Pick 3 players - Page 4

xooberon · 01-11-2009, 12:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xooberon

Falcons: John Abraham
Saints: Drew Brees
Bucs: Aqib Talib

updated for this season.

kiranadwaney · 01-07-2010, 04:57 AM

Bucs: Aqib Talib
Panthers: Julius Peppers
Saints: Marques Colston

BamaFalcon59 · 01-07-2010, 12:08 PM

Hmm. To win a game right now...

Bucs: Aquib Talib
Panthers: Julius Peppers
Saints: Lance Moore

Championship!

ATLDirtyBirds · 01-07-2010, 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BamaFalcon59

Hmm. To win a game right now...

Bucs: Aquib Talib
Panthers: Julius Peppers
Saints: Lance Moore

Championship!

Same for me, except I'd rather have Evans Or Nicks from NO.

brasho · 01-24-2010, 02:59 PM

Panthers: DeAngelo Williams
Saints: Will Smith
Falcons: Roddy White

BuffaloBillsFan · 02-06-2010, 05:26 PM

If you don't mind a Bills fan playing along, this is who I would take:

Panthers: Jon Beason
Saints: Drew Brees
Falcons: Michael Turner
Bucs: Aqib Talib

zachsaints52 · 02-09-2010, 12:41 AM

Panthers- Julius Peppers
Atlanta- Sam Baker
Tampa Bay- Sad to say, but Jeff Faine

Bosanac01 · 07-11-2011, 01:11 AM

Panthers: Cam Newton
Saints: Drew Brees
Bucs: Josh Freeman

etk · 07-12-2011, 09:44 AM

Newton for WR, Freeman for TE, Brees for RB, maybe even QB coach?

Falcons: Curtis Lofton.
Panthers: Jordan Gross.
Saints: Jahri Evans.

Upgrade the OL and get a thumper MLB. Hell yeah. I'd like a safety as well but slim pickins in this division.

Revis Island · 07-13-2011, 04:29 PM

Saints: Jahri Evans
Panthers: Jon Beason (OLB)
Bucs: Gerald McCoy

Smash28Dash34 · 07-13-2011, 04:55 PM

Saints: Jahri Evans
Bucs: Mike Williams
Falcons: Julio Jones

Revis Island · 07-13-2011, 10:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Smash28Dash34

Saints: Jahri Evans
Bucs: Mike Williams
Falcons: Julio Jones

I'm assuming taking Julio over Roddy is building for the future.

bullg8rdaddy · 08-03-2011, 03:02 AM

Panthers: LB Beason
Saints: LG Nicks
Falcons: RT Clabo

the_dark_knight · 08-15-2011, 01:52 PM

Bucs:
Kellen Winslow

Panthers:
Charles Johnson

Saints:
Carl Nicks

etk · 08-15-2011, 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by etk

Newton for WR, Freeman for TE, Brees for RB, maybe even QB coach?

Falcons: Curtis Lofton.
Panthers: Jordan Gross.
Saints: Jahri Evans.

Upgrade the OL and get a thumper MLB. Hell yeah. I'd like a safety as well but slim pickins in this division.

Atlanta: John Abraham
Carolina: Greg Olsen
New Orleans: Mark Ingram

Big changes from last time. I'm very comfortable with our OL right now and I wouldn't want to change up chemistry. Kalil would be a nice upgrade over Faine but Faine is a leader and makes the line calls. Lofton is obviously an upgrade over Foster but Foster should be good enough. They're similar players.

Instead I chose Abraham because we could use another quality edge rusher. He's a major upgrade over Clayborn in the short-term, but Clayborn is still a huge upgrade over White from last year (yeesh). Olsen gives us a dangerous weapon for Freeman. I'm not comfortable with our TE depth and Winslow's knee is always a concern. Ingram instantly becomes our best RB imo but more importantly he's an excellent 3rd down back and short-yardage back. Those are 2 weaknesses with the current group.

Burger · 01-10-2012, 03:10 AM

Since I am a Packer fan, I will pick one player from each team.

Falcons: John Abraham, We need a pass rush, and I love Abraham. His use of power would be able to help Green Bay generate a passrush opposite of Clay, and he would function like a Justin Smith in the 2008 49ers D, playing OLB, and DE.

Panthers: Matt Kalil, He would be a great guard on our team. He is a quick agile lineman who is extremely smart. He's a pro bowl caliber player on a team that makes him underrated, much like Jordan Gross. He would be an upgrade to our TJ Lang.

Saints: Marques Colston, Colston would compliment the deep ball ability of Jordy and Greg. His possession abilities would help Aaron find an open reciever when the other 4 are covered.

Buccaneers: Adrian Clayborn, I love how this man plays defensive line. He is able to run defend and penetrate the line to generate pressure. He has a lot of upside if he played next to BJ Raji.

