If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Any reasoning or counteroffers would be appreciated
Sandoval / Snider is not a significant enough upgrade over Young / Upton to lose Brian Matusz in a keeper league.
Based on 2010 projections, with the former you are probably looking at a combined .300 AVG, 45 HR, 165 RBI, 150 R, 7 SB while the latter will net you about .285 AVG, 30 HR, 145 RBI, 165 R, 45 SB. Although you're passing up the opportunity to improve on three stats (RBI is really hard to judge though), you still keep a HUGE advantage in stolen bases and an advantage in runs while keeping one of the better young arms in the game. Matusz is projected for between 80-130 K's and 5-10 wins (with respectable ERA and WHIP), depending on innings pitched.
Losing Upton hurt big. Sandoval is a good acquisition because he is a decent backup to Young and Pena. Fowler can be better than Upton as your starting CF if he manages to steal more than 30 SB annually. Fowler at Coors helps lot for power categories.
Brian Matusz is unproven but young. I dont usually chase young southpaws because it is too darn inconsistent to count on during first 3 years of their service time.
If Upton rebounds back and Matusz pitches fairly well then you will get jacked. Otherwise, you will have to pay attention on SB department because your lineup will get killed by frequent strikeouts which may hurt your average and home run for most of days per week. Reyes is a risky factor right now since you dont have any promising SS to replace Reyes this year.
I would not trade Upton away right before this season begins but hey, it is the first year. Good Luck and Have a fun....