Peyton Manning=Overrated

[SuperPacker]

We should just ban this guy before he becomes another JBCX!

[jrdrylie]

Originally Posted by SuperPacker

We should just ban this guy before he becomes another JBCX!

I loved JBCX.

[PackerLegend]

Overrated? No... He has earned all the praise he has received. He might not have all the rings but the guy is easily one of the best all time.

Now if people are expecting to see the MVP Manning in Denver... Theres a good chance we wont and may never will. He should still be good just not as great as he once was.

[vidae]

I have nothing more to add here, so I'm going to post a bunch of dogs. Come at me.

[Caulibflower]

Originally Posted by vidae

I have nothing more to add here, so I'm going to post a bunch of dogs. Come at me.

You're ruining this forum!

[killxswitch]

[Steady Lurkin]

<---Better playoff QB than Peyton Manning

[niel89]

Originally Posted by fear the elf

You're focusing too much on the 1 and not enough on the 10...

Honestly. Peyton isn't the best playoffs QB but at least Playoffs were a guarantee every season. 11 out of 13 seasons were playoff seasos.

[WCH]

[cmarq83]

Originally Posted by TACKLE

How does he compare to Tom Brady? Who is better between the two?

Not sure if joking, or if JMike has hacked onto Tackle's account.

[Splat]

Originally Posted by niel89

Peyton isn't the best playoffs QB but at least Playoffs were a guarantee every season. 11 out of 13 seasons were playoff seasons.

It's a shame he never had Marty Schottenheimer as a HC.

[descendency]

I just thought of the perfect sports analogy (ok, anything with NASCAR sucks, but the analogy is perfect).

Tom Brady is like Jimmy Johnson. Peyton Manning is like Danica Patrick.

[Rosebud]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Can we seriously just ban this guy already? Something tells me he isn't going to be a valued poster.

Never underestimate troll potential, kid still needs to learn from the classics before he can truly innovate.

[Rosebud]

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

I loved JBCX.

I wish we could've seen what this playoff run did to the poor little guy.

[njx9]

Originally Posted by descendency

I just thought of the perfect sports analogy (ok, anything with NASCAR sucks, but the analogy is perfect).

Tom Brady is like Jimmy Johnson. Peyton Manning is like Danica Patrick.

i was about to make jokes about people taking shots at peyton, then i realized half of you are pats fans and would've been taking the same shots literally no matter what happened.

[Rosebud]

Originally Posted by NFLBaller

Manning should have won 3-4 Super Bowls 1 is an underwhelming number for a guy marketed like he is.

For realz, can't even beat out a scrub like Tom Brady and his vastly more well coached and better put together teams.

[njx9]

Originally Posted by Rosebud

For realz, can't even beat out a scrub like Tom Brady and his vastly more well coached and better put together teams.

look, it's pretty clear that peyton manning is basically heath shuler with a better supporting cast. everyone should stop kidding themselves because someone created a duplicate account to troll the board with told us how it is.

[Rosebud]

Originally Posted by njx9

look, it's pretty clear that peyton manning is basically heath shuler with a better supporting cast. everyone should stop kidding themselves because someone created a duplicate account to troll the board with told us how it is.

lol Broncos homer, Peyton wishes he were Heath Shuler, if he didn't get to beat up on you guys in the first round his playoff #s would be pathetic...

[WCH]

Originally Posted by njx9

look, it's pretty clear that peyton manning is basically heath shuler with a better supporting cast. everyone should stop kidding themselves because someone created a duplicate account to troll the board with told us how it is.

http://shuler.house.gov/

Pfffft...Peyton couldn't even BEGIN to handle the pressure that Heath Shuler has to deal with everyday. A quick glance at wikipedia taught me that Heath Shuler is a "Whip of the Blue Dog Coalition," for crying out loud! I don't know what that means, exactly, but it sounds a lot different than "Quarterback of the Denver Broncos."

[njx9]

Originally Posted by Rosebud

lol Broncos homer, Peyton wishes he were Heath Shuler, if he didn't get to beat up on you guys in the first round his playoff #s would be pathetic...

worthless mike shanahan defenses letting him off easy. ooo, maybe the nfl can let us play the redskins in the first round of the playoffs every year? no doubt he'll manhandle that defense (which is still identical in every way to the defenses shanny ran in denver) the same way the chargers and patriots defenses (which are also identical to the same ones that peyton couldn't beat, even ty law came back this week) will manhandle him all season.

Originally Posted by WCH

http://shuler.house.gov/

Pfffft...Peyton couldn't even BEGIN to handle the pressure that Heath Shuler has to deal with everyday. A quick glance at wikipedia taught me that Heath Shuler is a "Whip of the Blue Dog Coalition," for crying out loud! I don't know what that means, exactly, but it sounds a lot different than "Quarterback of the Denver Broncos."

holy ****, i honestly had no idea shuler had done anything with his life.

[WCH]

Don't feel bad. I knew that he ran and was elected back in 2006, but I had no idea that he's been reelected twice. Apparently, North Carolina's 11th District loves him...they obviously never watched him play Quarterback.

[Monomach]

David Hasselhoff has a puppy on his sperminator. Your argument is invalid.

[Denver Bronco56]

Can you name another 4 time NFL MVP?

[Raiderz4Life]

Tim Tebow?

[descendency]

Originally Posted by Denver Bronco27

Can you name another 4 time NFL MVP?

Clearly, then he's the most overrated 4 time MVP, ever.