Mafia Discussion

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by Forenci

I really am starting to hate this. It's a damned if you, damned if you don't situation. If you're asked to role reveal it looks pretty suspicious of you're extremely opposed to it, but if you do it may potentially make it easier for the SK/mafia. Granted, people will lie like crazy, but toward the end of the game when so many roles have been claimed it's almost impossible to lie sucessfully because it typically just won't make sense.

It used to be a last ditch but since ATL and Gonzo started screaming it every game people just started to follow.

I mean seriously on every damn page people were screaming for someone that wasn't even going to be lynched to role reveal.

Now I role reveal most games but its to defend someone, give investigations. But **** right now its pretty ******** that people do it for the hell of it.

[ImBrotherCain]

Just for example this is through the first 6 pages.

Originally Posted by D-Unit

R-O-L-E.... R-E-V-E-A-L!!!!!

I wanna see if you have anything to hide.

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

Solid reasoning from you as always. I mean forget that I could have called nobody out and had no attention drawn to myself. I mean it is easy to get a lynch train started against me and you are the kind of person to get pissed when you are evil and called out. Add that to you never contributed anything even if you are good which I doubt. I have not forgotten you SP!

Unvote: SP

Vote: D

Reveal yourself! I mean you could also actually contribute something of worth too. That would be nice.

Originally Posted by D-Unit

You think your babbling is contributing something of worth? LOL. Yeah, you are pretty cocky.

The fact that you are constantly asking people to role reveal should put you at the top of everyone's suspicious list! If you think that's a fair question to ask, why don't you lead the way and role reveal yourself. Let the mafia know YOUR role!!! Until you do that, don't act like you're contributing a damn thing by trying to get others to role reveal.

Originally Posted by Caddy

Reveal Yourself Broth!

Originally Posted by Caddy

Reveal Yourself BB!

Originally Posted by broth223

"Reveal yourself!
Reveal yourself!
Reveal yourself!
Reveal yourself!"

Originally Posted by Caddy

Being the nice guy is no fun.

REVEAL YOURSELF CAIN

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

So far what I have not liked is SuperPacker breaking the rules and just being SP. I will be keeping my eye on those who voted Broth though.

Vote: SP

Reveal yourself!

Originally Posted by killxswitch

I was wondering what possible upside there could be.

How bout YOU get aggressive! You're Gonzo. Get after it! Or REVEAL YOUR ROLE!

[Grizzlegom]

Originally Posted by Caddy

Can people start killing Grizz on Night 1 now instead of me please.

I was just thinking this, its about that time that I'm due to be the first one killed for a couple games. :-(

[jrdrylie]

I only need 7 or 8 more people for the O.C Game. So if anyone wants to play, come aboard!

[ATLDirtyBirds]

Originally Posted by sbh15

I still want to know who the **** started the role reveal train? because that's a damn good way to lose the game

Reveal yourself!

Originally Posted by vidae

Role revealing works more often than not. That said, I ******* hate doing it too and feel like it cheapens the game, but I was pretty much forced to in this game.

Nope. I hate role revealing. I don't care if I die in every single mafia game from here until the end of time, I won't do it. It completely cheapens these games.

I will say that the tyrannical reign of these guilds must be put to an end!

And that is all I will say.

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

It used to be a last ditch but since ATL and Gonzo started screaming it every game people just started to follow.

Bahaha.

[vidae]

I love you ATL, but every time you copy me I love you less. Just remember that.

[ATLDirtyBirds]

Originally Posted by vidae

I love you ATL, but every time you copy me I love you less. Just remember that.

Don't be mad you broke your own code. I'm strongly considering adding it to "Reveal Yourself!" "Fall on your sword sir!" and "Duel."

[Caddy]

Originally Posted by Grizzlegom

I was just thinking this, its about that time that I'm due to be the first one killed for a couple games. :-(

I'll happily let you take my place.

[RufusMcDaniel]

When running your own game, is there a ratio of good to evil players that anyone uses?

[Wootylicous]

I always assume it was 75% good and 25% mafia. Add 2-3 neutrals to that 75%

[BeerBaron]

Depends on how strong each side is. If the town has a lot of power roles (cop, protector, watcher) you'll want to have a bigger mafia. Maybe 3-1 ratio not including 3rd parties.

If the town is pretty weak or the mafia is really strong (having framers, shields, etc.) you'll want more of a 4-1 ratio.

[Forenci]

I really am itching to do the Star Wars game again. I have a lot of ideas to make it more balanced but like I said previously, I'm moving soon and probably won't really be able to really run it. I could put together a lot of the ideas but I would probably need a co-GM who would act as a full-time GM, essentially, haha.

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by Forenci

I really am itching to do the Star Wars game again. I have a lot of ideas to make it more balanced but like I said previously, I'm moving soon and probably won't really be able to really run it. I could put together a lot of the ideas but I would probably need a co-GM who would act as a full-time GM, essentially, haha.

Your moving again?

[bantx]

I'm interested in doing a starcraft game, but I've never ran a game so if anyone is knowledgeable of the game let me know we can cook something up :D

[fenikz]

i shall build soooo many toss towers muahahahahha

[Bulldogs]

Since everybody is apparently throwing their hats into the ring, I was thinking at some point of running a 15-20 man game, much smaller than my last game which had 37. I was thinking either a South Park themed game or just a plain, good ole' fashioned non-themer.

[Forenci]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

Your moving again?

Yes sir. Well, I moved back up to Connecticut for the summer and now I'm moving back to South Carolina to start up summer classes.

Originally Posted by bantx

I'm interested in doing a starcraft game, but I've never ran a game so if anyone is knowledgeable of the game let me know we can cook something up :D

That would be awesome, haha. You could somehow try to make it a three way battle using each of the races. I could help you come up with some ideas, but I will probably be too busy to run it or co-gm it or anything.

[Grizzlegom]

You require more Vespene gas.

[BeerBaron]

DIBS

[OSUGiants17]

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

So I'm still interested in running that Dexter Mafia if someone experienced wants to help me run it that'd be great. I got pretty much all of it made I just need help running it since I've never run one before. PM me if interested.

So I guess no one wants to help out with this

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

So I guess no one wants to help out with this

I got ya boss. I have been working on a different setup.

Ill get back to you after the current game I am designing.

[OSUGiants17]

Originally Posted by ImBrotherCain

I got ya boss. I have been working on a different setup.

Ill get back to you after the current game I am designing.

Alright sounds good, I've made some tweaks to what we came up with a while back too

[ImBrotherCain]

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

Alright sounds good, I've made some tweaks to what we came up with a while back too

Haha I have a whole new setup. I think its 15x better.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by RufusMcDaniel

Ummmm...


Snicho! Reveal yourself?

Reveal yourself Snicho!

[Snicho]

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

Reveal yourself Snicho!

God Dammit.

Really? Have we not moved past this. I shall never reveal. Ever. Again. IN ANY GAME!