SWDC Mafia Game Thread (Town Wins!)

[OSUGiants17]

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

You might as well tell us why you will be useful, no point hiding it now.

Um yes there is...it's round 2 why the **** would I role reveal to some pretentious asshat who constantly demands as if he is the almighty leader of every mafia game.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Suspicions:

OSU - Obvious reasons
Brodeur - Followed him to Rob S
CJ - One of him and Brodeur is evil imo, possibly both
Fenikz - Don't like what I have seen from him

That's four ************. It's not that hard to do and that was after thinking on it for 30 seconds. I will be watching someone tonight so come at me mafia you ******* bitches.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

Um yes there is...it's round 2 why the **** would I role reveal to some pretentious asshat who constantly demands as if he is the almighty leader of every mafia game.

You are not helping your cause. Classic evil Vidae right here.

[BeerBaron]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

Why did jailkeeping Rob make no sense? What would you have done, exactly? Why did following me make sense? Should I have picked up on magical hints that were thrown out?

I wouldn't have jailkept on night 1. You're just as likely to hit a power role on the town's side than anyone evil. Which apparently you did because Rob could confirm he was blocked. I also wouldn't use a vigilante kill on night 1, but if TH isn't bullshitting us, he had to.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Suspicious of Bulldogs as well. TH I am unsure of. Forenci also is setting of something.

[OSUGiants17]

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

Suspicions:

OSU - Obvious reasons
Brodeur - Followed him to Rob S
CJ - One of him and Brodeur is evil imo, possibly both
Fenikz - Don't like what I have seen from him

That's four ************. It's not that hard to do and that was after thinking on it for 30 seconds. I will be watching someone tonight so come at me mafia you ******* bitches.

Me- I was busy all day, I am good. Quietness isn't that crazy

Brodeur- ok I agree with you on that one

CJ- Why because you think so and you're just always right? Provide some reasoning here otherwise why should I believe you?

Fenikz- Like what?

[Rob S]

Jailkeeping/roleblocking me was whatever. I'm not bitter. Night one is a crapshoot. Still though, I don't see an option better than Brody right now. We have a 50/50 shot.

Another option (if we believe TH) is to kill someone else and have TH target Brody every night so if he doesn't use the RB/JK on TH, he will die.

[Brodeur]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

I wouldn't have jailkept on night 1. You're just as likely to hit a power role on the town's side than anyone evil. Which apparently you did because Rob could confirm he was blocked. I also wouldn't use a vigilante kill on night 1, but if TH isn't bullshitting us, he had to.

Oh well, I always do random **** on night 1 because it's usually harmless.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

Um yes there is...it's round 2 why the **** would I role reveal to some pretentious asshat who constantly demands as if he is the almighty leader of every mafia game.

You already said you have a power and can be useful...why would mafia not kill you?

[BeerBaron]

Originally Posted by Rob S

Jailkeeping/roleblocking me was whatever. I'm not bitter. Night one is a crapshoot. Still though, I don't see an option better than Brody right now. We have a 50/50 shot.

Another option (if we believe TH) is to kill someone else and have TH target Brody every night so if he doesn't use the RB/JK on TH, he will die.

Again, in all of the games I've played or modded, I can't recall a single instance of forcing a guy to use his powers in a certain way actually working out.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

I wouldn't have jailkept on night 1. You're just as likely to hit a power role on the town's side than anyone evil. Which apparently you did because Rob could confirm he was blocked. I also wouldn't use a vigilante kill on night 1, but if TH isn't bullshitting us, he had to.

You are more likely to hit on a good role than evil. Rob just did not strike me as someone I would have jailkept.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

Oh well, I always do random **** on night 1 because it's usually harmless.

Not to defend Brody (but kinda) because I would lynch him over everyone else right now, but I would generally do the same thing. It's probably dumb but whatever.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by BeerBaron

Again, in all of the games I've played or modded, I can't recall a single instance of forcing a guy to use his powers in a certain way actually working out.

Me either. hence why I prefer the lynch of Brody, but just putting it out there,

[OSUGiants17]

Originally Posted by Rob S

You already said you have a power and can be useful...why would mafia not kill you?

