A lot of it is going to depend on Flynn/Manning. Both Cleveland and Miami have been linked to Flynn and Manning to the Redskins talk has been going on for the past few weeks.
I can't see the Redskins mortgaging the next two drafts for one player, they have been doing a good job building through the draft. I don't think Shannahan could survive another bad season so gambling on a rookie QB to come in right away and lead them to the playoffs would be a big risk.
He sure wasn't good last year, but Cleveland had problems throughout its offense. The running game fell apart and defenses didn't have to take it seriously, and his no. 1 wideout was a rookie, and a raw one at that. And you're talking about a second-year QB who doesn't have outstanding physical traits, but can make things happen with talent around him. I won't write off Colt yet, because I think he can have success in a team that's efficient and executes well. Kind of to the NFL what Kellen Moore was to college football. But I'll readily concede that if last year was what you're basing your opinion of Colt McCoy on, there's not a lot to be excited about.
This is pretty much how I feel. Colt did pretty much nothing to convince anyone last year, but traditionally QB's take time to develop and he was a 3rd Rd. pick for a reason.
I'd rather not give up what looks to be at least 3 top 40 picks and maybe more just to put a rookie in the same ****** situation.
Also, just look at the main "contributors" to this offense last year. I can't imagine RGIII doing significantly better with this supporting cast.
Greg Little - was raw and a year removed from football
Josh Cribbs - jack of all trades, probably an OK slot guy
Ben Watson - pretty decent when not concussed
Hillis/Hardesty/Ogbonnaya - Chris ******* Ogbonnaya was the best of the three last year
OL - Thomas, Mack, and three other guys not worth a ****
You are a little more optomistic than me (which might be a first, haha), because I think the combination of Shannahan and Snyder is going to result in some crazy compensation that Holmgren/Heckert won't match. Blackmon might run a bad time and could drop down draft boards - but hoping that Blackmon lights it up is good for the Browns in any case, whether it be to make St.Louis fall in love with him or in the event that the Browns take him.
This is how I feel. I think Washington is going to put some ridiculous package together to get him, while Holmgren and Heckertt are smarted than mortgaging an entire future for one player.
I think the limit I would pay for the 2nd pick would be both firsts and a third next year with maybe a super late pick this year... Too hard to rationalize giving up anything more.
The Browns will never be anything until they replace McCoy. I probably wouldn't give up 3 picks either, but I wouldn't blame them if they did. They have nothing at QB.
They could get to 8-8 with all of those picks!!!11! At this point, I'd take that!
But seriously, I'd rather get the talent at other positions now and pay the King's ransom for a QB next year. That's just how I prefer to build a team. Create a good situation, place a QB in said good situation, watch him thrive. I know some people don't agree with that philosophy, but it's so simple really ;)