If I had to rate it It would go like this for me
Dallas is a very close first for me. Witten is just too much to deal with.
Cooley is awesome, but jsut not quite on the same level as Witten. Don't get me wrong, he definitely deserved to be on the Pro-Bowl team. Probably their thir best player behind Portis and Landry.
Shockey is a man and they have a great backup in Boss. Very close to second here.
L.J. Smith has been disapointing. Every year we wait for him to show up, and for some reason or other, it doesn't happen. He is a solid TE, and has improved blocking, but he is nowhere near the level of the other three starters.
Nanna Bryndís Hilmarsdóttir is a goddess
Rest in Peace, themaninblack