Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

New York Giants Discussion

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by Malaka
    I say he can play another 2 max 3 at a high level. I think he'd still be serviceable by years 4 and 5, but I am not sure he'd be able to lead us to the Super Bowl. At the end of the day, is the end goal not to win as many super bowls as possible?
    My concern is whether Eli will be able to consistently play up to the level of his contract

    Comment


    • Originally posted by Big_Pete View Post
      For me the question is not whether Nassib can beat out Eli.

      The question is more about value and return on investment. Eli is 33 and has a relatively limited window of opportunity. He hasn't played well in a year and a half and has a very large salary cap number.

      Can Eli, with this team, regain the kind of form that won him a pair of superbowl MVPs? Eli is very good, I just don't think he is the kind of guy who can carry a team by himself.

      If there are any doubts about Eli's ability to get this offense sizzling, then it is reasonable to consider trade options and gain some return on investment which can be reinvested into the team. This would be dependent if it was considered that Nassb and Freeman can do an adequate job.

      I know people talk about Coughlin hanging it up soon, but he will coach as long as he can, there is no reason to plan rosters around that possibility.

      He carried the team in 2011. In fact, our offense showed cracks then. I stated this at the time. We were dead last in the running game and throw our way to victory.

      He proved he can win without a running game and the ball has to be in his hands. I am not talking about retiring when it comes to Coughlin. It will come down to if he gets fired or not.

      Everyone has 2 year deals or less from the coaching staff down to Eli and the offensive players.

      We are on the clock in terms of sense of urgency.

      Comment


      • I miss you guys!

        *some h0m0*

        Comment


        • Originally posted by NY+Giants=NYG View Post
          He carried the team in 2011. In fact, our offense showed cracks then. I stated this at the time. We were dead last in the running game and throw our way to victory.

          He proved he can win without a running game and the ball has to be in his hands. I am not talking about retiring when it comes to Coughlin. It will come down to if he gets fired or not.

          Everyone has 2 year deals or less from the coaching staff down to Eli and the offensive players.

          We are on the clock in terms of sense of urgency.
          I totally agree with you on the cracks for the last couple of years. I do think the major problem has been talent.

          For the last few years we have been plugging holes and trying to get buy at certain positions rather than building for the future and ensuring we had enough quality talent developing behind our starters.

          I think Jerry Reese is more on the hot seat than Coughlin

          Comment


          • Will Hill facing another suspension. Ughh Will get it together.
            #Chop


            sig by BoneKrusher

            Comment


            • He'll probably never get it together.

              Comment


              • Reports are that we're done with him either way.
                #Chop


                sig by BoneKrusher

                Comment


                • Deone Bucannon is a guy I like in the 2nd.

                  Comment


                  • I've been saying it for awhile, don't be surprised if we look at Ha Ha. Even before this news I thought it was possible bc Rolle's contract is coming up.

                    Comment


                    • Well S is definitely back in play.
                      #Chop


                      sig by BoneKrusher

                      Comment


                      • Originally posted by Giantsfan1080
                        Giants Schedule:

                        Monday 9/8 at Lions
                        Sunday 9/14 vs Cardinals
                        Sunday 9/21 vs Texans
                        Thursday 9/25 at Washington
                        Sunday 10/5 vs Atlanta
                        Sunday 10/12 at Philly Sunday Night Football
                        Sunday 10/19 at Dallas
                        10/26 BYE
                        Monday 11/3 vs Indy
                        Sunday 11/9 at Seattle
                        Sunday 11/16 vs Niners
                        Sunday 11/23 vs Dallas Sunday Night Football
                        Sunday 11/30 at Jags
                        Sunday 12/7 at Titans
                        Sunday 12/14 vs Skins
                        Sunday 12/21 at Rams
                        Sunday 12/28 vs Philly
                        Our secondary better come together quickly. And closing the season out against philly? That could be for the division or a wildcard spot.

                        Comment


                        • Eli and Snee were drafted 10 years ago today. I'm friggin old.
                          #Chop


                          sig by BoneKrusher

                          Comment


                          • Way to ruin my morning GF

                            Comment


                            • If I'm going to feel old then dammit everyone else in here will also.
                              #Chop


                              sig by BoneKrusher

                              Comment


                              • I think out of Atlanta, Indy, Seattle and San Fran we go 2-2. Probably go 3-3 in the division. The rest of the games look very winnable. I could see us going anywhere from 9-7 to 11-5. Week 17 very well could be for the division

                                SPLOOSH

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X

                                Debug Information