Originally Posted by Seamus2602
I agree that you can't rely on stats. But without watching every single solitary game you can't say that one player was definately better than others. I wouldn't have had Wayne as a 1st Team All Pro. I'd have had White and Lloyd. My 2nd Team All Pros would have been Andre Johnson and Reggie Wayne. I felt he played better than Jennings, Bowe and Calvin Johnson. Mike Wallace and Hakeem Nicks had breakout years but weren't in that league.
That sounds right, White and Lloyd at #1 and #2 for this year. Reggie Wayne fits the second team and the other slot is up for grabs: AJ but he was hurt? Nicks who missed some games as well and has a small consistency problem? Jennings who was almost nonexistent until week 6 and benefited from Rodgers? Bowe who also started extremely slow? CJ has drops and doesn't produce like he should. Mike Wallace is a stretch, not a polished player and inconsistent game to game.
1. Roddy White
2. Brandon Lloyd
3. Reggie Wayne
4. Andre Johnson
It was tough to leave my boy Jennings off the 2nd team but he doesn't command enough attention from the defense and his stats wouldn't be what they are with Schaub or Cassel or Stafford/Hill.