Worst Starter on your team

[TheBuffaloBills]

I would say Robert Royal for the Bills. He is not bad, but he could be so much better.

[NY+Giants=NYG]

Butler? He gets everyone lined up in the secondary! Tell me how many breakdowns and deep TD passes we give up? This whole Butler being bad thing is all fan hype. Ask Spags if he would keep a bad SS in the secondary making the calls, FOR A SUPERBOWL TEAM, if he sucked that bad?

[StripedWalrus]

Originally Posted by PalmerToCJ

Center - Eric Ghiaciuc

Thornton Comes in second.

[scottyboy]

Originally Posted by Shockey+Manning=Shocking

Butler? He gets everyone lined up in the secondary! Tell me how many breakdowns and deep TD passes we give up? This whole Butler being bad thing is all fan hype. Ask Spags if he would keep a bad SS in the secondary making the calls, FOR A SUPERBOWL TEAM, if he sucked that bad?

he is probably the least talented. He gets everyone else lined up great, yes, but then proceeds to get his ass torched on passing plays. It's between him and Danny Clark really. he's smart and the QB of the D, but he can't cover.

or tackle for that matter

[Jughead10]

Originally Posted by Shockey+Manning=Shocking

Butler? He gets everyone lined up in the secondary! Tell me how many breakdowns and deep TD passes we give up? This whole Butler being bad thing is all fan hype. Ask Spags if he would keep a bad SS in the secondary making the calls, FOR A SUPERBOWL TEAM, if he sucked that bad?

Well our pass rush probably has something to do with the fact long pass play can't develop. As for long pass plays? Driver in the NFC championship game and Randy Moss week 17 last year. Just off the of my head without really thinking about it.

[Smooth Criminal]

Steelers is either Kendall Simmons or Brett Keisel.

[NY+Giants=NYG]

Originally Posted by scottyboy

he is probably the least talented. He gets everyone else lined up great, yes, but then proceeds to get his ass torched on passing plays. It's between him and Danny Clark really. he's smart and the QB of the D, but he can't cover.

or tackle for that matter

That's just Giants fan BS. What play? The Gb play, where he was playing injuried? Besides that play he has done a great job for us. We have very few breakdowns in the secondary because of him.

Well our pass rush probably has something to do with the fact long pass play can't develop. As for long pass plays? Driver in the NFC championship game and Randy Moss week 17 last year. Just off the of my head without really thinking about it.

Watch that CB in the GB game. He completely got owned while jamming Driver, not to mention he was hurt that game. O yeah, focus on Wilson and the horrible angle he takes and ends up falling behind Driver. As far as Randy Moss and Butler, are you kidding me? Butler, is not the worst player, is my argument, not god! He isn't going to cover or get close to Moss. Moss does what he always does he gets behind the safties and Cbs and makes plays. That's why he is Randy Moss.

In my opinion. Gerris Wilk is the worst starter. The fact that he is rotating in with a rookie is bad enough. Also talking to the beat writers and reading their blogs, it would seem that Kuel still hasn't gotten the mental part of the game down yet, but still on the field due to his athletic ability, which is a huge slap in the face for Gerris, who has been in this system longer. So I would say he is the worst starter on the team.

This whole Butler thing is so dumb. I will ask one of my coaching buddies who explained it alot better than I on how Butler did. He is a DC, and actually explained it very, very well. But worse starter on the field? No, not even close!

[scottyboy]

shocking, in terms of talent, he probably is. He misses WAY too many tackles and takes horrible angles. he starts because he's the DC on the field. He does excellent job there, he really does. But he's a very sloppy tackler and takes just god awful angles. Wilk has been struggling, but he's still hurt too, not 100%.