                              CB A Samuels
                              S Y Bell
                              S B Merriweather

                              J Allen as well fits in wherever we can get him playing time. Daniels as a nickel/dime.

                              thoughts? Saves us a large amount of money and also gets us a young good oline and defensive secondary.
                              I love the draft and the Samuel signing except for the G in the second, i would prefer to get a OLB to replace spragan and get a guard later in the draft. He just doesn't cut it anymore.

                              Comment


                              • I agree he doesnt but I think we can replace him in FA with someone. Just not sure whom yet. I need to look it all over more. I just gotta wonder if we keep the 3-4 or switch to the 4-3

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information