Smash28Dash34 · 01-10-2012, 06:54 PM

Falcons: Julio Jones- Cam needs a young WR to grow up with and even as a Panther fan I have no trouble admitting this kid is going to be a nightmare for the rest of the division for years to come. Saints: Jahri Evans- Best G in the NFL Imo. We need to upgrade our o-line bad and this guy solves that problem easily. Bucaneers- Aqib Talib- Despite his off the field baggage his immense talent is too hard to ignore. We need a stud opposite Gamble and this guy would shore up our secondary.

Bulldogs · 01-10-2012, 10:35 PM

Panthers: Matt Kalil

Saints: Jahri Evans/Carl Nicks (interchangeable)

Panthers: Chris Gamble

Would fix our O-Line issues, and give us a legitimate corner to pair with Brent Grimes

kBuc5 · 01-21-2012, 10:03 AM

Saints - D. Sproles

Panthers - Greg Olsen

Falcons - Grimes

the_dark_knight · 01-21-2012, 01:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kBuc5

Saints - D. Sproles

Panthers - Greg Olsen

Falcons - Grimes

Gag me.

Best player on the Stains for the Bucs is Sproles? Lulz Drew Brees says hi2u Jimmy Graham says hi2u, Every WR on the Saints says hi2u, Will Smith *waves* I mean c'mon...

Most impactful player from the Panters - Greg Olsen (for one of the worst pass rushes in the league?)

Falcons - Grimes, meh okay, but Abe, Julio, Roddy, all come to mind as massive upgrades along with Lofton.

the_dark_knight · 01-21-2012, 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bulldogs

Panthers: Matt Kalil

Saints: Jahri Evans/Carl Nicks (interchangeable)

Panthers: Chris Gamble

Would fix our O-Line issues, and give us a legitimate corner to pair with Brent Grimes

You forgot that you picked 2 panthers and left off the Bucs.

For me...

Saints: Jimmy Graham would prolly get the edge over the 2 guards but just barely.

Panthers: I love your Matt Kalil pickup, hard to argue that one, but at the same time, if I have a chance to get Charles Johnson I'm taking it.

Bucs: Gimme, the water boy, he does a good job down there. Jk jk. Despite his off field issues I'd still have to put Talib at the top of my Buc list, I like some of the young talent down there, but I couldn't put any of them over Talib yet.

kBuc5 · 01-22-2012, 11:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_dark_knight

Gag me.

Best player on the Stains for the Bucs is Sproles? Lulz Drew Brees says hi2u Jimmy Graham says hi2u, Every WR on the Saints says hi2u, Will Smith *waves* I mean c'mon...

Most impactful player from the Panters - Greg Olsen (for one of the worst pass rushes in the league?)

Falcons - Grimes, meh okay, but Abe, Julio, Roddy, all come to mind as massive upgrades along with Lofton.

You could name a lot of players that would be upgrades. We had the 30th ranked rushing offense, you could argue every player you listed but give me Sproles because I don't like what the Panthers and Falcons have there. If our Dline can stay healthy they will be fine, Winslow is on his last legs and the attitude started to come outlast year, I'll take Olson. Just go watch EJ Biggers highlight reel from last year, gimme Grimes.... And FWIW Talib is overrated, how long can you use the word potential for someone?

Bulldogs · 01-22-2012, 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the_dark_knight

You forgot that you picked 2 panthers and left off the Bucs.

For me...

Saints: Jimmy Graham would prolly get the edge over the 2 guards but just barely.

Panthers: I love your Matt Kalil pickup, hard to argue that one, but at the same time, if I have a chance to get Charles Johnson I'm taking it.

Bucs: Gimme, the water boy, he does a good job down there. Jk jk. Despite his off field issues I'd still have to put Talib at the top of my Buc list, I like some of the young talent down there, but I couldn't put any of them over Talib yet.

You're right. Change Nicks/Evans to Jimmy Graham, and throw in Davin Joseph from the Bucs. That way our O-Line is still set, and we have a replacement for Tony G.

the_dark_knight · 01-23-2012, 11:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bulldogs

You're right. Change Nicks/Evans to Jimmy Graham, and throw in Davin Joseph from the Bucs. That way our O-Line is still set, and we have a replacement for Tony G.

I like this, I like it a lot actually. I'm still a fan of Talib, but I forget about Joseph because he's just in such a piss poor offensive line.

As far as the prior comment to Talib being overrated, I don't think he is at all, I think he's very fairly rated. No one is saying he's a top flight corner in the NFL, he's got the skill set to improve further, if he can eliminate off field distractions, which he's proven he has a hard time with. But he's a big fast physical guy who plays pretty well and I would consider him a nice upgrade to the Falcons secondary.

scar988 · 01-25-2012, 10:19 PM

my choices:
New Orleans - OG Carl Nicks
Tampa Bay - DE Adrian Clayborn
Carolina - LT Jordan Gross

Offense with the line of:
Gross - Blalock - McClure - Nicks - Clabo
would be scary. would much rather have a top 3 OG to go with the top 3 RT and a top 10 LT to go with a top 15 LG than Graham from NO and Johnson from CAR. That being said had Tampa had better OL I would have gone with a LT from them, but I don't like Penn. and Clayborn is a good pass rusher.