Vote Here, Whose Better?
 

Got into argument with my brother over whose the better saftey

Dawkins right now, Taylor in a couple years probably.

Dawkins.

I agree with Jensen.

I can't wait until seantaylor21 gets ahold of this one.

i agree and holy **** that is a nice sig

SEAN TAYLOR>GIBRIL WILSON

Brian Dawkins would be my vote. But I wouldn't be at all surprised if Taylor is the consensus best FS in the game after this upcoming season.

taylor and it isnt even close.

Taylor also has the potential to become one of the best ever.

Sean Taylor right now is better.

Taylor is better. Sean Taylor when it is all said a done will be one of if not the best safety of all time.

I'm waiting for toonster to verify this rumour.

If Taylor fufils his potential he could be the greatest, the question is will he? but now Dawkins in a couple of year Sean Taylor may blow this guy out of the water.

yourrrrrrrrr dreamingggggggggggggg

lol coming from the biggest Dawkins Fan alive. :lol: :lol: :lol:

Dawkins right now

Taylor is better than Dawkins and in my opinion, Taylor is surprisingly underrated by alot of people...his combo of size and speed is almost unmatched by any other safety in the league. He is one of the biggest hitters in the league but has the ability to cover a slot WR 1 on 1.

Dawkins is a great player and I really really like him, but I think Taylor is better.

Here are my top 5 safety rankings:

1. Ed Reed
2. Sean Taylor
3. Troy Polamalu
4. Brian Dawkins
5. Bob Sanders

Dawkins right now

Sanders better than roy williams?

Taylor has not proven himself to be better than Dawkins, period. He has huge upside still, but he really hasn't been dominant so far in the NFL. While Brian Dawkins has been one of the best Safety's in the NFL for years and years.

In 2 or 3 years, I could buy Taylor being better than Dawkins, but not right now.

Speed-Taylor
Size-Taylor
Coverage- Dawkins
Strength- Taylor
Hitting- Even
Intelligence- Dawkins
Blitz- Taylor (slightly)
Agility- Dawkins

To me it pretty much comes down to-

Tangibles-Taylor
Intangibles-Dawkins

I give Dawkins the edge just because of his leadership, intelligence, intimidation, and hitting (not saying Taylor cant hit or isnt intimidating.

I find this quite interesting because over the last 2 years Taylor has been better than Dawkins. Explain how he has not been dominant and since Taylor has been in the leauge do you really think Dawkins has been a better saftey?

Dawkins is not better in coverage than Taylor.

There he is!!!! :D . Your a such a flaming homer please dont post in this thread.

If that is all you have to say just go home