Originally Posted by niel89
I never really liked Mathews that much honestly. Nothing about his game was out standing to me.
Gerhart > Mathews forever
Gerhart is much more durable. That's a given. But it would be like having two Mike Tolberts on one team, which isn't a bad thing. Mathews, however, is the homerun threat on the team when he's healthy. He's deceptively fast like LT was. But what makes him so "outstanding" as you put it was his balance and agility.
It's just too bad he's so brittle despite all that muscle.