They keep me alive and kill someone else already confirmed to have a strong power like Gonzo who called me out and they can immediately blame me for it and get rid of 2 people. Gonzo you can track me if you really want your proof

[jrdrylie]

Anyone find CJ's grammar mistakes interesting besides me? He had one yesterday and then another today. Just one each day.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

Me- I was busy all day, I am good. Quietness isn't that crazy

Brodeur- ok I agree with you on that one

CJ- Why because you think so and you're just always right? Provide some reasoning here otherwise why should I believe you?

Fenikz- Like what?

Look at what CJ has added to the thread. Some soft defences, not much else. He just does not strike me as good CJ.

Fenikz I have a feeling about. Seems like he is playing a Fenikz mafia style game.

I backed my **** up, do you have anything to contribute or will you just continue to be useless, be angry, contribute nothing because you say its only day two, and tell us you can help the town later which I bet will be some xshot mularky.

[Brodeur]

No, you didn't. You say killing me no matter what will reveal a ton, except all it will show is that you and Caddy are douchebags who don't realize **** when it's completely obvious and right in your face. Best mafia player my ass.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by OSUGiants17

They keep me alive and kill someone else already confirmed to have a strong power like Gonzo who called me out and they can immediately blame me for it and get rid of 2 people. Gonzo you can track me if you really want your proof

Yo realize that is not how the mafia works anymore right? They have moved past obvious frames. So they take me out, great, but I might be watched one and two even if I do die cleanly they are wasting a ninja on someone with two one time use abilities. I am not even the main one against you and if you were evil there is no way you guys would kill me to in some way benifit you so its a ****** frame job.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

No, you didn't. You say killing me no matter what will reveal a ton, except all it will show is that you and Caddy are douchebags who don't realize **** when it's completely obvious and right in your face. Best mafia player my ass.

What is so obvious. You being ward and a jailkeeper? I mean I guess it makes sense but it would be a pretty great safeclaim. If you turn out good we can look at the people who popped in to offer soft defences on you. We leave you alive and either we use a bunch of powers tonight to figure out if you are good and even then no guarantee or you continue to be suspicious and we keep coming back to you. In my opinion breaking it all down lynching you benefits the town more than lynching anyone else.

[Rob S]

Bleh. Brody is the best best kill here. I'm not sure on it, but it's day 2 and there is some very strong evidence. Also, anyone ever think it may not be a good idea to keep this open until the power up trivia? Just an idea, but I feel like the mafia will be more motivated in these than the town.

[CJSchneider]

Originally Posted by jrdrylie

Anyone find CJ's grammar mistakes interesting besides me? He had one yesterday and then another today. Just one each day.

Any mistakes I make are contributed to the fact that I refuse to edit, even ninja edit, a mistake once I post a remark. They are not meant to be characteristic of my current role or character assignment.

[Brodeur]

Originally Posted by Dr. Gonzo

What is so obvious. You being ward and a jailkeeper? I mean I guess it makes sense but it would be a pretty great safeclaim. If you turn out good we can look at the people who popped in to offer soft defences on you. We leave you alive and either we use a bunch of powers tonight to figure out if you are good and even then no guarantee or you continue to be suspicious and we keep coming back to you. In my opinion breaking it all down lynching you benefits the town more than lynching anyone else.

If I'm a roleblocker, what can I really do? Not like I can kill anyone.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by Rob S

Bleh. Brody is the best best kill here. I'm not sure on it, but it's day 2 and there is some very strong evidence. Also, anyone ever think it may not be a good idea to keep this open until the power up trivia? Just an idea, but I feel like the mafia will be more motivated in these than the town.

Haha, honestly, I am with you on that. I doubt the majority will agree but I wont be competing in a 730 am trivia so I would be for lynching before them. Yes, I am a selfish bastard.

[Rob S]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

If I'm a roleblocker, what can I really do? Not like I can kill anyone.

c'mon Brody.....that's a lame excuse. If we can lynch a mafia of any kind, it should absolutely be done.

[Dr. Gonzo]

Originally Posted by Brodeur

If I'm a roleblocker, what can I really do? Not like I can kill anyone.

Roleblocker is imo the most valuable mafia role if used right.